MetLife Disability Benefit Denial Tactics

Disability Insurance
6 followers
7 Video Views·Jun 16, 2026
MetLife disability insurance claims are full of discrepancies, where on paper it sounds good but in reality, there are tactics for them to deny your MetLife short-term disability claim. MetLife’s claim forms aren’t universal, they’re biased and very vague. Be careful when you read your MetLife disability insurance claim forms.
AI Generated·May contain errors
Hi, I'm Greg Dell with Attorneys Dell and Schaefer, and I'm here with Attorneys Rachel
Alters, and we're going to discuss today MetLife Disability Claim Tactics.
And Rachel, this is the first video that you and I are filming remotely.
Usually we're doing this in our studio in our main office, but I'm really excited about
the ability to start filming again and also for our podcast to be able to get back to
providing all these helpful videos for the claimants nationwide that we've been able
to help.
But today specifically, we want to talk about MetLife Disability Claim Tactics, and getting
right into it with you, what do you see as basically the number one thing that MetLife
is relying upon to deny a long-term disability claim?
What I see most often with MetLife and the denials is that early on, whether it's right
when the person gets on claim or before LTD is approved, they will have a nurse consultant
hired to do a peer review of the claimant's medical records and render opinions that the
claimant's no longer disabled or was never disabled in the first place, and then they'll
deny the claim.
They do this early on as a tactic, so it appears as if they save money so they don't have to
hire a physician to review the records, so they'll hire this nurse, she'll review records,
and then the claimant will say to me, well, how is it that a nurse is even qualified to
review my records and render a medical opinion?
She's not.
So this is what they do early on in claims.
There's a body of law called ERISA, which governs many of these MetLife claims because
their employer provided benefits, and you mentioned that very often in the initial denial
by MetLife, they'll use a nurse when a claimant has three or four doctors.
So how can the person who's working for MetLife have a nurse review three or four doctors'
records, the nurse has nowhere near the training or experience of a medical doctor, has never
even seen the claimant, and yet that's considered a basis for a denial?
Is that reasonable?
Well, I don't believe it's reasonable, and I don't think a federal judge would either,
but they get away with it because they do it in the initial claim denial.
So once the claimant appeals, they will respond to the appeal with, usually, the proper physicians
to do the paper review.
They'll hire the proper specialist to correct their mistake, and they do get away with that
because as long as it's corrected before they get to trial, the judge usually says, okay,
well, at some point, they did hire the proper physician to review the record.
So it does seem unfair, but they do get away with it oftentimes.
Yeah, but you were being generous, calling it correcting their mistake, because I don't
think it's a mistake that they used a nurse.
I think it's a calculated plan that they know, let me use a nurse because I know no matter
what, if I deny the claim, there's no consequences whatsoever to MetLife to denying an initial
claim.
The claimant can't sue them right away because they're required by ERISA to file an appeal.
So basically, they're strong-arming a claimant into more time without payments, having to
do an appeal, possibly have to hire a lawyer to help with an appeal, and go through the
45 to 90 days to wait for an appeal.
So it's just a delay tactic and very poor claim handling.
I'm not saying Met does this on every claim, but I don't think they should be able to do
it on any claim where they just use a nurse.
Agreed.
So the next thing I move into is you mentioned that they should use an appropriate medical
specialist.
Now I know ERISA speaks to an appropriate medical specialist, and what would be an example
of that in a MetLife claim?
An appropriate medical specialist is one that specializes in the care that the claimant
is, you know, the condition that the claimant is disabled from.
So if a claimant has Parkinson's, for example, and has neurological issues, that he's got
cognitive issues, he can't remember things, he may have speech delay, he could be super
fatigued, and also have physical issues, he's probably being treated by a neurologist.
So what MetLife should be required to do is to hire the same type of physician, a neurologist,
to render an opinion as to whether the neurologist that the claimant is treating with's opinion
that the claimant cannot work is proper.
And that is something that they should do instead of hiring, you know, a physical rehab
doctor or a primary care physician to review the records.
They do need to hire the correct doctor, a specialist, to review the claim that specializes
in that type of disability.
And more often than not, I see that MetLife will rely on an in-house doctor, especially
at the group level, that's basically just an internal medicine or general doctor, regardless
of what the medical condition is of the person, and they'll rely on that doctor's opinion
to deny a claim as opposed to going to an orthopedic surgeon or a neurologist or different
doctors that go to school and get board certified in those specialties.
So can MetLife reasonably rely on the opinion of a general doctor versus the opinion of,
let's say it's a cardiac case and someone has a cardiologist, can the internal medicine
doctor have a stronger opinion than the cardiologist who's a heart-specific trained doctor?
I mean, absolutely not.
They try and get away with it.
They'll have their in-house or they'll have a guy that they hire on all of their cases
who renders the claimants always able to work and never disabled and they use the same doctors
over and over.
But when we come in and we file our appeals, we will absolutely lambaste them for not using
the proper doctors, for using doctors who are not qualified to render those medical
opinions.
And if they don't correct that situation, then yeah, in court, the judge hopefully would
hold that against them.
Another big problem I see with MetLife that leads to a lot of claim denials is the claim
forms that they require claimants to fill out.
Now every company has claim forms, but they're not a universal claim form for the 40 different
disability companies.
And MetLife specific has a claimant form and an attending physician's form that they often
request.
And I feel that these forms are biased for a variety of reasons and I'll also have you
speak to that.
But primarily because the attending physician's statement especially, it goes to the doctor.
There's no indication as to what the person's occupation is.
There's no indication as to what the definition of disability is.
There's no indication about any limitations in the policy.
The forms are vague at best and they're kind of designed to not really address the questions
about how a person works, but rather they address more of activities of daily living.
Why do you see that as a problem when it's addressing activities of daily living versus
the person's ability to work in their job or in any job?
Well the activities of daily living basically refer to somebody's ability to dress themselves,
bathe themselves, feed themselves, go about their daily activities.
But one actual job requires a lot more than that.
Just because somebody can get out of bed and put on their clothes and brush their teeth
and feed themselves food does not mean that they can function through a 40 hour work week.
Whether they have a physical job that requires lifting heavy boxes or whether they just sit
at a desk 40 hours a week, that is not the same thing as being able to do the activities
of daily living.
So the doctors need to see that and the forms often don't even include a less than sedentary
category.
So if they just give the doctors three options, can they do sedentary work, can they do light
duty, can they do medium, then there's no option even for the less than sedentary on
the form.
So the doctors become confused and they say well the closest to what this claimant can
do is sedentary.
They check that box and the claimant gets denied and the doctors are all confused saying
well I don't believe they can even do sedentary work but there wasn't even that option on
the claim form.
So what we do often times with the doctors is we'll create that option and tell them
to write below the options, this is a less than sedentary position, they can't even handle
the sedentary job.
So they do this to trick the doctors, doctors are busy, they don't have time to write long
letters.
Often times they're busy treating the patients and the insurance companies get away with
this because they know that the doctors don't have all the free time in the world to create
things outside the box for all other patients.
So that's where we come in.
So a lot of the denials we see are more often when there's a change of definition.
And a lot of MetLife disability policies go from unable to perform the duties of your
occupation and then usually after 18 or 24 months they switch to unable to perform the
duties of any gainful occupation and they define gainful occupation as maybe something
where you were making 60% of what you used to make or how a job, a particular job based
upon your skills was done in the national economy.
But how does MetLife generally speaking, if they say look any occupation to us is sedentary,
how do they manipulate this term of sedentary work to their advantage?
Well you know what they will do is they will say well if you can sit for X amount of hours
at a time and have breaks where your boss will allow you to stand up and walk around
for 10 or 15 minutes and give you some breaks then you should be able to sit for an 8 hour
day at a desk, work at a computer, do whatever you need to do as long as you're given breaks.
Which is ridiculous because first of all most employers aren't going to allow somebody to
get up every 10 or 15 minutes and take a 15, 20 minute break.
That's not how the real world works.
So they do manipulate it in such a way where they will get the doctors to agree that they
can sit for 4 hours at a time in an 8 hour period and that should be fine for them to
be able to handle a full time sedentary job 40 hours a week which is not usually the case.
Right because in a 24 hour day a doctor gets a form he's going to say sure you can sit
for 4 hours a day, I mean what else are you going to do but it's not the same as can you
sit with reasonable continuity basically for 4 hours at a time and focus on your job and
take phone calls and have a thought process and type documents and supervise and do all
the things that are reality of being at a job other than sitting at a chair watching
a movie which is completely different.
So it's unfortunately a biased system for the claimants but with proper preparation
and guidance I believe that these doctors and claimants can fill out the forms appropriately.
I want to move on to another tactic used by MetLife which I think you see very often is
video surveillance.
And how is video surveillance used by MetLife to deny claims?
Well what MetLife will do, they do a couple of things, they will first send out the claim
forms, the claimant fills out the forms, they ask in a typical day what can you do, what
can you not do, how often can you drive in a car, how often can you sit, do you travel,
they ask all kinds of questions.
So they get the claimant to put all this down on paper, then at some point in time they
will follow the claimant with video surveillance for either two days, three days, I've seen
them do it for a couple weeks at a time, depending on the value of the claim they'll spend more
money on the surveillance and they try and get a claimant out of the house at a grocery
store or doing things that the claimant said, you know driving in a car for two hours, whatever
may be they try and catch the claimant on video doing something they said on paper that
they couldn't do.
So when they do this, then they'll set up a field interview where they'll come out to
the claimant's house, they'll sit the claimant down, ask a bunch of questions about hey can
you sit in a car for more than two hours at a time and the claimant may say absolutely
not, that would hurt my back too much, I can't sit in a car for more than 20 minutes and
then they'll show the video and say well is this you?
And they'll show the claimant sitting in a car, maybe it was on a good day, the claimant
had an emergency, they had to go somewhere, they had to sit for that long and once they
catch you doing the thing that you said you can't, they use that against you to deny the
claim.
Well, one of the, they definitely do all those things and one of the advantages right now
that you mentioned, which was about the personal interviews, is that during COVID-19 they're
not coming to you but they're doing these on the phone and I'm starting to see it even
more proactively than they were, they seem to be getting a little bit more organized
now for whatever reason and they're like hey, we want more phone interviews and they're
not cutting back on the video surveillance even though you would think that more people
are staying home than going out, especially right now in August of 2020 when we're filming
this video but people are still out there and they still need to be aware of this video
surveillance which leads me to the last tactic I want to talk about is, and this is becoming
an issue because more people are home and more people are in front of their computers
is the use of their social media and I mean, can MetLife look at that, can they use that
against a person and how often do they do that?
They do it a lot and my clients are always surprised and they'll say well, I'm on private,
how do they see what I'm posting and somehow they always seem to get into the Facebook,
the Instagram, people's LinkedIn, they find everything and even if you're not posting
and you have a friend or a relative that's tagging you in pictures, they're finding these
so the problem is if you're saying you can't do certain things yet you're, and a picture
is worth a thousand words but a picture doesn't always portray how you're actually feeling
in the moment but if you're smiling or you're out with a bunch of people or you're doing
something physical and you post it on social media, they use that against you to say that
well obviously you're not as bad as you claim, you look happy, you look like you're out here
being physical, you're at a party, you're dancing so clearly if you can do all of that
you absolutely can work and that's not always the case, a lot of people will post for a
from the picture how they're really feeling so I tell all of my clients do not post anything
on social media, be very careful, please ask your friends not to tag you and your family
members because it just gives them ammunition that it's not necessary.
All right, I really want, I was going to stop there but I need you to address one more issue
because it comes up all the time with MetLife which is the musculoskeletal limitation used
by them, I would say more than half of the denials that we see from MetLife, what is
that, how do you deal with that?
Yeah, unfortunately these pop up in a lot of the MetLife's policies and the claimants
aren't aware of it because most people really don't take the time to read their long-term
disability policies to see what's contained in them so they're usually shocked when I
inform them that, hey, yes, you may have this musculoskeletal condition which could
be a back issue, a neck issue, you could have fibromyalgia, there's a lot of different musculoskeletal
issues that are disabling and they can be disabling for a lifetime but the policies
alone will limit those benefits to only 24 months and there are ways around it but the
ways around it are you have to get your physicians to perform certain objective tests so there's
a test called an EMG that can be done and that's basically a test to determine whether
you have nerve damage that's causing radiculopathy down one of your legs or your lower extremities,
there's myelopathies, there's all kinds of different exceptions to MetLife's limitation
that can get you beyond the 24 months but with conditions such as fibromyalgia, there
really isn't much way around it because fibromyalgia really doesn't have an objective test to determine
whether you have that at this point, maybe one day that'll be developed but right now
if you do have a self-reported symptom that you're claiming is disabling, MetLife will
limit that to 24 months only and that's really, it's a blow to the clients because then what
do they do after that?
Right, it's a big problem but I think the benefit is for people who watch our videos
and are even aware of this because many aren't even aware of this, all of a sudden they're
like, oh I'm totally disabled and wait, what's this limitation in my policy, they had no
idea it even existed, is that you can plan for that, anticipate it and really work up
the claim in such a way where you get yourself around outside of that limitation.
Sometimes you just fall in it and there's nothing you can do but better to be prepared
than to get broadsided by it and not know about it.
So look, there's so many different tactics we see and especially depending upon the person's
medical condition, the policy language, the occupation, there's so many factors that go
into that it would take us hours to address all of them and we have done hundreds of videos
on all different topics which we encourage our viewers and listeners to subscribe to
our channel and watch these other videos.
Most importantly, all of our lawyers, we always offer a free initial consultation to discuss
your claim so if you're having any issues with MetLife or you're concerned that an issue
is coming down the road, please feel free to reach out to Rachel or myself, we look
forward to the opportunity to speak with you and we appreciate you taking the time to watch
our video.
