5 Costco Meats You Should NOT Buy Again (Plus 1 You Should)

Thrifty Thinkers
9 followers
AI Generated·May contain errors
I spent $75 on Costco ribeyes last month and ended up throwing half of it in the trash,
and I'm not the only one. Meat is actually the number one most returned item at Costco right now,
and most people have no idea why it keeps happening. By the end of this video you'll
know exactly which meats to skip at Costco, and stick around because number six is the
one cut that's actually worth every penny right now. Meat number one, the Costco ribeye.
Here's the thing about Costco ribeyes, they used to be one of the best deals in the meat case.
Choice ribeyes at a warehouse price, good marbling, big cuts, and for a long time people
raved about them. I used to be one of those people, but something shifted around 2024 and
it's been getting worse since. Shoppers across the country started noticing that the ribeyes
looked different, leaner, thinner fat caps, less marbling overall. One Redditor from Southern
California put it this way, he had been buying choice ribeyes from Costco for decades and was
consistently happy, but over the last couple of years the meat started looking more like select
grade. That's a full quality tier below what the label says. He described it as buying like a
boiled frog. The change happened so gradually he almost didn't notice until he went to a different
store and saw the difference side by side. And it wasn't just one location, a thread on r slash
Costco filled up with nearly 100 comments from shoppers in Oregon, the Midwest, all over.
Everyone's saying the same thing. I call it beef bubblegum, one person wrote. You know what beef
bubblegum is, you chew it and chew it and it doesn't go anywhere. Another person from Oregon
just wrote mangled up cuts and left it at that. So what happened? There are actually two things
going on here. The first is how Costco butchers the ribeye. There's a price section called the cap,
technically the spinalis dorsi, and it's the most flavorful part of the whole cut.
What some Costco locations do is separate that cap from the main eye and sell them as two different
products. So what you're getting in the standard package is the eye only without the cap. That's
a worse cut. And you're paying full choice ribeye price for it. Some employees on Reddit confirmed
this practice became more widespread after COVID. The second issue is bigger than Costco.
A meat department employee put it this way in a Reddit thread. The food industry as a whole has
of how cattle are being fed and raised. It's a cattle industry problem, not just a Costco problem.
But you're still the one paying $75 for a package and not getting what you used to get.
If you can't verify the cap is still attached when you're standing in the aisle,
you're taking a real gamble. If you've noticed this at your store, you know exactly what I'm
talking about. Two, Costco raw chicken breasts. This one surprised me when I first dug into it
because I always thought the Kirkland chicken was fine. But the raw chicken breasts have had
a real problem over the past couple of years. And it goes deeper than just quality. First,
the texture issue. If you've ever bitten into a chicken breast and it felt almost stringy or
rubbery in a weird way, like the fibers just wouldn't break down. That's what's known as
woody chicken. It's been a growing problem in the US poultry industry broadly, not just Costco.
But Costco customers have reported it repeatedly throughout 2025. It's caused by how chickens are
bred to grow faster. The muscle tissue develops abnormally and no amount of marinating or cooking
fixes it. But here's the part most people don't know about. In December 2025, an advocacy group
called Farm Forward released a report based on USDA inspection data going back to 2020.
Costco's chicken processing plant in Fremont, Nebraska, the one that slaughters over 100
million chickens a year, and reportedly supplies about 40% of Costco's chicken,
has been failing USDA salmonella safety tests. Not occasionally. The plant received the worst
possible rating, Category 3, 92% of the time since it opened in 2019. And from September 2023
through July 2025, it received that Category 3 rating 100% of the time. Now, to be fair about
this, the USDA doesn't have the authority to shut down a plant or stop the meat from reaching
shelves just because it fails those tests. And raw chicken always needs to be cooked to a safe
internal temperature regardless of where you buy it. But knowing that this is the plant supplying
nearly half of Costco's raw chicken, that's information worth having. This next one might
be why I wanted to make this video. The Costco CEO reportedly received an email from a customer
about the chicken quality. He replied personally and said he would look into it. As of the time
I'm making this video, there's been no update on what came of that. Just something to keep in mind
next time you're in the poultry section. 3. Costco Deli Turkey. Think about the last time you bought
Costco Deli Turkey. Maybe you were making sandwiches for the week, picked up the big package,
seemed like a great deal. Now think about whether it smelled off before the Best Buy date.
And more specifically, think about whether you just opened it, let it air out for a few minutes,
and assumed it was fine. Here's what's actually going on with that. Some of the smell you get
when you first open vacuum-sealed deli meat is harmless. Lactic acid builds up inside the
packaging, and when you crack it open, there's an odor. That goes away after a few minutes, and the
meat is perfectly fine. Costco shoppers on Reddit have gone back and forth about this a lot,
and it's caused some confusion. But the issue with the Deli Turkey specifically is different.
Shoppers aren't reporting an odor that goes away. They're reporting meat that smells genuinely off
before the printed Best Buy date, and doesn't improve. One person put it directly,
I've been taking back a lot of meat that smells bad before the Best Buy date.
I'm not paying $60 for a package of meat and throwing it away. It will stink up my fridge
for a week. That post got a lot of agreement from other members. This isn't a one location problem.
Now here's a practical note for anyone who's dealt with this. If you return spoiled meat to Costco,
some locations reportedly don't require you to bring the meat back in. You may be able to bring
just your receipt and explain the situation. Call your local warehouse first to ask,
because loading a rotten package back in your car is its own kind of miserable errand.
But the better move is just to be cautious with the Deli Turkey going forward.
If you're buying it, check the date carefully, use it within the first few days of opening,
and don't assume a full week is realistic. 4. Costco ground beef, most of the year.
I want to be specific about this one, because it's actually not a blanket skip.
It depends entirely on when you buy it. The complaints about Costco ground beef are
consistent. Some shoppers say it tastes unusual. Others report a slimy texture.
And a number of people have pointed out that ground beef is widely available and often cheaper
at a regular grocery store when you factor in that you're not buying 6 pounds at a time,
which is the minimum at Costco. But here's the contrarian angle on this one that most people
miss. Costco employees have let this slip in Reddit threads multiple times. The best
ground beef comes right after major holidays. Thanksgiving, Christmas. Costco over-orders
steaks for the holiday rush. When those steaks don't sell, the leftover high-quality meat goes
straight into the grinder. So the ground beef you're buying in late November or late December
is reportedly ground from good steak trimmings, not the standard cuts.
One meat department employee also confirmed that usually the first grind of the day uses
steaks from the day before, and that any steaks left over from the previous day must be ground
and sold before 2pm. Which means if you get to the Costco meat case early in the morning,
right after a holiday, you might be getting legitimately good ground beef.
But if you're buying it on a random Tuesday afternoon in March, the quality is going to
be much more variable. For most of the year, most people are better off price comparing at
their regular grocery store first. 5. The pre-marinated meats.
You know the ones. The packs of pre-marinated tri-tip, the pre-seasoned pork tenderloin,
the already sauced chicken thighs. They look convenient, and that big Costco package makes
the price feel reasonable. But here's the thing about pre-marinated meat at any warehouse store.
You're paying a premium for someone else to add salt, oil, and seasoning to a cut of meat
that you could season yourself in about 4 minutes. I want to put a real number on this.
A plain pork tenderloin at Costco runs somewhere around $3.99 to $4.99 a pound depending on your
location. The pre-marinated version of that same cut costs noticeably more per pound.
You are literally paying extra money for salt and garlic that took someone 30 seconds to apply at
the processing facility. More importantly, the marinade does something that a lot of people
don't think about. It hides the quality of what's underneath. If you have a mediocre cut of meat,
a heavy marinade will mask that completely. You can't evaluate marbling, freshness,
or the actual quality of the protein when it's sitting in a red sauce or a teriyaki glaze.
You're buying blind. And at Costco's bulk sizes, buying blind on meat quality is a real risk.
There are also real concerns about sodium. A serving of some of these pre-marinated packages
can contain close to 600 to 800 milligrams of sodium before you've added anything else to
your meal. If you're having two servings, and with some of these cuts you will, you're looking at
well over a third of the recommended daily sodium intake just from the meat. For someone
watching their blood pressure, and a lot of people watching this are managing exactly that,
those numbers add up fast and quietly. The fix is easy. Buy the plain cut. Set a four-minute timer.
Combine olive oil, a little garlic, salt, black pepper, and whatever dried herb you like.
Rosemary for pork, paprika for chicken, Italian seasoning for beef. Put it in a zip bag with the
overnight. You control what goes in it. You can see the quality of the meat before you buy,
and you'll pay less per pound. It takes one small extra step, and it's better in every way.
And now, the one Costco meat that is actually worth buying right now.
The USDA prime beef. Specifically, the ribeye cap steaks. I know. After everything I just said
about the standard ribeyes, here I am recommending a ribeye product. Stay with me, because this is
genuinely different, and I want to explain why. Costco carries a specific cut called the USDA
prime ribeye cap steaks. And these are a separate product from the standard choice ribeye packs we
talked about earlier. The ribeye cap is the spinalis dorsi, which is that prized section
I mentioned. It's the most flavorful part of the entire ribeye. When Costco removes it from the
standard ribeyes and sells it as its own dedicated product, you're not getting what was left over
after the cap was removed. You're getting the cap itself. That's the opposite problem from what we
talked about in number one. Professional chefs and butchers have specifically called out Costco
as one of the best retail places to buy USDA prime beef. And the reason is purely about buying
power. Costco moves so much volume that they can source prime-grade beef at a cost most regular
grocery stores simply can't match. And they pass that savings to the customer. Think about it this
way. Most supermarkets carry USDA choice at best and select at cheaper stores. USDA prime is mostly
reserved for restaurants and specialty butchers. Costco is one of the very few places where a
regular shopper can walk in off the street and buy prime-grade beef without a special order
or a butcher relationship. And here's something worth knowing that most shoppers don't realize.
Costco does not use carbon monoxide in their meat packaging. A lot of other grocery stores do. It's
legal practice that keeps raw meat looking bright red even as it ages. What you're seeing in those
other meat cases isn't always what the meat actually looks like. At Costco the color you
see is the actual color of the meat. That's a meaningful transparency difference. Now these
cap steaks are blade tenderized which means for food safety they're best cooked to at least medium
145 degrees internal temperature. If you're a rare steak person these aren't for you. But if you're
grilling them and cooking through the flavor from all that fat and marbling is genuinely impressive.
Food writers and chefs on various forums have consistently described this cut as one of the
most underrated purchases in the entire Costco meat case. One practical note. They're not always
in stock. Your best bet is weekend shopping which is when Costco tends to restock its meat case.
And when you do find them, buy in bulk and freeze them properly, portion them individually, press
out the air and label them. A well frozen ribeye cap steak holds quality for up to six months.
At the per pound price Costco charges for prime cuts you're getting something that would cost you
two or three times as much at a specialty butcher. So here's the bottom line. Costco's meat department
has real issues right now. The standard ribeye quality has slipped. The raw chicken situation
at that Nebraska plant is something every Costco shopper should know about. The deli turkey has a
recurring spoilage problem. The pre-marinated stuff costs more and hides what you're actually
buying. And ground beef is only worth it during a specific two-week window after major holidays.
But the USDA prime ribeye cap steaks are genuinely one of the best meat purchases you can make
at any retail store right now if you can find them in the case. My question for you in the comments.
Have you noticed the meat quality changing at your local Costco over the past year or two?
I'd love to know if you're seeing the same things or if your warehouse has been holding up better.
Drop your state or region in the comments. I want to see if this is regional or if it's everywhere.
If you found this helpful, subscribing helps us keep bringing you these updates.
There's a new video coming this week on Sam's Club and there's one plus membership perk
that almost nobody is actually using. See you then.
