Can ‘Suggestion-Box Science’ Make Public Health More Useful?

Science Stops
9 followers
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedDr. Erica Walker discusses the need to shift public health research from a researcher-driven model to \"suggestion box science.\" By prioritizing community-defined problems over academic goals, she argues that researchers can rebuild institutional trust and create tangible health improvements rather than merely collecting data for academic advancement.
WNYC Studios is supported by Bayer. Science is a rigorous process that requires questions,
testing, transparency, and results that can be proven. This approach is integral to every
breakthrough Bayer brings forward. Innovations that save lives and feed the world. ScienceDelivers.com.
This is Science Friday. I'm Flora Lichtman. I don't need to tell you that public health policy
is a confusing mess right now. Layoffs and shakeups at major government agencies,
funding uncertainty, skepticism about vaccines, experts, and institutions. All of this has left
some scientists and epidemiologists doing some soul searching and asking the most basic questions
about their role and relationship with the public. Which is why we wanted to talk to Dr. Erica
Walker, an epidemiologist at Brown University who has a perspective on how to do public health
better. Erica studies the relationship between community health and environmental exposures.
She started off studying noise pollution and after finding that her research wasn't serving people as
she hoped it would, she pivoted. She broadened her scope to include other sources of pollution
like water and became more focused on how to include people in her research in the hopes of
more impactful. Today we're going to hear that story. Erica, welcome to Science Friday.
Thank you for having me. It's so great to be here.
I heard that your path into public health got started with noisy neighbors upstairs.
Tell us the story.
So like I basically lived in this basement apartment. I was a starving artist and that
apartment was my studio and it had been quiet up until this family moved upstairs for me and they
had these two small kids that ran across their floor which is my ceiling for like 24 hours a day
and it sounds like elephants, heavy elephants for like 30 pound kids. I don't know how they
managed to sound like heavy elephants. As the parent of heavy elephant small children, I know
how they do. So I realized that I was going nowhere. I would call my landlord, you know,
I would complain directly to my neighbors but then I realized like it was just crazy and I had a
trusted mentor who was like, Erica, I really think you would like this field called public health.
I was like, what the hell is public health? I'd never heard of it and so I did a little research
and I realized there were two public health schools. I applied to both, got in and became a
scientist. Okay, so you got in, you became a scientist and I've heard you call this your
selfish scientist era. Yes. Unpack that for me. Yes, so at that time I was still thinking about,
you know, noise issues and I was sort of going into the situations and like I'm gonna slay these
community noise beasts and I was studying noise and I was, you know, as a doctoral student and
so I had gotten to the point where I was getting ready to defend my oral proposal and I got there
and I failed. So like I'm probably one of the only people that will openly admit that yes,
I failed my oral proposal, my oral dissertation proposal and that made me do some soul searching.
I had to like go back to the drawing board and then I was like, this is kind of like when I
moved out of like that selfish science phase and really kind of wanted to dig deep into
noise issues. So I put up a survey, like a google form survey, like in the city of Boston
and I was just like, hey, are you bothered by noise? And I got so many responses and through
those responses that kind of really helped me to move from selfish science to like community science
and there were like other people in other communities, you know, dealing with aircraft
noise or living next to a busy highway and I thought I could win this battle for myself or I
could really dig deep into this and try to win battles for other people that felt like they had
no place to turn to when they were dealing with noise issues in their communities. So I went around
the city and measured sound levels in the city of Boston at like 400 locations. So I also made
it a point in my research to interview people, incorporate those survey responses into all of
these objective measurements. So the culmination was I graded each one of the neighborhoods in the
city of Boston like as a report card. So I gave them these report card grades as a 2016 Boston
noise report. That's what it was called. And so I went to a conference, a noise conference,
a local one in Boston, and I remember I was standing at the podium and there was this guy
like in the in my side view and he was kind of pacing back and forth and I was like, this guy
looks like he's mad at me. And so as soon as I got off the podium, this guy came up to me and he was
like, hey, you graded my neighborhood as an A plus. And I went to a community meeting to complain about
aircraft noise. And the official that was leading the meeting was like, well, noise in the city
graded your neighborhood as as an A. And he was like, I never knew about your research. I never
participated in your surveys. I looked at your map, you didn't measure noise at my house. So
how could you grade my neighborhood as an A plus? And you know, I apologize. But you know, he can
he was angry. I could remember spit like on the side of his lip. He was like, angry and like he
was shaking. And you know, that made me realize here I was in my doctoral studies struggling to
understand noise. I thought I made a valiant effort to do that. And I left that man out.
So I felt incredibly guilty about not including him and wanted to make sure that my science
moving forward included people like him and I didn't cause unnecessary harm. And so I entered
this phase called ride sharing science. I went from selfish science to ride sharing science,
like destination, public health, noise focus, I'm going to pick up these additional travelers along
the way, we may not be going to the same destination, but we'll be going in a similar
direction. So I wouldn't miss that angry guy. After the break, I want to pivot a little bit
and talk about your life if you're okay with that. Yeah, absolutely. Stay with us.
WNYC studios is supported by Bayer. Science is a rigorous process that requires questions,
testing, transparency, and results that can be proven again and again. It's the approach that
mapped the human genome advancing therapies for chronic diseases. It transformed farming to help
feed billions of people. It produces countless innovations that improve lives worldwide.
This approach is integral to every breakthrough Bayer brings forward innovations that save lives
and feed the world because the future depends on it. More at science delivers.com.
Can I ask you a little bit about your origin story? Yes, absolutely. Yeah. Okay. So you grew
up in Mississippi. Will you tell me a little bit about how you grew up and how it shaped your
perspective on public health? Yeah, absolutely. So I was actually born and raised in Jackson,
Mississippi. I grew up incredibly poor. And so for me, public health was all of those studies
that my parents enrolled us in that we would give them our blood, our spit, our surveys, and
they gave us like maybe 50 bucks and we never heard from them again. It was like showing up
to collect things but not really following up after that and noticing that things around me
never changed. I was still poor, despite these studies, wanting to investigate and address all
of these issues, but nothing ever changed. And as a matter of fact, it got worse. So I was a big
non-believer in public health when I was growing up. Really? Yes, absolutely. I didn't know it was
called public health, but whatever that was, I didn't believe in it. And you actually went back
to where you grew up and you did a research project there. What exactly were you looking into?
Okay, so one of the things that we don't realize, especially when we're living in
a place like Massachusetts, like Massachusetts is so adequately resourced. There's an expert
around every corner. There's a data set that you don't have to search hard for. There's just so
much knowledge and infrastructure. And I felt guilty. I'm like, so could I be successful there?
So I took all of my resources and was like, I'm going back to Mississippi. But as soon as I got
there, I was confronted with a water crisis. So I was like, I don't know how I was going to get
people to care about noise when they literally had brown water coming from their faucets.
So you went and you were like, I want to do my noise work. This is the issue that I have invested
in, in my career, in my education. And you got there and they were like, noise is not the problem.
Correct. So I was like, I'm just going to pivot. And I had a very, very,
very understanding funder. So like we ended up pivoting to do water, but I think it was so
beautiful because I learned a lot about water. I actually learned a lot about all of the other
infrastructural failures in Mississippi and in the process of trying to study water quality,
something I didn't know. And I learned a lot about what people felt about research,
what people felt was missing. And I used that to kind of do something different.
The quintessential example was when we would do these water tests and people would be like, okay,
thanks for the water test. But your lab's name is Community Noise Lab. Why is it named that?
I was like, well, actually, we were supposed to come down here and study noise. And then they
would ask questions about noise. And they'd be like, oh, yeah, by the way, like, they're building
this data center down the street for me. I've been hearing that they're loud. Can you come and
put up a monitor before it happens so we can see the difference? And so while we were passing out
water samples, people were asking us about noise. And I felt like I got a more organic buy-in and
just being like, hey, I'm from Brown University. Can I put a noise sensor in your yard? By being
with my people in my home state and them asking those kinds of questions and seeing that I was
able to help solve a problem, I was able to get more organic buy-in. The thing that I actually
really wanted to do was noise. Right. And you could actually do the rideshare version, right?
Correct. Of your work. Yes. And so it sort of reiterates the point that as public health
researchers, I mean, we need to have an organic connection to the communities that we're working
with. And actually, people need to need us there. So like we typically start studies based on our
own personal questions. And, you know, believe it or not, because we don't have the organic
connections to the communities, we typically end up farming out that organic connection.
So we go find a community organization that has a connection. And through them,
we give them money to carry out our our our. And I'm just like that. I can't. It bothers me a great
deal. And we're going to force this community to address my research questions. And I think that
that's a very bad way of doing research. Is that kind of the point, you know, that is that the
philosophy encapsulated that the questions that scientists should be studying should start with
the people who are going to be served by this research? Is that it? Yes. And they should be
the people. I think that we should have another type of science, a suggestion box science, like
we should be working on the questions that people want us to work on because we wouldn't have to
convince funders or community people that this work is relevant. I don't I don't know how much
more powerful it could be than to say I'm here because the community wants me to be here.
Is that a radical idea? Unfortunately, it is from like funders to the professors to the college
administrators, university administrators. It really is because what I've been so baffled by
is like in a school of public health, when you talk about community, it's automatically something
that's not tenurable. I mean, I can't my interview question when I applied to apply for my job was
like, how do we tenure somebody like you, Erica? And I'm like, I don't know, maybe you don't. I
don't know. But who knows? I don't even know where to start, because, you know, when I think about
some of the systemic problems we're facing right now, these giant, giant challenges that we talk
about on the show again and again and again, you know, you can see how there might be a connection
to some of those trust issues. Yes, I think we have created these trust issues. And I think until
we admit it, we're going to be running further away from the problems and not addressing them.
So I think we have to admit as public health researchers, we typically don't leave the
communities that we operate in better off. We don't build infrastructure, we don't think in
terms of sustainability. And honestly, the things that we're promoted on are just anti-public
health. We're promoted by the number of manuscripts that we get published that are typically behind a
paywall. We are promoted by the funding that we can that we can obtain. But we're not funded by
impact. Impact are these very individual things. But when it comes to public, the impact could
should be, how has your work impacted people in a meaningful, tangible way?
And like, if we actually solve a problem, then we don't get any more funding. You know, like,
so like, there's actually this kind of perverse incentive. Like, no, I don't need to solve the
problem. And I need to waste as much time as possible, because that means another three to
five years of funding. And there's no incentive for us to actually solve problems or address
issues. Because what am I going to do next if I can't get if I can't milk this for all the funding
that I can get? So there's like this perverse, individual incentive in the university structure.
And honestly, if we solve the problem, that means no more grant funding. That means I have to do
something else. And to me, that's, that's weird. It's weird. I mean, I have two questions. One,
you know, you're at a fancy university. And you are very clear about this being your mission.
Is that a sign that things are changing? Or I guess more generally, do you think things will
change in this field? So I think there have been some recent policies that have forced us to
address some very fundamental things like fancy universities depend on government funding
for their survival, right. So through that process of really coming down in the efficiency
of government funding, I think it has forced us to take a step back and look at what we're doing.
So I think that that has actually been great. It has forced us to reflect. But are things going
to change? I mean, according to my last promotional review, probably not. But more importantly,
I don't think things are going to change because I still don't think that we believe that we're
doing anything wrong. I still feel like we believe that it is the papers, it's the grant applications,
it's the personal successes as a professor that matter. But until we believe that we need to do
this a different kind of way, then I don't think so. But I am appreciative for the for the opportunity
to reflect, at least with federal funding to reflect on the impact of this, of what we're
getting money for. I'm very appreciative for that. Really don't hear that a lot.
I know. I will say this, like, I don't want to come across like I'm preaching because like,
I was wrong about my approach up until a few days ago. Like, I'm always I think,
like, I think that public health, like, we just feel like we're right. Like, once we get that PhD,
we're right. And like, we're never going to be wrong again. So I don't want to come across like,
this is the way because I can guarantee you, a year from now, because of my experiences between
now and then I'm going to have learned so much and will update. I love that sentiment so much.
And I think, to me, it gets at one of the heart, one of the sort of core things that I love about
science, which is that it humbles us. Yes. Yes. Like, we've forgotten the scientific process.
But I feel like as once we get that PhD, we forget that life is an iterative process.
And I think we're not open to revising and resubmitting. We do it when it comes to grants,
we do it when it comes to papers. But for some reason, it doesn't apply when it comes to our
methodology to science, our approach to community. And in a place like public health,
I feel like that's a very dangerous way of thinking. So I just want to put that out there.
I've been wrong up until yesterday, and I'm going to be wrong a million times after this,
but I am open to revising, improving, and resubmitting.
Erika, thank you so much for taking the time to talk to us today.
Thank you.
I really appreciate it. Dr. Erika Walker, Assistant Professor of Epidemiology at
Brown University, where she runs the Community Noise Lab. This episode
was produced by D. Peter Schmidt. Thank you for listening. I'm Flora Lichtman.
