What's up guys, it’s Ollie from History Profiles and today I will be taking you to 14th century France where the last trial by combat would take place. The Trial by combat was an ancient method of Germanic law to settle accusations in the absence of witnesses. This would result in a duel between 2 single warriors and the winner would be proclaimed to be right. During the life of the warrior Sir Jean de Carrouges, he would live though many wars and campaigns, being the veteran of many battles. For he lived during the time of the Hundred Year’s war, and need it be said that it was a time of betrayal, strife and blood lust. He would be immortalized for his deeds in life, but mostly for the final trial by combat to officially take place in France, the circumstances that lead to this duel have gone down in legend. This is a tale of two fierce friends and how jealousy, lust and pride would result in death. This is their story.
AI Generated·May contain errors
What's up guys, it's Oli from History Profiles and today I'll be taking you to 14th century France
where the last trial by combat would take place. The trial by combat was an ancient method of
Germanic law to settle accusations in the absence of a witness. This would result in a duel between
two single warriors and the winner would be proclaimed to be right. During the life of the
he would live through many wars and campaigns, being the veteran of many battles. For he lived
during the time of the Hundred Years War and need it be said that it was a time of betrayal,
strife and bloodlust. He would be immortalised for his deeds in life but mostly for the final
trial by combat to officially take place in France. The circumstances that led to this duel
have gone down in legend. This is a tale of two fierce friends and how jealousy,
lust and pride would result in death. This is their story.
First, let's have a look at the early life of Sergine de Carouges. He was born in the 1330s in
the village of Saint-Marguerite de Carouges and was the oldest son of a knight and minor noble
who shared his son's name, Sergine de Carouges. His father was a soldier and warrior and had been
rewarded for his years fighting in the Hundred Years War with a knighthood and castle overlooking
the town. He was also appointed as the man who would take care of the area so growing up, a young
Jean would greatly look up to his father, a man who had many tales to share and who had acquired
much. The boy would learn the art of the sword and would soon follow in his father's footsteps
and would join the army, for he wanted what his father had, respect and of course the glory of
triumph on the battlefield. In the early 1370s, Jean would marry Jeanne de Tilly, the daughter
of the Lord of Chambois. After the wedding, the couple would have a son together and Jean named
his best friend, the squire Jacques Le Gris as his godfather. The pair of friends would soon
be invited to the court of Pierre d'Alençon, but their relationship would soon grow sour,
as Le Gris would soon become the favourite of Count Pierre, being rewarded for his service
with a castle and a vast estate. Jean would become jealous of his friend and the two men
became rivals at court. However, tragedy would strike Jean, both his wife and son died of unknown
causes. Mad with grief, he left home and joined the service of another lord and went on a campaign
to fight against the English. He would distinguish himself in battle in a five-month campaign,
in which half of his comrades were killed. After seeing much death, he would return home in 1380,
where he then married Marguerite de Thibauville. Marguerite was described as young, beautiful,
good, sensible and modest, and the wife any man would be lucky to have. However, her father,
Robert de Thibauville, a Norman lord, had rebelled against the King of France twice
and was lucky to be allowed to live. Due to this, her family name was tainted.
In 1384, Jean went to a party to celebrate the birth of one of his neighbour's sons.
Le Gris was at the party and the two men agreed to end their resentment towards each other.
The two men would once again embrace each other as friends. At the party,
Jean would introduce his new wife to Le Gris. A few months after the two friends' reconciliation,
Jean decided to go to battle once again. His force of men would join the Scottish army
and they would raid Northern England, distracting the English forces from France's movements.
Jean and his men would arrive in Scotland with his commander and the two armies would
become one, marching south and burning many farms, castles and towns to the ground.
King Richard II of England then personally led his army and met the French and Scottish army
and offered them a battle. The French agreed to fight, but the Scots retreated,
which caused the whole army to flee. Once they got to Edinburgh, the Scots went north,
leaving the French alone in their city. Realising that they were outnumbered, the army then went
south around the English forces and went to Northumberland and continued looting and pillaging.
They then decided to go back further north, but they were attacked by an English army led by
Henry Percy, who destroyed the army's supplies and decimated their forces, taking many prisoners.
The surviving French retreated to Edinburgh and then boarded ships to return to France.
Even though the mission was a complete failure, Jean would shine on the battlefield and even
thrive. Another knight would notice his military prowess and knighted him then and there on the
field, surrounded by the corpses of fallen warriors. He would soon return home to his wife,
but he had business in Paris, so he left his wife and mother-in-law in the village
of Campo Mesnil and would then travel to Paris in January. Now, Marguerite, the wife of Jean,
was left alone at her residence. Her mother had legal business to attend to and took most,
if not all of her household servants, leaving her daughter vulnerable. A man would soon knock
on the chateau's door, which Marguerite opened herself whilst no one else was around. A man
named Adam Louvel announced that Jacques Legris was waiting outside of the door and wanted to
see her. She refused, but Adam said, he loves you and will do anything for you. At this point,
Legris forced his way into the chateau. He then violently sexually assaulted Marguerite
and told her if she told anyone, he would kill her. Once her husband Jean returned a few days
later, Marguerite told him everything. He brought together all of his friends and family and
Marguerite repeated what she had told Jean. He would immediately begin legal proceedings,
but the judge in this matter was Count Pierre, who had favoured Legris. At the trial, Pierre
acquitted Legris of all charges and accused Marguerite of inventing or even dreaming up the
attack. Outraged, Jean would not rest until justice had been served. He went to Paris to
appeal to the king himself. He knew that since Marguerite was the only witness to her own attack,
it would be seen as weak in court, but he needed revenge and needed to restore the honour of his
wife. So, Jean came up with a plan. Jean would soon be presented to the king of France and asked
him, instead of proceeding with a criminal trial, that he would challenge Legris to a trial by
combat, a fight to the death in which the survivor would have been deemed by God to be right in the
However, by 1386, the trial by combat no longer took place and the chance of one being permitted
was very doubtful. Legris and Jean would soon both appear at court and both threw down a gauntlet,
a sign that they intended to fight. Legal proceedings still took place as parliament
would look at evidence from both sides and took into account both testimonies.
Legris said that Jean was driven mad by jealousy and would do anything to ruin him. Eventually,
parliament handed down its verdict. As they were unable to determine who was guilty,
the two men would fight to the death. On the 29th of December 1386,
thousands would assemble to watch the trial by combat, as word had gotten around the whole
Dressed in black was Marguerite. Should her husband die in battle, she would be burned at
the stake straight after the duel, as then she would have been proven guilty of perjury.
Both men would take to the field, mounted on horses and dressed in full plate armour.
They were both armed with a lance, a longsword and a battle axe. This was known as the Holy Trinity.
Legris was knighted just before the fight so both men would be equals. They would then
both give oaths to God, the Virgin Mary and Saint George, thereby giving over their judgment of the
Jew to God. After this, Jean went to his wife and kissed her, promising to return to her.
The king instructed that anybody who interfered would be executed and anyone that verbally
interrupted the duel would have their hand chopped off. The two knights now prepared for battle.
They readied their horses and charged at one another. Their lances struck but didn't do any
significant damage. They charged again, this time striking each other's helms. Now dizzy,
with their ears ringing, they charged again but their lances would shatter on each other's shields.
It was an even contest, with both warriors being as skilful as the other.
They both threw their lances to the ground and drew their battle axes and once again charged for
a fourth time. They then clashed and would slash and hack at one another, until Legris, who was
said to be the much stronger man, managed to behead Jean's horse with a single blow. Jean quickly
jumped off his falling horse and swiftly swung his axe at Legris' horse, disemboweling it.
Both warriors were now on foot and they would draw their long swords and engaged in a traditional
duel. Their swords would clash but after several minutes, Legris would gain the upper hand and
became the aggressor in the fight. Jean would slip and Legris used this opportunity to thrust his
sword through Jean's right thigh. The whole crowd gasped, thinking it was the end for Jean but
against all the odds, he quickly grabbed Legris' helmet with both of his hands and slammed him to
the floor. He then began stabbing at his opponent but the blows only dented his thick plate armour.
Realising that his sword would not be able to finish the man, he drew his dagger and used the
handle to smash the lock of Legris' faceplate. He managed to break the pin holding the lock
and tore his faceplate off, exposing his face. Jean now fully mounted on Legris, demanded that
he admit his guilt but he cried out, in the name of God and on the peril of damnation of my soul,
I am innocent. Jean then would thrust his dagger all the way through Legris' neck,
killing him nearly instantly. Jean then stood over his dead opponent, victorious. The crowd
then roared and pages ran onto the field to bind the wound on his thigh. He then kneeled before the
king who presented him with 1,000 francs and an annual income of 200 francs a year. After this,
he went to his wife, in front of all the spectators. It was an emotional scene for all.
Soon after the fight, Jean would be promoted and would become the bodyguard of the king.
He would be sent on missions and other tasks of grand importance.
Jean would also be there to witness King Charles VI slowly descend into madness.
Years later, in 1396, there was a peace during the Hundred Years' War with England.
The French army would assemble an army against a new threat, the Turks, and would launch a
crusade against them. Jean and his commander would cross Central Europe and would unite
with the Hungarians, causing much devastation in the Ottoman territory. On the 12th of September,
1396, the army would arrive at Nekopolis and begin to lay a siege. Two weeks later,
the Sultan Bayezid himself arrived with his army and challenged the army of the French and
Hungarians to meet him in open battle. The two forces then clashed on the battlefield.
It was a massacre and the French and Hungarian were defeated and most were killed or captured
and then executed. The exact fate of Jean de Carouges is unknown, but it is said that his
garrison was completely decimated by Turkish cavalry. Jean would have been 66 when he died,
a veteran in battle, but not the man he once was in his youth.
Jean de Carouges lived a life full of grief and endured many misfortunes, but he also lived a
life of triumph and wealth. His famous duel was the last official duel recorded in French history
and it had immortalised him as a brave and noble man, fighting for his wife's honour and risking
both of their lives in the process. In the end, he died on the battlefield, a place where no doubt
he felt at home. Let me know your thoughts on this warrior and his extraordinary life.
If you enjoyed the video, make sure to like and subscribe and hit that bell to not miss
out on any upcoming videos and I'll see you all soon for another history profile.