The Greatest Literary Genius of the Tang & Song Dynasties Was Doomed to Hell for Criticizing Buddhism.
#gjwpluswatchparty Good news! Gan Jing World recently launched GJW+ streaming, a platform dedicated to presenting a wide array of clean, uplifting, traditional, and educational film and television works. Subscribe to GJW+ now for only $6.99 per month, the price of just two cups of coffee, and enjoy a top-notch viewing experience with your family. Click the link below and by using the exclusive discount code SARA, you can enjoy a 15% discount.
Unveiling the Forgotten, the Forbidden, and the Divine — a journey through China’s lost wisdom and a return to timeless tradition.
Follow me, and rediscover the China that time tried to forget. And consider supporting my research through a donation to help keep these forgotten voices alive. (Donation link: https://paypal.me/KSJBG)
Han Yu was a pivotal Tang Dynasty scholar who revived Confucianism and ancient prose. While celebrated for his literary brilliance and courage, his life was marked by rigid arrogance and a fierce opposition to Buddhism, leading to his exile and a legendary afterlife of suffering due to the enduring impact of his writings.
In the long river of Chinese history,
few figures shine as brightly as Han Yu.
To later Confucian scholars,
he was nearly a perfect sage — courageous,
upright, uncompromising,
and fiercely loyal to the truth.
At a time when literary culture had grown stagnant and hollow,
Han Yu rose to lead the Ancient Prose Movement,
restoring vitality to Chinese writing
and reviving the Confucian Way after centuries of decline.
The Song Dynasty poet Su Shi immortalized his achievement
in one of the most famous lines in Chinese literature:
His writing revived literature after eight dynasties of decline;
His Dao rescued the world from drowning.
For over a thousand years,
these words have stood like a monument to Han Yu’s greatness.
Yet behind the glory lies a far more haunting story
— a tale of brilliance and arrogance,
of divine mercy and missed opportunities,
and of the terrifying power hidden within human words.
23 00:01:10.218 --> 00:01:11.718 I’m Sara.
Today,
we’ll explore the extraordinary story of Han Yu
— and the profound lesson his life still holds for us today.
29 00:01:25.789 --> 00:01:30.108 and Daoism dominated the spiritual landscape of Tang China.
Temples rose across the empire,
monks enjoyed tax exemptions,
and even emperors bowed before sacred Buddha relics.
To Han Yu,
this was not merely a religious trend — it was a
dangerous corruption of Chinese civilization itself.
In his famous essay On the Origin of the Dao,
Han Yu denounced Buddhism as a
“barbarian teaching”
that weakened family bonds,
undermined loyalty to the ruler,
and pulled people away from productive labor.
He argued fiercely that monks
and nuns contributed nothing to society,
declaring: “Let the monks and nuns return to lay life,
burn their scriptures,
and turn their temples into ordinary homes.”
Then came the incident that would change his life forever.
In the year 819,
Emperor Xianzong brought a sacred Buddha bone into
the imperial palace for veneration. By then,
Han Yu was serving as a high-ranking official at court.
Outraged by the emperor’s devotion to the relic,
he submitted one of the most explosive memorials
in Chinese history: Memorial on the Buddha Bone.
In it, Han Yu boldly described the relic as
“a filthy object”
and urged the emperor to cast it into fire
or water in order to “destroy it forever.”
Furious,
the emperor at once decreed Han Yu’s execution.
It was only through the desperate intercession of
his ministers that the sovereign’s wrath was tempered:
the death sentence was commuted to exile,
and Han Yu was banished to Chaozhou, a desolate,
malaria-infested outpost on the empire’s sultry southern frontier.
68 00:03:19.228 --> 00:03:22.829 ancient legends say something miraculous occurred.
According to folk tradition,
Han Yu was actually a “banished immortal”
— a celestial being sent down to the human world.
Seeing that Han Yu lost in fame, ambition,
and rigid conviction,
the Jade Emperor sent Han Xiangzi — one of the Eight Immortals
and Han Yu’s own nephew — to awaken him.
Han Xiangzi attempted to warn him nine times.
During a family banquet,
the young immortal appeared uninvited.
He sang strange, otherworldly songs,
made flowers bloom into dancing cranes
and talking sheep warning Han Yu:
“Uncle,
a great snowstorm awaits you at Blue Pass.
Turn back from your path of hatred,
or you will suffer greatly.”
Han Yu, enraged by what he saw as superstition
and delusion, drove him away.
As Han Xiangzi departed, he waved his hand —
and on the stone steps outside the hall,
a cluster of golden lotuses suddenly bloomed.
On their petals appeared two lines of golden script:
Clouds block the Qin Mountains — where is my home?
Snow seals Blue Pass — my horse cannot move forward.
At the time,
Han Yu did not understand their meaning.
Months later, the prophecy came true.
As Han Yu struggled through the Qin Mountains,
a fierce blizzard struck at Blue Pass.
His horse refused to move forward.
Frozen and despairing,
he realized he might not survive the journey.
At that moment,
Han Xiangzi appeared through the storm.
Only then did Han Yu suddenly understand:
the poem he had once dismissed was a prophecy of this very moment.
Deeply shaken,
Han Yu completed the poem on the spot:
At dawn,
a memorial sent me eight thousand li into exile;
Clouds block the Qin Mountains — where is my home?
Snow seals Blue Pass — my horse cannot move forward.
You came from afar with good intention;
I pray you will one day gather my bones by the misty river.
Here, li (里) is an ancient Chinese unit of distance,
roughly half a kilometer.
“Eight thousand li”
is not a precise measurement,
but a poetic way of expressing an almost unimaginable
distance — a journey of total exile,
far beyond the reach of home.
The poem itself is simple,
but its meaning is heavy:
it begins with forced displacement,
moves through a landscape of blocked mountains
and snowbound roads,
and ends with the quiet anticipation of death in
a foreign land. Beneath the surface,
it is less a travel poem than a farewell — to home,
to safety, and perhaps to life itself.
132 00:06:26.899 --> 00:06:30.428 Han Yu encountered the renowned Zen Master Da Dian.
Their exchange would later become one of the most
famous encounters between Confucian rationalism
and Buddhist thought.
Han Yu, still firm in his criticism of Buddhism,
argued that it weakened family bonds
and allowed people to live off society without contributing labor.
After listening quietly,
Master Da Dian asked calmly:
“Which Buddhist scriptures did you read to arrive
at these conclusions?”
Han Yu admitted, somewhat bluntly,
he had never actually read the scriptures himself.
The master smiled
and replied with an ancient saying:
“A dog barks at a sage because it does not recognize him.”
He gently pointed out that attacking something without
understanding it was no different from a dog barking
at Yao, the legendary wise emperor.
Han Yu was speechless.
Over time,
he visited Master Da Dian several times,
showed respect,
and even presented him with two monk’s robes as a
parting gift when he left Chao Zhou.
In a letter,
he praised the monk as someone who could
“transcend form and master principle.”
162 00:07:48.938 --> 00:07:51.223 Han Yu had a strange dream.
A towering,
golden-armored deity appeared beside his bed,
holding a sword, and said:
“The Heavenly Emperor requires your service to wage
war against a rival realm. Will you come?”
Han Yu answered without hesitation, “I will go.”
He died shortly afterward at the age of fifty-seven.
According to a well-known Buddhist tradition,
and as personally recounted in the visionary experiences
of the modern scholar Zhang Taiyan (1869 – 1936),
Han Yu did not ascend to heaven after his death.
Instead,
because his powerful anti-Buddhist writings — especially
On the Origin of the Dao
and the Memorial on the Buddha Bone — had influenced
countless readers across generations to question
or reject Buddhism,
he was said to have descended into the Realm of Hungry Ghosts.
Zhang Taiyan himself claimed that,
in his own direct experiences,
he was occasionally taken by minor spirits to serve
as a temporary judge in the court of the Eastern
Peak Emperor. On one such occasion,
he encountered Han Yu in the realm of hungry ghosts,
who spoke with deep sorrow:
“It is because of those writings.
As long as they continue to circulate in the world,
I cannot escape this realm of endless hunger
and thirst.”
Fortunately,
because of his late-life meetings with Master Da Dian and some signs of repentance,
he was spared the deeper levels of torments of hell.
Here lies the deepest tragedy:
Han Yu was no ordinary man.
In legend, he was a banished immortal.
He received repeated warnings from both Daoist and Buddhist figures,
and in his final years he even showed moments of
humility and reflection. Yet his fierce pride,
and his rigid attachment to his own version of Confucian
purity, prevented him from fully letting go.
Han Yu intended to “restore the pure source”
of Confucian tradition.
Yet his legacy helped set in motion a later intellectual
pattern in which Confucian thinkers would publicly
reject Buddhism
while quietly absorbing its ideas.
In trying to defend orthodoxy,
he may have inadvertently contributed to fragmenting
the once more integrated divine cultural traditions.
Chinese tradition had long been shaped by a dynamic
balance between Confucianism, Buddhism,
and Daoism — a worldview often described as the harmony
between Heaven and humanity,
and the complementary nature of the three teachings.
The very weapon that made him great — the unmatched
power of his pen — became the chain that bound him
in the afterlife.
A brilliant light that revived Chinese literature
was, in the end,
dimmed by the shadow of his own unyielding words.
That’s it for today.
If you enjoyed this story,
feel free to leave a comment, like and share.
See you next time.