The Law Academy is a project designed to provide legal education for students studying law in the UK. Subscribe for more content.
Citations and Further Readings for each video found at the end.
Disclaimers:
At no point are these video lessons intended to provide any sort of legal advice. These are for educational purposes only!
These videos are intended to represent the law at the time of recording to the best of my ability. If there are any updates and/or mistakes, I endeavour to make sure these mistakes are corrected. Where you find a mistake, comment under the video and I will check and make the appropriate amendments.
The reality of law is that it is an ever changing and deeply complex subject. As such, mistakes and updates are inevitable. I feel that this it the best approach for this kind of educational content, given its static nature.
Image(s) Copyrights: This Photo by Unknown Author is licensed under CC BY-SA
AI Generated·May contain errors
In the previous lesson we spent some time looking at the relationship between international
humanitarian law and international human rights law. Looking at the areas of overlap, looking at
the shared goals and then looking at some of the areas where there might be distinctions and
delineations. Well in this lesson we're going to do a very similar thing but with respect to
international criminal law. So we will look at what the distinction between international criminal
law and international humanitarian law are. We will talk about how one feeds into the other,
specifically how international humanitarian law feeds into international criminal law.
The idea of war crimes being a very very prevalent focus there. We will talk about the idea of there
being some kind of complementary functionality with respect to the relationship between these
laws and then we will provide some examples of both reciprocity and cross-influence between
each of these different regimes as well. Now fundamentally for those of you who don't know,
for those of you who haven't ever studied international criminal law, international
criminal law is a branch of public international law that criminalizes the most serious violations
of international law. They are the violations that are defined as those which shock the very
conscience of humanity. So we're not talking about a violation of a basic treaty, we're not even
talking necessarily about things like money laundering or anything like that. This would
fall into the remit of transnational criminal law. International criminal law covers four distinct
crimes that are seen as having international character. These are the crimes of genocide,
crimes against humanity, war crimes and the crime of aggression. Now the thing that's really really
important about ICL that distinguishes it from a number of different regimes is as defined by
the international military tribunals at Nuremberg and the tribunal for the far east at Tokyo after
the end of the second world war, there are the established mechanisms which finds individuals
criminally liable for international crimes. This was one of the really really important developments
that we see after the end of the second world war because of course the the second world war
ends in 1945 with the defeat of the axis powers, with the defeat of the third reich and the defeat
of imperial japan and we see that of course there were lots of war crimes that had been committed
during the second world war, there were crimes against humanity, there was the crime of genocide
that was committed during the second world war of course with respect to the holocaust
and one of the defenses that some of the nazi war criminals attempted to try and utilize was this
idea of jurisdiction that an international tribunal does not have jurisdiction over
individuals. This is a thing that at Nuremberg was completely quashed that individual criminal
responsibility does in fact exist for international crimes. Now the core distinction between these two
regimes is that when we think about the idea here is that IHL will set standards for conduct in
warfare this naturally establishes obligations onto parties to conflicts usually states but
sometimes non-state armed groups in respect to non-international armed conflicts but by contrast
international criminal law is primarily concerned with violations of international law that were
committed by individuals that's the first point and these violations for the second point can
involve violations of IHL but also can take place outside of the basic confines of IHL.
One of the things that we see develop with international criminal law all the way through
to the development of the ICC and the Rome statute is the fact that most of the crimes
committed or that could be committed within international criminal law don't necessarily
require there to be a nexus with armed conflict. What I mean by this is if we look at the first
two of the crimes that are established by international criminal law today with respect
to the Rome statute the crime of genocide and the crime of crimes against humanity neither of these
require there to be a nexus of armed conflict you can commit genocide not in an armed conflict you
can now commit crimes against humanity not in an armed conflict although that is a recent change
that has happened since the 1990s. With respect to the other two we're thinking of course about
war crimes that does require a nexus with armed conflicts and the crime of aggression necessarily
necessitates the existence of an armed conflict given that it is a crime that is contrary to
article 2.4 of the UN charter. Now just because that is the case it doesn't mean that there isn't
a lot of overlap for example whenever there is a most of the times at least whenever there's a
genocide that happens or wherever there's crimes against humanity that happens it tends to be the
case that it is during some kind of war whether it's a civil war or an international armed conflict
there tends to be some kind of conflict involved even if it is not necessarily required. The sort
of crossroads of the regimes then and the sort of closest interrelationship between both of these
regimes is with respect to the crime of war crimes. So war crimes are defined as serious violations
of IHL. This means that not necessarily all violations of international humanitarian law
would represent a war crime that gives rise to individual criminal responsibility in ICL
so there are certain rules within international humanitarian law that tend to be a little bit more
a bit more procedural a bit more trivial compared to some of the more substantive rules.
So for example an IHL rule requiring specific canteen provisions for prisoners of war
would be an obligation but the failure to fulfill it would not necessarily be
criminally prosecuted and would not necessarily be viewed as a war crime.
There are also rules concerning certain emblems that have varying degrees of severity
with respect to their violations but when we think about war crimes we're thinking about
attacks on civilians we're thinking about airstrikes on civilian objects we're thinking about
the mistreatment of prisoners of war we're thinking about the use of starvation as a
weapon of war and things like that we're thinking of the really serious examples
and that is why article 8 of the Rome Statute defines war crimes as and references this idea
of grave breaches of the Geneva Conventions and other serious violations. So not necessarily
every single violation of the Geneva Conventions but grave breaches of the Geneva Conventions.
For those of you who have studied criminal law from a domestic perspective there are both
actus reus and mens rea elements so the actus reus of a crime is of course the acts that is
being committed so for example murder in at least domestic English law is the actual killing
of a person whereas the mens rea refers to the mental element of a crime so with the case of
murder it is to kill a person with the intent to kill or cause grievous bodily harm. It's not
necessarily just intention it can also include things like recklessness but for the most part
the guilty mind the mental state that is required within the confines of a criminal act. So with
respect to article 8 of the Rome Statute as I've just mentioned the court shall have jurisdiction
in respect of war crimes in particular when committed as part of a plan or policy or as
part of a larger scale commission of such crimes. For the purposes of this statute war crimes means
grave breaches of the Geneva Conventions of the 12th war was 1949 namely were any of the following
acts against persons or properties protected under the provisions of the Geneva Convention
and then it goes on to listing a big old list of different examples of war crimes and they are all
the serious violations that I mentioned a second ago. We will get to war crimes from the perspective
of international criminal law when we study international criminal law as its own topic
in future videos and I'm also sort of thinking about potentially doing a whole series on just
war crimes law specifically looking at war crimes as its own particular set of
videos and of lectures. Let me know if you're interested in that as a potential future set of
videos. Back to the relationship between these two areas of law then what about this idea of there
being complementary functions between regimes? Well the focus of IHL is of course to establish
norms governing the conduct of hostilities in armed conflict. This emphasizes protection of
life and of human dignity in war specifically the protection of those who are either not
participating in armed conflict or who are no longer participating in armed conflict as well
as the protection of human dignity with respect to the protection of people with respect to things
like prisoners of war and civilians who are living under occupation and things like that.
By contrast then, international criminal law focuses on, as any area of criminal law would,
the criminal enforcement of the most serious violations of international law. This includes
those that arise out of international humanitarian law and arise out of conflict scenarios but does
not necessarily require there to be the existence of or the nexus with armed conflict. This can
demonstrate a complementary function since international humanitarian law provides
substantive norms from which some action can be taken into ICL and can enforce those norms when
they are violated. So this provision of substantive norms and then the provision by ICL of mechanisms
to enforce those norms when they are egregiously violated is an illustration of this complementary
function that both of these legal regimes are able to substantiate. Finally then, what about
examples of and areas of reciprocity? We'll go through this in very brief detail because I've
already mentioned and looked over this already. When we look at prosecutions for instance in
international criminal law we can see that IHL acts as a helpful interpretive element for
international crimes. Heavy reliance on the rules and law of IHL can be seen with specific reference
things like the ad hoc tribunals for the form Yugoslavia and for Rwanda. The ICTY is particularly
heavily referenced in this series of lessons because of the fact that there is a lot of legal
rules that are developed and that are elucidated on and there's a lot of applying the the law to
certain facts in those tribunals. A specific example can be for instance this idea of command
responsibility, the doctrine of command responsibility. This is a principle that
developed in the context of international criminal law, the duty of commanders to prevent
or to punish war crimes by their subordinates but now has been fully absorbed and is now fully
operationalized in international criminal law.