What Happens When You Mulch Your Garden With Hay

My Green Garden
1 follower
1 Video View·Jun 17, 2026
In this video Peni Ediker & I explore the benefits of growing vegetables using hay and dried grass as a mulch. We cover some of the key questions people have such as weed problems and slugs based on our own experience of using hay as a mulch for many growing seasons. I hope you find this so useful.
…
AI Generated·May contain errors
This video we're exploring hay as a mulch for growing particularly vegetables and we're going
to go over and see what Penny is doing. She's been working with hay as a mulch for a few growing
seasons now and then at the end I'm going to come back and kind of round off with three
key points that I've learned over the years of using hay as a mulch.
So to hay mulch or not to hay mulch? I've been using straw for years but then straw you can't
really find it organically so it's sprayed with glyphosate which is carcinogenic so I don't want
that in my garden. So I've moved to hay. Hay has more health benefits for the soil because hay
has more proteins in it. If you think what hay is used for it's to feed horses over winter months
and animals so it's got some goodness in it. I use hay for mulching and to keep the moisture
to lock it in the ground. Sometimes had a bit of bad luck with hay it can give you seeds
but to make weeds but then weeds are going to come anyway. So over here I didn't have time
to go and get the last bit of hay and so this bed was weed free two weeks ago and then look at that
there's a creeping buttercup so that has come because there's no mulch and if we go underneath
the mulch there isn't any weeds. Well not yet. So there is pros and cons. I mean I generally
use the hay mulch for long standing veg so when I mean long standing veg I'm thinking about
the vegetables that are going to be in the ground for over winter or for like seven months. Say
I planted the garlic in October and it's going to be there until end of June beginning of July
and I really need to mulch that and I need to keep the moisture in and I need to keep the weeds
off even though the weeds have been getting away from me and if we look underneath the hay
it's we've just got this lovely lovely soil because when the hay breaks down it's feeding
microbiology so it's creating organic matter. So I've used hay when I clear garden beds
and I give a really good top hay mulch and then it keeps the moisture in and then when I pull
back the hay there's lots of worms because it's feeding the microbiology. Another use of hay
I have launched into flower growing and I mulch my dahlias with hay. So this year I cut the last
winter I cut the dahlias back and I gave them a good two foot of hay and then I covered with a
black plastic and when I uncovered them I didn't have loads and loads of weeds there's the usual
weeds that you get in the garden which in a no dig way you just keep hoeing your weeds anyway
and not having the weeding so if you're on top of your weeds you're just tickling the soil
and up rooting and the roots but then here there you go I have creeping buttercup anyway
and there you go it's in it's made its way in but from having a really good mulch it's really easy
to pull up a weed and I'm not struggling and fighting it's just come up really easy so that's
the other benefit of using hay I am holding a slug here that I need to get rid of when you weed
it's just really easy because it's just actually growing in the hay so I find that's a really good
benefit but I feel like it's breaking down organic matter and then it's keeping the moisture in
that's the main uses of hay it's really important to mulch whether it's hay or straw
and using wood chip is a good mulch but you've just got to be mindful not to get wood chip into
planting holes because otherwise you're going to get a nutrient lock up and your plants are going
to look unhealthy but I think wood chip is really good wood chip also harbors slugs but so does hay
and hay slugs are part of the world and we've got to live with them experiment this year
I've noticed on my west facing side of my polytunnel the soil gets really caked it gets
really really hot and then it really dries out and when soil dries out you get all sorts of problems
it's really easy to get ants and spider mites and whatnot so I've decided to give it a go
and do a hay mulch in my polytunnel just to help with keeping the moisture in and not drying out
my soil I might regret this I might end up having lots of weeds but I don't have lots of weeds all
over my other garden beds from using this hay I think one thing to think about if you're
going to use hay is where does it come from my neighbours cut hay for their horses they don't
like last year's hay and they like good quality hay so it doesn't tend to have loads of seeds in
but it's going to have the odd seed weed you know professionally if you're going to grow garlic
you'd have to have irrigation systems and I can't do that all over the farm so I really mulch with
hay or straw I prefer hay because straw also doesn't break down to the same and yeah I do get
some grass weeds but what I notice in sort of when we have those droughts of like this year was April
March and April the soil underneath the hay is still moist whereas if I didn't have that mulch
on there my garlic would be really small and it's not it's chunky and healthy because the soil is
being fed and we need to think about feeding the soil a couple of weeks ago I harvested this these
beds so I had my main crop potatoes and I had my elephant garlic so as soon as the crops were out
I top dressed with the mulch to keep the microbe population healthy and happy in this soil
and then I did a phacelia green manure that's looking rather lush I'll keep an eye on it and
when it grows up just before that it's going to flower I'll cut and drop that and then leave it
as a mulch over the winter and with this I'm probably going to sow a few winter cabbages in
here and net and then anything else will have a green manure and green manures that I recommend
are phacelia buckwheat and tares and try and avoid Italian ryegrass we want a community a rich
diverse community of microbes in in the soil and to help against pathogens and disease and just to
help create community in the soil just as we need diversity of plants in our gardens and small
holdings to help with pollinators insects and then just as we are connected to the plant kingdom
we're the human kingdom but we the soil has a biome we have a biome so it's also really beneficial to
eat fermented foods and basically it's all about microbes it's microbes on the leaves of the plants
it's microbes in the soil in the mulch it's microbes in our guts when we eat fermented food
and basically we're like 10% human and 90% microbes and it's the microbes that are running this show
so everyone loves growing potatoes and growing good potatoes they need to be earthed up so that
then the plant produces more tubers I've already earthed these up with compost but then I'm running
out of compost so another way to do it is hay if I just tuck them up with hay and it's a really
good mulch I've also grown potatoes in hay and straw and had really really good crops if it's
damp enough my favorite crop uh kale it's all blowing in the wind this bed has been mulch of
hay for years it's had garlic in it and it's had brassicas then it's got brassicas again
but my soil from hay that's no added compost that's hay being broken down over the years
look at the till it's absolutely gorgeous and it just goes down and down and down and down
and it's just like hay breaks down and feeds the soil and you just get this beautiful beautiful
soil from it and you know this bed's been mulched with hay probably for the last three years and I
haven't had touch wood um loads and loads of weeds let's talk about onions so guess what
I mulch my onions with hay or straw a friend of mine's onions um have just bolted and I feel
really sad for my friend but they weren't mulched and so the soil really really dries out and then
it starts raining and then you know the time for an onion to go to seed is around now so if they
if they're not keeping watered and they're not mulched then the plants get stressed and the
bolts but they've got they've got their hay mulch going on and we'll probably I think I
looked at the forecast and the forecast is um after around the 18th of June we're gonna go
banging into heat wave again so as much as we can we want to lock that moisture in the ground
and we can lock it in with a good mulch there's three main considerations that I would put forward
with working with hay as a mulch and the first thing is as Penny had mentioned the kind of the
worry about weeds and obviously there are going to be depending on where you source your hay from
or if you're getting grass clippings and drying that there might be or will be weed seeds in now
it's not going to be a problem when you're using hay as a mulch it is going to be a problem when
you remove the hay and then you expose the bare ground and that is where the weeds then want to
grow through so there's two ways of approaching it one way is to use a permanent hay mulch bed
system like this the other way is when you then remove the hay you could then hoe it a couple of
times just to allow the weeds to come through to have that flush to kind of clear a lot of the
weed seed bank and then plant into it but really you could also additionally look at other mulches
as well now the other consideration is the fact that definitely using hay can create a slug habitat
but there's a couple of really important points that I want to make clear the first point is that
almost any mulch that you can use can create a slug habitat be it grass clippings even like
using wood chips but also sometimes things work really strangely and we've done whole fields
before we've put down hay and then we've grown squash in them and we haven't had a single bit
of slug issue one of the key things that you need to understand though about hay is that it creates
underneath the perfect conditions of cool temperature moisture and that carbon for ground
beetles to dwell and for the ground beetles larvae then ground beetles are a ferocious predator
when it comes to slug so what we're doing here this is going to be where we're going to grow a
big patch of winter squash and it's going to break down and we're going to use the the natural
habitat for the ground beetles to help with managing the slug population and keep this
potentially keep this as a pretty much a permanently hay mulched area for the years to come
and just build that long-term habitat now if you want to build some confidence in using hay and
dried grass in your garden as a way of mulching the the area to go is perennials so here we've
got some we've got some trees that we've planted and we've got this dried grass and I can place
this around the base just to help stop any weeds coming through it's going to break down and add
fertility so anywhere where you have like fruit trees young trees saplings as well as soft fruit
currencies kind of things which don't have any issues when it comes to slugs and it doesn't
matter because you can just keep on piling up more to kind of hide and choke out any weeds
that's a really good place to start using hay in your garden to help you grow here in the
polytunnel the easiest thing that we can do to reduce the amount of water that evaporates is
to provide a hay mulch and because we're always going to be growing things like tomatoes every
year I don't worry about the weeds yes the the hay will just let it break down next year when
it comes to planting again you just put down more mulch whatever that may be so it's just
a very simple thing that we can do to add to create that fertility to activate the whole
soil food web to break down this organic material into organic matter
that then is going to help us grow nice healthy crops
