Scientists Can't Explain This 4,500-Year-Old Sumerian Queen's Skull

Archaeology Terrifying
3 followers
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThe video explores the discovery of the tomb of Puabi (formerly Shubad) in the Royal Cemetery of Ur. It debunks fringe theories regarding her \"inexplicable\" skull, explaining the deformation as a result of soil pressure. More importantly, it examines the brutal reality of the mass burials accompanying her and the unique power she held in ancient Sumerian society.
In 1928, Leonard Woolley sent a telegram to the directors of the British Museum and the
University of Pennsylvania Museum in Latin. He wrote in Latin so that the telegraph operators
who transmitted the message would not understand it, and the news would not leak before he was
ready to announce it. What he had found was too important to risk losing to a journalist
before the official announcement. The tomb he had uncovered in the Royal Cemetery of Ur,
a cemetery of nearly 2,000 graves in the ruins of the ancient Sumerian city buried under the
southern Iraqi desert, was unlike any other tomb he had found in six years of excavation.
It was intact. The looters who had robbed almost every other royal burial in the cemetery
over the 4,000 years since the graves were sealed had not found this one.
When Woolley's team entered the chamber, they found a woman.
She lay on a wooden bier in a vaulted stone chamber. She was covered in gold. A headdress
of intricately crafted gold leaves, four layers arranged to resemble the poplar leaves of the
Mesopotamian delta, sat on her skull. Large crescent-shaped earrings of gold hung at her jaw.
Rings covered her fingers. Strings of lapis lazuli and carnelian beads,
some of them originating in Afghanistan and the Indus Valley, covered her torso.
A golden comb. A golden belt. Three cylinder seals near her right shoulder,
one of which bore a brief inscription in cuneiform. The headdress alone weighed over
four kilograms, nearly nine pounds of gold arranged on a human head as if its weight
were irrelevant. The inscription on the cylinder seal read, Piu Abi Nintu Signs,
a name and a title. The name, now read in Akkadian rather than the Sumerian misreading
that gave her the name Shubad for nearly a century, means something like Word of the Father
or Orchard of the Father. The title, Nin, can mean Queen, or it can mean Lady, or it can mean
Priestess. In Sumerian, these distinctions were not always as separate as they are in modern
English, and the title a person held often contained elements of all three. What the
inscription did not contain was the name of her husband. Every woman's cylinder seal found
elsewhere in the cemetery, and in the wider archive of Sumerian administrative texts,
identified the woman in relation to a man, wife of so-and-so, daughter of so-and-so.
This seal contained nothing of the kind. Piu Abi Nin, that is all it said. Her name,
her title, no man. The title of this script says scientists can't explain her skull.
The true story is more specific, less dramatic, and ultimately more interesting.
Piu Abi's skull is almost entirely destroyed. The soil into which her tomb was cut was highly
acidic and saline, conditions that devastate organic material, and her skeletal remains
deteriorated to fragments over 4,000 years. What Wooley recovered was so little that his
wife Catherine reconstructed the queen's head using wax built over a cast of a different skull.
A female skull, presumed to be from the same period, modeled to resemble a local Iraqi woman
who lived near the excavation site. The face that appeared in newspaper photographs,
on the front page of illustrated magazines, and that drew enormous crowds to annual exhibitions
of finds at the British Museum, was not Piu Abi's face. It was a reconstruction of what an
The fragments of Piu Abi's actual skull that survived the excavation
are held at the Natural History Museum in London. Forensic anthropologists at that institution
determined from those fragments that she was approximately 40 years old when she died,
and that post-mortem cranial deformation had occurred because of soil pressure over the
millennia of burial. This is the explanation for the unusual skull shape that alternative
history sources describe as inexplicable. The weight of 4,000 years of soil compresses
and distorts bone. The skeletal record shows no evidence of chronic disease,
and no evidence of pre-mortem trauma to Piu Abi herself. The cause of her death is undetermined.
Natural causes, infection, age-related decline, are considered the most straightforward possibility,
given what the evidence allows. What the title gestures toward is this.
In the early 2000s, Zecharia Sitchin, the author who spent his career arguing that the Anunnaki of
Sumerian mythology were extraterrestrials from a planet called Nibiru who genetically modified
early humans, wrote to the Natural History Museum requesting DNA testing on Piu Abi's remains.
He believed the DNA would reveal non-human genetic signatures consistent with his theory.
The museum's response was standard institutional practice. Any such request would need to come from
a qualified ancient DNA researcher with access to appropriate facilities. No such researcher
submitted a formal proposal during Sitchin's lifetime. He died in 2010 without having secured
the test. The museum has confirmed that its holdings include the remains of Piu Abi,
also listed as Queen Shubad, and that it does not routinely conduct DNA analysis on remains
in the collection. This is where the skull story ends, for those who need it to end.
But the story of who Piu Abi was and what her tomb tells us about the civilization that produced her
is substantially stranger and more significant than any DNA result could be.
The Royal Cemetery at Ur contains 16 tombs that Woolley classified as royal on the basis of the
quality and quantity of the grave goods and the presence of mass burials of attendants.
Piu Abi's tomb, designated PG-800, is among the best preserved. When Woolley reached the pit
associated with her chamber, he found additional bodies. Five armed men near the entrance,
four grooms for a pair of oxen, more attendants, and ten women whose elaborate golden headdresses
were still intact, their arrangement suggesting they had been wearing them when they died and
had not moved significantly after death. In the associated pit above the chamber,
he found twenty-one more attendants, an elaborate lyre topped with a golden bull's head,
a chariot. He initially believed they had all voluntarily drunk poison from cups found near
their bodies, lying down in orderly rows to die peacefully in service to their queen.
The arrangement supported this interpretation, the headdresses undisturbed, the bodies in neat order,
no evidence of struggle. Later, after excavating other death pits and finding
similarly composed arrangements, he modified his account, still maintaining voluntary sacrifice,
but allowing for the possibility that some attendants had been made unconscious before
being laid out. In 2011, a team from the University of Pennsylvania Museum published a
paper in the journal Antiquity that changed this picture. Using computed tomography scanning
technology on two skulls from the cemetery, one belonging to a woman and one to a soldier,
they identified perimortem blunt force trauma. The fractures were depressed, consistent with
being struck with a heavy implement, the pattern matching the kind of injury a battle axe of the
period would produce. The bones showed evidence that mercury sulfide, cinnabar, had been applied
to the skulls after death, preserving them and possibly disguising the damage. The paper argued
the bodies had been intentionally killed, intentionally preserved, and displayed as part
of elaborate mortuary rituals. They were not willing participants composing themselves in
orderly rows to die in service to their queen. They were killed, treated to prevent rapid
decomposition, dressed in their finest clothing and headdresses, and arranged to appear peaceful.
The headdresses over damaged skulls, the ordered rows of the killed, the four thousand years of
silence. This is what Puabi commanded. Whatever she was, queen, priestess, ruler in her own right,
the institution she represented was powerful enough, and the beliefs she embodied were real
enough, that when she died around 2550 BC, some number of people died with her. Not willingly,
the evidence suggests. Not in a ceremony of ecstatic self-sacrifice, but in a ritual whose
meaning and necessity were sufficiently established in the culture of Ur, that the machinery for
executing it existed and was used. The Sumerian texts do not describe this practice directly or
explain it. The royal cemetery at Ur is unique in the archaeological record of Mesopotamia,
and no comparable mass burial has been found elsewhere in the civilization, in any other city,
in any other period. This is not a standard Sumerian practice. It is specific to Ur in the
early dynastic period, in a window of time roughly from 2600 to 2400 BC. Scholars have proposed
multiple explanations, that the primary burials were of figures who had undergone a sacred marriage
ceremony, representing a union between the city's patron deity Nana and a human counterpart, after
which the human representative was sacrificed, that the death pits represent an assertion of
power by rulers in a period of intense intercity competition, and that the practice was specific
to the religious ideology of Ur in ways that the surviving texts cannot recover.
None of these explanations is proven. The practice itself is documented. Why it existed here and not
there, why it began and why it stopped, who these people were whose headdresses were kept intact
over their damaged skulls? These questions remain open. Puabinin, she was Akkadian by name in a
Sumerian city, which itself tells us something about early dynastic Ur, that the distinction
between Sumerian and Akkadian was permeable, that a woman with a Semitic name could hold the highest
office in a Sumerian city-state, without any evident need to explain or justify this. She
ruled or held priestly authority, or both, in a city that was at the time one of the most powerful
in the known world, trading lapis lazuli from Afghanistan, carnelian from the Indus Valley,
cedar from Lebanon, and gold from sources scholars have not fully identified. The wealth in her tomb
represents a trade network of extraordinary geographic range for a civilization that had
only recently invented the wheel and had been using writing for perhaps 500 years. Her cause
of death is unknown. Her full name before the Akkadian abbreviated inscription, her parentage,
her relationship to the kings buried nearby, and her specific duties as nine are all unknown.
The cylinder seal says only Puabinin. The rest is inferred from the objects that surrounded her,
from the damaged skulls of the people arranged around her, and from the headdress that weighed
more than a modern newborn child, which was placed on a skull that was already, at 40,
beginning to decline. The Natural History Museum in London holds what remains of her.
It is not much. The soil consumed most of her across 4,000 years. What survives is fragments,
a few pieces of bone, the chemical trace of a life, the data point of an age at death.
The reconstruction that appeared in newspapers was another woman's face.
The skull that fringe sources describe as inexplicably large was compressed by the weight
of the earth above it over four millennia, a deformation that physical anthropologists
understand and can account for. The mystery of Puabi is not in her skull. It is in the two
cuneiform signs pressed into clay 4,500 years ago that identified a woman, possibly the most
powerful woman in the ancient world at that moment, by her name alone and her title alone,
with no reference to any man. It is in the ordered rows of the dead arranged in their
finest headdresses in the pit above her chamber. It is in the question of what the people of Ur
believed so completely that this was possible, and what happened to that belief, and why the
practice it generated appears only here, in this city, in this window of time, and then stops.
Puabi Nin. Two signs. 4,500 years.
The questions they generate have no answers yet in the archive of clay.
