Robert Curthose, the eldest son of William the Conqueror, has been judged by history in many different ways. Some have branded him a traitor, others have hailed him as a hero, and still others have dismissed him as a fool. Yet whatever the verdict, In my opinion he was undoubtedly the most fascinating of William’s sons. The bitter discord that arose between Robert, his father, and his brothers was not born from trivial quarrels; it was rooted in deeper grievances that would echo through the history of England.
Once the recognised heir to his father’s dominions, Robert had received the sworn fealty of powerful lords and barons. Yet fate carried him down a far more turbulent path—one that would see him stand in arms against his own father, William the Conqueror, and even face him in single combat upon the battlefield.
His life unfolded with the drama of an epic tale. He journeyed east to join the great expedition of the First Crusade, where he distinguished himself as a capable commander. There he played a notable role in the campaign that culminated in the capture of Jerusalem from Muslim forces—an achievement that secured his place among the celebrated warriors of the age.
Yet despite these feats, the crown of England never rested upon his head. His younger brothers, William II of England and Henry I of England, would each rule the kingdom in turn, while Robert—the eldest—was forever denied that honour. The reasons lay largely in the bitter disputes that had long divided him from his formidable father.
Today we will explore the life of Robert Curthose and uncover why the man once destined to inherit England’s throne ultimately never ruled it. This is his story.
00:00 Introduction 02:07 Ancestry & Early Life 03:20 Of William the Conqueror 05:02 Robert rebels against his father 10:37 The Conquerors death 13:06 William II Rufus takes the trone 16:10 First Crusade (1096–1099) 21:03 Henry I takes the throne 24:39 Character & Legacy
Robert Curtos, the eldest son of William the Conqueror, has been judged by history in many
different ways. Some have branded him a traitor, others have hailed him as a hero, and still others
have dismissed him as a fool. Whatever the verdict, in my opinion he was undoubtedly the most
fascinating of William's sons. The bitter discord that arose between Robert, his father, and his
brothers was not born from trivial quarrels, it was rooted in deeper grievances that would echo
through the history of England and Normandy. Once the recognised heir to his father's dominions,
Robert had received the sworn fealty of powerful lords and barons. Yet fate carried him down a far
more turbulent path, one that would see him stand in arms against his own father, William the
Conqueror, and even face him in single combat upon the battlefield. His life unfolded with the
drama of an epic tale. He journeyed east to join the great expedition of the First Crusade,
where he distinguished himself as a capable commander. There, he played a notable role
in the campaign that culminated in the capture of Jerusalem from the Muslim forces, an achievement
that secured his place among the celebrated warriors of the age. Yet despite these feats,
the crown of England never rested upon his head. His younger brothers, William II of England
and Henry I of England, would each rule the kingdom in turn, while Robert, the eldest,
was forever denied that honour. The reasons lay largely in the bitter disputes that had long
divided him from his formidable father. Today, we will explore the life of Robert Kurthos and
uncover why the man once destined to inherit England's throne, ultimately never ruled it.
This is his story. Robert was born in the year 1051, the eldest son of William the Conqueror,
who at the time ruled as the Duke of Normandy. Through his father, Robert traced his lineage
back to the legendary Viking leader Rolo, the first ruler of the Rouen and the forefather of
the Norman Dynasty. His mother was Matilda of Flanders, a woman of distinguished and powerful
heritage. She was the daughter of Baldwin V, the Count of Flanders, one of the most influential
princes of his age, and of Adela of France, herself the daughter of the French King Robert
II of France. Through this noble lineage, Robert was connected not only to the ruling house of
Normandy, but also to the great aristocratic and royal families of Western Europe. In his youth,
Robert displayed courage and considerable skill in the martial exercises expected of noblemen
of his rank. Yet alongside these promising qualities, there were also flaws in his character.
At times he was inclined toward idleness and he possessed a certain weakness of resolve
that would later shape the course of his life. William the Conqueror lived a life defined by
extraordinary triumph and relentless ambition. His early years as the Duke of Normandy were
overshadowed by violence, as rival Norman lords struggled to control the young ruler.
Yet William overcame these dangers, crushing rebellions from kinsmen and firmly securing
his authority in Normandy. By the 1050s, he had become a formidable claimant to the throne of
England, then ruled by his cousin Edward the Confessor. When Edward died in the year 1066,
the crown was taken by Harold Godwinson, but William insisted that the throne had been promised
to him and that Harold had sworn to support this claim. Later that year, William invaded England
and won a decisive victory known as the Battle of Hastings, where Harold was slain. On Christmas
Day of the year 1066, William was crowned king. His rule was maintained through both strength
and ruthlessness. Rebellions continued, most notably those surrounding Edgar Aetheling,
the last male heir of the old royal house. William crushed resistance with brutal force,
culminating in the devastating Harrying of the North, when vast regions were laid waste
and thousands perished. Such was the towering reputation of William, a conqueror, a warrior,
and a king, that his eldest son Robert, grew up living firmly in the shadow of one of the greatest
and most formidable rulers of the medieval world. From an early age, Robert held the title of Count
and occupied a place of honour at his father's court. On two occasions, the Norman baron swore
fealty to him as the future ruler and he was formally recognised as his father's heir.
He was also the nominal Lord of Maine and there is evidence that in 1077, he was ceremonially
invested with the Duchy of Normandy. Yet these honours were largely symbolic.
William, a ruler both commanding and cautious. Though he granted titles, Robert held no real
power, always bound to the will of his father. For Robert, surrounded by ambitious young nobles
and denied meaningful responsibility, this state of affairs proved deeply frustrating.
Like any prince destined for greatness, he longed for independence, a household of his own,
revenues and the authority fitting for a future king. William, fearing that such power might
weaken his rule, refused him. Resentment gradually took root. Encouraged by his reckless young
companions, the young prince approached his father and boldly demanded that the rule of Normandy
should be handed over to him at once. William refused without hesitation, declaring that
Normandy was his by inheritance and England by conquest. Neither would be surrendered before
its time. Though the matter ended in anger rather than open revolt, a final insult soon pushed
Robert toward rebellion. According to the chronicler Auderic Vitalis, Robert's younger
brothers William II of England and Henry I of England once mocked him by emptying a chamber
pot over his head. Humiliated and enraged, Robert erupted into a violent quarrel that only their
father's intervention could stop. When William refused to punish the younger princes, Robert felt
his honour had been grievously wounded. That very night, he gathered his loyal companions and rode
to the Rois, attempting to seize the castle by surprise. In doing so, he had crossed the line
into open rebellion. William swiftly ordered the arrest of the conspirators, spreading fear among
their ranks. Some were captured while others fled beyond the frontier. The crisis only deepened
when William discovered that his own wife Matilda of Flanders had secretly been sending money to
their rebellious son. Soon, Robert secured the support of Philip I of France and together,
they raised a formidable force. William was now compelled to act. Rebel bands harried the
northeastern borders of Normandy, spreading fear across the countryside. Determined to crush the
uprising, the king marched in the bitter winter of the year 1078 and laid siege to the stronghold
of Gerbois. For three weeks the siege dragged on. In keeping with the customs of the age,
knights from both armies issued formal challenges, and fierce skirmishes broke out between chosen
warriors. At last, the defenders of the Gerbois launched a sudden and daring attack,
drawing the besieging army into open battle. Amid the chaos of the fighting,
father and son met face to face. The ageing conqueror, hardened by countless campaigns,
was nevertheless overmatched by his younger and more agile opponent. William was wounded in the
arm or hand and his horse was killed beneath him. One account tells how a loyal English retainer
rushed forward with another horse to save the king, only to be struck down moments later by
an enemy arrow. Another tradition claims that Robert, recognising his own father's voice in the
struggle, dismounted and offered his own horse so that the wounded king might escape. The royal army
was defeated, many were slain or captured, among them Robert's brother William II of England,
who was wounded in the fighting. It was a complete rout and William's forces fled the field.
The defeat was a bitter humiliation in a reign otherwise marked by triumph. The historian
William of Mamsbury would later describe it as the only true disaster of the conqueror's career.
Enraged by both betrayal and disgrace, having been wounded and unhorsed by his own son,
William is said to have laid a terrible curse upon Robert, he also vowed to disinherit him
forever. Though the king later softened and granted a reluctant forgiveness,
many believed that the shadow of that curse lingered. In the long years that followed,
Robert's life so full of promise in his youth would often seem burdened by misfortune,
as though the weight of his father's wrath had never fully lifted.
Robert would spend much time as a wandering knight, as he travelled throughout France,
Germany and Flanders. He was in effect, a prince who had been disinherited.
Near the close of the year 1086, William the Conqueror departed England and returned to the
continent. Upon reaching Normandy, he arranged the marriage of his daughter Constance of Normandy,
to Alan IV of Brittany, a calculated alliance intended to strengthen his position against the
watchful kings of France. Meanwhile, his eldest son Robert was still aligned with the French crown
and continued to provoke unrest, forcing William to mount a campaign against France in the year
1087. In the late summer of that year, the king appeared with his army before the gates of Mons,
the town's inhabitants and its scattered garrison, taken completely by surprise, fled in panic.
William's forces stormed through the gates, plundered the city and set it ablaze. It was
a ruthless act of vengeance. However, on his way home, William would return to the Rouen a dying
man. Whether from illness or injury sustained during the campaign, his final days had begun.
Upon his deathbed, William made a momentous decision. His eldest son would not inherit the
crown of England. Instead, he declared that the kingdom should pass to his second son,
William II of England, known as Rufus. In truth, the dying king might gladly have disinherited
Robert altogether. In his final reflections, William observed that he held England not by
hereditary right, but through divine favour and victory in battle over Harold Godwinson at the
Battle of Hastings. England, therefore, was his to bestow as he wished. Normandy, however,
had been lawfully promised to Robert, and that grant could not be undone. Those gathered at
his bedside urged the king to forgive his son, fearing he might die with bitterness still in
his heart. At last, setting aside his anger, William called upon God and his nobles to witness
as he granted Robert forgiveness and confirmed his right to Normandy. Soon afterward, the great
conqueror died at around the age of 59, bringing an end to one of the most formidable reigns of
the medieval world. When William the Conqueror died in the year 1087, his sons inherited a
divided realm. Robert Curthouse received Normandy, while his brother William II of England, known as
Rufus, became the King of England. The youngest brother Henry would receive a large sum of money
to buy lands. Though Robert initially accepted William Rufus as king, powerful nobles soon
encouraged him to challenge his brother. Chief among them was Otto of Béxar, the ambitious
bishop of Béxar. Robert wished to invade England, but lacked the money to raise an army. He therefore
asked Henry for part of his inheritance. Henry refused at first, but Robert then offered him
vast lands and lordships in return for support. Henry accepted, thus the eldest and youngest sons
of the conqueror joined together in a plot to overthrow the middle brother and seize his throne.
In the summer of the year 1088, rebel barons across England rose in Robert's name. They ravaged the
lands of the king's supporters and strengthened their castles, filling them with supplies. If the
king failed to act quickly, they believed they could survive by plundering nearby lands and
plunge the kingdom into feudal chaos. King William responded swiftly and cleverly. First, he divided
the rebels by offering generous rewards of land and wealth to those who remained loyal to him.
Second, he appealed directly to the English people, promising them the best law that had
ever been in this land, which helped rally support for the royal cause. Finally, he led his forces
personally against the rebels. After a six week siege, he captured Pevensey Castle in Sussex
and took Odo prisoner. Meanwhile, the troops Robert was sending from Normandy were scattered
by storms in the channel and never reached England. William then marched on Rochester Castle in Kent,
where many rebels had gathered. With Robert unable to come to their aid, they were forced
to surrender and the rebellion quickly collapsed. Some of William's loyal barons urged him to show
mercy, reminding him that today's enemy might one day become a useful ally, a view later recorded
by the chronicler Auderic Fatalis. Many of the defeated rebels fled back to Normandy.
Odo, once the richest man in England, was stripped of his wealth and banished for life.
William dealt with the aftermath pragmatically. The nobles he needed were forgiven,
while those who remained dangerous were removed. Confiscated estates were seized by the crown
and redistributed among the king's loyal supporters, strengthening his rule and ending the revolt.
In the year 1096, Robert set aside the quarrels of his youth and answered the call of the First
Crusade, joining the great expedition to aid the Byzantine Empire against the Seljuk Turks,
and reclaim the holy city of Jerusalem. Though he was a prince of high rank, Robert was short of
money and in order to finance the journey, he mortgaged the Duchy of Normandy to his brother,
William II of England. Whether out of calculation or convenience, William agreed, thus sending his
restless elder brother eastward on one of the most dangerous adventures of the age.
Robert gathered a formidable host and joined forces with other great lords of the crusade,
including Robert II, the Count of Flanders, and Stephen II, the Count of Blois. Their armies
marched across Europe and Asia Minor, eventually arriving in the year 1097 at the magnificent city
of Constantinople, where they were received with honour by the Emperor Alexios I. There,
the crusader princes swore solemn oaths to return former Byzantine cities to the Emperor's rule
and to recognise his overlordship. Soon after, Robert joined the main crusading host besieging
the city of Nicaea, which fell in June of the year 1097. Not long afterward, at the fierce battle of
Doroleum on the 1st of July, Robert commanded part of the crusader vanguard when it was suddenly
surrounded by Turkish forces. The Normans and their allies endured a desperate struggle beneath
the blazing summer sun. When the enemy cavalry surged around them, Robert's men formed a tight
defensive circle and fought with remarkable discipline, holding their ground for hours
until the rest of the crusader army arrived and turned the tide of the battle into a decisive
victory. Robert's courage and leadership were again displayed during the brutal siege of Antioch
and one of the most desperate episodes of the Crusade. The siege dragged on for months and
when the city finally fell in the year 1098, the crusaders themselves were soon besieged by a vast
Muslim relief army. In the fierce battle that followed, Robert commanded the Norman and English
forces in the front line. The crusaders fought with extraordinary determination and ultimately
shattered the enemy host, securing one of the most dramatic victories of the entire campaign.
As the crusade pushed south toward its sacred goal, Robert eventually joined the army of Godfrey
of Bouillon during the advance upon Jerusalem. The crusaders reached the holy city in June of
the year 1099, but they faced a daunting challenge. Their army lacked the timber and materials needed
to build siege engines. Robert personally led efforts to gather wood from the surrounding
countryside, allowing the crusaders to construct the great siege towers that would prove decisive.
On the 15th of July of the year 1099, after weeks of desperate fighting, the crusaders launched
their final assault on the walls of Jerusalem. Towering siege engines rolled forward under a
storm of arrows and fire. Ladders were raised, gates battered, and warriors would fight in
hand-to-hand combat upon the ramparts. At last, the walls were breached and crusader banners rose
above the holy city. Robert Kurthos was among those who entered Jerusalem that day, sharing
in one of the most momentous victories of the medieval world. The crusade reached its final
climax a month later at the Battle of Ascolon on the 12th of August in the year 1099. Robert
commanded part of the crusader centre in the battle against the army of the Fatimid Vizier,
Al-Afdal Shahanshah. Fighting fiercely in the thick of the struggle, Robert reportedly struck
down the Egyptian standard-bearer and captured the Vizier's great command tent, a dramatic symbol
of victory. By the end of the crusade, Robert Kurthos had transformed his reputation. Once
known mainly for quarrels and rebellion, he had proved himself a courageous commander,
a skilled warrior, and a prince capable of working alongside many rival leaders.
The fulfilment of his crusading vows was a personal triumph, and for a moment at least,
the son who had long lived in the shadow of the conqueror had earned a glory worthy of his name.
William Rufus would die mysteriously in a hunting accident in the New Forest in the year 1100.
The English throne suddenly stood empty, yet Robert Kurthos, the elder brother and rightful
claimant in the eyes of many, was still returning from the First Crusade and remained far from
Normandy. Seizing the moment, his younger brother Henry moved swiftly. Within days,
he secured the royal treasury at Winchester and had himself crowned the King of England.
By the time Robert arrived in Normandy that September, the opportunity had slipped away.
Though he retained some supporters in England, they were quickly subdued by Henry and his allies.
Henry's advantage lay in his speed. A long delay while Robert travelled from the east
could have left the kingdom dangerously leaderless. Thus the young son of the
conqueror secured the crown before his elder brother could even press his claim.
The rivalry between the brothers soon deepened into open war. In the year 1105, Henry invaded
Normandy during their ongoing dynastic struggle. His campaign captured important towns such as
Bayer, though political tensions surrounding the Investiture controversy forced him to temporarily
withdraw. The following spring, however, Henry returned determined to settle the matter once
and for all. In the year 1106, he advanced into western Normandy and quickly seized the fortified
abbey of Saint-Pierre-sur-Dive. From there he marched south and laid siege to the strong
castle of Tarnsbray. When word of the siege reached the Duke, Robert gathered his army and marched to
relieve the castle. Negotiations were attempted but quickly failed, and Robert resolved to fight.
The two armies met on the 28th of September of the year 1106 in the fields below Tarnsbray.
Henry, displaying careful preparation, ordered most of his knights to dismount and fought on
foot alongside the infantry, an unusual decision for Norman warfare where mounted cavalry normally
dominated the field. He arranged his army in disciplined lines and held a strong reserve
under the command of allies from Maine and Brittany. Robert's forces advanced uphill in
determined attack, but Henry's steady infantry and dismounted knights held firm. When Henry
released his reserve into the battle, it struck Robert's army on the flank and threw it into
confusion. The struggle was fierce but brief. Within roughly an hour, the battle was decided.
Much of Robert's army was killed or captured and among the prisoners was the Duke himself.
This defeat would end Robert's hopes forever. Henry now took control of Normandy,
reuniting the lands once ruled by their father, William the Conqueror. Robert was carried away
into captivity, first held at various castles and later confined at Cardiff Castle. There he would
remain for the rest of his long life. The once celebrated Crusader and heir of the Conqueror
spent nearly three decades in prison before dying in the year 1134 at the age of 83. To some,
it seemed that the shadow of his father's ancient curse had indeed followed him to the end.
Many stories have survived that reveal the character of Robert Curtos, painting the
portrait of a prince both heroic and deeply human. One of the most famous tells of his
encounter with his own father William the Conqueror on the battlefield. In the heat of
the struggle, Robert wounded the aging king and by many accounts could have struck the final blow
and claimed the throne for himself, yet he did not. Instead, the rebellious son spared his fallen
father. Pride and shame however, prevented reconciliation and Robert soon drifted into
the life of a wandering knight. In time, he found new purpose in the great enterprise of the First
Crusade, where he distinguished himself as a courageous warrior. Fighting alongside the
princes of Europe, he became part of the army that captured Jerusalem, one of the most remarkable
victories of the medieval age. Yet alongside these feats, were tales of excess that followed
him throughout his life. The chronicler Auderic Vitalis recounts one colourful episode during
Easter in the year 1105, when Robert was meant to hear a sermon delivered by the venerable bishop
Sirlo. On the night before the service however, the duke indulged in revelry with harlots and
jesters. While he lay asleep in a drunken slumber, his companions stole away his clothes as a jest.
When Robert awoke, he discovered himself naked and unable to leave his bed, was forced to miss
the sermon entirely. Such stories give us a vivid glimpse of the man behind the legend.
Robert Kurthos was no cold figure of marble, but a living flawed prince, brave in battle,
easily swayed by those around him, and drawn equally toward glory and indulgence.
The legacy of Robert Kurthos is tragic and curious. Robert's legitimate legacy survived
chiefly through his son, William Clito, whose life became a symbol of a lost claim of the
elder Norman line. William Clito spent much of his youth as a pawn in the politics of France
and Flanders, supported by kings and rebels who opposed Henry I. Several times he came close to
restoring his father's fortune, even briefly becoming the Count of Flanders, but fate proved
unkind. In the year 1128, he was mortally wounded during a siege, dying young and childless. With
his death, the direct legitimate line of Robert Kurthos effectively ended. Thus, Robert's legacy
is remembered less through a flourishing line of rulers, and more through the romance of what
might have been the brave but ill-fated heir of the conqueror, whose son died striving to reclaim
a lost inheritance, and whose scattered descendants faded quietly into the nobility of Norman lands.
His story stands as one of the great tragedies of medieval kinship, where birth alone could not
secure a crown, and fortune favoured the shrewder hand. I would like to give a huge thank you to
all of my members, your contribution is valuable to the continuation of the channel,
and I appreciate you all immensely. A special thank you to John Sites and Stephanie Hassan.
I hope you all enjoyed the video, if you did, be sure to like, subscribe and share,
and I'll see you all soon for another history profile.