The Chola Empire- Indias Forgotten Global Superpower - Dr. Radhika Seshan

Ancient Indian
34 followers
AI Generated·May contain errors
But a multilingual empire is a lot more difficult to maintain when there is perhaps a little
less ability on the successors.
India's history has been written from a north-centric perspective.
South India suddenly came up only with Shivaji Maharaj.
What about earlier?
As though South India comes into existence in the 17th century.
And then we talk of Madras, the city, as the colonial city, that being the history which
is north-centric, which is agriculture-centric.
India is a country of craft and agriculture.
But the craft is scattered, the agriculture is visible, but it is the Dwara Samudra.
So that evocation of the greater world of the ocean and India's role in the ocean has been felt.
And that's why we have to bring in Charukya, Chola, Kadamba, Shilahara, all of them have to come into this.
Welcome once again to this episode of Heritage India Show.
I'm Manjiri Khandekar, Founder, CEO of Heritage India Communications, Private Limited,
and Editor-in-Chief of the Heritage India Magazine.
So today we have a very special episode.
Recently the Annamangalam copper plates have been in news because the Netherlands government has
returned them to our Prime Minister Narendra Modi.
And everybody is wondering what is the big thing about these copper plates.
So we have today with us Dr. Radhika Seshan, who is going to unfurl the mystery, so to say.
So welcome, Dr. Radhika.
We are very honoured to have you here.
Thank you.
Honoured to be here.
Thank you so much.
Yeah, it's my pleasure to give a brief introduction.
So Dr. Radhika Seshan retired as Professor and Head of Department of History,
Savitribai Phule Pune University in 2019,
and is now visiting faculty at the Symbiosis School for Liberal Arts, Pune.
Within the broad area of medieval Indian history, her research focuses on trade,
especially in textiles and maritime networks.
Her most recent publications include Merchants, Markets and Hinterlands
in Early Modern India, jointly edited with Ruby Maloney and Ishrat Alam,
published by Primus Books in 2026.
Archives and Archiving in the 21st Century, edited Routledge in 2024-25.
Empires of the Sea, A Brief Human History of the Indian Ocean World,
The Constructions of the Eastern-Western Travel Narratives, 1300-1800, again by Routledge, 2020.
Connecting the Indian Ocean World Across Sea and Land,
and Merchants and Boats in the Indian Ocean World, Across Sea and Land,
jointly edited with Ryuto Shimada, again Routledge, 2023.
And Wage Earners in India, 1500-1900.
Regional Approaches in an International Context, jointly edited with Yann Lukassen.
She also has numerous research papers to her credit in national and international journals.
So, once again, welcome to the show, Dr. Seshkant, and I will open with the first question,
which is, when we speak about the Cholas, who exactly were they? How did a regional dynasty
from Tamil Nadu emerge into one of the most powerful empires of the medieval world?
Okay. Now, one of the key things to remember is that the Cholas are first mentioned in the
early corpus of Tamil literature, which is called the Sangam Corpus. In that, there are three kings,
the Muvender, who are mentioned, who are the Chola, the Chera and the Pandya.
We do not get very much information. We get the names of two kings, particularly in this. One is
a king who is called Karikala. Another is a king called Kojanganan. And the poetry seems to
indicate that there were two branches of the family, one in the town of Udayur, another in
the port of Pohar or Kaveripumpattinam. And there seems to have been constant civil war between
these two branches of the country, of the family. But what we do know is that there is a poem which
talks about Karikala having defeated the Pandya and the Chera in a great battle and therefore,
becoming one of the three great kings of the Sangam Corpus. Now, what connection there is
between these kings and the Cholas who come up in the 9th century is something we do not know for
sure. They definitely claim a continuity. They claim a heritage. But whether that is
actually traceable is something we do not know. What we do know is that the Tamil epic,
the Manimekhalai, talks of the Cholas of the Sangam period as descended from the Sun,
the Suryavamshi. And the Suryavamshi lineage is claimed by the Imperial Cholas as well.
Now, there would definitely have been a continuation of the name. There would probably
almost certainly have been the tradition and a historical, even if it is only oral,
that is passed on. And this is definitely used by the later kings who come. The later kings,
we start hearing of them from a king named, I think Vijayalaya and Aditya I. And he is supposed
to have been a feudatory of the Pallava king and joined with the Pallavas in one of the
innumerable battles that happened between the Pallavas and the Pandyas. And in that,
the Pallavas succeeded probably with the help of people like Aditya, Vijayalaya. But the Pallavas
themselves began to decline. And it is at this point that the Imperial Cholas begin their history.
So, middle of the 9th century till about the 13th century, that is the period.
Now, why they become so important? I mean, it is like you said, a regional dynasty of Tamarindam
which becomes so important. I think one of the major reasons would have to be the fact that
they were able to grasp the moment and to understand that a regional dynasty located on
the southeastern coast of India, in order to become a great power needs access to multiple
sources of revenue and multiple areas of control. And that is what starts from Aditya, Sundarapandya,
all of the kings. I mean, we talk today of only Rajaraja Chola and Rajendra Chola.
But the fact is that there is a long history of expanding outwards from the Kaveri Delta.
The second is that they are in the Kaveri Basin and the Kaveri is the richest land in this area.
So, if you move north along the Kaveri, you get into the immensely rich and fertile and
timbered lands of what is today Karnataka. You move down towards the delta and get the equally
rich rice paddy growing fields. And also the Kaveri Delta, Kaveri is one of the few perennial
rivers that there is in the tip of the, in the southern most part of the peninsula. Constant
water and a knowledge of the management of water. Now, for instance, the Cholas are supposed to have
built 72 canals connecting the streams of the delta and 72 temples to control those canals as
well. So, there is a ritual element. There is a very, very conscious and clear understanding
of the need for multiple sources of revenue and the understanding that you need to work
in order to get the revenue. I think that is where the entire process begins.
What a fascinating history. It is a fascinating history. The more one reads,
the more one realizes how little one knows about what they did.
Exactly. So, which regions exactly did the Cholas rule at the peak of their power?
And for roughly how many centuries? You said 9th to approximately 13th, right?
The peak of their power would have been 9th, 10th, early 11th centuries. That is the period
from Aditya I till Rajendra I. That is your stretch. So, middle of the 9th century up to
definitely the first quarter of the 11th century till about 1060. That is the peak of their power.
And their area… The geographical expanse.
The geographical expanse is a little, is always a little difficult to determine.
They did have much of present day Tamil Nadu. And their own inscriptions talk of them as,
talk of the core area as being from Kumari, Kanyakumari and Eram, Sri Lanka up to the Venkata
Hills. That is up to Tirupati. That is supposed to be the core area. Westwards across the peninsula,
we do not know for sure. They did defeat the Pandyas on multiple occasions. They did go into
the Chera country. But then they also have influence as far north along the Bay of Bengal
coast as far as Odisha. And one of the inscriptions, I am told, and this is something I have
not seen for myself or I have not read about. But I am told that there is a recently discovered
fragment of an inscription which has come from the Solapur area which mentions the Cholas.
Okay.
So, in Maharashtra. I do not know, I have not found anybody who knows anything more than that
there is a fragment. And I have not met anyone, I have not seen anyone who actually has looked at
the inscription. For all we know, this is one of the stories that is floating around which has
its base in a strange name. We do know that there was a dynasty called the Telugu Choras
which was just around the time that the imperial Cholas were coming to power.
For all we know, it belongs to that dynasty, not to this.
No, but such a powerful empire, it is very possible in Maharashtra, it is just
across the border.
It is just across the border. And it is possible. And we know that they went wherever the
trading guild, they were very closely, the guild of the 500,
the Aihole guild was very closely associated with Cholapur. And the guild inscriptions have
been found in Solapur and I think one in Nashik as well. So, it is possible that
there is that connection that exists.
Because normally, when we talk about the Chola dynasty, everybody has heard about
Raja Raja Chola and Rajendra Chola. Were they the founders? Are they other defining rulers
of the empire? And what made the Cholas fundamentally different from other dynasties
of that time?
Okay, let me start with the last part of it first. Fundamentally different. I think at
the peak of their power, they understood the need to guarantee the succession so that there
would not be civil war and internecine fights among the brothers over the empire.
So, in each case, there seems to have been the official appointment of a Yuvaraja who
ruled along with the king at the time that the king was still alive and still functioning.
So, Rajendra ruled with his father. He was the general. So, when Raja Raja was going
southwards, Rajendra was moving northwards in the conquests. Both of them are issuing
inscriptions of the same time, of the same stature. But there is a difference in that
the inscriptions, actually with Raja Raja, we get a major difference in the inscription,
which is that there is, okay, inscriptions are in both Sanskrit and in Tamil and the
Sanskrit portion from Raja Raja time is constantly edited in order to include the latest conquests.
And in those, there is a mention of Raja Raja very often in the later period.
So, we find that is an innovation that comes up with Raja Raja. In terms of kings, we get
mention of Parakeshwari, Aditya I, Sundarapalai Chola. There is a large number of them. Raja
Raja and Rajendra are the ones who build up on all of this, but they do not create it. It is
created by their forefathers, grandfathers. So, there is a lineage, there is an understanding
and it is, when one talks of the Chola, this is the pinnacle of Cholapar, but it is not the
beginning and end of Cholapar. It is the final stages of it.
Yeah, now I am coming to your favourite part. So, I mean, many historians describe the Cholas as
one of the great maritime powers of the medieval world. So, can you help us understand the scale
of their naval strength, oceanic trade networks and connections with regions like Southeast Asia,
Sri Lanka and China? Again, the starting point would have to be
revenue. The Tamil Nadu, geographically, is very poorly located in terms of perennial sources of
water, annual sources of water. The rivers of Tamil Nadu, other than the Kaveri are all seasonal.
When it rains, they flood and when the monsoon is, they dry up. There is a trickle at most.
And so, also the landscape is very often very barren. It is sandy. We all know about Marina
Beach in Madras, the largest beach in Asia. But the fact is that all very well, nice to look at
the beach and sit on the beach, but the beach is of no use whatsoever for revenue purposes.
You cannot grow anything on it. And so, you need to be able to harness the sea,
to be able to get the revenue from that huge expanse of beach. So, the sea and the coast
would be finally areca nut, betel nut and fishing. But that is not going to give you very much
because all of those are consumables. How long can you keep it? So, the only thing that continues
is trade. And that is your starting point. And that is something that one finds even from the
Sangam poetry onwards. Now, the Sangam poetry talks about the five eco zones into which the
area is divided. So, the rich land along the river, the coastal lands, the lower foothills,
the dry barren land, in which incidentally, theft is the only profession that can be followed.
Theft or toddy making are the only professions that can be followed.
And the higher hills. Now, when you have got a clearly defined geography of this kind,
trade becomes your major connecting factor. And it is trade then which gives you the
major source of revenue. That would mean that you need to have access both to the hinterland
as well as to the lands across the river and across the seas. So, you need to establish
yourself in a river and go beyond the river to other rivers. So, like the, not the Vaigai so much,
but the up to the Godavari, Krishna and to the Mahanadi. If you look at their conquest,
they are going up to Odisha and up to the Mahanadi. And then they make the Rajendra's
general makes a quick dash up to Ganga and gets the ceremonial little,
this thing of a Kalash full of water which comes back to Tamil Nadu.
So, there is a ceremonial element, there is a ritual, but there is water always.
And water is both land and sea. So, land-based and sea-based. And that is where the maritime
dimension comes in, the connection with the sea. From what we know, the earliest
naval expedition was to the Maldives. There is one mention of the navy being sent to the land
which has 1,200 islands. But that is just a kind of a throwaway line in one of the inscriptions,
nothing more than that. But much more important is the conquest of Sri Lanka. And Sri Lanka is
very clearly attacked. There is a mention of the movement down through the Pandya country
and then around through the Chera country. So, there is a naval force that goes around,
bypasses the Pandya and gets to Sri Lanka. Sri Lanka is conquered and made a province
of the empire. Eelamandalam, Eelamandalam it's called. And that's, once you've got Sri Lanka,
you've got one of the major pivots of the Indian Ocean trade. Because anything that comes in will
touch India, Sri Lanka and then go further forward. You get to Maldives, you've got another
pivot. And then you've got the culminating point of the great expedition to Srivijaya,
which is your third pivotal point. It gives you access to what is today called the Asia Pacific,
but it gives you access to the South China Seas. So, your three pivots are there.
India, of course, Sri Lanka and Srivijaya gives you your three major points at which you can
control or get access to at least the intra-Asian trade networks. That's what you have with the
Jhumas. Did they go into Cambodia, Indonesia also? They did, to some extent, because you've
got mention of the expedition going up north into Cambodia, into Champa. And you've got mention,
you've got mention of Kadaram, which is Kedah, that is your Srivijaya area. And then further
north into the Champa area. And there is a mention of what is possibly the Isthmus of Kerala, but
that's not yet. But what you need to remember is that there's always been connection across the
Bay of Bengal. Today, we talk about the Nicobar and the Andaman Islands. The 10 degree channel
that goes between these two is something which is navigable most of the year and cannot be
navigated, and I'm talking about sailing ships, only during the period of cyclones. Otherwise,
it is shelter because you've got space on both sides to take shelter whenever you need.
There is a connection between Nagapattinam and Burma. Later on, there is a very strong
connection between Nagapattinam and, well, across to the Philippine areas. So, we've got
16th century, we have 17th century. We have mention of the Portuguese sailors from Policat
and Nagapattinam, Portuguese traders from Policat and Nagapattinam going up to Manila.
And at Manila, getting the gold that the Spaniards were bringing from South America
and bringing that back into India. So, you've got all kinds of connections. That's your maritime
connection. Yeah, it's just, I mean, so many different layers. It's not just history. We are
talking about economics, knowledge of geography, the shipbuilding industry, trade, and the whole
gamut. At another point in time, we'll go into all of that. But yeah, but what I'd like to know is
the Brihadeshwar temple because that is one of the largest monuments existing of the Cholas.
It was not just a religious monument, right, but also an economic and political institution.
And how did the Cholas use architecture, temple and public works to build state power and shape
society? A slight, a little anecdote about Brihadeshwar temple before I get into the
answers to your question, which is that Brihadeshwar temple is built from the loot
accumulated after Srivijaya. All the money that he got from Srivijaya is what he brings back
and builds the temple with. So, it's a, your starting point itself is material.
And there is an inscription just at the entrance, which gives you all of this.
Now, one of the things about temples, and again, that's something which begins possibly with the
sattvahans themselves. It's something which is typical, the grant of land for a religious purpose,
but concealed somewhere in the grant is also very often a slight throwaway line, which says,
okay, you make the land fertile and then claim it. We're not giving you any money for it.
So, there is through the temple an understanding that there is a corpus of knowledge,
but there is also people who are coming together in a particular area in order to apply that
knowledge and make that land. And that knowledge, we're in the peninsula, we know that we have
as much rain as we have rain shadow, and we have lots of areas which have no water at all,
or very little water, which means that supplies of water are crucial to any kind of existence
over here. And when you have a temple, which is located near a water source, and you expand
outwards from that temple, then you're expanding your water source, you're expanding your social
base, but you're also identifying one central point from which everything radiates outwards.
And that's where you have an earlier talk about, there are inscriptions which talk about the
Kotralam region, today famous for the medicinal properties of the falls. That's a seasonal,
it's only during the monsoon that the Kotralam area you have the falls. But those falls,
and there is a parallel. So, you have 10 villages income assigned to the maintenance of the Kotralam
area, 10 villages assigned to the maintenance of another area. This kind of assigning of income,
which implies that the income is continuous and is going to be standardized also starts coming.
So, linked to the temple is first administration of the temple itself, second the development of
the region surrounding the temple, third the agricultural development, and fourth the craft
and trade development around the temple. So, the temple becomes a socio-economic institution,
far more than anything else. And it is the Cholas who really perfect that art. So,
it's with them that you really have. And the temple becomes amazing. And we've got records
of India's cloth from very, very early times. We know that till probably about the 13th century,
the island of Sumatra did not have a very strong money economy.
And it is Coromandel cloth, Tamil Nadu cloth, which is used as a medium of exchange.
And it is from Sumatra that they get a lot of the major spices that come in,
which means cloth has to go both ways, which means control the weavers, which means get the
carpenters to make the looms. There's a craft history and there is a knowledge of the requirements
of the craft. All of it starts coming in. Even today, if you go to Madurai, to Tanjore,
and to Kanchipuram, you will find weaver clusters around the temple. They are still
there and they are still functioning. It's just amazing how our ancestors, I mean,
they had such a structured society and ran it in an organized manner. I mean,
they used all their knowledge so wisely, a combination, the right combination of knowledge
and wisdom in a positive society. It's amazing. It's really amazing. And the sad part is that we
end up limiting it to one dimension only, only the political dimension, and we ignore the
socio-economic dimension. Luckily, that's coming up now. So, a little better off than we used to
be when I was a student. So, one of the fascinating aspects of the Cholas is how figures like
Sembiyan Mahadevi helped popularize forms of Shiva worship such as Nataraj. Everybody knows
Nataraj all across the world, but not where it started. Would it be fair to say that the Cholas
were among the earliest Indian dynasties to consciously shape a large-scale cultural
and civilizational identity? Yes, I think so in many ways because the Cholas were
Shiva promoters. They are also Vaishnavites. But I think something else that needs to be remembered
is that the Chola power, the rise of the Chola power corresponds to the expansion
of the Bhakti movement. And the Bhakti movement, remember, starts in Tamil Nadu with Shiva and
Vishnu worship. And Shiva becomes the god of the hills, the god of the plains, the god of the
waters, the god of nature. He is, and here I'm going to sound very rude, but I think I'm entitled
to as a Shiva. Shiva is an all-purpose god. I mean, he's everywhere and he can be used in
multiple ways in whatever fashion you want. That's very powerful.
So, there is, and an earlier form of worship among the hills, a standard form of worship
has been of Murukha, who is elsewhere called Kartikeya. Murukha is the hunter. Now, you
bring in the Vedic structure and you make Murukha and Ganesha the children of Shiva and Parvati,
which means you have moved your Shiva from being Neelakantha or Bhekshatana, the one who haunts
the cemeteries, to Umapati and a family and you've established a structure of society right there.
You start with that. Then you incorporate and the Murukha worship possibly predates.
The, let's see, the organized Murukha worship in parts of Tamil Nadu definitely
is around the same time as Shiva. But Murukha is a very important god. You still have in Tamil Nadu
the annual Jatras that are for Murukha. They go and there is a circuit of six temples,
which takes you from the hill to the coast, which is only for Murukha. And then you have Shiva
sitting over there saying, he helps to maintain the circuit. You've got your patriarchal figure
right on top, who maintains the entire structure. Put that into politics and you've got the king
as the man in charge who puts everything in place. It's very easy to put the two together.
And that's what happens. But yes, on another side, there is definitely a belief.
The temple of the Kuladeva of the Chola family is Tiruvarur. And even today there is, it's near
Tanjore only, even today there is an annual pilgrimage, which sets out from Tanjore to go
to Tiruvarur, which is Shiva as bridegroom going to marry Parvati at Tiruvarur. Much later in the
18th century, you have Shahji Bhosle of the Maratha Tanjore family writing the opera about this,
Pallaki Seva Prabandham, which is the same thing which has been carrying on for so many centuries.
There is the worship. And it is in things like this that you would have the women of the family
coming in. Remember that ritual is often structured and performed through the agency of women.
So, the queen and her worship becomes central to the maintenance of the ritual structure of the
temple. That's where people like Samir Mahadevi would come in. Her village, her belief, her public
assertion of the place as the queen, but also her public assertion of her space as the wife of the
powerful king who is maintaining the structure of family through the temple. So, you get that
linking of family and temple linked to the power of the Cholas. And people like to have their
leaders, their rulers being both human and superhuman, I guess. And would have been much
more important in a pre-modern time when that public ritual affirmed both the presence and
the benevolence of those rulers. That would have been part of that. That's something which we need
to remember constantly. We tend to forget that again today. These are things which must be
remembered. Tell a little bit about the evolution of Shiva into Nataraja. Okay. This is something
which I'm not too sure exactly when it comes about, but probably with the Bhakti saints themselves,
the idea of creation. And therefore, Nataraja as the divine dancer and remember much of the
Bhakti is about music and dance as well. Yeah. So, the dance of creation with Chidambaram being
the centre of that. So, you get, there are poems, there is one of the 13th century, which is called
the anklets on his, the sound of the bells on the Gungro that he is wearing. And it describes,
every stanza is about the sound of the Gungro and an assortment. It gives you both a musical
and a poetic rhythm to it. But there is also a very clear idea that what is created must come
to an end. So, you have in the Tillai, that is the forest near Chidambaram, you have Shiva creating
the world through the Ananda Tandava, which is Nataraja. So, he danced. So, he danced the dance.
And the story also is that Vishnu stood there looking on as did Bhagyapada and it is he who
writes down the steps of the dance. But at the same time, there is also an end. So, if in the
you have the Pralayam, here in the Shaiva tradition, you would have Shiva dancing the Rudra
Tandava, the dance of anger, which will end the world. So, that which is created comes to end.
That is your Nataraja. But the Chidambaram temple is another fascinating place because you have got
two Garbha Grihas, one of which you have the Nataraja and in the other, you have only
silence and darkness. And if you go inside, you can see very, very faintly the
trees, it is called the Vilva leaf in Tamil. I have no idea what it is called in any other
language, unfortunately, but it is a leaf which is sacred to Shiva. And it says, go look at Nataraja,
but remember that nothingness is the true philosophy. From nothing to nothing and
everything in between is what Shiva is all about. So, you have got these two at Chidambaram.
Very, very interesting. It is neating stuff, I know.
Yeah, absolutely. Now, we come to today's hot live topic, the Anai Mangalam copper plates,
also known as the tiny plates. So, why were they in Netherlands and what is the importance,
why have they now come into the news and returned to our Prime Minister?
Now, the Leiden plates were taken from India by the Dutch sometime in the 1860s.
The Dutch did have, in 1659, the Dutch conquered Nagapattinam from the Portuguese and they made
that their, well, I guess, effectively their capital. It used to be Pulicat, but it becomes
Nagapattinam post 1659, even if their centre of activity is Batavia, what is now Jakarta.
Nagapattinam is their centre point in India, Nagapattinam Pulicat. The grant for Nagapattinam
is renewed by Ekuji Maharaj of the Tanjore thing and that is on plates as well. And the Dutch
continue to be associated with Nagapattinam for quite some time, even after they formally leave
India. So, it is possible that the plates came into their possession sometime earlier or we
don't know for sure how they got into, but sometime in the 1860s, they were taken by the Dutch and
deposited at the library collection in Leiden. I personally think, and I'm not sure this,
I need to substantiate, is that it is possible that this was part of the collection that was
sent to Batavia earlier when they left Nagapattinam. So, they had access to it earlier and
they moved everything to Batavia and then moved everything because the plates, the inscription of
Jankoji is also over there. It has come back to, it came back to India quite some time ago,
but that, those plates were also there. So, the Leiden plates went there 1862,
official, the Leiden University, I think it's OR1687 is the catalogue number.
So, it's great that they have decided to return it.
It's a very good thing. It's something which is important to our own past because it's a very sad
thing that we've had to go there to compare and we've got something called the Madras Museum plates
which are of an earlier time and we've got the Leiden plates, but to study the Leiden plates,
never mind that Leiden has been very generous in always sharing digital or photographic evidence of
all of this, but the fact is that if you want to look at it and to actually get a feel of it,
you had to go to Leiden. So, this way, if it is put into the Madras Museum along with the
Madras Museum plates, you've got a history of inscriptional writing as well and quite apart
from the content, you have the changes because the Madras Museum plates are mid-10th century
and the Leiden plates are late-10th, early-11th century. So, it gives you a continuity of what
inscription epigraphists would call orthography and paleography. Look at that as well.
Never mind that, but the fact is that these are a set of 24 plates,
one set of 21 which is called the greater Leiden, the larger Leiden plates and another set of three
which is called the smaller Leiden plates. They are basically, they are Anemangla plates because
they record the grant of, at Anemangla of a series of villages of an area for the support of
a stupa that has been built in Nagapattinam by the Shailendra King of Southeast Asia.
He sends a grant for the establishment of the temple and that is matched by Rajendra first.
It is a whole list of things and it says that there are, there is a specific measurement that
is given of how much, how many areas of land will provide this income. So, there is an accurate
measurement of the village, level of the village, size of how much land, how much income, all of
this is given in tremendous detail. For anyone who is interested, the details are available
actually online. Epigraphia Indica volume 22 which was published in 1938 is now digitised
and is available online and this is on pages I think 220 to about 240. That is where this
entire thing is. So, it is a phenomenal record of revenue, of the assignment of revenue,
of the method of the collection of revenue and the smaller Leiden plates increase the amount
of the grant a little bit. So, it is basically a continuation of the original grant,
but it gives us all kinds of things. It gives you village administration.
For instance, it starts off by saying that in association with the Natar people of the
village, the king made this grant. So, embedded in this is the idea of the consent of the people
that they are taken into consideration, they are taken into discussion and based on discussions
with them, the land is granted to them. The land is not granted. That is to be remembered.
The income from the land is granted. So, there is no, there is nothing about removal of the
business. The business continue, they continue to work. Only the king instead of collecting
the revenue, assigns the revenue to somebody else. So, it is not a land grant, which is a
mistake that everybody keeps making. It is a land revenue grant. And it is a very, very
carefully worded instrument of how much revenue, at what period, from where, till when.
And following that, Kulothunga says that this is not enough, it is no longer enough.
Assuming possibly that there has been a certain drought or a reduction in the area and so some
is being done. So, there is the drought. So, it is…
My God, so much, so much of information about society of those times.
It is, actually the inscriptions as a whole give you so much. There was one that I was reading of
the, in fact, the Madras Museum plates that I was talking about. It tells you about the layout of
Kanchipuram city, that there are four quarters. So, one can do urbanization, one can do society,
one can do weavers, one can do plough, all kinds of things. You name it and you will probably be
able to find it somewhere in the inscriptions. So, it is a phenomenal record. But it is important
that it has come back to us because it is a record which is crucial for understanding our own,
well, heritage in terms of our own methods of recording, our methods of maintaining
and our methods of administration from top to bottom. Because it is the king's grant,
but it is done at every level, along with the provinces, along with the people, everything is
done carefully. Anything specifically unique about the Chola administration that you would
like to talk about, urban life, trade, girls, women's participation?
The involvement of merchants at every stage. That is something which is distinctive because
we have, again, inscriptions which talk about the nagaram and about the guilds being involved
in municipal administration, including the right to decide how much of the customs that is collected
at the gate comes to the city and how much is transferred to the central treasury. They decide.
So, what we would today call slightly decentralized, but it is more than decentralized,
I think it is local decision making. And that is something which they maintain,
that local decision making and the reasonable autonomy to make decisions based on the ground
reality, because it is understood that the king cannot keep his finger on every single thing that
is happening. So, the local people, but there are records to be and there is the entire structure
of the writing down of the records. So, scribes in the court who take it, two scribes on duty
every time who take down everything that the king says, which is then transcribed, read out to the
king and then passed in the form of orders. All of this is there in detail. You will find them
constantly in the inscription. Imagine we have such written detailed records and
we do not learn about them. We do not learn about them. In fact, when
jumping of centuries in the 19th century, when the British brought in the Rayatwari settlement
in the Madras presidency, the basis was the village level records known as the Kaifiats,
because they give you the detail of who owned what and for how long.
So, these are ownership documents, the deeds to the land.
Yeah. So, every great empire eventually declines and what led to the weakening of
the Cholas and their eventual fall. So, I will say standard and probably the
truest answer is that less able successors, which is something that we have seen over and over and
over again in history, that they reach a peak and for whatever reason, the later rulers are
not able to match that. Equally important, I think would be that the empire outgrew itself.
And when you have got to control so much land, so much territory,
there are always going to be people who are locally defined and who are locally rooted,
who will then get local support against a superior or an outsider.
What one scholar called a regionally oriented nobility and these would have emerged from
the administration itself, because when you have got an empire which takes in Kannada, Telugu,
Tamil, Malayalam and assorted other languages, you need to have people who know those languages
in charge of those areas. So, a multilingual, I wouldn't say multi-ethnic and I wouldn't bother
with the multi-religious because that was taken for granted. But a multilingual empire is a lot
more difficult to maintain when there is perhaps a little less ability on the successors.
And then newer kingdoms, new kings come up who are able to use the Chola methods to their own
advantage. Whether it is the Hoysalas or it is the Kakadiyas, remember they all come up post
the decline of the Cholas. And then finally, we have Vijayanagara coming in as totally different.
So, what aspects of their legacy still live on today in South East Asia?
The importance of the name itself, the Cholas and the kind of legitimacy that they lend to
structures in the far south is something which is phenomenal. And why would Shahji Bhosle,
who is finally a Maratha, who has come through Bijapur, talk about continuing the legacy of
Cholas? Why would he inscribe the Bhosle Vamsha Charita on the Brihadeeshwara temple? Unless
there is a certain aura associated with the name of the Cholas. So, I continue the legacy of the
Cholas. That's one part of it. The other part of it is definitely the craft. We know, we talked
today of the Chola bronzes. The Samai behind you is something which is very typical of the Tanjore
region. So, the craft, the pride in the craft and the maintenance of the tradition of the craft,
most clearly seen in cloth these days, but continuing in other areas. The instant evocation
of Coromandel as Cholamandalam. It is Cholamandalam and everybody knows Coromandel.
It is the Europeans who found it difficult to, can't really blame them. Many Indians can't
pronounce Cholamandalam properly. So, the Cholamandalam becomes Coromandel. The name
Coromandel itself is evoking the Chola heritage. Pandimandalam, Cholamandalam, Kongumandalam,
Tondamandalam, all the names, the mandalam that is used are the administrative divisions of the
Cholas. So, embedded in the language is the legacy of the Cholas. That I think is something we should
not forget. And you are talking not just about India, but also their legacy.
Also the legacy beyond, across the oceans. So, it is there and there is a constant,
there are words which one hears in Indonesia, which are very, very, well, I have seen the
comparative word in the Tamil inscriptions and it is used in day-to-day language even today.
So, Tamil Nadu does not use those words any longer, but Indonesia continues,
especially Bali and others, they continue to use those words. And if you look at the other side,
the Lakshadweep Islands, the word that is still used by many of the boat people,
the words that are used for distance are the Tamil words and those come up from the Chola times.
The language is a constant memory and the support that the Cholas gave to the
gills and therefore the ways in which the gills expanded gives you yet another dimension. So,
an economic, social and a linguistic dimension, that I think is something that we see beyond.
This actually answers the next question, but there is still more to it. So,
if a young Indian today asks, why should I learn about the Cholas? What would you say?
What can modern India learn from their vision, innovation?
I would love to give an answer, which I used to give to my children when they were young,
which is because, I'll stop over there, but that isn't enough. The fact is that a country the size
of India, we need to understand both the vision that dynasties had, the vision of India that
regional dynasties had, the vision of India's place beyond India that regional dynasties and
particularly Cholas had. You would find this in, for instance, Chhatrapati Shivaji Maharaj
and his idea of Swaraj is something which is picked up in the national movement.
And in the same way, the Chola history tells us what kings did, how they dealt and how they
incorporated the structures of society and the existing structures of economy to create a system
which worked very, very well for over 600 years. So, if we do not understand what they did,
we cannot understand how they did. We need to understand what in order to understand how,
in order to try and modify that how for present day conditions.
That I think is what is most important. Yeah. So, while medieval Europe was still
fragmented politically and economically, the Cholas were building massive temple cities,
managing global trade and projecting power across the oceans. Yet, why do you think the Cholas
remain relatively unknown globally, despite being one of the most sophisticated empires
of that era? I would say the answer to that is colonial historiography, which tended to negate
everything Asian in favour of everything European. And we have unfortunately continued with that
colonial historiography. Also, remember British historians, given British colonialism which
emphasised land over everything else, they set out to negate our maritime history. And as the
Cholas were central to that maritime history, that was marginalized. So, historiography is
unfortunate, but history has been. And well, I am one of those that continues to argue that
India's history has been written from a north centric perspective. Peninsular history has not
been there. So, if we do not, I studied in Delhi and I know that when I was studying in the 70s
in Delhi, there was no mention of South India at all, any of it.
Tragic. Yeah.
Tragic. So, the first South India suddenly came up only with Shivaji Maharaj. What about earlier?
As though South India comes into existence in the 17th century.
And then we talked of Madras, the city as the colonial city. That being the history which
is north centric, which is agriculture centric, which has totally incorporated the British idea
which said that India is a city of agriculture, India is a country of agriculture. India is a
craft and agriculture. But the craft is scattered, the agriculture is visible.
And in that, all of these have been lost. You have got the Chalukya King Pulakesh II
conquering Gharpuri, which is Elephanta. You have got the Trimurti at Elephanta.
You have him saying that he is Trisamudradipati. You have the Hoysalas naming their capital
Dwarasamudra. Which Samudra? Dwarasamudra is equidistant from all three seas, but it is the
Dwarasamudra. So, that evocation of the greater world of the ocean and India's role in the ocean
has been forgotten. And that is where we have to bring in Chalukya, Chola, Kadamba,
Shelahara. All of them have to come into this. Absolutely. So, this is exactly what we are
trying to do with the Heritage India show. We are reviving the glory of Bharat and our mission is to
take this knowledge and information across the globe. So, thank you so much for being with us
and sharing your knowledge. My pleasure. Thank you so much for inviting me. And to our viewers,
please subscribe and share so that you can help us in this mission. Thank you so much.
Thank you so much.
