The Hidden Galaxy (Caldwell 5 or IC 342) - Deep Sky Videos

Time Space
7 followers
Jun 11, 2026
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThis video discusses IC 342, known as the \"Hidden Galaxy.\" Despite being the third largest galaxy in the sky by angular size, it remained undiscovered for a long time because it is located behind the dust and stars of the Milky Way's plane. The discussion covers its discovery by amateur astronomer William Denning and its striking similarities to our own galaxy.
OK, Professor. You've been out with your telescope again?
I've been out with my telescope looking at Cold World 5, since we're working our way
through this Cold World catalogue and we've got to number 5.
How lovely is that? I mean, that is pretty good.
It's a beautiful galaxy. It is the third largest galaxy in the sky.
Oh, OK, so it was an easy one then. Yeah, although it's a galaxy that no-one's
heard of. The famous ones like the Andromeda galaxy, the biggest one in the sky everyone's
heard of. No-one's heard of IC 342.
What's the second biggest one in the sky? M33, the Triangulum galaxy, another spiral
galaxy. And then this one. Has this one got like a
cool name, like the Dragon or anything? It's sometimes called the Hidden Galaxy, for
reasons which we'll come to, but yeah, it's not a particularly well-known galaxy.
So you remember the galaxies are generally put into catalogues and most of the famous
ones, some of them are in the Messier catalogue, but actually most galaxies don't make it to
the Messier catalogue, they're in a thing called the New General Catalogue, which is
why a lot of them are called NGC something or other, which was a catalogue compiled kind
of towards the end of the 19th century. This one didn't make it into the NGC. It was
too late. So after the NGC was made by a guy called Dreyer, and I think it was published
in 1888, he published a couple of kind of supplements to the NGC that were called the
Index Catalogue or the IC, and this made it into the Index Catalogue.
Wow. Third biggest in appearance to us, not third biggest in actual size.
No, third biggest in angular size. It's kind of a, it's a little bit smaller than the full
moon.
Okay. What do you want to tell me about it?
I'll tell you. Well, let's go back to its discovery. As I say, it slightly missed the
boat in that it didn't make it into the NGC. That's because it was discovered in, let's
get the date right, 1893 by a guy called William Denning, who was an amateur astronomer. So
the reason why kind of various things didn't sort of quite make it into the NGC, but then
there were a whole bunch of more galaxies were found is really because photographic
astronomy was coming along at that point. So people were taking photographs of things
that hadn't made it, you know, weren't really that visible just through telescopes. But
as soon as you started taking pictures, suddenly you could see much fainter things. This galaxy
is a bit interesting because it wasn't a photographic discovery. It was an optical discovery, which
is the discovery of somebody looking for an eyepiece by this amateur astronomer from Bristol
in the UK, who was mainly looking for comets and was interested in meteor showers and all
sorts of things he's quite famous for. But in one of his sweeps for looking for comets,
he found this galaxy and it was published in this short-lived journal called Astronomy
and Astrophysics. There's a current journal called Astronomy and Astrophysics without
the hyphen, but there was this short-lived journal at the end of the 19th century. So
I sort of dug down and managed to find the original copy of his claiming to have discovered
this galaxy. And it's quite entertaining because it's this wonderful piece of passive aggressive
writing. I think it's fair to say it's the way to describe it. It's nice to know that
astronomers haven't actually changed in the last hundred or so years. Let me read a bit
from this. It says, Professor Swift writes in the August number of Astronomy and Astrophysics
about a new nebula independently picked up by Professor Barnard and myself at certain
coordinates. Blah, blah, blah. He claims to have seen this nebula many years ago with
his four and a half inch comet seeker. My purpose now is not, however, to discuss the
question as the priority of discovery, but to mention that while hunting for comets,
I found another one. So basically, he wants to just put it on the record that he actually
found that other object as well. But actually, he's passed that now. He's not going to raise
that again, even though he's just raised it again. And here's this other object that he
found in passing. And then he goes on to describe it. He talks about this new object he found.
It's rather faint with the nucleus about 12 magnitude and very small. It's kind of interesting
because I just told you it was the third largest galaxy on the sky. But it was sufficiently
conspicuous to be discovered with his 10 inch reflecting telescope. And then he goes on
to give the coordinates of the right ascension and declination of where it is in the sky.
Turns out the coordinates are quite important for this galaxy. And so that's where they
were. And again, I went and checked. And indeed, that's exactly where this galaxy is on the
sky. What's going on? Why has it been so elusive? So actually, interestingly, it kind of comes
down to its coordinates. And so there are various ways you can measure where something
is on the sky. Basically, you know, you need some way of saying left to right, some way
of saying up and down. You just basically need two coordinates to specify where something
is on the sky. So the ones that astronomers typically use and so the ones that were used
in this discovery are these things called right ascension and declination, which are
essentially related to the Earth. They're to do with how far north or south the thing
is relative to the Earth and how far east or west, having to allow for the fact that
the Earth rotates, which complicates things a little bit. But basically, it's a sort of
Earth based coordinate system. There are other coordinate systems that astronomers sometimes
use. For example, sometimes they use this thing called ecliptic coordinates, which is
a measure relative to the solar system. Essentially, it's how far along things are in the plane
of the solar system or how far out of that plane they are. That's useful for measuring
planets and asteroids and those kinds of things. But there's another coordinate system.
So I looked this up in its other coordinate system. So here are the various ways you can
measure the coordinates of this galaxy. So we talked about right ascension and declination
and there were these ecliptic coordinates. But the one I want to talk about are galactic
coordinates. So another way you can measure where something is in the sky is you can set
your zero point for your coordinate system to be the center of the Milky Way. And then
you can measure how far out of the plane of the Milky Way they are or how far along the
plane of the Milky Way they are. And again, that gives you these two directions. And so
in this particular case, this galaxy is at a galactic longitude. That's how far along
the plane is at 138 degrees. But a galactic latitude, that's how far out of the plane
it is of only 10 degrees. So it's very close to the plane of the Milky Way. And that's
why it wasn't discovered for so long, because close to the plane of the Milky Way, you've
got all this dust, all this obscuration, all this sooty material, which makes anything
that lies behind it appear very faint. So that's why when this object was discovered,
it was small and faint because you could only see a little bit of light from the center
of it.
So what you're saying is like, basically, you're looking through a big, thick chunk
of the Milky Way, like almost looking straight through the whole thing.
Absolutely. I mean, you're 10 degrees out, so you're not quite in the plane of the Milky
Way. But even so, that's looking through a lot of Milky Way. And in fact, you can sort
of see that just by looking at it, because there's an awful lot of stars here. And these
are just stars from the Milky Way that you're looking through. But not only are you looking
past the stars, but you're looking through all this sooty, dusty material.
So Denning wasn't seeing much of it. He didn't realize just how big a thing he was looking
at.
Right, because he didn't have the luxury of integrating for a long time by taking a picture.
He was really just looking through his eyepiece. And with the eyepiece, even with a moderately
large telescope he was using, you really can't see much of this galaxy. It's only when, so
I think this was a two-hour exposure I ended up taking. It's only when you take a relatively
long exposure of it, you see quite what a big, dramatic galaxy it is. It's about the
same size as the Milky Way, so it's actually kind of a twin of the Milky Way.
Glass?
I mean, it's not really a barred galaxy. The Milky Way has one of these sort of rectangular
barred structures in it, but other than that, in terms of it's a spiral galaxy, it has roughly
the same kind of spiral structure as the Milky Way, it's the same luminosity as the Milky
Way, so it's pretty much at least a close cousin of the Milky Way.
One last question. It's in the Caldwell catalogue, and we've discussed the Caldwell catalogue
before, that Patrick Moore catalogued these objects that he thought were good to look
at, they were good sport. That sounds like this isn't, though. Unless you're using the
tech that you were able to use, this isn't one you're going to have fun in the backyard
with, is it? Like, you're not going to see much.
You can just about glimpse it with a telescope, just with an eyepiece, but I think the Caldwell
catalogue was at least in part designed with taking pictures in mind, so actually, and
it's big enough that if you're prepared to look for long enough, it does make a pretty
dramatic picture. It is a beautiful spiral, undeniably.
It is nice. Have you looked up anything more about them? Are they big, are they small,
is there anything about them that's special, or are they pretty, you know, run-of-the-mill
average joes?
I mean, what's interesting about them is they're both very similar. They're on very similar
orbits, they're very similar sizes. I think they're estimated to be about six or seven
kilometres across each.
