The Patient That Changed My Entire Career Forever

Evidence Health
2 followers
22 Video Views·Jun 12, 2026
Heart disease remains the world's biggest killer, yet the vast majority of conversations around it focus on medications, procedures and what happens after the damage has already been done. This video is about a patient I wish I had done more for....
AI Generated·May contain errors
I want to tell you about a patient I saw three times over the course of nearly 10 years. So
the first time I saw him, he survived. The second time, he survived. The third time I saw him,
he died. And a large part of why he died, I believe, was the way the healthcare system,
including me, had failed him between those three visits. This is a patient that,
if I'm being completely honest, I've not really stopped thinking about since that third visit.
And it's one of the biggest reasons why I'm behind the camera here in the studio talking
about these sorts of things rather than working full-time in the A&E. So if you take one thing
from this channel, I want it to be the lesson buried inside this man's story. If this is the
first video that you're watching of me, then welcome to the channel. I'm Dr. Alex. I've
worked in emergency medicine for 10 years now, and somewhere in the middle of that career,
I changed completely how I think about what a doctor's job actually is. And this is basically
the story about why. So I met this patient in my second year as a doctor, so eight years ago,
in a very small countryside A&E in Yorkshire. So he had come in describing some tightness
in his chest. And when I took a proper history, he told me that he'd gradually been getting an
ache in his chest on and off for the past few months. But every time it came on, it would go
away when he stopped walking and he rested. But today was totally different because the pain
hadn't stopped when he rested. And what he was describing to me was pretty much a textbook case
of what we call stable angina, progressing to unstable angina where the pain doesn't ease with
rest and eventually a heart attack. The thing that didn't add up though was his age. He was
40 years old. This is the conversation that I would have with people in their 60s or 70s or 80s
or even 90s. So I examined him, we did an ECG, we sent his blood tests off, and the result that came
back changed everything from there. So the most important blood test that we do to diagnose a
heart attack is something called a troponin, which is a protein that's released into the bloodstream
when the heart is damaged, you know, starved of oxygen. Now in the UK, in the hospital that I
worked at, basically anything less than five is considered normal. His level was 44. So this man
was having a heart attack at the age of 40 years old. And I remember the exact moment I read his
result because 40 was the age that my dad was when he had his heart attack. So, you know, this patient
sat very differently with me than most other patients. He could have been my dad. So we went
straight into the standard heart attack, you know, workup. We gave him some aspirin, we gave him
something called tarquegralol to thin his blood, we gave him something called Fondoparanox, which is
as an additional blood thinner. We gave him GTN to open up his coronary arteries and a bit of pain
relief as well. We gave him morphine as the main pain killer as well and some anti-sickness because
morphine quite often makes you a bit nauseous as well. And once he was stable, but before he went
up to the ward upstairs, I went to find the consultant and I told her about my dad, about how
my dad had received pretty much, you know, no lifestyle recommendations and, you know, no conversation
around any of that after his own heart attack at the age of 40. And I said I wanted to go back and
take this man into a quiet room and talk to him about his life and his diet and his sleep and his
activity as well. And I remember it vividly because the department was so full that he was actually
sat in a chair, almost like in this holding pen full of other patients that were well enough to
not require a trolley because we didn't have any beds. Now the answer I got from the consultant
was no. I was told there were too many patients to see and that the lifestyle conversation, all of
this advice about diet and exercise and all of the sort of stuff, is the job for his GP in the
community, not for the A&E, not for the emergency room. You know, there was nothing harsh and abrupt
about how she said it but she said it very firmly and there were a long line of other patients to see.
I completely get it. So I didn't give him this advice. So he went up to the cardiology ward where
over the next couple of days he had further tests and then he was started on the full preventative
package, you know, secondary prevention, which was a statin, a beta blocker, more blood pressure
medication and long-term blood thinners as well and then eventually he was discharged and I never
spoke to him again on that admission. Now four years later I was working in a much bigger hospital
in a much busier department and a man was wheeled into the resource bay and I recognized him
immediately before I'd even looked at his notes. He was 44 at that point and he was grey and clammy
and visibly unwell. You get a sort of sense for when somebody's having a heart attack
and he looked extremely unwell and he was having another heart attack and it was a big one, it was
massive. Now when we checked his troponin level this time, remember less than five is normal, the
first time it was 44, this time it came back at 22,000, not 44 anymore, 22,000. Now to give you a
scale, the first heart attack had been a serious event but this was on another order of magnitude
entirely. Enormous amounts of his heart muscle were being damaged as we spoke to him and there
is a fundamental truth about heart attacks that you've got to know about which is that once it
dies, once that heart muscle is starved of oxygen and dies, it doesn't grow back. If this man survived
he was going to walk out of that hospital with a permanently weaker heart than he'd walked in with.
Now while we did all the stuff that we usually do with heart attacks, I asked him about his
medications as part of the drugs history and he told me very calmly and without any sense that
he'd done anything wrong that he had stopped taking all of his medications about a year after
that first heart attack. He said that he'd felt fine and he hadn't had any symptoms for months,
no chest pain, no nausea or anything like that and because nobody had ever actually checked in
on him after his discharge, he'd assumed the medications had done their job and that he
simply didn't need them anymore. I asked him whether his GP had ever checked in on him or
reviewed him or talked to him about his lifestyle or his medications or anything along those sorts
of lines and he said no. He hadn't seen a single doctor or nurse practitioner or PA since being
discharged four years earlier, not one. Nobody had checked in, nobody had rang him, nobody
had visited him, nobody had said come in just to have your blood pressure checked, nothing and
nobody had actually called to see why he wasn't collecting his prescriptions because this is
something that flags up on the computer system. If somebody hasn't been in for a couple of months
we ring them up to say is everything okay, why aren't you taking your aspirin or your bisoprolol?
This man had slipped completely through the net here and I made a note of this in his record for
the other doctors that would read it later on in the admission because this man very obviously needed
far more than just another round of tablets and stents as well. What he needed was somebody to
sit down with him and talk to him properly and give him the time that he needs. Now he was admitted
up to the cardiology ward within a couple of hours before there was ever a real chance for me to do
that because I had multiple patients going on at the same time. The next morning though before my
next shift in the A&E I went up to the ward intending to see him on my own time because
something in me wanted to make sure that that conversation actually happened rather than this
man being discharged like he was last time and I just wanted to make sure that somebody actually
told him this stuff that he needed to know. When I got there though I was told that he'd been
transferred to a specialist cardiac center in a different part of the county so I never actually
got to speak with that man on that admission and this is something that I feel incredibly guilty
about this whole time. Now six years had passed after that point and I'd worked in different
hospitals, different parts of the country, different sized units, working as a locum doctor
in all sorts of different environments and specialist centers, trauma centers, every
different kind of A&E that you can imagine and then on another night shift the resource door
swung open again and the paramedics wheeled this guy in again and he was now 50 at this point and
he was pale again he was clammy and he was barely able to speak. Now his ECG showed the unmistakable
changes of a major heart attack what we call an ST elevation myocardial infarction STMI or STEMI
which is the worst kind of heart attack where one of your coronary arteries you've got three of them
one of them is completely blocked and the heart muscle downstream is being starved of oxygen in
real time and we did what we always do we gave him the life-saving medications to thin his blood
try to open up the artery we gave him morphine again we gave him nitrates and this guy was
rung through by the paramedics to the regional cardiac center but they didn't quite agree that
the ECG was bad enough to warrant going straight for PCI where they put an emergency stent in your
heart so they brought him to the local center which was us instead now obviously by the time he
arrived that heart attack had evolved and now it looked pretty bad on the ECG so I called the cardiac
center again sent them a picture of the ECG and they said yeah we'll accept him blue light him
over there in the ambulance as soon as you can and the reason for that is that they are the local cath
lab that are able to open up that coronary artery with a stent by going through the radial artery
all the way through into the heart into the coronary artery and you know opening that artery
mechanically to let that blood flow through to save his life and the ambulance crew were still
here they were still milling around sort of the atrium of the A&E so they loaded him back onto
their trolley to drive him the 10 or 20 miles down the road to this specialist cardiac center
that would hopefully save his life because it had gone past the point where medication alone
was appropriate and as they wheeled him out of the recess doors I remember standing there in recess
feeling incredibly sad this man should never have ended up here a third time you know every
single warning sign had been there a decade earlier and somewhere in this system of the NHS
the right conversation had simply never been picked up we know that for a fact nobody had
had that conversation with him and we know that lifestyle changes are so powerful in protecting
you from another heart attack now 30 seconds after disappearing through the recess doors
the paramedics came back through them one of the paramedics was on the trolley straddling this
patient doing chest compressions he had gone into cardiac arrest in the back of the ambulance before
they'd even left the car park so we pulled the emergency alarm and every doctor from the A&E
you know flooded in to this recess bay and we worked on him for the better part of an hour
we gave him multiple shocks multiple rounds of adrenaline and we did everything that modern
medicine has to offer but his heart was in a rhythm called asystole which when that goes on
long enough we know we're not going to bring him back and in the end we called it and we
pronounced him dead on the trolley in the same A&E that I'd worked in for years now after he died his
family came back in and we sat with them and we told them what had happened and we gave them
all the time that we could and over the course of that conversation they mentioned a few times how
he'd sort of felt forgotten about since that first heart attack all those years ago he felt like he
was simply pushed out of the system and nobody really cared about him and they described how
he'd mentioned a few times how after that first heart attack he felt like he was just pushed out
the door with a bag of medications and he was never properly seen again nobody had ever sat
him down and actually told him what could save his life what could prevent a next heart attack
in the future and the thing that I keep coming back to again and again is just how many people
had a chance to change the direction of this man's life multiple doctors and specialists and
gps and nurses you know multiple people have been involved with this man at some point over the last
10 years and pharmacists who never flagged why he wasn't collecting his medications and whether
that conversation whether it happened or not would have changed the outcome we'll never know for sure
but it wasn't just one person's specific job that's the point of all of this it was everyone's
responsibility and that is exactly how he ended up falling through the cracks when something is
everybody's responsibility it very quickly becomes nobody's responsibility what broke me though was
just the sheer number of opportunities that the system had collectively missed I should have told
him in that first admission of 40 that improving his cardiovascular fitness through regular exercise
lowers the risk of a future heart attack more powerfully than the statin that we just sent him
home on I should have told him that shifting to a you know proper mediterranean way of eating a whole
food diet has been shown across the largest dietary studies that we have that it outperforms
almost any single cardiac medication that we have I should have told him that fixing his sleep and
his stress levels and his weight and the amount of movement he does every single day would do more
for his heart than the entire bag of tablets that we were sending him home with you know I knew that
as a second year doctor and I trusted that the system would pick this guy up and tell him all
that but how naive was that now if I had my time again and I could go back and I desperately wish
I could the way that I would approach this man is as though medications didn't exist at all
I would sit him down and ask myself what is the advice and the guidance and the counseling that
I should be giving this person to genuinely prevent the next heart attack what is the stuff
that my dad should have been told after he had his first heart attack what does the research point to
again and again as the most powerful things that he could possibly do to bring down his blood
pressure and his cholesterol and his triglycerides and the risk to his arteries you know we need to
build that entire lifestyle plan out first and only then on top of all of that then say to him
now in addition to all of that which is the most important part of your treatment
we've also got some medications that really do work and become much more powerful when you combine
them with these lifestyle changes but you have to make those lifestyle changes as well because
the tablets alone are not enough and we know that because we see people having multiple heart attacks
taking these medications we also have to remember that even a tiny heart attack at the age of 40
is pretty significant it means that disease and plaque have been very quietly building up in those
coronary arteries for years and decades until one of them is finally got big enough and ruptured
a small heart attack or angina is not a minor event that is an absolutely massive warning sign
that something serious is going on and serious change is needed in this person's life right now
but doctors are trained to follow protocols and flow charts and pathways you know not to step
back and engage with the bigger issue and it drives me crazy that medical education is like
this almost every patient we see falls into this same pattern and we simply don't have the time
to spend 30 minutes with each of these patients the numbers do not add up we don't have even a
quarter of the doctors that we would need to do this properly in the community or in the hospital
and the incentives within the NHS and most healthcare systems around the world
are stacked towards prescribing and giving out tablets like they're sweets rather than preventing
disease and this is in large part if we're being honest because of how powerful and influential
these drug companies really are and how they shape and influence all of the pathways that
we follow in the hospital there is no money in prevention there is no money in preventing
a heart attack you know if we prescribe somebody four or five or six different medications and they
take them for 30 or 40 years that is tens of thousands of pounds worth of medication
per person multiplied across millions of people and that's before you account for all of the
downstream costs of treating the diseases that prevention would have stopped in the first place
once you see that maths laid out in black and white you can understand why we've been trained
to medicate first and prevent well prevent almost never we don't bother telling anybody about how to
prevent a heart attack through lifestyle and so this is more or less you know one of the biggest
reasons why i started this channel and i love emergency medicine i love the thrill i love
the adrenaline rush i love the nature of saving somebody's life i love the variety that you see
you know you see elderly people you see children you see obstetrics you see psychiatry you see
trauma you see everything goes through the A&E it's where i trained it's where i've met the best
nurses ever and i miss not working there all the time but the thing is i've come out of those years
convinced that the way our health care system is currently set up no individual doctor however
good they are nobody has the time to give this man what he actually needed A&E doctors don't
have the time cardiologists in their clinic don't have the time GPs in the community are very often
more stretched than we are they are often the hardest working doctors out of all of us and
some of you will scoff at that but trust me i've worked in GP and they are so incredibly stretched
and so what happens is that we all reach for the prescription pad because it's one of the
tools that we can hand over in five minutes it's something that we can do really quickly
and feel like we've done something and we send these patients back on their way
with a bag of medications and we never give them a second thought well that is not medicine that is
just giving them smarties and hoping that we've just patched them up until we next see them in
the A&E with a bigger heart attack this is not how medicine should be now i cannot see this system
being fixed anytime soon it would require such huge amounts of money and reform and reorganization
that i can't see any government actually doing that successfully but what i can do and it's what
i spend most of my days doing these days is i can have that conversation publicly on a platform like
this on youtube with anybody who will listen and i can talk about food i can talk about sleep and
movement and building muscle and reducing your glucose spikes and eating more fiber and your gut
microbiome and your stress levels and social connection all of these things that we know
according to the research that we have are so powerful for us because we have to remember that
the things that save people's lives are not the things that we hand out in pill bottles they are
not medication they are the things that people do every single day that our ancestors would have done
all the time and you know people need to do them consistently over many years to get that
protective effect alongside these emergency medications that their doctor prescribes for them
the single biggest lesson i want you to take from this story is imagine doctors don't exist at all
obviously if something serious happens then you've got to go to a you've got to call an
ambulance and medication obviously does have its place you know modern medicine can be life-saving
in an emergency but before you ever get to that point in the years before any sort of crisis or
emergency do not wait for something to go wrong because you think a doctor will then save you
and keep you healthy just imagine from the very start of this that we don't exist and that the
only thing standing between you and disease are the decisions that you make every single day
the very honest truth is that we cannot make you healthy we can a lot of the time prevent death
and extend your lifespan but extending your lifespan without improving your health span
is not the thing that i would want for myself i don't want to live until a hundred years old
on all of these medications where my quality of life is pretty poor you want both you want both
lifespan and health span you want to live longer and you want those extra years to be really really
good years and the only real way to make that happen is by eating well and moving well and
staying strong and socially connected the sad thing about getting healthy these days is just
how aware you become of how unhealthy society really is and the answer more than anything else
is to go back to the habits that caused the problem in the first place rather than relying
on pills that we hand out after the problem has started and you know every doctor will have a
patient that stays with them forever and this patient is mine and i will always have a sense
of guilt that i should have done more for him and so i really hope this channel helps as many people
as possible and raises the awareness of these big issues that we have this day and age in the
modern western world and so that is what this channel is all about is about helping people
prevent the things that we see all the time the diseases that are caused by how we live this day
and age so anyway i hope you found that video useful and if you did share it with people that
you think could benefit from it leave me a comment in the description below and let me know what
things you're struggling with and how i can help you anyway i'll stop rambling now thank you for
listening and i'll see you next time
