Birthright Citizenship- Is it Hurting the U.S

Artifact Archives
9 followers
Jun 6, 2026
The 14th Amendment was ratified after the Civil War to define citizenship for those born or naturalized in the United States and to guarantee equal protection under the law, especially for formerly enslaved people. Over time, courts have stretched its language to cover many issues far beyond its original purpose, including immigration, welfare, and f
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThis video examines the legal and political controversy surrounding birthright citizenship in the U.S., focusing on the 14th Amendment. It analyzes the tension between the principle of *jus soli* and arguments regarding political allegiance, while highlighting the human impact of family separation and the legal crackdown on \"birth tourism\" schemes.
The United States Supreme Court is once again being asked to interpret one of the most debated
sentences in the Constitution, the Citizenship Clause of the 14th Amendment. The case centers
on birthright citizenship and whether children born in the United States to illegal immigrants
automatically become American citizens. President Donald Trump has challenged the long-standing
interpretation of that clause, arguing that the Constitution does not grant citizenship
to every child born on U.S. soil. Supporters of that view point to the phrase,
subject to the jurisdiction thereof, claiming it places limits on who qualifies for citizenship.
Others argue the opposite. They maintain that the 14th Amendment guarantees citizenship to anyone
born in the United States regardless of their parents' immigration status. That interpretation
has guided American law for more than a century. So what does the Constitution actually say,
and how did this debate begin? Should birthright citizenship be granted, and if so, why? Do other
nations offer birthright citizenship? Is the argument to abandon the practice feasible?
What does the law say, and how can that be challenged?
Hello, I'm Colin Heaton, former history professor, Army and Marine Corps veteran,
and welcome to this episode of Forgotten History.
The beginning of the toughest 26 days in Marine Corps history.
With confidence. The ex-president of the United States died this afternoon.
Telling their children and women in here to call it off.
The 14th Amendment to the Constitution states in section 1,
quote, all persons born or naturalized in the United States and subject to the jurisdiction
thereof are citizens of the United States and of the state wherein they reside.
No state shall make or enforce any law which shall abridge the privileges or immunities of
citizens of the United States, nor shall any state deprive any person of life, liberty, or property
without due process of law, nor deny to any person within its jurisdiction the equal protection of
the laws. The argument against continuing this practice surrounds the phrase, subject to the
jurisdiction thereof, and this is the problem. Foreigners who are not citizens, or even legal
residents, do not owe allegiance to the United States. Their allegiance is to their nation of
origin, not America, and federal law does not allow non-citizens to vote in national elections,
buy firearms, or make campaign donations. Given these examples of the law, supporters of
abolishing birthright citizens stand on solid ground, and there is also legal precedent.
American Indians were only granted U.S. citizenship on June 2, 1924, when Congress
passed the Indian Citizenship Act, also called the Snyder Act. This was because they belonged
to their separate, self-identified respective nations, such as the Sioux, Cheyenne, Apache,
Comanche, etc. Their allegiance was not to the USA. Before 1924, some Native Americans had already
become citizens through other paths, such as military service, independent treaties with
various Indian nations, marriage to U.S. citizens, and accepting land allotments under the Dawes Act,
but the U.S. is not that unique. Despite what a lot of people assume, the United States is not
the only country with birthright citizenship, but it is part of a small club. According to a 2026
Pew Research analysis, only 33 countries, including the U.S., currently grant automatic
citizenship at birth regardless of the parent's legal status. Most of them are in the Americas
and the Caribbean. Countries like Canada, Mexico, Argentina, Brazil, and the United States are on
that list, along with a smaller number in Africa and the Asia-Pacific region, such as Benin, Chad,
Lesotho, Mozambique, Pakistan, and Tuvalu. The bigger global picture is simple. Automatic
birthright citizenship is the exception, not the rule. One important fine print point,
even in countries with broad jus soli, meaning justice or right of the soil,
there are usually narrow exceptions, especially for children of foreign diplomats.
Many other nations only have conditional forms of birthright citizenship tied to a parent's
citizenship, permanent residence, or years of lawful residence. The challengers say the 14th
Amendment does not grant citizenship to every child born on U.S. soil because the text includes
the limiting phrase, and subject to the jurisdiction thereof. They argue that this
phrase means more than just being physically present in the country and obeying its laws.
In their view, it means being born to parents who owe full political allegiance to the United
States, not merely temporary obedience while living here. Under that argument, children born
in the United States to people here illegally or only temporarily, such as tourists or some visa
holders, are said not to be fully subject to the jurisdiction of the United States in the
constitutional sense. The theory is that their parents still owe primary allegiance to another
nation, so the child does not automatically receive citizenship at birth. Reuters reported
that this is the position advanced by the Trump administration in the current litigation, which
argues that citizenship should be limited to children of U.S. citizens and lawful permanent
residents, or at least those with a more permanent legal tie to the country. Supporters of this
challenge often point to the historical context of the 14th Amendment. They say it was written
to guarantee citizenship to freed slaves after the Civil War, not to create a universal rule
covering everyone born in the country no matter their parent's status. They also argue that the
traditional exceptions, such as children of foreign diplomats and invading armies,
showed that simple birth on U.S. soil was never the whole test. Allegiance and jurisdiction
mattered, too. The legal obstacle for that argument is huge. The long-standing understanding
of the Citizenship Clause, and especially the Supreme Court's 1898 decision in United States
v. Wong Kim Ark, which held that a child born in the U.S. to foreign parents who were not diplomats
was a U.S. citizen at birth. That case is widely treated as the main precedent supporting modern
birthright citizenship juxtaposed to the American-Indian argument. The rebuttal against
Trump's position says the restrictionism argument tries to smuggle in a concept of
complete political allegiance that the Citizenship Clause itself does not use.
The text does not say born to citizen or lawful resident parents. It says born in the United
States and subject to its jurisdiction. They say that if the framers had wanted to make
parental immigration status a requirement, they could have written that. They did not.
Others would say that they never anticipated illegal immigration on a scale such as that
allowed by the Biden administration. Cornell's Constitution Annotated traces the clause back to
the Civil Rights Act of 1866 and the constitutional adoption that followed. Another rebuttal point is
practical and historical. For well over a century, the United States has treated everyone
born on U.S. soil as a citizen. Courts, agencies, and Congress have operated on that assumption.
They are trying to upend the settled understanding of citizenship with a much narrower reading that
courts have generally not accepted. Reuters reported that during the April 1, 2026 oral
arguments, several justices appeared skeptical of the attempt to cut back birthright citizenship
through executive action and questioned both the legal basis and how it could work in practice.
So, boiled down to one sentence, the challenge is this. Birth on U.S. soil is not enough by
itself. The parents must also be under full U.S. political jurisdiction and allegiance.
That is the argument. As of April 2026, the Supreme Court justices who heard the latest
case appeared skeptical of that position during oral arguments. We shall see where they land on
this issue, but Congress could amend the Constitution by changing and clarifying the
law to support the anti-birthright collective. Even if the liberals prevail and birthright
citizenship is upheld by the Supreme Court, there are still laws that will make their
remaining in country quite difficult. A child born in the United States is considered a U.S.
citizen at birth, but that does not automatically give the parents legal status and does not by
itself stop the government from deporting them. The law treats the child's citizenship and the
parent's removability as two different things. A U.S. citizen child has the right to remain
in the United States, but an undocumented parent may still be ordered removed. That creates the
family split people argue about. In practice, the child usually is not deported as a legal matter
if the child is a U.S. citizen. The child either stays in the U.S. with another caregiver, a legal
resident parent or relative, if there is one, or leaves with the parent as a practical family
decision. Currently, the government can remove the parent, but it cannot cancel the child's
citizenship just because the parent is removable. Current litigation over birthright citizenship
does not change that baseline for children recognized as citizens under existing law,
but should the law be changed. As a general rule, it is legal to deport undocumented or
illegal aliens or otherwise removable parents, even if they have a U.S. citizen child. Having
a citizen child is not an automatic shield against removal. Relief exists, but it is limited and hard
to get. The main statutory form of relief is cancellation of removal for certain non-permanent
residents, which requires, among other things, continuous physical presence, good moral character,
and proof that removal would cause exceptional and extremely unusual hardship to a U.S. citizen
or lawful permanent resident spouse, parent, or child. That hardship standard is not ordinary
sadness, disruption, or financial strain. The Board of Immigration Appeals has continued to
describe it as hardship substantially beyond what would normally be expected when a close
family member is removed. Recent BIA decisions in 2025 and 2026 show that citizen children can
be qualifying relatives, but the parent must still meet the very demanding legal standard,
and children can age out of that qualifying relative category once they are adults.
Why this becomes such a legal and moral mess is because, under the current interpretation of the
law, the child is a citizen with constitutional and legal rights in the United States. That part
is believed to be straightforward under the conventional reading of the 14th Amendment
and federal statute. But if that were true, why were American Indians not given this consideration?
They could not be deported, but until 1924, or through other measures, they were not citizens
either. Second, the parents may still be removed under immigration law. Citizenship of the child
does not erase unlawful presence, inadmissibility, or deportability, and being in an unlawful status
and other bars still matter. Third, the family must choose between two bad options,
such as if the child stays in America without the parent or parents, or if the child leaves America
with the parent or parents, even though the child has a right to stay. This is the human dilemma.
The law can be technically tidy on paper and still produce a wrecking ball in real life.
Therefore, a citizen child cannot usually fix the parent's status while still a minor.
A U.S. citizen can petition for a parent as an immediate relative only when the citizen is at
least 21 years old. USCIS says plainly that the petitioning U.S. citizen must be 21 or older to
Even then, sponsorship is not always a magic wand, because unlawful presence and other
inadmissibility issues can still create separate obstacles. Background checks, sponsorship, and
proof of self-sustainability would also apply, although none of that mattered under the Biden
administration, which allowed an invasion in violation of federal law. This is considered
necessary because illegals who have children then expect to have immunity from deportation.
The solid argument is no, they can be deported and they can take their children with them.
DOJ says a non-permanent resident generally must show at least 10 years of continuous physical
presence, good moral character, and that removal would cause exceptional and extremely unusual
hardship to a U.S. citizen or lawful permanent resident, spouse, parent, or child. That is a
very high standard. Ordinary hardship is not enough. If the children want to be considered
U.S. citizens, then they may legally return to the USA after they reach the age of majority,
usually age 18. In several federal cases out of Southern California, operators helped pregnant
Chinese clients come to the United States, hide the pregnancies from immigration officials,
and give birth here so the children would receive U.S. citizenship at birth. That's just another
way of invasion. In December 2024, the Justice Department said one California operator was
sentenced to 41 months in prison for running a scheme that helped Chinese clients obtain birth
right citizenship for their children. A person enters on a tourist visa, gives birth in the U.S.,
and leaves. That child may still be treated as a U.S. citizen at birth under the traditional rule,
but the parent may later face problems if the government concludes there was misinterpretation
or visa fraud. The DOJ's Southern California birth tourism prosecutions were built on exactly that
theory. The alleged fraud was in the entry and concealment, not in the child's citizenship
status itself. These cases were prosecuted as visa fraud, immigration fraud, money laundering cases,
not as proof that the babies were not citizens. In other words, the child's citizenship and the
parent's immigration violations were treated as separate issues. So, the question becomes
straightforward. Should the current interpretation remain in place, or should the law be reconsidered?
Should birth right citizenship continue as it has, or should the United States adopt
a different standard? We let you decide. Thank you for watching this episode of
Forgotten History. If you liked what you saw, please click like, share, and subscribe. And,
if you would like to assist with the ever-increasing costs of production,
please consider becoming a channel member and joining our Patreon page.
