Fear Sets In for Trump as SCOTUS Prepares Biggest Ruling Yet!!!

IFN
2 followers
4 Video Views·Jun 18, 2026
Mother Jones reporter Pema Levy joins Court Accountability Action’s Lisa Graves to talk about one of the most important cases in front of the Roberts Court, Trump v. Barbara, which considers Donald Trump's counter-constitutional attack on birthright citizenship. Pema and Lisa discuss the case, the fringe legal claims of John Eastman (the disbarred Clarence Thomas clerk), and the devastating consequences if the Roberts Court rules for Trump--along with the good PR John Roberts would get by ruling against him.
AI Generated·May contain errors
Hello everyone, this is Lisa Graves with Court Accountability Action here on Legal AF, part of
the Midas Touch Network, and I'm joined today by an amazing, intrepid reporter. Her name is Pema
Levy. She is with Mother Jones Magazine, and she is amazing, I have to say. I read her writings
regularly. She wrote about a month or so ago, co-wrote a piece with Ari Berman,
blaming John Roberts for everything. That's the cover shot. The inside headline,
just to share with you, is quite accurate as well. This is all John Roberts' fault.
And she says, and she wrote there, that Trump owes his corrupt and abusive reign to one man,
John Roberts. There's more in that story. I've had the great good fortune of having the chance
to be interviewed by Pema. I have the great good fortune, as you all do, to read her investigations
and her writing. And we wanted her to come on today, not just to talk about John Roberts,
a favorite topic of mine, but to talk about one of the cases that is still pending before the
United States Supreme Court, before John Roberts and his cohorts. It's the Barbara case, United
States v. Barbara. It is a case involving the Trump administration's efforts to claim
that a president has the right to redefine the citizenship that the 14th Amendment guarantees
to anyone born in the United States. It has enormous stakes, and it is still to be decided.
Now, let me just say, when the Supreme Court decides it, given the way this Roberts court
has been ruling, I don't think that's the final word if they go against the actual language of
the Constitution. But we'll take that up if it happens that way. There's a lot of speculation
about how the court will rule, whether they'll turn back Trump. But without further ado, Pema,
thank you so much for coming on Legal AF. Thank you so much for having me.
Thank you for your patience, too, as we got this interview going this morning. Can you tell me
about what you've been finding, what you've been seeing in your examination of this case that stems
from that executive order that Donald Trump issued on the day he was sworn in, trying to
redefine citizenship in America unilaterally and, in my view, in defiance of the plain language
of the 14th Amendment? That case is being litigated. What have you found?
So it's not just your view that the first sentence of the 14th Amendment
makes virtually everyone born here a citizen. That is the view of virtually everyone, historians,
legal experts, constitutional scholars, and the group of people that are trying to question that
and to rewrite that. I think in one of my stories, I write a small band of misfits here.
You have, obviously, the Trump administration, and then you have a band of scholars, all
notable in their own way, but a very small crew of people who have Trump sympathies and who want to
rewrite our Constitution in order to create—there's no other way to put this—a
drastically different country, just to truly uproot American society as we know it.
A society where you are born here and you have a—whether or not it's realized—the
potential to be whatever you want, right? That is the American dream. And they want to rewrite it
and say, no, you inherit the status of your parents, and if you are not born to a citizen
or a legal permanent resident, then you will forever be consigned to a lower-class status.
You might not be able to get an education or healthcare. You won't be able to pursue
the jobs that you want. It is a truly radical vision for American society, and that is why it is
almost universally frowned upon. And the fact that we are even having to talk about this,
right? The fact that the Trump administration has got the Supreme Court to take this up is really
a testament to how far they have successfully moved the Overton window that we even have to
be debating this. Well, that's exactly right. It really is extraordinary. It is the language of the
14th Amendment. It has been unquestioned by anyone except the fringe that this is the way
the Constitution reads. Donald Trump asserted when the case was argued before the U.S. Supreme Court
that anyone who—any country that would have birthright citizenship is, quote, stupid.
Well, that's the country that he was elected president of, and that's the country he took
an oath to uphold the Constitution, which plainly requires birthright citizenship.
And in fact, 30 other countries, more than 30 other countries in the world have birthright
citizenship in one form or another. And in fact, it's a longstanding part of U.S.,
sort of the Anglo-Saxon legal tradition dating back to England. And the longstanding notion
in the country that colonized part of America that we had that Revolutionary War from,
the Declaration of Independence from, but was still part of our heritage of law,
England had that longstanding position of territory being the determinant of birth,
not other factors. And as you point out, this is not some new position. This is the position
that the U.S. Supreme Court articulated as well in the—I think the case is called—yeah,
the Wong Kim Ark case. This was back in the 1800s. Someone who was born in the United States
to parents who were not lawful permanent residents, who didn't have that sort of
some permanent visa status, and the Supreme Court looked at that case closely. And this
was in a period in which there was a rampant discrimination against Chinese people in the
United States. There were the Chinese Exclusion Acts and other limitations. But the U.S. Supreme
Court, the same U.S. Supreme Court that had allowed racial segregation in America, the Plessy
case, they looked at the Fourth Amendment and said, no, you cannot exclude this American citizen
born of Chinese parents, parents who moved back to China, who did not have a right to stay
indefinitely in the United States. There's a really tremendously helpful documentary that
The Washington Post published about that man and his family. But this goes against this claim,
this fringe claim by Trump and his loyalists, goes against the language of the Constitution,
U.S. Supreme Court precedent and more. And I would be remiss if I didn't mention something
that I know you know well, that one of the people who has spawned and spurred on this
outrageous theory of citizenship is none other than John Eastman of the Claremont Institute,
the man who was also behind Trump's efforts to subvert the 2020 election and stop the vote from
being counted, a man who lost his law license in California due to those activities. He,
John Eastman, has submitted a brief, an amicus brief in this case, among other right-wing
aficionados. Eastman is a former clerk for none other than Clarence Thomas, and he has been
buttressed in his extreme claims by one of these Wall Street billionaires who bankrolls the
Claremont Institute. Can you tell us a little bit more about Eastman or some of the other people
who are supporting this really outlandish, counter-constitutional claim? Yeah, definitely.
So Eastman is, I think I've called sort of the grandfather of this idea. He's been pushing it
for a long time. I actually interviewed him in 2015 when Trump first ran for president,
because Trump endorsed, you know, changing birthright citizenship all the way back in
2015, and John Eastman was like, ah, finally, my theory is getting some attention. So he was
very excited at the time. Clearly, as you mentioned, there's a bit of a cloud over John Eastman
at the moment, and so it is really interesting to watch other scholars sort of
either try to use his work without attributing it to him or say, well, this is not going great
because it's a John Eastman theory, so I need to come up with my own theories. So Eastman's
theory is essentially, yeah, yeah, England had this birthright citizenship rule, yeah,
that's the common law, but we had a revolution, and we took off the shackles of common law,
and even though it shapes so much of our law otherwise, and, you know, we started our own
thing, which is inherited citizenship through parentage, right? So that's sort of his theory,
and it doesn't align with really anything that has followed, but that's what, yeah,
that's what he says. There's, I'll just briefly mention, there's another scholar, Richard Epstein,
he's sort of a libertarian, and he has also jumped into the fray and has a similar argument
about how the United States cast off the shackles of birthright citizenship in the revolution.
And then there's a prominent newcomer to the debate who I've written about, Elon Wurman,
who's a professor at Minnesota Law School, and he takes a different tact. He says, actually,
we do take the rule from common law from England, but in England, birthright citizenship had all
these exceptions, and those exceptions include the exceptions that Trump wants now.
And the theory has two points. I don't know how many weeds we want to get here, but on the one
hand, they argue that citizenship requires an exchange of protection on the part of the
government in exchange for allegiance from the citizen, and that if you are here, if you are
undocumented or just sort of passing through on vacation, not a permanent resident or a citizen,
then you have not engaged in this allegiance for protection compact that allows your children to
citizenship. The other argument is that in order to truly be under the jurisdiction of the United
States, as is mentioned in the 14th Amendment and the Citizenship Clause, you have to be
domiciled here. And domiciled is not really a technical term. It's sort of a broad term.
And what's really terrifying about that is that the president or Congress could just say what
domicile means at any time. So it would, if your parents had to be domiciled for you to have
citizenship, that would be an ever-changing influx group of people, depending on what the president
or the Congress decided domicile meant at any given time. And so I think what's really important
here is that after the Civil War, the country ended a system of inherited status and replaced
it with a system where politicians couldn't say, this disfavored group, they're a permanent
underclass. And that's exactly what these arguments bring back. They say, now it's back to politicians,
back to presidents, back to Congress. They can point to a group and say, you're disfavored.
You don't get to be citizens anymore. And by the way, I just have to say there is nothing
in these arguments that actually limits this citizenship stripping to newborns. There is
nothing legally that would stop them from going back and questioning the citizenship of millions
of Americans. So it is, those are the basics of the arguments being put forward. And those are
really like the main scholars. There's a few others that are sort of pushed parts of it,
or sort of pop up in this story, but those are the main scholars who've been pushing these
arguments. I mean, it really is a fringe theory. It's just a handful of people who are making this
claim against the weight of historians, the weight of both legal historians and baseline historical
historians about what the constitution means and meant and what the Supreme Court has consistently
viewed it to mean. I recall hearing John Sowers' scratchy voice making this claim of jurisdiction.
And it's such an outrageous argument. The United States asserts jurisdiction over everyone within
its borders. That's how the United States operates. The only ones who have an exception are
people who are ambassadors when they're at their ambassadorial facility. And in fact, there's this
sort of limitation for ambassadors because that embassy is considered to be the property of the
other country when it's on the U.S. soil. And so that's the one exception where it's very hard and
almost impossible to get an ambassador before a courthouse, whether it's for traffic tickets or
something else, because the embassy is actually considered to be foreign territory that the U.S.
cannot enter. But other than that, everyone else is subject to the jurisdiction of the United States.
And I really appreciate your underscoring the point of how far this claim would go, because
even though Trump has asserted in this blatantly, in my view, counter-constitutional executive order
that as of February of last year, he gets to decide that certain people born in the United
States who are American citizens are somehow not U.S. citizens because their parent is a student,
for example, or their parent has an H-1B visa. They may be here for a decade or more. They may
have deep ties to the United States, but somehow they're not subject to the jurisdiction.
That's a ridiculous argument. But we know that the next thing this administration would do if
it was allowed to proceed prospectively would be to proceed retrospectively. There's no way to
limit them if they are given this power. And one of the things we know is that Donald Trump
is obsessed with Kamala Harris and Joe Biden. And Don Eastman has made this very claim
that supposedly Kamala Harris is not or should not be considered a citizen of the United States because
her parents were here on student visas. So they would almost certainly move to try to strip her
and millions, literally millions of other Americans over time of their rightful U.S.
citizenship, something that I think would be a moral abomination. But people like
John Eastman would be saying, yeah, go ahead and do it. And it really is. It is just such an
outrageous assertion of power. Donald Trump talked about how the initial beneficiaries of the 14th
Amendment were white. And I think that that's the end of the story. But that's like, as you point out,
this is about making sure that no class of politicians can create an underclass, denying
their citizenship rights if they are born here, that no one can use their color or their background
or their ethnicity to deny them equal protection of the law, which is what the 14th Amendment
commands. I wonder if you could talk a little bit more about this issue of, like, this is a
case that should be an open and closed, open and shut case. The Supreme Court never should have,
in my view, even had arguments. It's just such an outlandish case. But they're entertaining it
as if there's something, some there there, when in fact, it's just political, in my view, political
will, domination and the subservience of the Roberts Court, which why, when I saw this, I'm
going to go back to the fabulous. I'm going to get this frame, by the way. But when I saw the headline,
Blame Democrats for Anything. Yeah, I mean, this, this court is not acting like a normal court.
It has invented immunity from criminal prosecution for Donald Trump, even though the Constitution
does not have immunity for a president at all, and says the contrary. The president's job is to
faithfully execute the law. That's the oath he takes. There's immunity for Congress only for
statements on the floor to protect them from being sued for libel every other second for something
they say on the floor. But there's no immunity for presidents. But we are in this crisis because
John Roberts and his fellow Republican appointees are entertaining outlier claims in order to
aggrandize presidential power. So I know there's a lot of speculation that the court won't go this
far, will not let him do this. That's the conventional wisdom. I'm not sure that we can
count on anything, actually, given what John Roberts has been up to on a whole host of issues,
re, you know, reinterpreting, inventing, changing our laws at will, regardless of the language of
the Constitution. But I hope they strike it down. Are you what are you hearing and seeing
in your reporting about this, about this issue from the legal field?
Yeah, so I think the consensus is that is that he, Donald Trump will most likely lose this case.
I think there are a few issues here. I think it is. I am usually very pessimistic about this court.
I do think that he will probably lose and he will probably lose on constitutional grounds.
However, it is possible that he loses on statutory grounds, which would leave this whole
question of how the Constitution defines citizenship to another day. And that would be
dangerous. You know, it would basically mean that, you know, a pliant Congress could go and change,
change the law. And it would, you know, I think, leave some cracks and some maneuvering for Trump
to try to essentially continue down this path. Because the fact of the matter is that Congress
has basically, I think, in 1940 or so, they basically codified the citizenship clause of
the 14th Amendment. And so the Supreme Court could say, we don't need to reach
the constitutional issue. We'll just rest this on on the statute. I do think this is a very
political court. John Roberts is always thinking about politics in many ways. I don't think there's
any way you can look at his jurisprudence and say he is not trying to help the Republican Party
and the interests of the Republican Party and the wealthy people that support that party and
his court. On the other hand, he seems to have some awareness of the reputation of the court.
And so there is a different game of politics that I think he and his colleagues are probably also
playing at all times. And I think that there is probably a sense for him that if they uphold
birthright citizenship, as we have always defined it, and Trump loses, that he will generate a lot
of good headlines talking about what a reasonable court this is and how they don't do whatever Trump
wants and that that will provide cover for all of the things that they are doing to give Trump
exactly what he wants. And that, I think, is very much in line with Robert's history,
which is, you know, give give Trump, give the Republicans, give them 90 percent and then make
sure you take a case here and there to make you look reasonable. And so I think that could be
this could be one of those cases as well. I will say from oral argument, I don't think this is a
opinion. We'll see. But I think there is at least one vote, possibly two, for Trump. And just that
fact, I mean, again, we are talking about such an easy case. There is like no no real debate here.
And the fact that you're going to lose one to two justices most likely on this is is a real
statement of where this court is. And again, it it opens that Overton window a little bit more.
Right. It it it says like, look, it was only seven to was only eight. One one of the justices,
you know, is over here. You know, if a just you know, if Justice Alito says that Trump is right,
like, how wrong can he be? So I do think that there is a real danger in taking this case,
you know, for the health and vitality of the 14th Amendment and the Citizenship Clause.
So, you know, I think different people can, you know, debate strategically what they wanted the
court to do since Trump did do this executive order and it has moved through the courts.
There are probably people that argued that the Supreme Court should have just shut it down by
not taking the case or like some sort of one sentence curium opinion to just sort of like,
you know, dismiss it out of hand and, you know, put the administration back in its place.
Maybe people want a robust 9-0 opinion, sort of reaffirming everything that we
have known and thought about the 14th Amendment for 150 years. I think like the strategy of that
one can debate, but I don't think we're we are certainly not getting the first option.
And I don't think we're going to get the second option. I think I do not think we're going to get
a unanimous opinion. And I think that, you know, that in itself is really a testament to how far
Trump and John Roberts have moved the country.
I think that's right. And, you know, that oral argument, the reports coming out,
and I listened to it as well, you know, the idea that Sam Alito and possibly Clarence
Thomas would go along with Trump, they've been the most extreme on an extreme court
in terms of their willingness to just bend over backwards and make the case for Trump,
act like advocates for Trump in lots of ways, including around immunity and more,
and the special counsel, you know, Jack Smith investigation with Clarence Thomas sort of
instructing how to deep six that investigation and more. So I, you know, it should be a 9-0
decision. This should be an open and shut case, but it's not. And there was something else that
you mentioned that that struck me, you know, when you were reprising John Sowers arguments,
this is the former criminal defense attorney for Donald Trump, who is now the Solicitor General
of the United States, in his arguments before the Supreme Court in which he was trying to claim
that the only way that you can really get citizenship is through like showing some
sort of loyalty that you've relinquished your ties to some other country. But obviously,
we have dual citizenship for a number of people. Elon Musk has dual citizenship,
Peter Thiel has dual citizenship. So where's the relinquishment of their loyalty to
some other country in that way? But also, we have Donald Trump offering, like basically allowing
people to buy green cards in the United States who have no loyalty, they just have cash.
And so, you know, the argument that was put forward about, you know, some sort of theoretical
loyalty that you don't have if you're on a green card, that's not true. A lot of people
who are here, hundreds of thousands, millions of people who come to the United States through
green cards, working for U.S. companies, serving their communities, they have deep ties to their
community here, to their families and friends and their neighbors here, and want to stay here.
A lot of them are working to, you know, move that, you know, move from being a lawful current
resident to becoming a citizen because they love the United States. They love, you know,
the opportunities here. And they have children who are U.S. citizens who are born here. And so,
the sort of claim that Sauer posits is defined by the reality of how things work and how people
who are being, would be mistreated, their children would be mistreated under this rule
because their children are U.S. citizens, are somehow in a worse position than people that
Donald Trump wants to give to give cash to get legal permission in the United States.
I wonder if you have any thoughts on that before we wrap, Tema.
Yeah, definitely. Look, one of the things that, in the people I've talked to, is so frustrating
about Donald Trump's argument, John Sauer's argument, the arguments of John Eastman,
Elon Werman, Richard Epstein, is that they make no sense. They're just really bad arguments,
and they are disingenuous arguments. So, not only do they not make sense now, right? Not only do
they not actually comport with how our immigration system works, and to your point about those green
cards, they don't comport, they don't make sense in 1866 when they're crafting the 14th amendment,
right? Because the overarching point of the citizenship clause is to overturn Dred Scott
and ensure that the newly freed people are citizens on equal footing with everyone else.
Well, the newly free people did not choose to be here. They were not protected by this country,
and they did not offer allegiance to this country. So, it would have actually disqualified
the very people that the amendment was meant to give citizenship to. At the same time,
no one questioned whether or not the children born in the confederate states during the war
would be citizens when they were born in territory not controlled by this country,
by people who were literally considered to have committed treason. They were not
giving allegiance to the United States government. They were trying to leave it,
right? They were not protected by it. Their towns were being destroyed by it,
right? And no one said, like, those children are not citizens, right? So,
absolutely from the very moment it was written, their idea makes no sense. And you don't have to
be a lawyer or a genius to understand that it just makes no sense. And it continues to not
make sense and to just spawn chaos and inequality and suffering. The more you think about how it
would be applied into the future. And so, I think that for the scholars who have just entered this
debate, it's just like you just want to tear your hair out. Because there's such an obvious
sort of ideological and partisan motivation here. It's so much about this sort of
retrograde country that they want the United States to be. And it is absolutely not about
history or the law or common sense in any way.
Yeah. Wow. That was just so well put. It's been an honor to have this conversation with you today,
Pema. Really so appreciate your deep reporting, your investigations, your analysis
for Mother Jones Magazine and for the world, the work you're doing as a journalist. I really
appreciate it. I'm Lisa Graves with Court Accountability Action. We are here on Legal AF,
part of the Midas Touch Network. Please subscribe and like to get content like this,
to get more. And Pema, please come back. We'd love to have you come back on and
talk about your next story and other stories that are in the queue anytime. I really appreciate your
courageous, truth-telling journalism. Thanks, Pema. Thank you so much.
Oh, it's really fun. Thank you for having me.
Can't get your fill of Legal AF? Me neither. That's why we formed the Legal AF Substack.
Every time we mention something in a hot take, whether it's a court filing or a oral argument,
come over to the Substack. You'll find the court filing and the oral argument there,
including a daily roundup that I do call, wait for it, Morning AF. What else? All the other
contributors from Legal AF are there as well. We got some new reporting. We got interviews. We got
ad-free versions of the podcast and hot takes. Where? Legal AF on Substack. Come over now to
free subscribe.
