Your support is very much appreciated. Thanks, guys!
AI Generated·May contain errors
So just a quick phone vlog from the house today.
I want to talk a little bit about this AUR situation.
So the ARCH user repository has had,
like last I checked, 2000 packages or so
that were compromised as far as
they were infected with malware.
So, you know, some bad actor, probably some group,
some nefarious hacker group, maybe even a foreign entity.
You never know about these things.
They have targeted the AUR.
Basically what they've done is the AUR has a system
where orphaned packages can be adopted by a new maintainer.
So this group or this person,
they're going through and all these unmaintained packages,
and because the AUR is filled with tens of thousands,
I don't know, maybe a hundred thousand or more packages.
It's a very large repository of user contributed software.
They're going through,
finding all of these thousands of orphaned packages,
and they're saying, Hey, I'll maintain it.
And then when they're able to maintain it, you know,
they take ownership of it.
And what they do is then they insert into the package build.
Basically they, through using NPM or BUN,
they install this malware, right?
They install this payload that then tries to spy on you
in some way.
It tries to get your SSH keys and API keys,
for those of you that are a developer
and have a lot of API keys laying around on your system.
I'm sure it's probably taking a look at your browser history
and things like that.
Probably password managers,
like it's doing some really nefarious stuff.
It's scary stuff.
And all of us should be concerned.
I've checked all the packages that I have installed.
I don't think anything I had installed
from the AUR was infected.
Plus I haven't taken an update on my home computer here
in about two weeks.
So this runs Arch Linux.
My office computer runs Cache OS
and I hadn't done an update
in about three weeks on that machine.
I'm gonna give it a couple more weeks,
which is a very long time to go
on a rolling release distro like Arch.
Because going more than a month without an update,
I'm gonna have a lot of packages to update
when I update my machines.
There could be some breakages,
but it's what we have to do, right?
That's all we can do right now
because I'm not gonna take a chance
that some infected piece of software gets put on my machine
and then they steal my SSH keys, for example.
And then they've got access to things like, I don't know,
my various GitLab repos, some of my web servers.
There's a lot of sensitive information
on some of that stuff too.
Got private repositories on some of the servers.
I've got API keys on scripts
that are running on some of my servers.
Again, it's dangerous stuff
and I can't take that chance.
You can't take that chance either.
So if you're running an Arch-based system,
just don't take an update as far as your AUR packages.
If you've got things that are installed from the AUR,
consider uninstalling all of it if you can.
For me, I've got some AUR packages installed
that I can't uninstall
because I have to have those pieces of software.
There are things, unfortunately, in the AUR
that you just can't find anywhere else.
They're not packaged anywhere else.
I know people will say,
well, you've got snaps, you've got flatpaks,
you've got app images.
Yeah, but not everything's gonna be available,
especially as a flatpak.
People often push flatpak, like flatpak.
Can you go find a flatpak for everything?
No, because flatpak is actually designed
specifically for desktop applications.
And a lot of the things people are grabbing from the AUR
are not desktop applications.
They're command line applications,
server kind of applications, libraries,
things like that.
That cannot ever be packaged as a flatpak.
It doesn't work as a flatpak.
So snaps, oddly enough, do work on the server.
Snaps are actually great as far as installing
server software, command line software.
App images also work for that as well.
I've actually run the bash shell
and the phish shell before as app images.
That does work.
But still, there are gonna be some things
that are in the AUR you'll never find anywhere else.
And if you need it, you kind of have to use it.
So for me, there's two or three packages
on each of my machines that I've installed
from the AUR that I just can't get rid of.
But most of the stuff I can get rid of, and I have.
I've gone through my package list
of everything installed from the AUR.
I uninstalled everything that I either don't need
or I could find in another format.
I've installed several packages now
as flatpaks on this machine.
I've got a couple of snaps running.
I've got one app image on this machine
and the office computer on an application
that I have to use every day.
And it is available in the AUR,
but I'm gonna run it as an app image.
I'm gonna run several things as flatpaks,
a couple of things as snaps.
And I'm just, you know, the AUR right now,
I'm just gonna stay away from it.
Matter of fact, one of the questions
and comments I've been getting is,
hey, is it just time to ditch Arch?
Is Arch so insecure?
Maybe I should run somewhere else.
And I think that's probably something
that I wouldn't consider right now.
For one thing, you don't wanna overreact
because all of these package formats are vulnerable.
Anybody can infect any repository of software.
The AUR, I guess, is an easier target,
but we've seen malware in the Snap Store.
We've seen malware in flatpaks.
App images don't even have a central repository
where all app images go.
People just put app images all over the internet
and you as the user go and download random app images
from all over the internet.
And it would be very easy for a user
to go grab a app image that was malware, right?
You just have to be careful
where you go and grab these things.
Make sure you're grabbing,
whether you're installing AUR packages
or snaps or app images or flatpaks,
what's that package by the actual maintainer
of that piece of software?
If it's an official package
from the official developers of that software,
you can probably trust it.
If it's not, you're always taking a chance
regardless of the package format.
So I'm not going to nuke and pave or reinstall,
especially since I don't think I was infected anyway.
Now, if you think you downloaded one of those packages
from the AUR and you think you might've been infected,
you should format the drive this instant
and reinstall to whatever distro.
But you need to wipe out
because you need to wipe out this existing distro
because this is not going to end well
if they get ahold of some of that sensitive information
that's stored on your computer.
So, but right now I'm just in a wait and see.
Gonna wait a couple of weeks before I take any updates
and see how the Arch team handles this situation.
See if it all gets fixed or not.
And I'm not against the idea of hopping.
Obviously I've used desktop Linux for 20 years, right?
And I've used dozens of different distributions
on production equipment.
I've tried hundreds of distros, right?
In virtual machines.
So I'm not against the idea of hopping to something else.
It's just, you know, I don't want to hop unnecessarily
because I'm just going to hop to a different distro
and make it the same as this one.
In the end, it'll be the same distribution
running the same software.
I like it, it'll be the same thing.
I'm going to run the same Fish Shield
with the same command line utilities,
running the same Emacs,
running probably the Neary scrolling window manager, right?
So wherever I go, but if I was to hop,
you know, I don't know what I would run.
I would want to run another rolling release, right?
I want rolling release distros on these machines.
I don't want to go back to old and crusty.
I'm not going to go to Debian stable.
I'm not going to go to Ubuntu LTS.
It has to be a rolling release distro.
What do you guys think?
If I were to hop, say if in a couple of weeks,
I think the Arch team isn't doing a good job
and I had to hop,
what would you recommend for a rolling release distro
that has good software availability?
So it can't be a rolling distro
where their repositories kind of suck
and you can't find software, right?
I don't want that.
You know, I'll stick to Arch and deal with malware
before I go to a distro that, you know,
their repositories are kind of light on software.
One interesting thing I do want to mention
is I know the Arch team tells everybody
not to use the AUR, right?
It's kind of one of those things.
Hey, the AUR is fantastic.
It's great.
It's one of the defining features of Arch,
but don't use it, right?
And I find that kind of silly,
especially since most Arch users
are almost forced to use the AUR
because there are pieces of software in the AUR
that are extremely popular pieces of software.
And I don't understand why the Arch team
doesn't move the really popular programs
that are in the AUR over into the core repositories.
For example, maybe the most popular piece of software
in the AUR is the Brave browser.
Why do I have to go to the AUR
to install the Brave browser?
You know, very popular web browser these days,
growing in popularity.
Probably has tens of millions,
maybe hundreds of millions of people around the world
using it, not on Arch Linux,
obviously most of those people are running Windows,
but very popular piece of software.
Why is it in the AUR, right?
Zoom, Zoom, almost everybody has to use Zoom
at some point in corporate environments,
in universities, it's proprietary software.
But here's the thing,
Arch does not have a ban on proprietary software
in their core repositories.
For example, I think Discord is actually
in the Arch repository, standard Arch repositories.
Why is Zoom in the AUR?
That's another piece of software,
probably hundreds of millions of people around the world
use Zoom, right?
It's very popular piece of software.
You shouldn't have to go to this place
you tell us not to go to get the Brave browser
or to get Zoom.
And there's a lot of other, to get Spotify,
very popular app also in the AUR.
Several very popular browsers,
I mean, I've mentioned Brave,
but you've got other things that are less popular,
but still pretty popular,
especially in the FOSS space,
the free and open source software space.
LibreWolf is in there.
Things like, is unGoogled Chromium in there
or is that in the standard repositories?
I can't remember.
I know regular Google Chrome is in the AUR.
Why?
Put that in the core repository, have that maintained.
You know, if you get the top 10 to 20 AUR packages
that are really popular,
if you just move that stuff into the core repository,
you saw probably half the number of people
that go to the AUR wouldn't have to go to the AUR
if you get the stuff that really matters
into the core repository.
Now, you're still gonna have those people
that have to go there for obscure libraries,
obscure drivers that are for not 20 year old hardware.
I mean, that's where the AUR kind of shines.
It's for that stuff that's really niche.
And there will always be people that have to use it for that,
but I shouldn't have to go to the AUR
for really popular pieces of software
like a Zoom or Spotify or something like that.
That should just be in the standard Arch repos.
And maybe the Arch team will take notice of that
and fix that problem.
And that's a problem I've been complaining about
for several years now.
I've been a brave browser user
for about four or five years now
because it's become pretty popular.
I've never understood why,
as this thing has grown in popularity,
I still have to go to the AUR to get it.
It doesn't make sense.
Anyway, super thought these guys.