Warren Buffet is retiring as CEO of Berkshire Hathaway at the end of 2025. He is 94 years old. Most consider him the greatest investor our time. He built Berkshire Hathaway into a trillion dollar company and his net worth is over 160 billion. But there is much more to his story than his financial genius and the numbers. This is not an obituary. It is simply a moment to look at a man and appreciate what he means to us all...
Original Air Date: 10/1/2008 For more, please visit www.charlierose.com
Warren Buffett analyzes the 2008 financial crisis, describing it as an \"economic Pearl Harbor\" caused by a real estate bubble and dangerous derivatives. He advocates for decisive government intervention to restore credit and confidence, arguing that the U.S. Treasury is the only entity capable of preventing a total systemic collapse and ensuring long-term economic resilience.
Warren Buffett is retiring as CEO of Berkshire Hathaway at the end of 2025. He is 94 years old.
Most consider him the greatest investor of our time. Some say the greatest investor of all time.
He built Berkshire Hathaway into a trillion-dollar company, and his net worth is over $160 billion.
But there is much more to his story than his financial genius and the numbers. This is not
an obituary. It is simply a moment to look at a man and appreciate what he means to all of us.
He views himself as an artist and his company as a painting. He has represented the best of
capitalism and the best of America. He feels a profound obligation to his stockholders,
whom he has also made very rich. He understands his credibility and uses it appropriately.
If Warren believes in you, that is money in the bank. His gift is his intelligence,
but also his common sense, his sense of history, and his wit. He is a man, as Hamlet said about
his father the king, we shall not see his like again. I consider it one of the great blessings
of my life that Warren and I became friends, and I cherish his support and what I've learned from
him about life. Of our many interviews, his favorite is this one in 2008 at the height of
the financial crisis, when his strength of character and belief in America helped many
who were losing their confidence, their savings, and their faith in the future.
We are in San Diego, California this afternoon for a conversation with Warren Buffett.
He is the man congressional leaders, the administration, and the Federal Reserve
want to talk and talk to. He is the legendary chairman and CEO of Berkshire Hathaway.
Its success has made him the world's richest man. He's admired for his investment results
over a long period of time. He is trusted for his common sense and the fact that he's warned
over the years in his annual letter to stockholders about some of the things that are contributing to
the crisis facing America and the global economy. For all those reasons, we have come to see him in
San Diego, where he is attending the Fortune Magazine's Most Powerful Women Summit.
Later, he will be interviewed at that conference by the Fortune reporter and longtime friend Carol
Loomis. We come this evening from the studios of our public television affiliate in San Diego,
KPBS. I thank my friend Warren Buffett for taking time in a busy schedule to talk to us.
My pleasure, Charlie.
Let me talk with the news of today. You have announced an investment of $3 billion in General
Electric along the same terms as the Goldman Sachs. Yeah, almost identical. Why GE?
Well, I got a call this morning from a friend of mine at Goldman Sachs saying they might be
interested in such an investment. I'm familiar with the company. I've known the management,
the current management, Jack Welch before Jeff Immelt. I've known him for decades.
And so I understand their businesses. We do a lot of business with them. And
I think it's the longest running stock in the Dow Jones Industrial Average. It'll be 100 years
from now. It'll be around. I hope I'm around then, too. And it was an attractive investment.
And we've had a lot of money around over the last two years. And we're seeing some
things that are attractive now. Are you looking at other things?
I look at everything, Charlie. That's my job. I really do. I mean, every day. I'm
thinking about everything. But cash is said to be king now. I mean, are you sitting on a lot
so that this is a time for Berkshire Hathaway and Warren Buffett to look carefully at a lot
of opportunities? Yeah, we want to use cash. The reason we haven't used our cash two years ago,
we just didn't find things that were that attractive. But when people talk about cash
being king, it's not king if it just sits there and never does anything. There are times when
cash buys more than other times. And this is one of the times when it buys a fair amount more.
And so we use it. There's a time to accumulate and a time to spend.
Absolutely. You want to be greedy when others are fearful and you want to be fearful when others
are greedy. It's that simple. And where are they now?
They're pretty fearful. In fact, in my adult lifetime, I don't think I've ever seen people as
fearful economically as they are right now. Then why is that?
Well, it's because they have seen the credit market seize up. They've gotten worried about
money market funds, although the latest proposition from government should take care of that.
They've seen eight percent of the bank deposits in the United States get moved very skillfully,
I might say, within the last couple of weeks from institutions that they thought were fine a few
months ago to other institutions. I mean, they are not wrong to be worried.
Is it being felt, as people often point out, on Main Street?
Well, it's been you know, I read about auto sales today. I mean, if you're an auto dealer,
you're feeling it. If you're a furniture retailer like we are, you're feeling it.
If you're a jewelry retailer, you're feeling it. I know some of these businesses were in them.
Yeah, it's being felt, but it'll be felt big time more if we don't do something about it.
What's going on? The Senate will vote
sometime this evening. Right.
Are you satisfied with that rescue plan? Well, I don't I don't think it's perfect,
but I don't know that I could draw one that's perfect. But I'd rather be approximately right
than precisely wrong. And it'd be precisely wrong to to turn it down. We need we we have
a terrific economy. It's like a great athlete that's had a cardiac arrest, you know, and it's
it's flat on the floor. And paramedics have arrived. And, you know, they shouldn't argue
about whether they put the resuscitation, you know, a quarter of an inch this way or a quarter
of an inch that way. Or they shouldn't start criticizing the patient because he didn't have
blood pressure tests or something like that. They should do what's needed right now. And I
think they will. And so I think the Congress will do the right thing. I think that they've
you know, they get into certain arguments and they start worrying about assessing blame.
And there's a little demagoguery. But in the end, something that's important,
they'll do the right thing. This isn't this really is an economic Pearl Harbor.
That sounds melodramatic, but I've never used that phrase before. And this really is one.
But go through why that is true beyond the fact that there's a freeze on credit,
beyond the fact nobody's making loans, beyond the fact that banks don't lend it back,
beyond the fact that Treasury bills are at a low.
Yeah. When when 40 billion of Treasury bills are sold like they were last week,
seven day Treasury bills at a yield of one twentieth of one percent. That means the
whole country is basically at the point virtually or a lot of the country is at the point of putting
their money under the mattress. I mean, you're only one one twentieth of one percent away from
where it's better to put it under the mattress. You don't want 300 million Americans
putting their money under the mattress. I mean, this economy doesn't work well without the
lubrication of credit and trust. And that's been lost. And it's it's it's a huge problem.
What you have is you have the major institutions of the world all wanting to deleverage. They want
to take down their assets and liabilities. They want to what seems so easy to borrow against
a year ago now looks like rat poison to them. So they're trying to deleverage.
There is only one institution in the world that can leverage up in a way that's all a
countervailing force to that. That's the United States Treasury. Are you approving of what has
been taking place along the stages that got us to where we are now, whether it's Bear Stearns
or Lehman Brothers or AIG, Freddie and Fannie, or what you've done with Goldman Sachs and the rest?
Yeah, I think that basically the right things have been done, but but no one saw the the tsunami
coming, you know, fully. And and so when Bear Stearns came along, it looked like if you stopped
the flood at that point, you know, you didn't have to worry about being downstream from it.
And and I think I think the Fed did the right thing there. And I really thought that would
probably halt runs on other major institutions. But it didn't. We have seen wave after wave.
And admittedly, there's been somewhat of an ad hoc response. I'd rather have an ad hoc response
to no response at all. And I don't think I don't think the Treasury could remotely have gone to
Congress three or four months ago and laid out the scenario of what's happened and been credible
and gotten the necessary tools. I think I think it took a crisis like this and asking for the
powers, asking for and the levels it was asking. No, they wouldn't have gotten. So I I think it's
been, you know, kind of like a tragic play to this point. But at this point, I think it's
clear and will be clear to a majority of the Congress. I think it's clear to the American
people that there is only one countervailing force to a world where financial institutions
are trying to sell instruments every day and where credit is dried up. And that's the United
States Treasury. But at the same time, there has been in Congress, men and women will tell you
there's a resistance across the country because they think, as you well know, it's a bailout of
Wall Street and that they are sitting there in their own economic life and nobody's coming along
to say, we're here to help you. We're from the government. Well, the patient that's on the floor
with the cardiac arrest is not Wall Street. It's the American economy. I mean, do you think they
understand that yet? Because they probably don't communication. Yeah, I think they probably don't.
And I think at any time you couple the term Wall Street with bailout or something like that,
you know, I don't like what's going on at Wall Street. I don't like what's going on in
executive compensation, you know, but I don't want to give a lecture to this body that's out
there having had the heart attack. I want to get it back functioning. And as a practical matter,
I mean, if you were Bear Stearns and you were a shareholder, you know, you lost 90 to 95 percent
of your money. Good many lost their jobs. They lost very cushy lives, many of them. If you were
Lehman, the same thing happened. If you were at AIG, the shareholders are getting creamed on these
things. And those shareholders are not just a bunch of big shots in Wall Street. Those are
pension funds and those are investors all over the country. I wouldn't worry too much about that.
Justice won't be perfect. I mean, you may be very mad at some guy that walked away with a huge
golden parachute, but that really isn't the important thing. I mean, if Pearl Harbor came
along, you could have said the planning was wrong by the military ahead of time, or maybe this
battleship shouldn't have all been in the harbor and all that kind of thing. It doesn't make any
difference. I mean, it's Pearl Harbor and you better not spend weeks and weeks and weeks trying
to assign blame or deciding on a complete plan for fighting the whole war and letting a committee
decide where the battleship should go and all of that. You better spring into action with the best
people you have. You have never seen anything like this in your life. No, I haven't. There are those
who argue that we're headed for a recession, you know, and they look at depression as the great
fear. Sure. Is that a possibility? This plan doesn't work. Yeah, it's a possibility. Yeah,
we have about six point one percent unemployment now. We've been in a recession by any common
sense definition, because if you look at the American public, they've got 20 billion,
20 trillion, I should say, worth a worth of residential homes, like a 20 trillion worth
of stocks, very roughly. Those are the two big assets of American families. They're both down
dramatically and different for different families. But ninety five percent of the people
at least are worse off in terms of their residential wealth plus stock wealth from
a year ago or two years ago. That is bleeding into the the real economy. I mean, that's bleeding
into auto sales and jewelry sales and furniture sales and all that. But that wave is just starting
to hit. And if if the paralysis we have in the credit markets, if every company continues to
fail, all we want to do is get our balance sheet down, sell assets. It's just the start
of what can happen. Unemployment is going to go up under under any circumstances. I mean,
the six point one is going to go higher. But whether it goes and quits at seven or whether
it quits at ten or eleven or twelve depends on, among other things, the wisdom of Congress and
then the wisdom of it in terms of carrying out the plan that Congress authorizes. Would you say
that this plan, which you have argued very strongly, the Senate ought to pass and the House
ought to pass is simply the plan that we have? And I don't have a better idea, but it's essential
for the confidence of the nation and the system. Yeah. And I just worry about whether it's enough.
But I think it is what I every day that goes by. I mean, if you don't react to Pearl Harbor
for a week or two weeks or three weeks, you are behind in the war that you otherwise would have
fought. But it's very important that the determination of the U.S. Congress to do what
is needed be made evident this week and by the actions of most of the members. I mean,
you're not going to get total assent. What makes you confident that this plan will work? I mean,
well, I think you've got I don't think you could have a better secretary of the Treasury than
Hank Paulson. You know, I mean, he is he is in there at the wrong time. He probably shouldn't
have taken the job. He's a friend of mine. But he knows markets. He knows. He knows. He knows
how corporations work. He knows money. And and he's got the interest of the country at heart.
And so you've got you've got the right. You've got a wonderful person with Sheila
Bear. But most most of the viewers have never heard of Sheila Bear. Sheila Bear,
in the last two weeks, has taken eight percent of the deposits in the United States and seamlessly
move those over to sound institutions, which in turn have got more capital into them.
It's been a magnificent job. Eight percent of the deposit in the United States,
tens of millions of depositors. And nobody's ever heard of. She'll never get a golden parachute
or anything. She's done a great job. We've got some great public servants. We have, I think,
the right people in there to get the job done. And then they need more tools. And those more
tools might be in addition to what's in this plan. Well, they need plenty. They need plenty of money
and they really need plenty of flexibility to carry out this plan. They also need, in my view,
to very much tie it to market prices. I have said, Charlie, that the 700 billion,
if they buy mortgage related securities or mortgages themselves at current market prices,
they're going to make money over time because the United States government has staying power
and it has a low cost of borrowing. And if I could take one percent of that 700 billion pot and take
the gain or loss from it and be their partner and and they would buy the stuff at market,
they'd make a lot of money. No, it's I mean, you have hedge funds and people like that buying these
assets to yield 15 or 20 percent. I mean, that's the buyer for these people that are trying to
unload them. The U.S. Treasury has got borrowing costs like nobody else has. They can borrow
basically unlimited amounts. They can stay there for years and years. These assets will be worth
more money over time. So when Merrill Lynch sells a bunch of mortgage related assets at 22 cents on
the dollar, like they did a month or so ago, the buyer of those is going to make money and he's
going to make a lot more money if it happens to be an institution like the U.S. government, which
has very, very cheap borrowing costs. So you are saying to those taxpayers who are worried about
what's going to happen to 700 billion dollars, chances are good that when these securities are
purchased and sold, you'll get a lot of money back. I think I think you're all of your money
back and maybe something else. I would bet on it. I mean, if I got a chance to take one percent of
the deal either way, I would make that bet. But when Berkshire Hathaway's laid out three billion
dollars for GE today, we didn't spend it. We invested it when the federal government buys
the mortgages. They're not spending it. They're investing it now. They're investing it in distress
type assets, but they're buying them at distress prices if they buy them at market. It's the kind
of stuff I love to do. I just I just don't have 700 billion. Maybe we can go in it together
with your money and my brains. I mean, there's no telling how far we go.
I'll take the deal, whatever you want to do. There is this, though, I mean, in terms of
alternatives, some people have suggested, for example, that why don't we why isn't America doing
what Berkshire Hathaway is doing? Why isn't that a better deal for America? I don't I don't think
it would be crazy to have a a model or an entity model on the Reconstruction Finance Corp. That
goes back to 1932, although it was really implemented in 33 under Jesse Jones. And it
invested in mostly banks initially and preferred stock and that sort of thing. So
there is there are two things needed in the system. The one that's needed overwhelmingly
is liquidity. I mean, when people are trying to do deliveries, there has to be somebody there
to buy and they don't have to buy it at fancy prices, but to buy. And then there's also a
capital problem with some of the institutions. We have provided capital here with a couple of
institutions recently. The federal government did that in the 30s for the RFC, and I think
there could well be a proper role for government in that. But would that have been a better idea
today? It wouldn't have been big enough today. I mean, and it wouldn't. In fact, you couldn't
if you'd set up an RFC today and you gave them 100 billion dollars to invest in the capital,
there'd be a very cumbersome type of application process and everything. These assets are getting
shoved out day by day and loans are coming to commercial papers not being renewed. I mean,
the commercial paper market, when that dries up, you know, that's just like sucking the blood
out of the of the economic body of the United States. And that's happening. So I would say
that an RFC like thing might make sense. I probably would do it myself. But I don't think
trying to combine that with what's going through now, I think what's needed now is liquidity.
All right. There are those who believe and it has been suggested, you know, that this is the time
for Warren Buffett to answer the call of his government and a country that's been very good
to him. I mean, what are you prepared to do yourself beyond run Berkshire Hathaway?
Well, that's my job. But I any any time I can be of help to the government in terms of
giving advice, I've given a lot of advice.
Most of it gets ignored when it really counts. But anyway, the no, I am obviously willing to do
that. I'm here tonight talking about this for that reason. It isn't going to do anything for
Berkshire Hathaway. Well, that isn't really true. I mean, anything that enables this economy to run
in the manner that it should. I mean, we've got the same plants out there we had two years ago.
We've got the houses. We've got people that are more productive than they've ever been in
the history of this country. We've got a wonderful economic formula in this country.
But right now it is being you know, it's been brought to a halt by by some events that well,
it's it's it's the deleveraging that's going on right now that has caused the credit crisis.
I mentioned earlier in this introduction to you, if you read your letters to your
stockholders, which you write and Carol Loomis edits every year and you think of your sister
as a person you're trying to explain to your sister. Yeah, I'm pretty adores.
You have talked about derivatives. Derivatives are in part at the core of this problem. Yes,
AIG would would be doing fine today. It was one of the ten largest companies in the United States
in terms of market value, over 200 billion, the most respected insurer and everything in the
world. If they never heard of the word derivatives, they'd be doing fine. Everybody going to work in
the morning and they would have no troubles. But they they it was very easy to do because
very tempting to write numbers on little pieces of paper. And you can kind of report the profits
you want to. And and there's no limit on it. I mean, there's no capital requirements to order
anything of the sort. And basically, I said there were possibly financial weapons of mass
destruction. And they have been. I mean, they destroyed AIG. They may they certainly contributed
to the destruction of Bear Stearns and Lehman, although Lehman had other problems. I'm interested
in this because people are asking, how did that did people get away with murder here?
Were there people who simply gained the system and took advantage and made huge amounts of profit?
And we had excesses that inevitably led to where we are today. Well, we had all of that. But I
would say the biggest single cause was that we had we had an incredible residential real estate
bubble. I mean, you can go back to tulip bulbs in Holland 400 years ago. The human human beings
going through combinations of fear, greed and all of that sort of thing,
their behavior can lead to bubbles. And it may have had an Internet bubble at one time. And
you've had a farm bubble farmland bubble in the Midwest, which resulted in all kinds of tragedy
in the early 80s. But we've had a 300 million Americans, their lending institutions, their
government, their media all believe that house prices were going to go up consistently. And
that got built into a 20 trillion dollar residential home market. Lending was done
based on it. And everybody did a lot of foolish things. And where people really behaved in a
fraudulent way or something, we'll go back and find the culprits later on. But that really isn't
the problem we have. I mean, that's where it came from, though, that we leveraged up. And
if you have a 20 percent fall in the value of a 20 trillion dollar asset, that's four trillion
dollars. And when four trillion dollars lands losses land in the wrong part of this economy,
it can gum up the whole place. And it continues with respect to the housing market. It continues.
And and some will argue that we have to do something about that in terms of the long term
recovery of the American economy. Well, there's no question we have an excess stock. The good
thing is we have household formation in this country. We have a country where I don't know
whether it's a million households a year or more, but get formed so we can eat off an inventory.
But the inventory is too big. And and house prices just soared beyond beyond reason in many places.
And they got financed in silly ways. And people lied about loans, all kinds of excesses entered
into it. But that is what that that is the single biggest cause of why we are here. And should wise
people have known better? Well, people always should know better. I mean, people people don't
get they don't get smarter about things, about things that get as basic as greed. And, you know,
and you can't stand to see your neighbor getting rich. You know, you're smarter than he is. And
he's doing these things, you know, and and he's getting rich and your spouse is getting unhappy
with you because you are doing pretty soon you start doing it. And so you get you get what I
call the natural progression, the three eyes, the innovators, the imitators and the idiots,
you know, and that's what happens. We've been through all three, have we? Everybody just kind
of goes along and you look kind of silly if you disagree. I mean, you know, you can have these
crazy Internet valuations in the late 1990s, but they prove themselves out in the market.
I mean, the next day they were selling for more than they were the day before. And people said,
you know, you're crazy if you don't get in on this. So it's very human. Now, with housing,
it's something even more dramatic than that, because most people aspire to own their own home.
And if you really think that housing prices are going to go up next year and the year after,
you feel if I don't buy it this year, I'm going to have to buy next year. That's not true of an
Internet stock, but it's true of a home. And then when somebody makes it very easy for you to do it
by saying you don't really have to put up any money or you can lie about your income a little
or, you know, we'll give you 100 percent mortgage, you're going to do it because everybody that's
done it has been proven right. You have what they call social proof. And, you know, you're going to
feel like an idiot if you didn't do it next year. The house costs more. It's found money. It's found
money. Sure. And so when you look at where we are going, there seems to be two issues that
that are apparent to me, at least risk and leverage. We just lost sight of risk and leverage.
Yeah. What was appropriate? People will do, you know, again, because it pays off for a while.
I mean, you know, you can use leverage and it's the only way a smart guy can go broke.
I mean, it basically is if you owe money, you can't pay tomorrow. If you just pay for everything
and you do smart things, eventually get very rich. You can do smart things and use leverage.
And if you do one wrong thing along the way, it can wipe you out because anything times zero is
zero. And but it solves reinforcing when the people around you are doing it successfully,
you're doing it successfully. And it's a lot like Cinderella at the ball. I mean, you know,
at midnight, everything's going to turn to pumpkins and mice. Right. But as the evening
goes along, I mean, you know, the guys look better all the time. The music sounds better.
It's more and more funny. I think, why the hell should I leave at a quarter of 12? You know,
I'll leave it two minutes to 12. But the trouble is there are no clocks on the wall and everybody
thinks they're going to leave it to get done. Yeah, sure. Yeah. So if this plan you hope it
will do what? It will loosen credit. It will stop the slide and the panic. People will have
more confidence. Confidence is key. Confidence is key. You're not going to put your money. You're
not going to leave your money with me unless you're confident I'm going to give it back to you.
And at this point, when Treasury bills that seven day Treasury bills at one twentieth of one percent,
it's not because people want to earn one twentieth of one percent. It's because they trust the fact
the Treasury will give it back to them next week. And I'm sitting with six and a half billion
dollars we're going to use to close the Mars Wrigley deal on October 6th. I've got to hand
over that six and a half billion on October 6th. Now, I I have to be very careful about where I
leave it in between now and then because they're expecting me to show up when I lose confidence in
other people, all kinds of institutions. And there are plenty of them that I've lost confidence in.
You know, then they get their funds aren't available. They don't have it for the next.
I mean, the whole economy just comes to a grinding halt and confidence,
confidence in markets and in institutions. It's a lot like oxygen. You know, when you have it,
you don't even think about it. I mean, indispensable. You go years without thinking
about it when it's gone for five minutes. It's the only thing you think about. I mean,
and that's exactly the oxygen has been sucked out of the credit markets and confidence. And
and there has to be it's it's got to be given a jump start, basically.
And and that's what this that's what I hope it gets done. And if it doesn't work,
you turn the spigot. But but you don't get it. I have argued with the senators, congressmen I've
talked to, you know, you don't want to be too little too late now. They're being, you know,
they're they're being somewhat too late in my view. Yeah. But that's OK. I mean,
you know, we're going to argue for a few weeks after Pearl Harbor decide whether it's really
the Japanese that attacked or whether we should actually commit a few battleships. But the the
little part, you know, it could be a mistake. I mean, this has to be done on a little meaning
in terms of of dramatic steps or the amount of money you're spending. It's whether people think
it's too little when you get all through it. I mean, in the end, 700 billion is a lot of money
and it will buy a lot of distressed property. And if you buy them at the right price,
you may be buying two trillion mark of that. I mean, two trillion of face value percent.
The one thing you don't want to do, it doesn't make it. Here's what the guy paid for it,
and one way to do that is if some institution wants to sell you a billion dollars worth of
mortgages, you know, they might have to sell 100 million in the market and then you'll buy the
other 900 million on the same terms. Now, the very act that you're the very fact that this
has been authorized or will be authorized, I hope will firm up the market to some degree.
And that's fine. But but you don't want to have artificial prices being paid.
What do you believe might never be the same? Oh, I think confidence will come back. I will
tell you this. This country is going to be living better 10 years from now than it is now. It'll be
living better 20 years from now than it is 10 years from now. The ingredients that made this
country, you know, the miracle of the world. I mean, we had a seven for one improvement in the
average American center of living in the 20th century. Now we had the Great Depression. We
had two world wars. We had the flu epidemic. You know, we had the oil shock. We had all these
terrible things happen. But something about the American system unleashed more and more of the
potential of human beings over 100 years so that we had a seven for one improvement. And there's
never been any. I mean, you have centuries where you've got a one percent improvement in something.
So we've got a great system and we've got more productive capacity now than we ever have.
The American worker is more productive than he's ever been. We've got more people to do it.
We've got all the ingredients for a sensational future. It's just that right now the athlete's
on the floor. But this is a super athlete, isn't it? And what's the impact of the athlete being
on the floor around the globe? Plenty, plenty. And we're finding that out. And the same things
happened to quite an extent around the globe. I mean, the European banks were doing what the
American banks were failing. Yeah. I mean, they were they were getting the mortgage of some guy
in Omaha, you know, securitized a couple of times. I mean, you had all these you had all these types
from Wall Street, you know, they had advanced degrees and they looked very learned. And they
came with these they came with these things that said Gamma and Alpha and Sigma and all that. And
all I can say is beware of geeks, you know, bearing formulas.
Have we learned something about decoupling or the American economy in terms of its impact?
For example, China, a place where you've had investments and you know, well, yeah,
we just made a new one a couple of days ago. What was that? And a company called BYD that
may may develop a really good electric car, I hope.
Is there is there an operative narrative to the kinds of investments you're making
other than you look at and you buy on value, look at management, you look at a place that
can absorb the amount of money you want to invest and you look at its prospects and you look at
price. Yeah, they have to be pretty good size for us now to have to move the needle. But
we look for fairly large situations. We look for things I can understand. A lot
of businesses I don't understand. So some guy may know how to make money in cocoa beans,
but I don't. So I just let him have that. But it's got to be something I understand.
It's got to be a business with fundamentally good economics. It's got to be a management
that I like and trust and admire. And there's got to be a price that makes sense. And lately,
the price price makes sense. The prices make a lot more sense now. Yeah,
now is it. And I'm not worried at all about the investments we make. I mean,
this country, we've got we've got forty six or seven thousand dollars of GDP per capita. Now,
we've done pretty darn well. We'll do better in the future. I am not worried about the country.
I'm just worried about anything that gums up the potential of the country. And right now,
it's pretty gummed up. OK, but we do this emergency urgent rescue. Right. Come January,
we have a new president. We have a new treasury secretary. We have a new legislature. What's their
imperative? What will be the challenge for them? Because they then can take a little bit of a
longer term. Look, maybe the patient's getting up off the ground. And but you want to get
him or her moving faster. Yeah, well, I think it will get moving faster.
Once I mean, once you get it off the ground, once credit flows now, I don't the recession
is going to get worse. I mean, I don't want to I don't want to hold out false hopes that
by some magic bullet that things will turn around in a couple of months because they won't,
Charlie. I mean, and it's a big mistake to try and mislead people. They will turn around. I don't
know whether it'll be six months or whether it'll be two years. It's more likely two years. And I
don't know. It's going to be one month or two months, no matter what happens. All I can imagine
six months from now, it's beginning to turn around with the conditions that are there.
That's sort of the best case. Yeah, that's sort of the worst case. Worst case is a long
time. And I would say this is five years or if we don't do the things we should do,
it could be five. It should do, though, beyond where we are now. What are those things? Well,
I would say this if if it becomes evident that I understand the latest
bill, they're talking about three hundred fifty billion early and then going back.
But we need to throw the resources at this that are necessary. But like I say,
we are not spending the money. I mean, if we if we buy these assets intelligently,
the United States Treasury will make money. I mean, it's it's borrowing money. It's just a few
percent a year. And these assets are better than that. OK, but that's a very big if if we
make a difference with the treasury secretary. So that's an important question in terms of
whether we buy these assets wisely. I would say it's more important that the treasury secretary
is that who the vice president is. If you want to have a whatever whatever debate here, I like
I like a debate between two potential treasury secretaries. The vice presidential might be a
thing for the presidential candidate to tell you who it is they're going to be listening to and who
might be a potential treasury secretary. Well, the presidential candidates will tell you they'll
listen to you. I mean, I assume they're telling you that. Well, no, but I mean, it's not their
job to narrow the candidacy field. When all these people call you up, what are they asking you?
I mean, I mean, you're hearing from your friends and people in the Fed. You've been through this
before, too. I mean, you were that long term capital. A lot of other times you have had to
face difficult. I've seen a lot of things happen. So they come to you and they say you fought wars
before, Warren. We'd like to talk to you. But what's the question they're asking? What is it
they want to know? And I'm talking about smart people who are charged with fixing it. Yeah, well,
lately they've been asking, will this work? Right. Yeah. And and you're assuring him that if they do
it, if they do it, I don't know the next treasury secretary. I would say this. I would I would I
would. They hate this term in Washington, obviously, but I would I would I would hand
something pretty close to a blank check to a fellow like Hank Paulson. Would you like
seven hundred billion dollars? Go spend it. Yeah. Go invest it. And maybe put up a little
of your own money up beside it. I mean, I might I might ask Hank to invest with me. That's right.
But no, I I think that trying to invest through five hundred and thirty five people is a tough
job. You know, and so I would give more latitude. That isn't going to happen. And I you know,
I can't do it with oversight. I mean, that's what I decided to do it with. I don't don't try to make
the decision. No, I think the overs I think oversight is great. And I think that oversight
ought to be devoted almost entirely to the question is, is this being done at market?
You know, I mean, in other words, you you want to make sure that the government isn't investing
foolishly, but you don't want to you don't want to care about whether which congressional
districts it goes to or whether banks get favorable. But how do we determine whether it's
being done wisely? I think it's a big question. Yeah, I think I think you'll have plenty of
scrutiny as how money is invested. I mean, just like the RFC, when the RFC operated, people knew
which institutions they were buying preferred stock in. And it worked very well. But is this
different from the Resolution Trust Company because they're talking about securities,
not real estate? Well, Resolution Trust Company was set up to liquidate a bunch of assets that
the government inherited because the savings and loans went broke. So the savings and loans
went broke. The government stepped in, paid off depositors, and now they're left with this
mass of assets to sell. We're not talking about selling here. We're talking about buying
intelligently. They were selling what they got handed to them by a bunch of savings and loan
operators that, in many cases, had done some very dumb thing. But their job was to liquidate
and they liquidated. This is an entirely different proposition. You have said to me before that
capitalism is not a perfect system. It may be better than all the other systems, but it's not
a perfect system. You've talked about it in terms of some of its failings. People are looking at
this now and saying, you know, excesses of capitalism, number one, markets that don't work.
And there's some people in certain countries are pointing a finger at us and saying, see,
we told you that market was not all the markets will not always deliver for you.
Markets are people do. As long as you have markets, you'll have excesses. People went
crazy with tulip bulbs. They went crazy with the South Sea bubble. They went crazy with
uranium stocks back when I was first getting started. I mean, you know, you're not going to
change the human animal and the human animal really doesn't get a lot smarter. Now, you can
have institutions that put curbs on that in various ways. And actually, with the banks,
you know, they have various capital ratios and that sort of thing. But the banks got around
them. I mean, they set up sieves and that sort of thing just to get more leverage. People love
leverage when it's working. I mean, it's so easy to borrow money from a guy at X and put it out
everything's going up. Yeah. But if you don't get your X plus one back and you still owe the X on
the other side, you're in trouble. There is this to accounting. You have strong feelings about
accounting and mark to market. Right. Tell me where you are on that issue. I and a lot of people
disagree with me on this. I believe in mark to market. I think that accounting in nineteen
seventy four is either nineteen seventy four, seventy five. We owned a bunch of common stocks
in Berkshire Hathaway. I told our shareholders what the market was and we use that. I said,
I think these things are worth a lot more than market. And I think we're gonna make a lot of
money out of it. But this is what they're worth today. And I don't think anybody gets hurt by
telling the truth on that sort of thing. And I think that once you start saying we're going to
peg these things at some price that isn't market, you know, God knows what, you know, what a
financial. The other argument these people make them argue against you will say the assets are
and therefore they're not worth it. Therefore, we're not seeing a reality. Well, but that's that
is the reality. And that's the reality of what they're going to sell them to the treasury for.
You get in a lot of trouble when you start putting fictitious numbers on value on value. I mean,
you can explain the fact that these are depressed prices. You know, we think these assets are going
to be worth a lot more. And if I think I think that case can be made in certain situations.
But I think to just say, you know, we're going to say a dollar of cash is worth two dollars all
of a sudden. I mean, it isn't worth two dollars. It's worth a dollar today. And I think once you
start putting phony figures into financial statements, you can get in a lot of trouble.
And, you know, we've seen so much of that in the last 20 years. I mean, is it getting worse?
No, I don't think it's getting worse. I think what people want to do is get it, make it get worse.
But I mean, what would you reform about that in terms of the way the accounting process?
The rules get ungodly complicated. I mean, it's a it's a nightmare to administer some of this sort
of thing. But but I want to tell the shareholders of Berkshire to the extent we own marketable
securities or things for which there are markets, even if those markets are. I want to tell them
what it's all about. Matter of fact, I've already written a section in the annual report for next
year explaining why I think in one case that the figures on our balance sheet as calculated are
wrong. But it's the standard way of doing it. You know, it's holy writ. The SEC wants us to do
it that way and we'll do it that way. And then I'll explain why I think it's wrong. And shareholders,
they can read it and see whether they read my logic or don't. When you look at the prospects
for this country, there are other people who argue, you know, that America, as good as it is,
lives in a world today and their books being written in which our supremacy, our primacy
will now have to be shared, that we may still own as much of the pies we have, but other people
own a lot more. That's great. You know, I want our I want our I want our pie to grow all the time.
But if some guy's other guy's pie is growing a little faster, that's terrific. It'll be good
for us in the long run. And and I mean, there are, you know, six six and a half billion people in this
world. And and it's great for 300 million to keep enjoying more and more prosperity. But I think
the remainder do. And I think if they can learn something from us in terms of our system,
and I think they have, they are learning more about how to unleash the potential
of their citizenry to turn out more goods and services that their citizens want or that we want.
I think that's terrific. And that's you know, I I think it's much better to live in a world
where those around you, particularly when some of them have nuclear bombs,
I think it's much better to live in a world where their lives are getting better. Also,
when you look at China today and you look at some Asian countries and the amount of American debt
they have, how much does that concern you in today's economic circumstances? And are they
losing some of their confidence in America? And does that pose a huge problem for us?
Well, somebody's buying these Treasury bills at one 20th of one percent. I mean,
the way we have been consuming about two billion dollars a day of goods and services beyond
what we're producing. In other words, the rest of the world sends us about two billion dollars a
day net of something. We've got to send them something in return, don't we? So we send them
little pieces of paper. That'd be nice if they stuck them all under a mattress, but they got
to buy something with them. Sometimes they buy our Treasury notes. Sometimes they set up sovereign
wealth funds. They can do all kinds of things. They can buy our companies here. As long as we
consume more than we produce and we trade away little pieces of the country daily,
they're going to own something. Now, on the other hand, they can't run from American assets. I mean,
every day the rest of the world is going to have about two billion more of American assets than we
have as long as they sell us these goods. Because we're borrowing two billion dollars a day. Yeah,
and they want to sell us these goods. Yeah, but you don't believe that's good. I mean,
you believe that an increasing current accounts deficit is bad. I think it's bad. And it reflects
America's consumption ideas rather than its saving ideas. But how does that change? Well,
I laid out a kind of a Rube Goldberg plan a few years ago, which I don't like myself,
except I like it better than the alternative, which is what we're doing. But we've actually
been pretty good on exports. I mean, we are exporting 12% of our GDP now, roughly. That
was 5% many years ago, but much smaller GDP. So the rest of the world really likes our stuff
pretty well. It's just we buy so damn much of what they produce. And I think that should be
something addressed by the ministry. I don't think it's the most pressing problem now at all.
We are trading away a little bit of our country all the time for this excess consumption that we
have over what we produce. That is not good. I think it's terrible over time. But our country's
productive capacity grows enough so we actually can do that and we'll still be better off. We
just won't be as well off as if we hadn't done it. What's all this going to do to the price of
the dollar? Inflation is a likely consequence out of what's going on now. Right now,
we are, in effect, to some extent, making a choice between future inflation and getting
off the floor. And we're likely to have more inflation in the future as a consequence of
the things we do to fight the present situation. Senator Obama, who you support,
talks about another stimulus program. Is that essential at this time? I think the biggest thing
we need now is to unclog the credit markets. And we may need another stimulus. If we do,
it's certainly it should go to the lower and middle income people. I mean, the truth is I've
never had it so good in terms of taxes. I am paying the lowest tax rate that I've ever paid
in my life. Now, that's crazy. And if you look at the Forbes 400, they are paying a lower rate
counting payroll taxes than their secretary or whomever around their office, I mean, on average.
And so I think that actually people in my situation should be paying more tax. I think
the rest of the country should be paying less than the 95 percent that Obama talks about,
or maybe even a little higher than that. But I think that a stimulus plan should really be geared
to the people. You know, you've got what, 24 million households, one fifth of the households
in the United States, you have earning, you know, $21,000 a year or less, you know, an average of
close to four people, three people in those households, two and a half people actually,
probably. But just imagine living on $21,000 a year, Charlie, $22,000 a year. I mean,
you have 20 percent of the population doing that. So they don't have to worry about guys like me.
I would push purchasing power. You know, you push out a thousand dollars a person to those people,
it's going to get, it's going to get spent and it needs to be spent. They need it. And it should
come to some extent from guys like me. But what about the capital gains tax? Well, I, you know,
the capital gains tax is 15 percent now. Right. So I sit there in my office and I make a lot of
money by capital gains and I pay 15 percent and I pay no payroll tax on it. Right. You know,
the woman that comes in to take the wastebasket away, she's paying 15.3 or whatever it is,
you know, just payroll tax alone. I mean, it is, I've never had it so good, you know.
But so therefore the capital gains tax should be changed to 18, 20, 25, 30.
I think it's terrible for people to, in effect, to say that, that income from investment should
be taxed at a much lower rate than income from labor. I mean, I just, I just think that
you're going to, we're going to spend 3.1 trillion, you know, or something like that
this year. We're going to only raise about 2.6 trillion or something. You're going to
raise it from somebody, you know. Now, who are you going to get it from? You're going to get it
from me and you? Or are you going to get it from the, you know, the people that drive the taxi
that brings me here or whatever it may be? I mean, you got to get it from somebody. And, you know,
everybody's against paying tax themselves. I feel the same. Everybody feels that way.
But if you want a government that's going to do the things we ask our government to do,
you've got to get it from somebody. And over the years, the last,
particularly the last six or eight years, they've taken less and less from a guy like me. Now,
you know, everybody likes to talk about how the top 1% pays this percent of the income,
but the income tax is, we'll say 1.3 trillion. The payroll taxes are over 900 billion.
That 900 billion, that doesn't come from me. I mean, I pay it on the first hundred thousand
or something like that, but that comes from the people in my office and they are paying 900
billion. Nobody ever talks about that when they talk about how the 1% is paying. They love to tell
how I'm suffering, you know, because 1% we're paying 25% of the total. We're not paying 25%
of the total taxes on individuals. We're paying maybe 25% of the income tax, but the payroll tax
is over a third of the receipts of the federal government. And they don't take that from me on
capital gains. They don't take that from me on dividends. They take that from the woman who
comes in and takes the wastebaskets out. You mentioned inflation, possibilities of
inflation. Are you there for, do you have a position on what interest rates would,
what the fed should do about interest rates? Well, I think that's almost, for the time being,
that's just, just put it, yeah, just put that aside and we'll get to that after the patient's
up and walking. It's interesting though. I mean, we are, you know, what's going to happen,
things we're doing are going to have some inflationary consequences, but you see interest
rates at very low levels and including the long rates. When we watch this, I mean, you and I
having this conversation today, the Senate votes tonight, House may vote. People I talked to today
believe it's going to pass whatever happened that changed minds and either in the combination of
what they did with the plan and tweaking the plan or B some people got so scared by the failure
of the vote last time that it brought home the danger of not doing anything. All right. Uh,
how will we measure the progress, whether this is working or not? What's going to be an issue?
Yeah, it's going to be tough because the economy is going to be getting worse for a while and
it'll get, it might fall off a cliff if this doesn't pass, but nobody will ever know that
they will not see immediate reaction. I mean, we'll be pounding on that guy's chest, you know,
on the, on the floor and you know, he's not going to just jump up all of a sudden. So it,
it makes it tough. I mean, it's tough to be in a legislature, you know, and vote for something.
And then people say, well, you voted all this money and you know, it's all getting spent. It
isn't getting spent. It's getting invested, but it's all getting spent. Nothing's happening. You
know, how could you have done that? You haven't done anything for me. I mean, you go through all
of that and that's going to be tough. And it takes the, what it really takes is leadership
that knows what it's all about and can explain what it's all about.
And that hasn't been missing though. Leadership that can explain what it's all about. I mean,
the reason you're here and the reason I want to have a kind of fireside chat with you,
it is that somehow it hadn't gotten through the idea. Go ahead.
When the president of the United States goes out at, you know, eight o'clock in the morning
and then his own party votes against him two to one in the house, you know, that somehow
message isn't getting out. No, it takes real leadership. I mean, Roosevelt didn't, you know,
when he came in, he didn't print any money or that way. You actually may have done a little
bit of that, but he, he, it wasn't like, you know, you've gotten the greatest economics professor in
the world or anything else, but he did restore confidence. I mean, and, and they, and they did
a lot of things and you needed it. You needed to jumpstart the economy. It took a long time.
I mean, the world did not change, you know, in 1933 or four, but we put in things like the FDIC.
I think the FDIC was one of the great inventions of the American. Well, they had to tweak that in
Roosevelt also said the only thing we have to fear is fear itself, which is clearly
the fear that exists in the country. Tell me when you worried the most of all the things that you
have seen over the last three weeks, say, I mean, how long in the last month, when did you say,
my God, I never knew it could get to this point. Well, I don't get that afraid in a sense because
I really do have faith in both. I know the country works extremely well, you know, what,
when it isn't clogged up and I know that Congress will do the right thing, but I will tell you what
I, when I watched the house vote the other day, I wasn't afraid I cause I, I still felt something
would pass, but I, we are going through a very, very tough period. And, and I did not think I
would see the day when, you know, an AIG would, would not be able to have checks clear. I mean,
if ALG had failed, would Goldman Sachs had been exposed and at risk with Morgan Stanley,
everybody wouldn't have been exposed. Charlie, everybody, you look, so why was even there
question of not rescuing AIG at that time? I think with people that understood that they're probably,
well, they were hoping the private sector would do it. I mean, that's the same way I would behave.
If I were, if I were the treasury secretary or head of the fed, you know, I would try to scare
the hell out of the private sector and say, you better save this because you're going down with
the ship. So you guys save it. And I'd wait as long as I could, but if they didn't save it,
well, did that in fact happen during this crisis in which the secretary of the treasury said,
you better save this or we're all going down. I think certainly you better put up some cash
right now. I think that they hope the private sector would, would come in and the private
sector tried to come in until they saw the size of the problem. I mean, there were people
on that weekend that thought they had a solution and then the whole gap kept getting bigger and
bigger. And all of a sudden it became apparent that 20 billion wouldn't do it. And 30 billion
wouldn't do it. And 40 billion wouldn't do it. So it got beyond anybody's ability to certainly
to do it in a short period of time. There was not enough capital available
from the government. It's an unknown situation. You have a derivative book called AIG financial
products. You know, nobody's ever heard of it except it was a, it was, it was a terrific profit
center. You know, you could manufacture earnings out of do all these things. And I will guarantee
you that the top management and I'm not knocking them for this. I don't think I could, they couldn't
get their mind around. I bought a company called general reinsurance in 1998 that had a similar,
but much smaller operation had 23,000 contracts in it. I got to get out of this. It cost me 400
and some million dollars in benign in a benign situation. But when this was not a benign situation,
if AIG had tried to unwind that derivative books, I don't know, it would have hit every
institution in the world. And there was no private capital to come in and do that. Not
big enough. Not even Berkshire Hathaway. No, not even Berkshire Hathaway. I mean,
if I thought five or 10 billion would have bought me a good deal and I could have done it,
I'd have done it. I'm not bashful. 10 billion was within reach, but 85 billion might not have been.
No, but, and the fed structured that thing very, very well. I mean, they have put themselves in
a position where they, they are very likely to get their money back. Maybe more. They participate
80%. I mean, they drove tough terms. I mean, I want to hire the guy that made that deal. He
fitted well at Berkshire. A lot of people are looking at you and Goldman Sachs and GE saying,
I want to hire the guy that made that deal for you. Tim Geithner did a better job on this one.
But, but the, so we come down to the close of this conversation and you have been warning us
about certain kinds of things. I hear from this conversation too. This plan is essential now.
Otherwise we're in a very, very difficult place. And each week we go back beyond
not doing something. We get deeper and it becomes more irreversible.
And yeah, whoever said, you know, an ounce of prevention is worth a pound of cure,
understated it. And an ounce, you know, a pound of, a pound of cure that's delayed another six
months, you need a ton of cure later on. I mean, it, it would be crazy not to do this. It, it will
not produce dramatic results though in the economy. That's, that's, that's what people have
to understand. You're going to see unemployment go up. You know, you're going to see lousy earnings
in many businesses and they're not going to see people unemployed. You're going to see more people
unemployed. But the difference, Charlie, if we, if we bottom this thing out at 7% unemployed versus
9%, that's 3 million people. That's 3 million people that if we do it wrong, you know, lose
their jobs unnecessarily in my view. I mean, yeah, you know, I've never been unemployed. I've never
been very fully employed here, but I, you know, just think of what it's like, you know, to go
home with a mortgage payment, you know, and kids and everything else. My dad had that happen to him
in the, in the early thirties. It, you know, it, you don't want to create 3 million people more
unnecessarily, but I don't think you, you can't, it really is. And you can't, you can't help some
increase from this point. I don't want to, I don't want any viewer to go away. Think the magic wand
exists in Congress. So they're going to see some more bad news, but if we do this, we're doing the
right thing. And the system will work over time. There's no, we've got a wonderful system.
Okay. But that's, I'm going to come to that in the end. Is it, how do we need to do anything
about the system? I'm beyond the emergency of the moment, the urgency of the moment.
Come January, about the system, lots of talk about regulation, as you know,
and finding the right balance. Lots of talk about whether government involvement
is an idea we need more of rather than less of. Rethinking sort of what President Reagan
brought to fore. Once we get the athlete back, we can tell him to change his diet a little,
exercise a little more. We can do all of that sort of thing. And, you know, I'll,
if I got a good ideas out of that, or I think they're good ideas, I'll be glad to contribute
them. But the system will probably overdo some other things. I mean, the nature of democracy
is such that when there's this, there'll be this revulsion, obviously toward that's never going to
happen again. So we'll, we'll, we'll probably attack it in various ways that don't make sense,
but that's what Congress is for. And that's what, that's what advisors are for. And I'm all for
getting the best minds. You can get to work on that kind of thing. Like I said, I don't think
it'll be done perfectly. Maybe we'll end up with a little bit better system at the end. We had a
pretty good system over time, but when it, when we went crazy and we did go crazy on residential
real estate, it set things in motion that just the dominoes started toppling. Thank you for coming.
Thank you, Charles. Pleasure to see you. Enjoyed it. Warren Buffett, we're in San Diego. My thanks
to the people at KPBS here, a conversation here about the crisis that we all face and hearing
from a man that a lot of people want to hear from. And I'm pleased that we were able to join
with him here. Thank you for joining us. See you next time.