The Law Academy is a project designed to provide legal education for students studying law in the UK. Subscribe for more content.
M. Freeman, Lloyd’s Introduction to Jurisprudence (Sweet & Maxwell, 2014). R. Wacks, Understanding Jurisprudence: An Introduction to Legal Theory (Oxford University Press, 2020). J. Penner & E. Melissaris, McCoubrey & White’s Textbook on Jurisprudence (Oxford University Press, 2012).
Jurisprudence is the philosophical study of law. It encompasses the examination and analysis of legal principles, concepts, and theories, aiming to understand the nature of law, its origins, and its underlying philosophical foundations. Jurisprudence explores questions about the essence of law, its purpose, and its role in society.
Disclaimer:
At no point are these video lessons intended to provide any sort of legal advice. These are for educational purposes only!
Image(s) Copyright: This Photo by Unknown Author is licensed under CC BY-SA
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI Generated
This lesson explores the core tenets of John Austin's legal positivism, focusing on his specific definition of law. It examines the \"Sovereign Command Theory\" and the \"Separability Thesis,\" emphasizing that law is derived solely from the authority of a sovereign and is independent of morality, supported by institutional enforcement mechanisms like the judiciary and police.
In the previous lesson, what we did was talk about Austinian positivism, some of the major
component aspects of Austinian positivism, a basic recap of some of the early and traditional
concepts within legal positivism, and then the critique, major critique, of John Austin's legal
positivism, which is of course his reaction to and relationship with international law,
given the fact that according to Austinian positivism, law is derived from the sovereign,
whatever that sovereign may be, and given the fact that international law is made without the
existence of some kind of international sovereign, it's suggested that therefore international law
is not law. It may still exist, but it is not law in the way that we understand domestic law,
for example. But what we're going to do in this lesson is go into far more detail looking at
Austin's definition of law. We're going to talk about some of the elements of Austinian positivism,
we'll talk about some of the key components of it, and some of the very specific elements
of it as well. So, so far we have been examining the nature and origins of legal positivism,
the jurisprudential theory of legal positivism. We know already that legal positivism is something
that has developed from the sort of mid to late 1800s with people like Bentham and people like
Austin, and then developed further post-second world war, and now we have some of the more
modern legal positivists, people like H. L. A. Hart, and then you have the sort of
Hart and Dworkin debates that that were had in relation to to to positivism and jurisprudence
more generally. But for now let's just focus on some of the classical theories, some of the
traditional legal positivists. The origins are in the work of John Austin. So given the fact that
what we did in the last lesson was essentially delineate between what is natural law and what
is legal positivism, I want to actually get into some of the specifics relating to Austin's
definition of law itself. So we talked about where law where law comes from as a as part of
Austin's theories of law, but what about his definition of law? So what then actually is
law according to legal positivism? So according to Austin himself, law is quote
by the express or tacit authority of its sovereign or supreme government. That is the
conclusion that Austin derives when he thinks about what law actually is. And this is interesting
because we're talking about the express or tacit authority of its sovereign or supreme government.
Remember the last lesson we focused on the fact that law is derived out of the sovereign according
to John Austin. And this is obviously different to the fact that there is an inherent link between
law and morality according to natural law theorists. And so you establish law either
impliedly or expressly through the authority of the sovereign or supreme government. And this
gives rise to what Austin describes as sovereign command theory. This is the theory that law
derives out of the sovereign authority of the state. And it's a simple extension of the thesis
of Austinian positivism. It's a simple extension and logical conclusion that you can derive
out of thinking about what John Austin believes in terms of his understanding of legal positivism.
In its simplest form, the sovereign command theory is the proposition that the law is at the
command of the sovereign. As the name suggests, sovereign command theory, it suggests that
the sovereign is in command of the law itself. And this again forms a basis of this particular
quote, this particular passage. The idea that law is established in an independent political
community either expressly or impliedly by the authority of the sovereign. It implies that
therefore it is the sovereign that is in command of the law. The proposition that law is at the
And with that being said, and given that fact, it also is extended. The next extension is that
there are no external influences which impact on law except through that of the sovereign.
Not only is sovereign command theory telling us that the sovereign has command of the law,
but it is telling us that only the sovereign has command of the law. There is no other external
influences on the law. And the key distinction and delineation that we always derive here and
we always point to is the idea of morality. Morality is not something that is influencing
the law and the creation of the law. Only through the sovereign is their influence and creation of
law. That is the point of sovereign command theory. The next general principle of Austinian
positivism is known as the separability thesis. And again, this sounds quite fancy and academic,
but in reality is very, very simple, just like sovereign command theory. Because what the
separability thesis tells us is that it's essentially the assertion that distinguishes
positivism, legal positivism, from the natural law theory. Because essentially what the separability
thesis tells us is that law is dependent on nothing else for its existence than the command
of the sovereign. So remember what I said here earlier on, talking about sovereign command theory,
that there are no external influences and that it is the sovereign that commands
law. And then I also mentioned that it is only the sovereign that commands law, that there are
no external influences. Well, this is explained and exemplified in the separability thesis,
because what this is telling us is that there is nothing else that law depends on for its existence
than the command of the sovereign. So long as the sovereign commands it, that's how law is
justified, how the existence of law is justified. There is no concept of justice, there is no
concept of fairness, there is no concept of equity, there is no concept of anything like this,
or morality as well, if we want to include that and distinguish to natural law,
that influences the law. That is not to suggest that these things don't exist, it is to suggest
that these things don't influence law, because it is only the sovereign and the command of the
sovereign that influences law. So bear that in mind, because of course John Austin was writing
at a time where things like equity existed, at least as legal concepts, equity existed and has
existed for nearly a thousand years in the common law system. But it's not that they don't exist,
or that you can't derive justice out of some legal principles, but it is just that justice,
fairness, equity, morality do not influence the law. Austin wouldn't suggest necessarily that
there are laws which are not moral, or that don't align with morality, it is just that they are
inherently distinct. If they align with morality, that is because the sovereign commands it,
not because they have to, there's a prerequisite that they have to align with morality,
or that they are influenced by morality. Law is only influenced by the command of the sovereign.
So command of the sovereign plus sanction are the core elements of law in Austinian legal theory,
and essentially when we think about this, how do we think about this in relation to the
enforcement of law? Because the will of the sovereign is not necessarily the only aspect
of Austinian positivism, it is the only influence and the only point in which law is derived, but
it's not the only aspect, okay, because what Austin also does is place emphasis on the importance of
law enforcement, enforcing the law. Actually there's a difference between actually thinking
about the law, and thinking about what the law is, and how it ought to be, and how it should be
made, and then also thinking about how we then apply that law to real world situations. This
takes us from the realm of the academic to the real world, and there ought to be a mechanism in
place, according to Austin, that exists for law to be enforced. And this is, according to Austin,
exists in the form of the institutional enforcement of law, so things like the police force, a police
system, a judiciary, a military, etc., etc., all of which play their role in applying the law, and
enforcing the law, because it is the police who do the sort of day-to-day work of ensuring that
the criminal law is adhered to, and investigating those who do not adhere to the criminal law.
It is then the judiciary to then make a judgment as to whether or not the police have been correct
in their decision to charge an individual with a particular crime. In certain very extreme
circumstances, a state can be put under what is known as martial law, where a military then
takes hold, and sort of enforces the law as applied in military situations, in situations
of emergency often. So when we combine both this idea of sovereign command theory, and the idea of
the enforcement of law, we get what we believe to be, we form the notion of law according to Austin.