Finding The Best Hot Dog In New York | Food Tours | Insider Food

American Local Food
161 followers
"Food Wars" hosts Harry Kersh and Joe Avella travel across NYC to find the best hot dog in the city. They'll be visiting five different locations in just one day to see what the city has to offer. This is "Food Tours."
#hotdogs #foodtours #insiderfood
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedTwo friends embark on a culinary journey across New York City to experience its most iconic hot dogs. From historic pubs and legendary stands to classic street carts, they evaluate various styles, toppings, and textures, ultimately discovering a deep appreciation for the city's diverse street food culture and the satisfying \"snap\" of a high-quality beef frankfurter.
Here we are at Grey's Papaya.
This place is legendary for street noise
and also hot dogs.
Yes.
Any New Yorker will tell you,
if you want to get a good idea
of how great hot dogs can be in this city,
gotta take it to Grey's.
All right, I'm here for it.
Should we try it out?
Yeah, let's eat.
Let's go.
Yeah, I want to do two of the specials.
Let's do the hot dogs with kraut, onion, and mustard,
and two of the pineapple drinks.
Oh, papaya, sorry.
Can we get these to go?
Okay.
Thank you very much.
All right, a bag of dogs and a drink, buddy.
Let's go.
Let's go eat this in the park.
There's no room in here.
Come on, it'll be fun.
Check it out.
Well, there it is.
Beautiful.
Who let the dogs out, am I right?
All right, so this is Grey's Papaya,
and we got two New York dogs and their papaya-flavored drink.
I guess the standard New York hot dog
is onions and sauerkraut and mustard.
Sure.
I know you like kraut, right?
Yeah, I like kind of anything pickled or mustardy.
So in terms of toppings,
this is very much up my street.
So let's take a bite of the dog,
then we'll take a sip of the papaya drink,
and we'll see how you feel afterwards, right?
I'm intrigued to see how this combination works together,
because it's not something that we'd find in the UK.
Yeah, I'm starving, so let's do this.
All right, man.
The snap of the dog is 100% beef.
Dog.
Flavorful.
Goes really well.
I mean, yeah, you're right.
I guess the acidity of the kraut
pairs with the snappiness, the full flavor of the dog.
Coming from someone who doesn't eat a lot of hot dogs
or love hot dogs, me,
this is actually really, really good.
I feel like they've mastered the topping ratios here.
There's just enough onions to kraut to mustard to beef
to really kind of balance this all out.
It really works together.
The papaya drink, it's fantastic.
And with the saltiness and the vinegary-ness of the dog
paired with this, fantastic.
I can't say I've eaten many papaya things before.
Get in there, buddy.
It can't be 100% papaya juice, right?
Like 100%?
No, they can't do that, right?
How expensive would that drink be
if that was 100% papaya juice?
You definitely wouldn't be able to get a combo
for $4 or something.
This is really good.
It's very good, right?
This is like, the texture's quite creamy, I would say.
You get that?
Hell yeah.
And sweet.
Yeah, I think that does actually work really well
as a combination, which is not what I was expecting.
I don't know if this reference will hold up in the US,
but hopefully the UK viewers will get this.
Let's go.
For some reason, this tastes exactly like
a vanilla mini milk ice lolly.
I do know what that is.
Yeah?
Yeah.
You had one of those before?
I had one years ago when I was there,
but it's not something that I clamber for.
They're not even super common,
because it's kind of like for kids.
Yeah.
But it's a very nostalgic flavor,
and honestly, I get exactly this.
Yeah, we have something similar here.
Yuzu Fruito is a dreamsicle.
It is a vanilla popsicle.
I think you said ice lolly?
Yeah.
It's orange and cream, so it's not vanilla.
It's an orange and cream popsicle.
It is exactly this, because obviously that's orange.
This does have, though, that tropical fruit
and cream combo that is really good.
I will say, again, for a self-confessed
not really hot dog enjoyer,
I have just kind of passively found myself
eating this whole thing.
Yeah, because you've been eating those UK dogs.
Who knows what they're putting in there?
That's all-American beef dog, buddy.
In the UK, it's way more common
to get a pork frankfurter,
and maybe that has something to do
with why I'm enjoying this one slightly more.
It's definitely got more of like a savory taste to it
that I'm used to, which I'm really enjoying.
All right, on to the next spot.
Let's go.
Harry and I already had enough of eating outdoors,
so I brought us to some familiar territory,
a dark and noisy bar named McSorley's Old Ale House.
This bar's been here since, I think, the 1800s.
It might not seem that big of a deal
for you coming from London,
but here in America, that's really old.
Yeah, for you guys, that seems like
it's been around a while.
Almost when you were founded.
I forget when that was.
Yeah, yeah, this was,
this is definitely New Amsterdam days.
Okay.
I don't know.
It does kind of remind me of like a British pub.
It's nice.
This place is amazing.
It's ridiculous.
They have two types of beer, dark or light.
You have the light, I have the dark.
Houdini was here once.
Abraham Lincoln drank here.
E.E. Cummins mentioned it in a poem.
So I'm not even the most famous Harry to have drunk here.
Harry Styles dropped in after his first brewery.
Yeah, of course.
He'd sold that Madison Square Garden,
he went right to McSorley's.
He came to McSorley's.
Everyone was like, who is this child?
Anyway, one thing about this place
that most people don't know about
is they have a fantastic hot dog.
Okay, I'm here for it.
Dude, you know what they have here
that's totally ridiculous?
You can get a plate of onions, cheese,
and like saltine crackers?
Like cooked onions?
No, they're raw.
Okay.
We're not getting it, but I want to say for the record,
that's totally not normal.
Well, now I feel like we should get it,
now that you've mentioned it.
Can we do two hot dogs
and a plate of the cheese and crackers on the end?
For the hot dogs, do you want chili and sauerkraut,
one of each or?
I think just the sauerkraut.
Just the sauerkraut.
One sauerkraut for each.
Yeah, thanks, bud.
Do you need a couple of Oreos?
Yeah, sure, why not?
Yeah, come on.
Yeah, for props.
Yeah, thanks.
Thank you.
Did he do two hands or one?
I think he had all of those in one hand.
No.
How many of those can you do in one hand?
Because I cannot do eight.
It's impossible.
He definitely did that with one hand.
It's impossible.
Let's see how many I can do in one hand.
I reckon like three or maybe four.
I feel like four.
Do I have tiny hands?
Oh, here we go.
There we go.
Thank you.
There we go.
I love this, a sleeve of saltines.
Just a full sleeve of saltines.
A full sleeve of saltines.
I don't know that I've ever had a saltine cracker,
you know?
You haven't?
I don't think so.
They're not really a thing in the UK.
Oh, no, this is like what you get with soup.
Yeah.
I know there's a dot.
Oh, is this mustard too here?
I was kind of rude about it,
but the onion's kind of winning me over.
Immediately, you come around on that.
Let's dip that.
Oh my God.
That is some strong mustard.
Definitely try that mustard.
Oh, man.
I love a bit of strong mustard.
Yeah?
That's a mustard?
It's not English mustard, man.
No, it's hot.
It's powerful stuff.
Is that Grey Poupon level?
It's what?
Grey Poupon.
You know what a Grey Poupon is?
I've got no idea what you're talking about.
You don't know what Grey Poupon mustard is?
Grey Poupon.
What are you saying?
Poupon.
First word, Grey.
Yes.
Second word, Poupon.
Poop.
Well, not poop.
Poupon.
There was this ad campaign in the 80s
where they made a thing like this brown mustard
called Grey Poupon was like a really fancy mustard.
And you see one guy sitting in the back
of like a nice town car.
He's like eating a meal in the backseat of his car.
And the second car pulls up,
another rich guy rolls in the window.
He's like, pardon me.
Do you have any Grey Poupon?
And the other guy's like, but of course.
And then when he hands him the jar
and the guy goes to get it from one window to the next,
they pause and they're like, Grey Poupon.
This mustard's fancy.
I don't know what the...
They make a joke of it in Wayne's world.
If we're talking mustard in the UK,
like English mustard,
I guess Coleman's probably has the market cornered
on that one.
Okay.
But yeah, this is good.
This is like some powerful stuff.
And weirdly, yeah, I'm kind of enjoying the onion.
Joe wipes the sawdust off his back.
Okay, we're the dogs.
You're going to flip your Grey Poupon when you try it.
I'm telling you, buddy.
Thank you.
Look at this.
This looks real good.
Thank you so very much.
Thank you very much.
Awesome.
Okay.
Did I tell you I'm not playing with this hot dog, dude?
This is for real.
This looks like a serious hot dog, man.
You got to have a little bit of the mustard ahead of time
with the cheese.
I'm getting a little taste already.
It's powerful stuff.
I feel like using it kind of sparingly.
This mustard, I mean like,
just a clear of sinuses.
Man, I'm excited.
Yeah, this dog is ridiculous.
This looks pretty good, man.
All right.
Get in here.
I think I'm ready.
Let me tell you, how good is this dog?
Whoa, that mustard just hit.
It's a Feltman's hot dog?
Right, okay.
It's different from the other ones we've had today?
Who are Feltman's?
Probably one of the oldest hot dog companies in the U.S.,
certainly in New York.
Right.
Others have moved in,
but they're sticking with the originals.
Okay, but they don't have too many hot dog stands, right?
Not as common as you think.
Sure.
There is a definite difference in the taste there.
Really taste the difference, right?
And the casing is really good.
There's like a real snap to it.
There's a good snap to it.
Yes, I was going to say.
Look, it even has like the excess casing here.
Like, I don't know what that means,
but it feels like because of that,
it's more natural.
That looks like,
you know the sausage you see in like Tom and Jerry?
When it's got, it looks like a balloon knot on the end.
It's like that.
Like the sausage legs.
Has it been cut in it?
Oh man.
You get a chance, try a bite on the other end
with just the dog.
The meat, it's impeccable.
It's really good, man.
I will say like,
when it arrived, it looked like a lot of sauerkraut,
but it's not the most like aggressive sauerkraut
you've ever had, right?
It's like fairly gentle,
not overly tangy and in your face.
Dude.
Are you getting the mustard?
Yeah, I get like a mustard pocket.
I was about to agree with you.
That thing just,
that just goes right up your nose.
It really does.
Mustard here is weird,
because it's more that like wasabi,
like attacks the back of your nose.
I love this.
It's really good.
I told you, man, this dog is incredible.
This is a serious top dog, man.
Yeah, this might be the one to beat.
Man.
It's like eating with Kasia.
I keep hitting like,
what, are you getting the mustard at the end there?
Man.
You take a bite,
you chew,
you think you're in the clear,
and then you hit a pocket of mustard.
Yeah, you get real cocky with your breathing again.
And you're like,
now that it's out of my mouth,
time to inhale.
Gotcha, yeah.
You have deleted that dog.
Wow.
I think the dog,
and with nothing on it,
if I just got that with just the dog and bun,
I still would be very,
very pleased.
The way that, yeah.
Yeah, let me try just like a little bit
of the sausage on its own.
Yeah, freestyle just the dog.
That might be the best snap we have all day.
That might be the best one.
That's like,
right?
It's so flavorful.
It's like,
what I imagine biting someone's finger off
would be like,
pop!
Right?
That's not how I wanted to imagine it.
Oh, okay.
But you do you.
Yeah.
Considering how spicy it is
and how much it like almost hurts,
it's like so more-ish,
you just keep,
you've got to keep going back every time.
It's almost like eating hot wings
in a certain way,
where like,
the pain of it,
and then like the endorphin rush after it like,
adds to it.
Why do humans do that?
It's like,
things that are like spicy,
really sour.
We just like,
can't get enough of it.
And now I'm kind of picking up the onions again.
Well, I mean,
we still got like half a sleeve of saltines
to get through.
So, you know.
We'll get those to go.
Perfect for dessert.
Well, as much as I'd love to stay in a bar
all day and night,
we unfortunately have to go
and eat more hot dogs.
So let's finish these
seven or eight more beers
that they gave us.
Yeah, cool.
And then,
on to more hot dogs.
I'll drink to that one.
Cheers, buddy.
One quintessential New York hot dog experience
is getting one
at one of the blue and yellow umbrella carts.
That's right by Central Park.
So,
here we are on 93rd Street,
I think.
Gonna get two dogs from my guy,
get over to the park,
hang out and eat them.
Sounds good.
Nice, let's do it.
Behold,
the dog.
Mustard,
sauerkraut and onions.
I don't know what he put on this,
to be honest.
I think I was moving lightning fast.
He really was.
Yeah, he knew his stuff.
$2 for a dog.
Did you notice that?
I did.
That's cheap.
That's really cheap.
Is that like the standard kind of
street hot dog price?
Because we're right next to Central Park.
We're in a good location.
Yeah, I know it varies.
I think that guy,
that guy,
he's in it for the love of the game.
His car was wrapped in plastic,
like it had just been murdered.
Yeah,
like a crime scene.
It did a little bit, yeah.
Okay, great.
But,
he's working hard,
so we'll do a dog's proud,
but I'm actually really hungry,
so.
Yeah, let's give it a try
and then we'll discuss.
Not as much of a distinct flavor
as the dog we've had before today.
But,
still an incredibly good hot dog.
Yeah,
I'm pleasantly surprised.
I think like,
often in the UK,
hot dogs tend to be boiled,
rather than grilled.
Yeah.
I know sometimes places will boil them here,
like this one.
Yeah, oh yeah, good point.
These are boiled though.
I think generally speaking,
I prefer the texture of like a grilled one,
because you get more of like a snap on the crust.
Yeah, yeah, yeah.
But you still get like a little bit of that here.
And honestly,
like it hasn't changed the flavor that much,
I don't think.
Yeah.
Still tastes fairly similar.
Yeah, this is like a nostalgia play,
you know?
Yeah, so he put ketchup on this one.
Yeah.
Where do you stand on ketchup on hot dogs?
Because some people find that controversial.
Who gives a ----?
Put whatever you want in your dog.
I can't stand this.
We did it with the pizza episode the other day,
like,
pineapple.
It's true.
Put whatever you want in your hot dog,
who cares?
People have rules.
Some people like to stick to the rules.
Absolutely nonsense.
You're more of a maverick.
Don't you think it's a weirder topping,
sauerkraut and onions,
right?
And with the ketchup,
it's like,
hold on,
ketchup's the third weird thing on here,
right?
Apparently the National Hot Dog and Sausage Council,
A,
there is one,
and B,
they released a statement,
because they released statements,
saying something to the tune of,
you can put ketchup on your hot dog
until you're like 13 or 14,
and then have to add that,
like be an adult or whatever,
grow up.
I love the existence of a National Hot Dog
and Sausage Council.
The word council is brilliant, though.
Not like organization,
council,
like the council has spoken.
Yeah,
these carts like this,
they're all over the city,
but this one specifically,
at 93rd,
Billy's,
I'm assuming that was Billy himself,
who helped us,
has hundreds of five-star reviews.
It's almost like the most popular,
or well-reviewed hot dog cart in the entire city.
if I'm taking the one,
you gotta take the best one, right?
Yeah,
I mean,
I wonder why he's got the best one.
The location's great.
We're right on Central Park,
that's pretty cool.
And he seemed like he knew his stuff.
Yeah,
he's a perfectly nice guy.
Yeah.
I just think it's insane to be rating a hot dog cart.
Just eating it out of your mouth.
Really bizarre to be like,
mm-hmm,
two stars.
Unless I got like the worst food poisoning ever,
and I logged on to give a bad rating.
I don't know like,
how are you gonna have a good one?
So you get the worst food poisoning ever,
and you give it a bad review?
You don't call the health inspector?
Call that guy.
I feel like that feels too much like-
I'll show that,
that's the British in you,
like why don't we be impolite,
so let's give him two stars.
that feels too rude.
That's too much like snitching.
Went to the hospital,
two stars.
Dog was pretty good on the way down.
Yeah,
yeah,
yeah.
That's pretty good.
I finished up,
we got more hot dogs to eat.
All right,
Billy, let's go.
From there,
we made our way to Madison Square Park,
for our next dog.
We're here at Madison Square Park,
the original Shake Shack location.
Now it used to actually be a shack,
probably right there,
that sold hot dogs,
that eventually burgers and shakes got in the mix,
but this is where it happened,
all right here at this park.
This hot dog is one of the highest rated hot dogs
in the city,
but that might be because of the Shake Shack
is highly rated,
and they also sell hot dogs here.
Okay.
So they've kind of like hacked TripAdvisor a little bit.
Yeah,
yeah,
exactly,
yeah.
But this is the dog that launched a thousand shacks then.
That's right.
So,
of course,
we have to show off,
this insane debacle of a hot dog.
I believe it's called like a flat top hot dog.
Right.
Because they do that,
cut it,
cut it in half,
and put it down,
so called like the butterfly cuts.
Sure.
The idea is,
if you're making a hot dog,
and an earthquake strikes,
it doesn't roll off of the grill,
because,
Got it.
It's just,
I mean,
I think the original Shake Shack guy used to,
his first job was making hot dogs on a pirate ship.
I don't know,
for whatever reason.
On a fault line.
Yeah,
yeah,
that's right,
yeah.
It looks pretty well cooked.
There's like a nice bit of color on that.
I'm biting this dog,
see how it tastes.
Cheers,
let's go.
Yeah,
the char taste really comes through with this.
I almost,
in a weird way,
I almost wouldn't want to put anything on this.
I do slightly disagree with you.
I do think it needs some moisture,
is the main thing.
Oh,
and then toppings.
Toppings,
you didn't mean like,
just like spray a little bit of water or whatever.
that works.
Okay.
No,
I think like,
a little bit of sauce,
or like some caramelized onion,
or something.
Oh,
well.
Just to kind of,
you know,
aid it on the way down,
but,
the dog itself is really tasty.
It's got like a,
chewier,
texture,
than I've had before.
I would,
make some changes,
with like,
the toppings.
I think,
if this came with some grilled onions,
and maybe a little mustard,
I'd be a happy man.
Did somebody say toppings?
I did say toppings.
All right.
Funny you should mention toppings.
I did have,
a bit of an ulterior motive,
bringing you here.
This Shake Shack,
actually has a Chicago style dog.
And me being from Chicago,
I think Chicago style dog,
is the best style of hot dog,
at least in America.
Keep your voice down man,
we're in New York.
Crazy.
And,
I wasn't sure if,
any other places we were going today,
was going to have one,
so I want to make sure you got,
at least,
a try,
one while you're here.
Here it is.
Feast your eyes,
on,
that's right,
I said it,
the best,
hot dog combination,
in America,
the Chicago style dog.
I did notice they split the hot dog,
and did it how they normally do,
that's not a Chicago way of doing it.
Sure.
But,
you got tomato,
wedges,
diced white onion,
relish,
sport peppers,
celery salt,
yellow mustard,
and a wedge,
of a pickle.
So you mentioned before,
you kind of were responding favorably to,
the sauerkraut having that vinegary-ness to it.
Yes,
a little bit of tang,
yeah.
This is all tang.
Even though I don't like pickles,
Yeah.
I do like,
the wedge,
on the dog.
You'll make an exception,
for Chicago.
I know I make an exception,
reasonably authentic then,
as a Chicagoan.
Yeah,
so far it does.
The bun should be a poppy seed bun,
but we don't cut them in half.
It's a regularly boiled hot dog.
All right,
I've never had one of these before.
Okay.
I'm excited,
let's go.
Let's go.
Mmm.
You're destroying that thing,
wow.
You're going,
the way you're going in on that,
I guess you like it.
Yeah,
I've had a few before.
This right here is the secret ingredient.
These sport peppers,
the little green peppers.
They're not very spicy.
No.
Give a little bit of a kick to them,
but they're still good.
And the tiniest thing I got,
like a snap to them.
Mmm.
Fantastic,
fantastic dog.
This is really good.
Yeah, right?
Told you.
Why do we not put pickles on hot dogs more?
This is delicious.
I don't know,
I don't know why not.
See,
this is more up my street,
because it's got
plenty of moisture in here.
Yeah.
There's like texture contrast going on,
you get crunch,
you get snap,
you get chew.
I don't know if that,
if we can consider that
a contender for a New York
hot dog video.
You and I might not be welcome back in New York,
if we say that the best dog in New York
is a Chicago style dog.
You know,
that's on them.
If they can't offer something better than this,
then it's their fault.
Can you please explain the term glizzy to me?
Because I've seen this all over the internet.
I think that's what people nickname a hot dog.
Really?
A hot dog suddenly became like,
not cool to eat.
I'm normalizing eating hot dogs,
not with these kids and their apps,
making fun of it.
All right,
I'm going to finish this beer,
we got more glizzies to eat.
I'm ready to gulp some more glizzy, man.
Let's,
let's head off.
Someone please isolate that audio,
make it a viral TikTok audio.
I will take the shame to be sort of famous.
No New York hot dog tour would be complete
without a trip to Nathan's Famous over in Coney Island.
I know we've been eating hot dogs all day.
That we have.
This is a bit of a haul.
Went pretty far south,
but had to take you to Nathan's,
the world famous,
the one and only here in Coney Island,
also home of the hot dog eating competition.
Yes.
Your boy Kobayashi.
Even I've seen that.
It's horrifying and fascinating in equal measure.
Nathan's has been here since 1916.
It started as a hot dog stand.
And remember we were talking earlier
about Feltman's hot dogs?
Yes.
When Nathan's opened,
they undercut them by selling five cent hot dogs
instead of 10 cent hot dogs.
So that rivalry runs deep.
They have locations all over the world.
You can get Nathan's hot dogs in grocery stores
all over the country and possibly also internationally.
It is the quintessential hot dog,
arguably the most famous one.
And I think you should see why.
Also, if you're listening,
you can hear we're only steps away
from the Coney Island carnival grounds,
rides, the whole thing.
So all that screaming is people on roller coasters
and not people eating hot dogs.
Sure.
That's reassuring to know.
I do love how I'm here
and it feels like I could also be
somewhere on the British coastline.
Really, why's that?
I feel like just coasts in general,
or at least in the UK and the US
from what I've experienced,
have that similar kind of like rundown charm,
I would say.
It's not like glamorous over here,
but it's very fun.
It's nostalgic and I like it.
So yeah, I feel right at home
and I'm ready to eat this hot dog.
All right, once again, we get the sauerkraut.
We got the onions on here.
This is a pretty good looking hot dog.
I like the color on the onions.
Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.
It's a thinner frank,
but that's to be expected.
I know Nathan's are a little bit thinner.
I think a hot dog eating competition
would be a lot better if they had to eat ones
with the toppings on it.
That'd be really funny, right?
That would be.
All right.
That's the challenge on hard mode.
But before we go any further,
we gotta eat this dog.
Is that a taste?
Ready?
Cheers.
Mm.
Mm-hmm.
So good.
Mm-hmm.
So, so good.
As far as first bites go,
really, really good.
Even though it's like thinner
than most we've seen today,
does have a really good snap to it.
Mm-hmm.
Incredibly flavorful.
100% beef.
These have like a distinct flavor.
The frank has a distinct flavor
that I could probably pick out of a hot dog lineup, right?
I'd say, although this is a beef frank,
tastes fairly similar to some of the more like
pork-based frankfurters that we're used to
maybe in the UK.
Oh, is that right?
Yeah.
Something to do with the seasoning.
The texture as well.
It's quite like homogenous, I guess, the texture.
I feel like some of the ones we've had,
maybe you can taste like more distinct bits of meat.
Whereas this is kind of like just one solid piece of meat.
Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.
I like how this place is like a hot dog complex.
You know what I'm saying?
We're in line there.
It's like-
This is huge.
Just running through hot dogs like crazy.
Yeah, they're churning them up.
Friendly vibe in there.
I like it.
Really nice, yeah, yeah, yeah.
This dog is as iconic as Coney Island itself.
If you are here, you're eating a hot dog.
Yeah, can you kind of like separate Coney Island
from Nathan's or are they kind of just one and the same?
One and the same.
Yeah.
You're enjoying it so much
that you wanted your pants to get a taste of that too.
I know, god damn.
I'm a wreck, I've had 20 hot dogs today.
And about five beers.
Yeah.
I think it's the hot dogs.
The kraut's really good here.
Crunchy.
Yeah.
Tangy.
Honestly, like I added mustard,
but I'm not sure it needs it
because you actually get quite a lot of sourness
from the sauerkraut and a little bit from the onions.
If you had to enter the hot dog competition tomorrow,
how many dogs do you think you could put away?
What was the record again?
I don't know if it's a record,
but Kobe actually did like 69.
Nice.
And that's in 10 minutes, I think?
That's a lot.
In 10 minutes, I could-
I can't eat 69 hot dogs in a year.
No.
Can you?
If I was really hungry,
I reckon I could maybe do 10 in 10 minutes.
10 hot dogs.
Get out of here, 10 hot dogs.
How many do you think in 10 minutes?
I bet you'd put away six and then you'd puke, right?
You got so little faith, man.
We eat fast food professionally.
You think our stomachs aren't used to that?
Oh, God.
Give me a one-beat, mate, mate, mate.
Oh, sorry.
I feel like my stomach's getting more sensitive.
It screams like, it's pretty jarring.
They're okay.
They're fine, they're fine.
We spent the whole day eating hot dogs,
went all around the city to decide
what was the best hot dog you had today.
Let's run down a few.
Every hot dog I think was great for its own reasons.
Grace Papaya, I think, was just a classic dog, right?
The snap, the texture, that was a good start.
But, you know, the one that we had in Central Park,
it was just like the nostalgia play, right?
It just was, yeah, you know, this is what it's all about.
Having a hot dog in the park,
contemplating your existence,
the futility of your existence, if I may.
That was great.
Shake Shack, I mean, maybe I'm biased.
We got that Shackago dog.
Shackago dog, I think, was very good.
But their actual regular dog,
as much like the hate on the butterfly cut-in-half thing,
it did have a nice flavor to it.
McSorley's, I mean, that whole thing was just ridiculous.
That specific frank they had on there.
I loved the sauerkraut, too.
And then here, look at the size of this building.
You don't have a building this big
unless you're selling some serious hot dogs, right?
You really don't.
You're moving a lot of dogs.
So it's a real hard choice.
But what do you think?
What are some things that stood out to you?
The main takeaway for me
is that New York has slightly changed my opinion on hot dogs.
Oh, that's fantastic.
I wasn't much of a hot dog guy.
But honestly, we've had some really great hot dogs,
pretty much at every location,
to the point where I think in the future,
I would now voluntarily eat a hot dog.
I would go out of my way to buy and eat a hot dog.
Whereas in the past, maybe I wouldn't have done that.
So I think, broadly speaking, New York has done well.
You guys do a good hot dog.
But I think my personal favorite was McSorley's.
Really, why's that?
I really liked the vibe in that.
It might be because I kind of felt
like a nostalgic British pub vibe from it.
Interesting.
But it's very classic in that.
It's very about people were friendly.
It was cheap, good quality.
That hot dog was just delicious.
We both destroyed that thing.
Do you agree?
I agree, we both destroyed it.
And I'm going to agree with you.
I think McSorley's was the best hot dog we had today.
Now, I thought it was gonna be Grey's Papaya.
After we had it, I'm like, come on.
We're not getting a better hot dog than this.
But what jumped out for me is McSorley's is,
it didn't have as much sauerkraut on it,
or the kraut wasn't as strong of a flavor, right?
So the dog did more of the chalking.
Definitely.
The Feltman's dog, which I don't think anyone else
had a Feltman's dog that we had.
Certainly not Nathan's.
I think that most of them were Nathan's or something else.
And with that mustard, ooh!
Now, what else could you put on that dog
after that mustard?
I don't think it needed anything else.
There weren't onions on there.
I don't think it needed onions.
So, with just their kraut and the mustard,
made for a fantastic hot dog.
Yeah, I think simple, but very, very effective.
And like I said, the vibe in there was really great.
Yeah, it's a cool place.
You can happily go back, even if you weren't gonna eat,
just go back for a drink in the evening.
Yeah, it's cool.
Just friendly in there.
And yeah, would happily endorse that to any tourist
who is heading to New York.
Do you want to go on a rollercoaster now
that we have a stomach full of beer and hot dogs?
That's a recipe for throwing up.
So, yes, let's do it.
See you in a couple of weeks
for the hot dog eating contest.
Is that eight?
I said 10.
Nah, that happens.
Bring it on, man.
That happens.
