Youmans Claim (USA v Mexico) (Protection of Foreigners from state officials)

Global Affairs Academy
6 followers
2 Video Views·Jun 18, 2026
In this international law case, Mexico was held to be responsible for murders carried out by Mexican police, even when it was clear that they were disobeying their orders.
AI Generated·May contain errors
This case began as a dispute between a Mexican worker and his American boss on a tunnel digging
project in Mexico in 1880.
The worker claimed to have been underpaid by 12 cents.
The American was offended by the worker's conduct towards him and ejected him from the house.
Things escalated.
The worker and his friends began throwing rocks at the American and at other Americans
in his house.
They advanced with a machete.
The American fired into the air with a pistol and then fired a shotgun at the man with the
machete.
Things escalated further.
Soon a mob surrounded the house, perhaps a thousand people.
The Americans called on the local mayor for assistance and he sent an armed detachment
of police.
Instead of restoring order, however, those police fired on the house, killing the Americans
inside.
Eumenes was one of the Americans killed.
His son sought compensation from the Mexican authorities.
The question of law was whether the state of Mexico was responsible for the conduct
of its officials, in this case its police, when those officials were acting directly
contrary to the orders they had been given.
The commission acknowledged that sometimes an official who grossly exceeds their authority
might reach the point where their conduct can't be attributed to the state.
However they said,
because any such wrongful act must be considered to be outside the scope of his competency.
If this were the meaning intended by the rule, it would follow that no wrongful acts committed
by an official could be considered as acts for which his government could be held liable.
From this they concluded that Mexico could be, and in fact was, responsible for the conduct
of its officers, even when they weren't following orders.
They then considered what happened after the crime and said,
This also led to liability for Mexico.
The principles emerging from this case are that states have an obligation to protect
foreign nationals from harm by their officers, and to diligently investigate if such harm
occurs.
For more information visit www.fema.gov
