The US and Iran announced a new deal to halt the fighting and reopen the Strait of Hormuz. And while the details of the agreement haven’t been made public what's clear is that Donald Trump has failed to achieve almost every one of his goals in this war. The future of Iran’s nuclear program, for example, has yet to be decided. The issue still has to be negotiated over the course of a new sixty-day ceasefire set to begin after the signing of this framework agreement in Switzerland on Friday. But when Trump announced that a deal had been reached yesterday he didn’t mention any of that. Instead, you had him celebrating the possibility of a return to the pre-war status quo—writing on social media:
“I hereby fully authorize the toll free opening of the Strait of Hormuz, and, simultaneously herewith, authorize the immediate removal of the United States Naval blockade.” “Ships of the World, start your engines. Let the oil flow!” He then claimed in a subsequent that “many presidents” had tried to make peace with Iran
before him but all had failed—adding: “The Leaders of the Region have, for the first time, found a President who can help them achieve real Peace.”
But let’s review, shall we? The US and Israel attacked Iran on February 28th—killing the supreme leader, numerous other high-ranking officials, and more than 100 schoolchildren. Trump and his team laid out several other constantly shifting and sometimes contradicting objectives and justifications for the war. And—in addition to keeping Iran from ever having a nuclear weapon, which US intelligence agencies had not found Iran was pursuing—these included:1) destroying Iran’s military and especially ballistic missile capabilities; 2) ending its support for regional proxy groups; and 3) enabling the Iranian people to rise up and overthrow the regime.
Trump initially claimed the US would accomplish these goals in “four to five weeks.” And—just one week after the strikes started—he said Iran’s only path to a deal was “unconditional surrender.” But months later US intelligence showed Iran retained significant missile capabilities—and we’ve seen no indication that the new deal includes restrictions. And Iran has reportedly made it clear that it intends to keep building ballistic missiles. And it has also reportedly made clear that it will keep supporting its proxy forces as best it can—including Hezbollah in Lebanon, Hamas in Palestine, and the Houthis in Yemen. —————————— Produced by: Cory Ray, Philip DeFranco Edited by: James Girardier, Maxwell Enright, Julie Goldberg, Christian Meeks, Matthew Henry Art Department: William Crespo Writing/Research: Jared Paolino, Philip DeFranco ———————————— #Iran#Trump#StraitofHormuz
AI Generated·May contain errors
The United States and Iran have halted combat and resumed reopening the Strait of Hormuz.
It has announced a new preliminary agreement.
The details of this agreement have not yet been made public, but President Donald Trump
I have not achieved nearly everything I aimed for in this war
It seems to be.
For example, the future of Iran's nuclear program has not yet been decided.
This issue will commence after the signing of the basic agreement, on Friday in Switzerland.
It is stated that the issue must be resolved through negotiations during the new 60-day ceasefire period.
Interestingly, yesterday President Trump announced that the agreement had been reached.
This point was not mentioned at all.
appearing as though celebrating the possibility of returning to the state before the war
It appeared.
In his statement, he fully endorsed the free access to the Strait of Hormuz while simultaneously
It announced the immediate lifting of the U.S. maritime blockade.
shouting, "Engines on, let the oil flow from ships across the globe!"
Many presidents have attempted peace with Iran before, but all
I have failed, and only now do the local leaders finally realize true peace.
He claimed to have found a president who can do it.
Well then, let's summarize.
The United States and Israel attacked Iran on February 28, targeting its supreme leader and numerous
High-ranking officials and more than 100 students died.
Trump and his aides have presented various objectives and justifications for this war.
Yet those justifications constantly changed and sometimes even contradicted each other.
evidence that Iran is actually developing nuclear weapons, according to U.S. intelligence agencies
Beyond preventing Iran from acquiring nuclear weapons, despite not having found it
The objectives include destroying Iran's military capabilities, particularly its ballistic missile capacity, and Iran's regional proxies.
Cease support for the regime and overthrow the government through the air of the Iranian people.
It was included.
Trump initially said the U.S. would achieve these goals within four to five weeks.
argued that it was the case.
He said the only way was unconditional surrender.
However, a few months later, U.S. intelligence officials stated that Iran still possessed significant missile capabilities.
demonstrated that it possesses, and imposed sanctions measures regarding the new proposal
There is no evidence whatsoever that it is included.
It has been clearly stated that Iran intends to continue its development of ballistic missiles.
Also, Hezbollah, the Palestinian Hamas, the Houthi rebels of Yemen
will continue to support Iran's proxy forces, such as the Houthi rebels, to the greatest extent possible
It's said that the viscosity was clarified.
Therefore, as President Trump has sometimes claimed, a coup d'état is impossible.
It seems so.
It is the very regime that slaughtered thousands in a brutal crackdown on protests earlier this year.
The hardliners may actually have gained greater power by now.
Moreover, this agreement includes no measures capable of checking the hardliners.
There is no evidence that it has become so.
In an interview with The New York Times, President Trump said Iran was again sending protesters.
Receive up to $25 billion in frozen funds and sanctions relief if killed
I said it would be countless, but the current draft of the agreement does contain such conditions.
It is said that it is not specified at all.
In lieu of that, issues regarding sanctions relief and asset freezes will be addressed in future talks with Iran concerning its nuclear program.
Even judging solely by the current situation, the issue that is most difficult for both sides to reach an agreement on is
These are the issues that the United States and Iran have still not resolved.
Nevertheless, President Trump acted as if he had already concluded everything, despite such circumstances.
It is acting as if it is falling.
even before officially announcing the agreement on negotiations, let alone additional negotiations
Although the agreement had merely laid the groundwork, President Trump nonetheless used social media
Through media, claiming to have achieved better results than former President Barack Obama
claimed it had done so.
The nuclear deal signed in 2015 during the Obama administration
has opened an easy and smooth path for Iran to develop nuclear weapons.
Argued.
Moreover, if Iran had not abrogated the agreement, it would already have nuclear weapons.
even went so far as to argue that they had developed and used it.
That claim seems to have absolutely no basis in reality.
At least in part, because the Obama deal worked properly.
Yes.
Under the Obama deal, Iran transferred 97% of its enriched uranium stockpile to Russia.
I have sent it.
as well as the agreement from the end of Obama's term to the first term of President Trump
Complied with the specified concentration limits.
However, after President Trump withdrew from the agreement, Iran reached its highest level ever.
And ultimately, Iran could produce enough uranium for 10 to 12 nuclear weapons.
It has stockpiled it.
Of course, we did not actually develop nuclear weapons, and as far as we know, we had no such plans.
There was none.
Now, one of the key issues that must be addressed is exactly that uranium reserve amount.
It has been completed.
Trump stated in the post that the U.S. would enter Iran once the situation calms down.
claimed it would recover its stockpile of high-enriched uranium, but Iran's stockpile
Only half of the quantity is to be handed over, and the remaining half can be used solely for civilian purposes.
There have been reports that it agreed to dilute it to a certain level.
Another important issue is how long Iran will suspend uranium enrichment.
That is the point.
In an interview with The New York Times, Trump said he would push for a 20-year halt to enrichment.
has stated, but later in the negotiation process, it was indicated that an agreement could be reached within 15 years.
He said.
It is the same period that Iran agreed to under the nuclear deal during the Obama administration.
However, the Obama agreement allowed enrichment only up to 3.67%, whereas Trump's stance was different.
It argues that the concentration level must be discontinued.
Moreover, in an interview with The New York Times, Trump stated that Iran is using it for military purposes.
Permanently prohibit enriching uranium to a level usable for purposes of weapons
he said that.
He did not specify the exact ratio, but he probably himself did not know it.
It might be because it's impossible.
And ultimately, all of this has not yet even officially begun.
It depends on the negotiation.
The reason a former U.S. ambassador to Israel posted a message on social media also
That's exactly it.
As for the nuclear issue, an actual agreement has not been reached.
There is a possibility that no agreement will be reached at all, and even if an agreement is reached,
much more than could have been obtained through diplomacy before the war
The likelihood of a bad outcome is high.
Overall, many experts are adopting a critical perspective.
Some experts say that the United States is demanding complex new surveillance and verification measures.
It argues that they did not demonstrate the patience required to complete nuclear negotiations.
But the nuclear issue is not the only one.
Of course it is natural for us to focus considerable attention on the nuclear issue, but that is not all.
This is not all.
Another issue is that President Trump misrepresented the contents of the agreement with Iran.
The point is that they made another argument.
In addition to reopening traffic flows in the Hormuz Strait, he also
It said that Iran has agreed to open the strait for research purposes without tolls.
Done.
However, Iran's Ministry of Foreign Affairs spokesperson stated today that Iran is passing vessels through the strait.
It suggests that fees may be charged for the services provided.
Done.
Therefore, we must closely monitor how the situation develops in the future.
In any case, even if the strait were fully reopened, it would not happen immediately.
There are still remnants that need to be removed, and oil production and refining facilities also need to be restarted.
must be done
Moreover, shipping companies are fully confident that passing through the strait is actually safe.
It may take some time to get there.
In fact, the chairman of a certain shipping company is confident about navigating vessels to the Persian Gulf.
saying it might take several weeks or even months, yet still unresolved
Despite all these circumstances and uncertainties, the market reacted very positively to this news.
Responded positively.
Oil prices fell by nearly 5%, dropping to around $83 per barrel, the lowest level in months.
A significantly lower figure than $126.
Still significantly higher than the pre-war price of $73
It is.
Meanwhile, the average U.S. gasoline price is approximately 37% higher than it was at the onset of the war.
It maintains a high level.
As you can see, there is a possibility that prices may surge again if the situation deteriorates.
One of the main causes that could lead to such a situation occurring is Israel.
The siege and attack on Neve Yamin.
Israel bombed the church area in southern Beirut once again just before the announcement of the agreement.
It nearly caused the agreement to collapse.
Former President Trump said on social media that the agreement was imminent.
The attack occurred, and Israel will no longer conduct attacks anywhere in the Neve Zohar region.
We strongly warned against attacking Israel.
Although this preliminary agreement has been reached, Iran insists on including Hezbollah in all matters.
Alleging that it includes the content of immediately halting military operations on the front lines.
Done.
However, President Trump asked whether the ceasefire would also apply to the fighting inside Lebanon.
Has not been publicly mentioned.
Israel and Hezbollah, who are actually engaged in combat in Lebanon this time
No measures were taken in accordance with the agreement.
Israeli leaders have already clearly stated their position that they are not bound by this agreement.
Revealing this, Israel's Defense Minister stated in a statement this morning that he and Netanyahu
The prime minister stated that he opposes the withdrawal of the Israeli military from Nevalon.
We will have to watch and see how the situation unfolds from now on.
But in the end, Iran's decision to launch the attack resulted in thousands of deaths from starvation, among whom were
It seems that almost nothing has actually been achieved in this situation.
Iran has weakened militarily but has not been completely defeated.
And it seems to have significantly enhanced our negotiation power, oddly enough.
That's right, there was always the threat of escalating tension, wasn't there?
What will happen to America? They are changing the direction of the Strait of Hormuz.
It has practically proven that it can stand up to the world's largest military power.