Why do professional coaches need a liability insurance

Liability Insurance
3 followers
Jun 7, 2026
AI GeneratedยทMay contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedBob Weil, legal counsel for the ICF, explains why professional liability insurance is essential for coaches. He highlights that even meritless lawsuits can cause severe financial strain due to high legal fees. To ensure business stability and personal asset protection, coaches must implement a robust risk management plan involving specialized insurance and proper legal structuring.
Okay, so first, tell us who you are and what the deal is with liability insurance.
Why is that so important for coaches? Okay, happy to. First of all, it's a pleasure to be here today.
My name is Bob Weil. I have served as ICF's outside legal counsel for about 11 years
on a variety of issues, which is what makes this organization so much fun to work with.
We're here today to talk about insurance for your coaching services for your business
and why it's important. And I think the easiest way to address that is,
if you're operating a business, and whether that's in the United States or anywhere else,
and your services are of a professional nature,
you have clients who, at some point or another, may or may not be pleased with what happened,
for lack of a better way to put it. And if where you live is anything like in the United States,
we tend to be a little litigious. People like to go to court here. I don't, but people do.
So it is important to have an overall risk management plan for your business, whether
that's you're a sole proprietor, whether you're incorporated, or whether you're
a limited liability company, however you've structured your business.
As part of that business plan, when you went out on your own or working for another company,
there needs to be some risk management model. And at the pinnacle of that
needs to be insurance coverage. The reason being, all it takes is a single lawsuit.
It could be the most frivolous thing that's ever come down the road or been seen by the
clerk's office in that particular court, but you're going to have to retain legal counsel.
And as you may suspect, that's not an inexpensive proposition.
Even trying to seek the dismissal of a frivolous claim costs money. It takes your time away from
your coaching. It's a drain on finances. And in the end, if you're unsuccessful, it just drags on.
So one of the ways that what I've told people over the years is professional liability coverage
and other types of coverage, I'll talk about here for your business,
is what should allow you to sleep at night. And there's no amount of money
you shouldn't be willing to pay to do that, because all it takes is one. And I'll give
you just a quick example. A few years ago, this was on the employment practices side,
which, for example, might be something you'd consider if you've got paid employees in your
company. Employment practices liability claims were a huge deal. There was no such thing as
insurance coverage for them before the mid nineties. And then one company jumped in the
market after that. And what I discovered when I was looking into that coverage, and I worked with
a few of the carriers that were underwriting it, was that the average cost of defending an
employment practices claim, and this was back around 2000. So I'll give you an idea. It was
about $230,000 then. I submitted is significantly higher now. So that's an example of the way a
lawsuit, frivolous or not, can run up fees and cost your business money and you time.
So for that reason, I think, and I recommend this to all of my clients, whether they're
nonprofits or for-profits and every one of the nonprofits, you need to establish a relationship
with an insurance professional. This is not something you do on your own.
Insurance is a very complex area. I'm not an insurance professional. I spent 20 years
defending them when they got sued under their professional liability policies, but I'm not
an insurance professional. Everything I'm giving you here today is more or less an overview on
why it's important. There are any number of reasons why you should sit down with someone who
understands what you do for a living as a coach and what's involved, because there are,
I did some legwork and there are four or five insurance carriers out there
that write in this particular market, meaning coaching services, professional coaches,
and those policies, what I have found from past experience, are generally not too dissimilar.
There may be some inconsistencies, some may cover something that another one would not,
but the only way to identify those carriers and identify your risk is to sit down with somebody,
an insurance professional who can do that, and that would be an insurance agent or an insurance
broker. If the person you've used for your home or your auto is not experienced with professional
liability, go to another agent. It is not everyone's area of expertise. So that's my
first piece of counsel. If you don't have an insurance agent and have never even talked about
this type of insurance, you should. And what I will say also is years ago, I used to teach
insurance agents and brokers how not to get sued. It was a grueling eight-hour class, unlike this,
which will go very quickly. And at the end, the message, my primary message was always the same.
You need to stay in touch with your client and they, you need to remind them that they need to
stay in touch with you. You should meet with your insurance professional, whether it's about this
kind of coverage or any other coverage for your business, every year, every single year, whether
it's by phone or video conference or in person, not by email, except nothing in writing. You want
to talk to these people. You want to look them in the eye or hear their voice and say, yes, that's,
this has changed. This is something I'm doing now I wasn't doing before. I've expanded my services.
I've got new programs in my company with respect to coaching. Are these covered under my current
policy? Or for that matter, do I have insurance? And if not, why not? Because I'm counting on you
as my insurance agent to guide me. So that's really at the heart of the matter is that if
you don't have insurance, you need to think about this in terms of what you're willing to risk.
That's what it comes down to is how much risk are you willing to assume
in what you do for a living? You have client relationships, you have confidentiality
obligations, you have a code of ethics that you're obliged to adhere to as a professional
coach. These are all duties that you engage in that could theoretically result in liability,
professional liability. And the only policy out there that's going to defend you for that type
of claim, which would usually sound in negligence or a breach of your contract with the client,
is a professional liability insurance policy. They also refer to them as errors and omissions
policies. It could be either one. But those are the terms you want to use when you talk to your
insurance agent and say, do I have professional liability or errors and omissions coverage?
I suspect you'd know. But if you don't, why not? Ask the agent, what's available? Because
your property coverage for your business, if you have business equipment, you've got an office
that you have to insure your commercial liability, which is outside of the scope of
your professional services. For example, you're driving somewhere to do a presentation in your
car and you hit someone, that policy, that claim is going to come under your commercial
liability policy, which would also include your business auto insurance.
I don't want to run too far off track here. But for example, that coverage, commercial liability,
insures against bodily injury or property damage. Professional liability policy does not.
It insures against, it insures your professional services. It insures against your negligence
in rendering your services or wrongful breach of contract. So keep in mind that while you may have
commercial general liability coverage, that's not going to protect you if there is a professional
liability claim. They are two distinct types of coverage and they don't overlap.
So please keep that in mind. If you have talked to your agent about commercial liability or property
damage, property coverage for your equipment or office, that's great. You should have that.
But you also should have, if you're looking at reducing your risk and managing it better,
a professional liability claim or a professional liability policy. So that's the why you should
consider it. It is, again, it comes down to two words, risk management and, well, three words,
avoiding sleepless nights. That would be another one. So I think from my research, I know that
I obtained through ICF a copy of the form policy for one particular underwriting company, which is
Easley, but there are four or five more that I identified. When you go, if you go, I hope you do,
to your insurance professional or to an insurance professional and ask about this,
see who, see which companies they can write with, meaning they're agents for certain companies
and they can write with those companies. If they're not agents, approved agents,
then they would have to go to someone else to broker that policy. So that's the, again,
that's most of the why. There are some other components here that we can talk about.
The coverage itself is really directed to you and your employees. If you've got employees,
you're professionalized, and they, let's say you've got four or five coaches who are members
of your staff. If they're rendering professional services on behalf of your company, they're
covered under this policy as well. This would all be disclosed when you take out the policy,
you'd fill out an application and it would indicate, okay, how many coaches do you employ?
And each one of them would be listed. And obviously the more employees you have who
are coaching and the more exposure the insurance company would have, the higher the premium.
So keep in mind that that will have an impact, but clearly and accurately
convey everything you can think of about your business to the insurance agency. Because
what happened early in my career was that it became quite obvious to me that the average
person, including me, not me anymore, but doesn't read their insurance policy,
has no, probably can't even find it in the house or in their files. And what you have
to realize is that an insurance policy is a contract between you or your business and the
insurance company that's insuring you. And like any other contract, you're supposed to read it.
And if you have questions, it's the agent that you can go to, to get the answers,
because they're authorized by that company. So keep in mind that you do not want to just
throw it in a drawer. There are decisions from, I'm practicing here in Virginia,
from Virginia, where judges have thrown out a claim by an insurer against their insurance agent
because they weren't covered for something, which was clearly explained in the policy,
but they didn't read it. So you are obligated to read that policy. So keep that in mind. It's a
piece of advice that I give to everyone when I talk about insurance, because you don't know what
you don't have until you look at it. As far as the specifics of different types of professional
liability policies, you want to consider what your limits might be. What is your appetite
for insurance premiums? If your business is just getting started, you may not want the
Cadillac of limits. You may not want $3 million or $5 million in coverage limits. You might
want to keep it at a million or even a half million if it's available. But
the amount that you select will have an impact on your premium. I typically tell people now anytime
they're doing professional liability or any other type of coverage that's based on services, don't
do less than a million dollars. The old adage used to be no less than a half a million dollars. Well,
now I go a million. And if you can afford more, I'm all for open insurance,
simply because there are other components to the policy that will impact how much coverage you
actually have, which is these policies, professional liability policies come in two
forms. There are claims made and there are occurrence policies. The claims made policy,
the carrier is insuring you for any claim made against you during the policy period.
So if your policy period is January one of this year to January one of 2022,
any claim made against you in that one year period is covered unless it's specifically excluded by
some provision in the policy. And the coverage typically runs not just to a judgment against
you damages. It also covers claims related matters, meaning legal fees, court costs.
So, and one of the trickier parts of that, and again, this is a question you can ask the insurance
agent, and this will just demonstrate how prepared you really are. I can tell you that right now,
is that certain, most policies when they're written, do not include the defense costs,
the claims related expenses in the limit. And by that, I mean, let's use an example. You have a
million dollars in liability coverage, but, and you think that's great. You know, no one said
with me, you cover that much against me. Then you find yourself embroiled in a lengthy lawsuit
in which your legal fees and court costs, as this drags on, approach three or $400,000,
which is certainly possible. What that means is in the typical policy, you've got $600,000
left to pay a judgment. In other words, if a verdict goes against you, or you're going to
settle it, you've got $600,000, not a million. So the question to ask your insurance agent is,
are my legal costs, my defense costs included in the limit, or are they apart from the limit?
Are they outside the limit? If they're outside, which is far preferable, you have a million
dollars to be applied against that judgment. The defense costs are totally separate,
and the carrier pays those. And sort of the last component of this is your, what they refer to as
retention. I prefer just to call it a deductible. That's the way most people understand it.
They can range in a policy like this. An example would be mine. I have a professional liability
policy. I have a $10,000 deductible. That means that the first $10,000 that are spent by me
on that, a piece of litigation, on a claim, come out of my pocket. Once I've exhausted that,
it's all on the insurance carrier. The higher your deductible, the lower your premium.
So if you went with a $2,500 deductible, your premium's going to be higher because you're only
on the hook for the first $2,500. So that's another thing to discuss when you sit down
with the agent. Limits, defense costs inside or outside the policy. What's my retention or
deductible? You can piece all these things together to help control the cost of the policy.
I wish I could ask if there were any questions because I'm sure there would be some, but
we won't even go there. Also, with respect to professional liability claims, there's no
coverage for bodily injury. They insure for emotional distress that's related to your
service, that's caused related to your services, but not for actual bodily injury and certainly
not for property damage, which is why you need to carry that other insurance, commercial general
liability and the business owners, if you want to call it that, business owners policy.
Those are the other two to keep. Know also that if you are the subject of a claim
and you are covered, the insurance company will likely appoint defense counsel for you.
Don't fight it because more often than not, they choose from panel counsel like when I was doing
this and that's all that attorney does is work on claims related to coaching professionals.
I learned more about insurance representing insurance agents than any human being should
ever have to learn. Don't fight that. That's their responsibility. Another important point
that I wanted to share with you is that if you have a claim, don't report it promptly
to your insurance agent. In other words, if someone sends you a letter, one of your clients
sends you a letter alleging that they've suffered damages or some manner of emotional distress,
send that letter, that demand letter. It's usually from an attorney typically, but even if it's not
from an attorney, send it to your agent and send it promptly. Don't sit on it hoping it will go away
if you ignore it because what happens is the clock starts running and the insurance company
can do a lot to protect you while that clock is running, meaning before they start the lawsuit.
I would typically be asked once the letter came in, I'd go to the insured client's office. I would
look at all the records and I'd be ready to go. So the day the complaint was actually served
and I got a copy, I could go right out and file an answer or whatever motion needed to be filed.
So keep that as part of the line of communication between yourself and your insurance professional.
The other type of policy I mentioned was an occurrence policy, which is pretty unusual
in the professional liability realms. I won't go into that in any detail,
but you want to also, when you are talking to the insurance agent about this coverage,
look to see, and this is really important, they tell you what's covered in about three lines.
They say, okay, you're covered for professional services rendered
by the named insurance, meaning you or your company or your employees. Well, that's great.
What you want to find out is what you're not covered for. And that's where people trip up.
You need to go to see what's excluded. And if you have a question about what's excluded,
you go to the insurance agent and you say, what does this mean? Because I've had to do,
I don't know what some of this exclusionary language is supposed to say. It's written by
people who are very good about being obtuse. And so you want to make sure you understand it,
even if they don't. And what I wanted to include in that was the typical policy
for a coach, I believe, based on the form that I was looking at, indicates that you,
let me find that language here. It's really quite interesting. They don't cover criminal
acts, intentional or reckless wanton misconduct. They don't cover fraud or dishonesty.
They don't cover, again, malicious acts, errors, or omissions committed with criminal,
dishonest, fraudulent, or malicious purpose or intent. Okay. Well, that kind of tells you
everything you need to know, but it also doesn't cover claims where this one caught me by surprise,
where the coach is providing professional services to a professional athlete.
So if you've got professional athletes on your client list, check to see if that's covered under
your policy. Just a thought, because they make a lot of money and they can suffer big damages.
So again, look at the exclusionary language, talk it over with your insurance professional.
That's what they're there for. That's how they get paid. They get paid by commission.
And so it's best that they serve you to keep you coming back, but make sure that's done
every single year. Let's try to think of the next question. Oh, yes. It's about,
I don't live in the US. Do I still need to consider insurance for my coaching practice?
Well, unless you don't have a court system in your country and don't have lawsuits,
I would suggest that the answer to that is yes, unless you are just completely at home with risk.
You may never be sued. Most professionals aren't ever sued, but that's not the point.
As things become more complex with the internet and various ways to communicate these days
and new exposures being created all the time in your field where you are interacting with
individuals or companies who are coming to you for your valued professional counsel, advice,
leadership, it's important to know that, keep in mind, things can go wrong. And that's what
the insurance is about. So again, the quick answer to that one is yes, you should, no matter where
you live. If you don't have coverage available there, if someone tells you you don't have it,
I'd go ask someone else. Don't accept the answer you get from the first insurance agent you get
if it's not what you expected. Shop, look around, because that agent may not be aware of another
insurance company that writes coverage in the place where you live. Some carriers write all
over the world. Some don't. So if you want to essentially follow the same model that I would
recommend if you were in this country, you would look at insurance as part of your risk management
program. The next question is, what kind of insurance is right for me?
Well, I would say if you're a business owner, if you have a business entity that you formed,
which you should, to protect yourself from personal liability,
that's the purpose of a limited liability company or a corporation. It's to protect
your personal assets from being subject to a judgment. If you're a sole proprietor without
any structure, arguably your individual assets are exposed. So keep that in mind as also part
of your business model. Am I set up the right way to protect myself and my family and my practice?
And if you find that you are set up as a limited liability company or corporation,
you're going to want to look at, as I said earlier, commercial general liability and property
coverage. Because presumably, maybe you have a great investment in office equipment and computers,
printers, scanners, whatever else. You may have office furniture. All of that would be covered
under what they typically call a business owner's policy. That incorporates both general liability
and property coverage. And that general liability coverage would protect you in the event someone
comes to your office and slips and falls. Or like I said, you're driving somewhere on your business
and you have an auto accident. That's where that kind of general liability coverage comes into
place. If you have staff, you have employees, more than a certain amount required in any given state.
For example, in Virginia, it's if you have more than two. If you have two or more employees,
you're required to have what we call workers' compensation. That, again, would be something
else you'd want to explore. If you have an active practice online, you've got client data,
information stored. If you're engaged in, you operate a blog or anything else related to your
profession, you want to look at cyber liability insurance coverage. That's the new kid on the
block. And it's the one everyone's running out and buying these days because it protects you
in the event you were hacked and some outside party has unauthorized access to your
data, which might include personal information stored by you that is of your clients.
And so there are certain, under certain statutes in the United States, when that happens,
you are obligated to notify, promptly notify the people whose data may have been exposed.
And this sort of policy provides you with the services and cost coverage that's related to
all those notification requirements. And maybe you've been, maybe your computer's been hijacked,
which is becoming the hobby of the day for some folks. You want to be sure you can get back
online. And the insurance company that underwrites that particular coverage, and again,
it's called cyber liability or cybersecurity coverage, has the experience and the experts
that can help you with that. That is another coverage you can consider and talk to your
agent about. And then finally, there would be professional liability, which is what really,
what we came to talk about today. That is a piece that I cannot recommend strongly.
If you have clients and you perform professional services without it, you're taking a risk that
you probably shouldn't be taking. And there are ways to address it that are,
that you can work to fit within the budget or appetite for insurance that you have. You just
need to sit down with your professional. So Bob, you mentioned if you don't have an agent or if
your current homeowner policy or auto policy don't cover liability, if that's just not something that
they're able to do, what kinds of tips would you have for our coaches to find an insurance broker
who maybe provides this professional liability? Yeah. Literally, if you were to Google,
well, first of all, in the United States, there are two primary insurance professional societies.
One is the Independent Insurance Agents of America, the IIAA. I think it's now IIAAB
because they include brokers in there now. And then there's the National Association of
Professional Insurance Agents. They're both here in Virginia, their headquarters, but they all have
state organizations, affiliates. So in your state, you could reach out to, you could Google to see
if the IIAAB has a state affiliate and reach out to them because those organizations are comprised,
their members are insurance agents and brokers. And like I see at these coaches,
that's where they go. That's where insurance agents and brokers go.
And that would be one way to reach out to either IIAAB or PIA, the affiliate in your state,
or you could call the national office. They're both in Alexandria, Virginia.
The other way would simply, literally, I did this myself. You could Google
professional liability insurance agent, and whoever's doing it will come up in your area.
You can, I mean, that's how I found the other insurance companies that write in this field.
I just Googled insurance companies underwriting professional coaching services. And I want to say,
I came up with, there's Beasley, the Hartford, CNA, one called Hiscox, and Liberty International.
So there's a number of them that underwrite this. And you could even reach out to them directly.
Again, Google it and those names will come up. And I guarantee you, if you go to the
Hiscox, for example, website, there's a way to reach out to them for a quote
and to talk about the coverage with them if you don't have it. So it's all readily accessible.
Again, whether you want to go through the national agencies that I recommended that
insurance agents belong to, or just doing it directly online. But it's out there and easy
enough to find out. Even your insurance agent, if they don't write that type of coverage,
they may be able to recommend you to someone who does because they'll know someone.
Well, those are the ways I think you can identify who you might want to talk to,
whether it's an agent or the carrier director. Then the last question I had was,
does ICF require insurance for membership or credential holders? To my knowledge, it does not.
That's going to be obviously a personal choice. There are other professionals and other
professions that will have a sign on their door that says, I don't have insurance coverage,
which is when I turn around and go the other way, particularly the dentist.
I think it is not a requirement, but it is part of a prudent, well thought out business plan
to protect you and your assets and your business. And it's a critical component. And I believe
probably the most critical component of a good risk management policy for your business.
I hope I've answered all of the questions sufficiently. If not, you can reach out
directly to ICF and they can send questions on to me. I'll be happy to answer any way I can.
Again, it is critical that you talk to an insurance professional, not a lawyer like me.
You want to go talk to somebody that plays in that sandbox every day.
Thank you. And I hope it was helpful. Yes. Thank you so much, Bob. We appreciate everything.
And we'll consider this complete unless you have anything else you'd like to add.
No, that's it. I'm good. All right. Thank you. All right.
