I will be taking you to 19th century Edinburgh where the subject of anatomy was still being studied in order for doctors to understand how to perform surgery and to learn even more about the human body. But back in the 19th century in order for a doctor to become skilled at the art of surgery and knowledgeable in anatomy they would need a supply of corpses in order to practice on. However, where throughout history dead bodies were common due to people being executed, this was no longer the case as in 1823 the Judgement of death act saw the numbers of crimes punishable by death in Scotland drop significantly. This would lead to an extreme shortage of dead bodies available.
It's Oli from History Profiles and today I will be taking you to 19th century Edinburgh
where the subject of anatomy was still being studied in order for doctors to understand
how to perform surgery and learn even more about the human body.
But back in the 19th century, in order for a doctor to become skilled at the art of surgery
and knowledgeable in anatomy, they would need a supply of corpses in order to practice on.
However, where throughout history dead bodies were common due to people being executed,
this was no longer the case as in 1823 the Judgment of Death Act saw the numbers of
crimes punishable by death in Scotland drop significantly. This would lead to an extreme
shortage of dead bodies available. Scottish law at the time deemed that suitable corpses
that could be used for the purpose of study were only people who had died in prison,
suicide victims and the bodies of orphans. As the supply of bodies became extremely rare,
doctors were literally waiting for people to die. This increased the demand and grave robbers and
body snatchers would take this opportunity to begin trading corpses. Now, the two important
men in this story were named William Burke and William Hare. Burke was born in 1792 in Ireland.
He had a comfortable upbringing, coming from a middle class family and he joined the British
army as a young man. He met a woman and married her and would settle in County Mayo in Ireland,
but the marriage wouldn't last long and he abandoned his wife and moved to Scotland to
become a labourer. He eventually settled in Edinburgh and met a new woman named Helen McDougal.
Burke would eventually become a cobbler and he was pretty good at it,
earning a decent and honest living. His partner in crime was William Hare and his early life
isn't recorded and his age and date of birth are unknown. It is said that he moved to Edinburgh in
the mid-1820s where he would work as a coalman's assistant. He resided at Tanner's Close and after
the landlord died, he began a relationship with his widow named Margaret Laird. He now
would permanently reside at Tanner's Close. Hare was described as illiterate and uncouth,
lean and quarrelsome and a violent man with scars from old wounds all over his face.
Hare and Burke would meet in 1827 when they both went to work on the harvest. The men would become
fierce friends and when they both returned to Edinburgh, they moved into Hare's Tanner's Close
lodging house where they would get a reputation around the neighbourhood for long drinking sessions
and loud rowdy behaviour. Now, this is how Hare and Burke would discover a gap in the market
for corpses. On the 29th of November 1827, a man named Donald would die while lodging
at Tanner's Close but he still owed four pounds worth of rent. The pair took the corpse to
Edinburgh University where they would look for a buyer. Students would point them to an anatomy
lecturer named Dr Knox who paid seven pounds and ten shillings for Donald's body. Hare and Burke
now saw how lucrative the corpse market was and they would take advantage of it. This was further
proved as once the transaction was done, one of Dr Knox's assistants told them,
we would be glad to see you again when you have another body to dispose of.
Shortly after their first sale, one of the pair's tenants would become ill. Hare and Burke would
jump on this opportunity and got the man who was called Joseph extremely drunk on whiskey.
They couldn't help themselves and wait to see if Joseph would die so they restrained him and
smothered him with a pillow to cut off his airways. This particular way of murder would ensure that
the body had no markings and was perfect for sale. The practice would become known as burking. The
pair again took the body straight to Dr Knox who this time paid ten pounds. Their next victim was
an unnamed Englishman who was a travelling seller of matches and tinder. He too would fall ill at
Hare's lodging house. Hare was concerned that the illness of the unnamed man may have an effect on
the business of the lodging house so they decided to deal with the man swiftly. They crept up into
his room and Burke would put all of his body weight on the victim stopping him from moving
while Hare would crushingly suffocate the victim until their last breath. Following this, the pair
would meet a woman who was a pensioner that lived in a nearby village of Gilmerton. She would
regularly visit Edinburgh to sell salt. She was invited back to the inn and Hare and Burke and
the pensioner would start drinking heavily. The pair ensured the pensioner was too drunk to return
home and after tucking her into bed they killed her. Again Hare and Burke went to Dr Knox and he
gave them ten pounds of body. Apparently Dr Knox approved of the freshness of the bodies and Hare
and Burke would become his favourite suppliers as the bodies were always fresh and unspoiled.
Burke and Hare would prey on the most vulnerable people in society who were likely to not be
recognised or missed by anyone. It is said that the pair murdered at least 16 people and then sold
the bodies for seven to ten pounds although the real number of people they killed is likely to be
higher. Burke would later meet two women in early April called Mary Patterson and Janet Brown. He
would buy the women drinks and would invite them to his lodging for breakfast and a place to stay.
Burke's wife would find him and the women drunk and accused Burke of having an affair.
An argument then broke out and Burke threw a glass at his wife cutting her across the eye
while Janet Brown said she didn't know he was married and left the inn. However Mary Patterson
was still in the inn and they murdered her while she was sleeping. Again they took the corpse to
Dr Knox who paid eight pounds for the body which was still apparently warm when they sold it.
One of Dr Knox's assistants named Ferguson thought he recognised the dead woman. He asked
Burke and Hare where they obtained the body and Burke said that the girl had drank herself to
death and they got the body from an old woman. Dr Knox not caring about morality was absolutely
delighted with the corpse simply caring about his studies and putting aside his ethics in search for
knowledge. When Janet Brown later went looking for her friend she was told she had left for Glasgow
with a travelling salesman. The pair's greed was becoming uncontrollable but with greed
came carelessness and it was only a matter of time until Burke and Hare were discovered.
Their last victim was killed on October the 31st 1828 and her name was Margaret Doherty.
She was a middle-aged Irish woman who Burke had lured into the inn by claiming his mother was
also a Doherty and with his charm the pair began drinking and talking. Burke left the inn telling
Margaret he was getting more whiskey but he was actually going to get his friend Hare as he had
to kill this woman. Two lodgers however were already at the inn they were named Anne and James
Grey and Burke and Hare paid them to stay at Hare's lodging that night saying that Margaret
Doherty was family. Burke, Hare and Margaret continued drinking and by the end of the night
Margaret had been murdered with the usual method and her body was put by a pile of straw at the
end of a bed. The very next day Anne and James Grey returned and the pair became suspicious
when Burke did not let them go near the bed where Anne had left her stockings.
When the pair realised they were alone in the inn they searched the straw and found Margaret's body.
They then quickly went to alert the police but they ran into Burke's wife Helen McDougall who
tried to bribe them with £10 a week in order for them to keep their mouths shut but they refused
and reported the murder. Burke and Hare quickly sold Margaret's body but the police searched
the inn swiftly and found blood-stained clothes and brought Burke and Hare in for questioning.
The police also went to Dr Knox's dissecting room where they found Margaret who was then identified
by Anne and James Grey. Burke and Hare were subsequently charged with murder. Hare however
was offered full immunity from prosecution if he provided details of the murder of Margaret.
He would make a full confession to all the murders that he carried out but when it came to the trial
Burke would plead not guilty and Hare would give evidence saying that Burke was the sole murderer
of Margaret Docherty. Burke was then found guilty of murder and he was given the death sentence.
As the death sentence was being passed the judge said,
Hare on the other hand was held in custody for his own protection and was released on the 5th
Wherever he went an angry mob would follow and would throw stones at any establishment he was at.
His presence would create chaos in general due to the public hating him. He later made his way to
the English border where there are no more recorded sightings of him and where he disappears from
history. As for Dr Knox he left Edinburgh due to public outrage and would begin to lecture in
Britain and Europe trying to salvage his career. Margaret Hare the wife of William Hare fled to
Ireland and Burke's woman Helen MacDougall started a completely new life in Australia.
When you turn a blind eye to evil due to the search for knowledge do you too deserve to be
punished? Do you think that Dr Knox and Margaret Hare and Helen MacDougall should be found guilty
as well due to their knowledge of all crimes? Let me know in the comments section down below
and I'll see you all next week for another history profile.