Most apologies are “pseudo-sorry.” In this excerpt from the podcast, American Recovery, Dr. Stephen Marmer explains what making amends actually requires: truth, empathy, and repair. If you want real relationship healing (not just relief), this is the apology vs amends difference that changes everything. Watch the full episode ➡️ https://l.prageru.com/4o9ol6n
This discussion explores the critical distinction between superficial apologies and genuine amends. It emphasizes that true healing and personal transformation require an honest acknowledgment of harm, the practice of \"mentalization\" to understand the victim's perspective, and a commitment to reparation rather than simply seeking forgiveness to clear one's conscience.
What is the difference between, right at the top of the order, saying sorry, apologies, and an amends?
Okay. Well, there are all kinds of ways of saying sorry. You can have pseudo-sorry, like,
I'm sorry if I hurt you. Or, if I made you uncomfortable, I'm terribly sorry.
Well, what do you mean if I made you uncomfortable? So, a genuine amends has to start
with an acknowledgment of the truth of whatever it is that you've done. Not a hypothetical,
not if I might have, or if you misunderstood me such that, but rather, I'm acknowledging
that I did something that I regret, that I shouldn't have done, and that I want to repair.
That's the minimum foundation for a genuine expression of sorrow. A lot of people have fake
I'm sorries, and then they think that if they say I'm sorry, well, that wipes the slate clean. Well,
it doesn't wipe the slate clean because it doesn't reverse the damage of what has been done.
It doesn't indicate that you have made an effort to find out why you did this thing
that you're supposedly apologizing for, or the impact of whatever it is that you did,
both on the other person and on your character, and if I may say, even your soul.
It's interesting because I think to myself, how does one become aware of what they've done
in order to make a clear amends to somebody? And as it pertains to how we're talking throughout
this entire series of changing your life around, there was a part back number four that talks about
making an inventory of yourself. And I know for myself and many others who have gone through this
process, it's about getting to know what you did wrong. What was your part to play in that?
Correct.
And then you can take that to go make your amends. So is that what you were talking about,
where you need to go in clear on what you are sorry for?
Yes. Acknowledging that you actually did it and that it's not just the other person's
delicate, overly sensitive feelings. A lot of people apologize, go through a pseudo-apology,
and what they're really saying is, I'm sorry that you're so ultra-delicate and that my
otherwise good behavior bothered you, so I'll give you a little bit of a crumb of an apology,
a pseudo-apology. No, a genuine apology is, hey, I really did something that I shouldn't have done
and I'm going to really try and figure out what drove me to it, that's on my own self,
and how it impacted you. What did I do to affect you? I know we're kind of jumping ahead a little
bit, but that gets into some of the difference between shame and guilt. If I could talk a little
bit about that now. Absolutely. We're going to definitely get into that in a bit. Before we get
there, I want to set the stage a little bit more. The question I would have to get us into all this
is, why is making amends such a key step in turning one's life around? If you don't have
a truly honest awareness of what you've done, not just what you've done, but the impact that
it had on somebody else, and with real what we call mentalization or real empathy, you understand
what it looked like through the other person's glasses, then you can begin to make true change.
I don't believe that you can make the full impact of change of yourself until you have told the
story through the other person's glasses. There's a new fancy term for that called mentalization.
It's kind of empathy on steroids. Not just feeling, but really understanding the impact
that it had on the other person. If you can get to that point, then you have a much deeper sense
of what it is that you've done. You only know what you've done, but you don't know the full
story until you actually mentalize what it did to the other person and have a desire to repair
and restore and make reparations. Dr. Mommer, how do genuine amends differ from just saying
sorry and why are they so powerful? I know we're kind of getting into this now,
but the difference is where I feel like a lot of people get hung up.
Most people, when they say, I'm sorry, if it isn't a fake apology, if it's a legitimate apology,
most people want just the expression, I'm sorry, to be good enough to wash the slate clean
and to be forgiven. And that's not enough. You have to truly understand what the experience was
on the person whom you've hurt in order for it to be a genuine apology. And then you have to
want to actually correct or repair or make reparations for what it is that you did to
them. So it's partly acknowledgement, it's partly reparation, restoration, all of those things.
You spoke about empathy. I feel like a lot of people use sympathy and empathy incorrectly.
They think of their very interchangeably. First off, can you explain the difference
between sympathy and empathy? And we're curious to hear your thoughts on, can you
actually feel true empathy towards somebody? Okay. Sympathy is resonating with the emotion
that the other person has. If they're crying, then you feel sad watching them crying.
Empathy is understanding what experience they are going through. And then there's a higher degree of
empathy that we now call mentalization, where I can actually think I can get into your head and say,
I understand how this feels to you because I understand enough about you that I understand
the ways in which I injured you. And that's the highest degree of empathy we now call mentalization
to distinguish it. And can you ever really have complete empathy? No. It's something that you
reach, if I can use a mathematical term, asymptotically. You can approach it and get
really, really close. But of course, I can't feel your toothache. I can understand what your
toothache is like because I've had a toothache, but I can't actually feel your toothache. But I
can get really, really, really close if I try and if I'm open to it. So if I've hurt you,
one of the ways in which I would increase my empathy is to reflect on all the ways that I've
been hurt and then say, you must have been feeling something similar. I can really sense
how insulted you felt that I treated you badly or how disappointed you were that I promised to do
something and I went out and got drunk and didn't do it because I've experienced something similar.
And really trying to put myself in a position where I'm looking at the world through your
glasses, not through my glasses making an interpretation of you, but trying to get
inside of your head and seeing it through your glasses.