Reasons for God's Commandments The Flavors of Jewish Living - with Rabbi Michael Skobac
"I've heard about commandments before—but what are they actually supposed to do for me?"
Why did God give commandments? Are they simply rules to obey, or do they contain deeper wisdom meant to enrich our lives?
In this thought-provoking presentation, Rabbi Michael Skobac explores a centuries-old Jewish debate about the purpose of the Torah's commandments. While some sages taught that mitzvot should be observed simply because they reflect God's will, many others believed that every commandment contains profound lessons and benefits waiting to be discovered.
Whether you are Jewish, Christian, a Noahide, a former Messianic believer, or a sincere spiritual seeker, this lecture offers valuable insights into how Judaism understands the role of divine commandments in personal growth, ethical living, and our relationship with God.
In this video, you'll learn: • Why Jewish thinkers have debated the reasons behind the commandments • Whether every mitzvah has a discoverable purpose • How commandments shape character and spiritual awareness • Which Torah teachings apply universally and which are unique to the Jewish people • What the Torah's commandments can teach all humanity about meaningful living If you enjoy thoughtful Jewish learning, please like, subscribe, and share this video. Jews for Judaism is a Canadian educational organization dedicated to strengthening Jewish identity, promoting authentic Jewish teachings, fostering respectful interfaith dialogue, and helping individuals explore questions about faith, scripture, and spirituality.
ABOUT RABBI SKOBAC: Rabbi Michael Skobac is the Director of Education and Counselling for Jews for Judaism. With decades of experience, he is a leading expert in Jewish-Christian dialogue and has helped thousands of people navigate complex theological questions about the Messiah, Bible, and faith
ABOUT JEWS FOR JUDAISM: Since 1989, JEWS FOR JUDAISM is has been a trailblazer in global Jewish outreach. Jews for Judaism wins back to Judaism those Jews who have been influenced by these “Seven Threats to Jewish Survival”:
• Evangelical Christian Missionaries convert 1,000’s of Jews worldwide annually • Destructive Cults induce Jews to abandon family, friends and careers • Eastern Religions are now the spiritual choices for many Jews • Jewish Apathy and Ignorance cause many Jews to assimilate, abandoning Judaism • Intermarriage is exploding at a 75% rate in many locales • Anti-Israel propaganda brainwashes millions detering Jewish support for Israel • Antisemitism promotes Jew-Hatred and alienates Jews from Judaism
JEWS FOR JUDAISM strengthens and preserves Jewish lives through its worldwide Internet outreach, social media, free educational programs and counselling services that connect Jewish people to the spiritual depth, beauty and wisdom of Judaism.
This video examines the nature of the Torah's commandments (*mitzvot*), debating whether they are rational instructions or divine decrees. It concludes that while some reasons may remain hidden, the *mitzvot* serve to refine human character, foster a connection with God, and transform mundane existence into a disciplined, spiritually meaningful life.
The Hebrew word Torah means instruction. When God spoke to the nation of Israel at
Mount Sinai 3,300 years ago, He didn't reveal a set of doctrines or theological concepts.
The people of Israel received a set of divine guidelines detailing how God expected the nation
and its individuals to live and how they are to conduct themselves during their lives.
The books of the Torah contain hundreds of commandments that form the core of what we
call Judaism. How are we supposed to understand the nature of these directives?
There's an interesting discussion in the Talmud in Tractate Barachot 33b which can shed some
light on this question. The Mishnah deals with a situation where someone, while praying publicly,
says about God, you are so compassionate and gracious that your mercy extends to the bird's
nest. Now, this person is referring to a commandment that is found in the book of Deuteronomy
chapter 22 verses 6 to 7. And let me read those verses. The Torah says, if a bird's nest happens
to be before you on the road, on any tree or on the ground, young birds or eggs,
and the mother is roosting on the young birds or on the eggs, you shall not take the mother
with its young. You shall surely send away the mother and then take the young for yourself
so that it will be good for you and you will prolong your days. And the Mishnah rules
that while someone is leading public prayer and they say regarding this law in Deuteronomy
that God's mercy extends to the bird's nest, we silence this person. The Talmud is surprised
by this ruling and asks, what's the reason for silencing him? What was so terrible about what
he did? It actually seems that he's correct. God seems to be sparing the feelings of the mother
bird and instead of allowing someone to take its children or the eggs away in its presence,
the Torah says that you have to send away, shoo away the mother bird and it won't see you taking
away its children or its eggs. It seems that this is a commandment where God is exhibiting mercy
to the bird. So the Talmud wants to know why is it that we silence this person? And there
were two sages from Israel who had different views on this question. One explained that we
silence him because he instills jealousy in the works of creation. What does that mean?
Because he implies that God's mercy is extended to birds but not to other creatures. And that's
why we don't like what he said. But the other sage said that we silence him because he makes
the laws enacted by God into expressions of mercy but that's not correct. They are nothing other,
this sage says, than divine decrees. So the second sage says we silence him because he seems to be
implying that this law is all about having mercy for the bird but he says no, the law is simply a
decree of God. So this second view takes the position that there are no reasons for the
commandments. The commandments that God gave us don't really have reasons other than the reality
that they are the will of God. Why do you observe the commandments? This is what God has commanded.
They give us the opportunity, these commandments, to submit to God's will and demonstrate that we
are his servants. However, it turns out that this view has not been accepted by the great majority,
virtually all of the sages of Israel throughout history. This is what we call an isolated view
and most sages maintain that there are reasons for all of the commandments in the Torah,
although we may not always be able to grasp them. There's another Talmudic discussion
found in Tractate Sanhedrin 21b that explains that there are reasons for the commandments,
indeed there are reasons for the commandments, but generally God does not reveal them
and the Talmud says that actually in two places the Torah did give a reason for the commandments
and it caused one of the greatest people in history to stumble. In Deuteronomy chapter 17
verse 16 the Torah says that a king may not have too many horses so that he won't return the nation
back to Egypt to get more horses for him. Apparently Egypt was the great source of horses
in the world and so the Torah says that kings shouldn't have too many horses. There was a
concern that if the king was obsessed with getting horses that he would take the nation back to
Israel, back to Egypt and they would get horses for him and then in the next verse in Deuteronomy
chapter 17 verse 17 the Torah says a king should not have too many wives lest they turn his heart
away. Now Solomon, King Solomon violated both of these prohibitions because knowing the reasons
he believed that they didn't apply to him since he could be careful in his mind thinking that he
could avoid violating the reasons. Solomon was able to say well I'll marry as many women as I
want to marry but they won't turn me astray and I'll have many horses and I'm not going to send
the nation back to Egypt. However, we see in the Torah that Solomon ended up sending agents
to actually settle in Egypt in order to buy horses and he married a thousand wives,
700 wives and 300 concubines and the Torah tells us in 1st Kings chapter 11 verse 4
that when Solomon got older his wives led him astray and he turned a blind eye to their idolatrous
practices. Later in the book of Ecclesiastes which Solomon wrote, the book of Kohelet,
Solomon admits he says there in chapter 7 verse 23 I said I would be wise but it is far from me
meaning he's admitting that as the wisest person in the world he thought he could fully
understand the Torah but he admits that he didn't fully grasp the intention of the Torah.
The greatest sages over time believed that all of the Torah's commandments have reasons.
Maimonides felt that each person should think about and consider the reasons for each of the
commandments. Maimonides almost said this is an obligation if the Torah has reasons and the Torah
makes sense and there's a rationale for observing the commandments we should try to understand them
however our obedience should never be contingent on our appreciating the reasons could be that
there's a reason that we don't resonate with or our observance should not be contingent
on being able to come up with the reason but nonetheless it is positive to try to
think about the reasons for all of the commandments. The Hebrew word for reason
is ta'am and the way of saying in Hebrew reasons for the commandments
is ta'amei hamitzvot reasons for the commandments but the word ta'am doesn't only mean reason
it also means flavor or taste so the purpose of exploring the reasons for the commandments
is so that they should be tasty for us and we should appreciate them that's the reason we
engage in this one angle one angle to pursuing the reasons for the commandments what does it
mean to try to understand the reasons for the commandments it's trying to appreciate some of
the benefits of the commandments what are the benefits of the commandments so I want to share
a couple of the benefits not all of the benefits but some of the benefits that we know
we find in the commandments the word for commandment in Hebrew is mitzvah and mitzvah
also has the connotation of connection the word mitzvah is a connector a binder commandments
bring us close and connect us to God by helping us to be conscious of God throughout each day
and by giving us ongoing opportunities to live in obedience to God's will every commandment
therefore serves the purpose of helping connect us to God to build a relationship with God
in addition each commandment reveals something about God in the same way that every artist
reveals himself or herself through their artwork God reveals himself through his revelation
God reveals himself through the world that he created and God reveals himself through the
commandments through the Torah that he revealed so the more that we're able to gain insight into
who God is through what he revealed the closer we can get to God the more we're able to in a sense
know God a second benefit to the commandments is that the midrash explains that the commandments
don't benefit God God gets nothing out of our observance of the commandments we cannot do
anything for God God gave them to us for our benefit the commandments were given the midrash
says to refine us the commandments were given to refine us the commandments are designed
to positively impact our character traits we cultivate humility by submitting to God's will
and various commandments help us to become kinder to become more sensitive to become less
self-centered etc. Nachmanides explains the purpose of commandments like sending away
the mother bird not as a way of of demonstrating kindness to the bird
Nachmanides says the purpose of the commandment is to help us become kinder people it's not for
the benefit of the bird as much it is a benefit for ourselves a third purpose of the commandments
is to submit to the discipline by submitting to the discipline of observing the commandments
it helps us develop self-control and discipline in life it's a discipline to observe the commandments
Dennis Prager famously used to say that it's not a bad thing for a young child to learn
that they can't eat every candy in the store it's an incredibly important thing to grow up
and understand that you cannot do everything that you want to do or feel like doing in life
and the Torah inculcates this lesson to us with its hundreds and hundreds of commandments
that we have to constantly pay attention to and constantly submit our will to God's will
and so that's a third benefit of the commandments is that they build within us
this important trait of discipline and self-control the various commandments
that cover every possible aspect and corner of our lives provide spiritual nourishment
for our souls our souls are not physical our souls are spiritual what is the soul
food that we live on what does the soul get nourished by well God specifically designed
the commandments of the Torah to provide this kind of spiritual nourishment for our souls
a fifth benefit of the commandments is that the observance of the commandments helps orient us
to a life of holiness and a life that's elevated over the mundane it's very easy to go through life
simply on a physical level for example eating can be experienced as a physical activity an
instinctual activity we get hungry and we eat that's the response but the commandments are able
to elevate something as physical and mundane and instinctual as eating and elevating it to become
a holy spiritual ritual it elevates something which can be very mundane
up to a much higher level and what this does is it provides a whole layer of meaning to our lives
some of the psychologists said that mankind's greatest need is for meaning in our lives
one of the greatest causes of sadness that people often have is they find that their lives lack
meaning and so by elevating all the things that we do that can be on the same level as a cat or a
dog we do so many things that are physical and instinctual the Torah gives meaning and purpose
to each of these activities and elevates them up to a higher level a sixth benefit and again these
are not all the benefits of the commandments just sharing a few with you a sixth benefit of the
commandments is that they solidify our identification with the nation of Israel and they remind us
of our identity as Jews they unify the Jewish people and remind each of us of our unique history
a seventh possible benefit of the commandments is that they are geared many of the commandments
are geared to promoting a more harmonious society all of the commandments dealing with
perfecting human character traits to creating people that are more honest and more generous
and all the commandments dealing with interpersonal relationships and all the commandments
dealing with civil law and lost and found and employer-employee relationships they help promote
a more harmonious society an eighth possible way of looking at the commandments
is that every single commandment has a pedagogic element they teach us things
they teach vital truths and they provide a way of transmitting these truths these lessons
to the next generation there have been many books written over the centuries
by great Torah sages offering very profound rationales and reasons behind the commandments
there are incredibly deep lessons behind every single commandment entire books for example
have been written to explain the benefits of observing the dietary laws the reasons for the
dietary laws entire books have been written about the benefits of observing the sabbath
the meaning of the sabbath entire books volumes and volumes of books volumes and volumes explaining
the purpose and the meaning behind the Jewish marital laws of family purity every single law
in the Torah has an entire literature that provide us with incredibly profound lessons and truths
that come out of these laws and therefore every single law becomes a vehicle for teaching us about
ourselves teaching us about life teaching us about God teaching us about so many parts of existence
that the observance of the commandments becomes one of the most powerful ways of transforming
our lives as individuals and transforming the lives of the Jewish nation