If miracles are real... where's the evidence? Elijah Stephens is Director and Executive Producer of Send Proof. Elijah’s full-length documentary includes opinions from ministry leaders, apologists, theologians, scholars, and skeptics. His journey to find evidence for miracles will inspire you to seek, think, and pray. Have you experienced a miracle?
Elijah Stevens discusses his documentary *Send Proof*, exploring the intersection of intellectual skepticism and supernatural experiences. He examines the definition of miracles, the philosophical barriers of naturalism, and the theological tension between cessationism and continuationism, ultimately arguing for a balance between rigorous empirical evidence and faith in the resurrected Christ.
All right, welcome to Actual Faith. I'm so glad to have Elijah Stevens with us today.
We're going to be talking about his new full-length documentary film,
Send Proof, and I'm thankful to have you on today. I want to take a moment before we get started
with today's broadcast to take a look at your trailer. I'm excited to talk about some things
today, particularly pertaining to miracles. So let's take a look at this and then I'll let you
introduce yourself and get right on into what we have going on today. Thank you for joining us,
Elijah. All right, so give me just one moment here as we take a look at this.
The power of God hit me and I was instantly healed.
This man's spinal cord had been severed and he was totally healed.
To see a little five-year-old girl who's never heard before,
when all of a sudden the ears open, that's enough for me. I don't need to see a doctor's report.
Jump up from there and start running.
The standardly understood definition of a miracle is an occurrence that has no other
good explanation. But many people mistake things that happen entirely by chance as some sort of
miracle. I mean, there are hundreds of millions of people who claim to have experienced divine
healing. Are you going to dismiss all of that? My passion has been to bridge the gap between
the intellectual and the supernatural. I heard all of these testimonies of people having
extraordinary miracles. What I wasn't seeing was objective evidence. So I decided to go find it
I speak to all pain in the shoulder in Jesus name.
Is the pain gone?
I say full healing in the name of Jesus.
Why do you think miracles don't happen when the cameras are on?
Some testimonies are false. Some testimonies are exaggerated.
Miracles don't happen. The moment you investigate them carefully from a scientific perspective,
they unravel. Be skeptical.
Have you ever seen anything like this?
No.
Wanting evidence is not a lack of faith. There's power in truth.
Currency miracles are anomalies, but thousands of miracle case studies
would change the way we think about the world.
Elijah, thank you so much for coming on again. If you're just joining us,
we're talking about miracles today on actual faith, and I'm grateful to have Elijah with us.
Elijah, for those that don't know you, would you just kind of talk a little bit about yourself,
your academic background, as well as your church background?
And then what motivated you or inspired you to put this documentary together?
Yeah, I went to Covenant College. I dual majored in psychology and philosophy,
spent a year overseas in the reserves, and then came back. I became an
executive pastor, which is kind of the administrative side of the church for about
seven years in the vineyard movement. I led their prayer teams. I went to ministry school
at Bethel in Redding, California. I felt led to make a documentary about miracles with medical
evidence and raised about $135,000 on Kickstarter. And while I was doing that, I got two master's
degrees from Biola. That's where we met. And one is in apologetics, and the other is in science
and religion. So, yeah. Yeah, and I do know Elijah from Biola University. I did some graduate work
there as well, and I know we probably rubbed shoulders at the residency, and it's a great
program, which is why we're here today. We're just trying to find some common ground talking
about miracles, also wanting to promote your film. I did watch it two times, and I felt like
you did a great job trying to find a balance. I love that you have this heart for wanting to
bridge the intellectual with what you say the supernatural or the spiritual realm,
and I believe that's important because no matter where you fall on the denominational spectrum,
I think we all can attest to the fact that God is a God of miracles, that the Holy Spirit works,
and that we trust in Him to do a work in our life that we cannot do ourselves.
And I believe that's important. And so today, we're going to talk a little bit about that.
And again, if you're just joining us, please share this stream. It might be helpful for somebody to
join along with us, or if you're going to be watching it later, be sure to subscribe to
ActualFaith. Check out SendProof.com. We're looking forward to talking a little bit more
about miracles today. Now, how do you define a miracle? When you think of miracles, Elijah,
talk to me about how you might define that. Well, when you think about miracles,
you've got to think about something in contrast to miracles, which is divine providence.
So a lot of people in the West think of miracles as the world's just kind of operating on natural
law, and God just boops and messes up the natural laws. But that's not the biblical
worldview. The biblical worldview, God is sustaining His creation. It talks about that
in Colossians. And so miracles are when the normal course of events,
had they been allowed to occur, would yield one outcome, and God alters the normal course of
events so that another outcome. And in the biblical worldview versus... So we in the West
were influenced by the Enlightenment a lot. And so in the Enlightenment, people were trending
toward deism a bit more than in the biblical times. And so they would define miracles as
things that are physically impossible. So that might be Jesus turning water into wine. So God
certainly does those types of miracles, but it also allows for miracles like the Red Sea parting
that has a natural element to it to be defined as miracles in the worldview. And so skeptics tend to
use the Enlightenment definition, but that eliminates things the Bible and its authors
would have recognized as miracles. Yeah, you mentioned deism. Can you talk a little bit about
that? So deism is the idea that God created the world, but He does not interact with the world.
And so that's very distinct from the biblical worldview, but it was very popular around the
time of the founding of the United States and shortly thereafter.
So sort of the idea that God's hands off in our life, we don't see too much interaction,
or just sort of wound us up and let us walk around and figure life out in a naturalistic way.
Yeah, yeah. And you can know God exists through reasons, the moral argument for God's existence,
ontological one, and then you can know natural law, but you really can't know God at a personal
level because He's not personally involved in the universe. And so no miracles occur in that
worldview. That's where we get the phrase naturalism from because it allows for a deistic
worldview where God doesn't interact and an atheistic worldview, both could be considered
naturalist and supernaturalism certainly opposed to both of those worldviews, and it challenges
those. Now, in your view, would you say that natural explanations when speaking as a Christian,
could they be categorized as miracles in some way if God is sovereign and He's the creator of all?
Aren't those natural explanations and some of the medical explanations that we'll talk about later,
could those be categorized as miracles in a sense?
Sure. And this is the thing with natural explanations. They can create blinders for
people, especially people who adhere to methodological naturalism. So think of most
scientists, whether Christian or non-Christian, practice science naturalistically. They're not
looking for a divine being to come in and stir the particles. But sometimes science points
toward the supernatural. You can look at and go, every naturalistic explanation we can think of
that we know about scientifically right now cannot explain this phenomenon. I think the
origin of life is one, the creation of the universe from nothing is another. And what happens
is if naturalism's so embedded in our culture that, for example, I was talking to a gentleman
and I asked him, if you saw a miracle with your own eyes, would you believe it? He said, no.
And I said, what about the arm growing back? Like if I had 10 guys with missing arms and they grew
back, would you believe in God? And he said, no, I would believe that you had an arm growing
machine. So for him, his naturalism makes it more probable that if 10 arms grew back after prayer
in Jesus' name, that he would believe I, Elijah, that lives in the middle of nowhere, has an arm
growing machine somehow rather than God could answer a prayer. And so it makes it, there's this
bias that naturalism can't see. It's got a blind spot and it's this, if miracles occur, it can't
see them because the philosophical lens through which they look does not allow for them to ever
recognize the hand of God. And so the film had to attack that issue. And it does it very subtly,
but it's trying to go, you've got blinders on to this stuff. And I think we have to take the
conversation to that level. If we want to talk about miracles in modern times.
That's good, Elijah. You mentioned philosophical blinders and I'll just be brutally honest with you
aside from hosting this channel, I'm a full-time pastor. I have a Baptist background. I didn't grow
up in a Christian home, but I was saved at a Baptist church. I tend to take a, I guess you
could say generally a dispensational view of scripture. So what I mean by that is that when
it comes to miracles, signs, and wonders, I typically look at it as something that God used
to be assigned to Israel. And as the Lord Jesus Christ came to earth, we see that he had established
apostles, disciples, and followers in the early church. It was essential for signs and wonders,
number one, to reach the Jew, but number two, to see the spread of Christianity through the
Western world. And that there was essentially this tapering off, you could say a transition
from a time of great signs and wonders to basically a place where we trust more for the comfort and
the leading of the Holy Spirit, which right now, even in our church, we're going through
some essential Christian doctrine. We're talking about the spiritual realm. And when we talk about
the spiritual realm, it's difficult because I will tell you that I pray for people and I pray
that God will heal them. I pray that God will do a work in their life. And we even say things
sometimes like, I feel like the Lord is leading me. And I'm even wary of saying those comments
anymore because sometimes we don't know. And I brought you on because I know that you are still
a teaching pastor, is that correct, at Bethel, at the school? Well, I teach off and on there.
Like more of an adjunct? This season, I'm not teaching courses because I've got to launch a
movie, but yeah, I teach there a lot, yeah. Yeah, so I know that you have a background there,
and I guess, would you call yourself more of a charismatic background or how would you identify?
I would say third wave would be the tradition I'm most identified with, which is
a high view of Scripture, a high view of the presence and power of God, and a low-hype
approach to Christianity. It came out of the vineyard would probably be
the tradition that most shaped my theology. Yeah, and I think it's important. One of the
reasons why I have this channel is because I think it's important for us just to talk about,
not only denominationally, but hopefully in the future, even talk to some skeptics or those that
are unbelievers and understand where we fall because no matter how we break it down, we have
these lenses that we look through, whether it's philosophical or sometimes even doctrinal,
denominational. And so I'm grateful because when I saw your film, it did inspire me. Whether I
believe in everything that I see or a viewer might see it, it inspired me to see God, to pray more,
and to recognize that God is a God of miracles. And even I have some Baptist friends, especially
in the mission field, that have shared stories with me that are pretty miraculous. And I don't
know, sometimes if it's locational or sometimes we don't see in the West as much as we would like to.
What is your take on that? Have you seen more interaction of miracles internationally versus
here? Well, that's a good question. I feel I personally have seen miracles here,
but it's because I live here, so I'm not international a lot. But I think there's
this high correlation in our traditions, the third wave charismatic Pentecostal tradition,
of an existential approach to knowing God. Sometimes people turn down the scripture,
and that I'm totally against. You need to follow scripture because it's authoritative,
it's God's word. Live it out because you have knowledge. It contains theological and moral
knowledge, the teaching of Jesus. It's how he takes authority over his church, I guess.
But there are times, and you can call these impressions or whatever,
where I am open. And when I grew up reformed, I would experience during the preaching of God's
word, the pastor saying, if you sinned against someone, go and apologize. And I would see a
picture in my mind of a person I'd sinned against. And I go, I did not create this picture. And so I
would obey those impressions. And I think we can all agree, whether we're continuationist or not,
that if Jesus is telling you something and you feel a nudge to go do it a particular way,
it's highly probable the Holy Spirit is at work because the devil's not going to tell you,
you know, go obey Jesus in our fleshes. And so I experienced those in other formats as well.
And sometimes when I pray for people, I see supernatural healing. I think the difference
between when I was a cessationist and when I became a continuationist is I'm willing to dial
down and listen. And I expect the third person of the Trinity to speak to me as a person.
And that's a tension, I think. But even cessationists will say, you know, the Holy
Spirit can impress you. Jonathan Edwards was a cessationist. I mean, his wife had two-week
visions. People were falling down in his church, repenting. And so healing was a part of the Great
Awakenings. And it's a part of American culture. I think the reason where we don't see it, I think
there's a high correlation between risk in an existential sense. Like there's objective
knowledge, God can heal people. And then there's, I go to the street and I see sick people and pray
for them. And I think if you trend cessationist, you're probably not doing that very frequently.
And I have friends that do that 20 times a week. And I, well, then if there's one thing I would
encourage the cessationist movement to pick up is just obey the teachings of Jesus to go pray for
the sick. And share the gospel as you do all of that on the streets. And I think you'll see
miracles in America very frequently, especially if you go to dark places, go to ghettos, go to
outside of strip clubs, and take the gospel to places where if God doesn't show up,
these people aren't converting. And I frequently see God show up on the streets more than the
church. That's interesting. I think you're right about that. Why do you think God
allows us to experience miracles? Because I think he wants to show his love to people.
I mean, he, while we were still sinners, he came in and he put on flesh, you know,
the second person of the Trinity took on a body and he showed us what the father is like. If you
seen me, you've seen the father, Jesus would say. And so Jesus was a miracle working God to show
love. And so one of the things you brought up earlier is I'm not so sure miracles were
to confirm the scriptures. Because when I look at the apostles, most of them, we don't have a
record of the miracles they did. We've got the book of Acts that primarily focuses on Paul,
John, and Peter. But I just am not sure that's what qualified for the writing of scripture. I
think it's the eyewitness, that they were eyewitnesses and the Holy Spirit guided Paul.
So that may be a debate point. I don't know. And so for me, miracles are demonstrations of love.
They're not confirmations of correct belief because you have miracles. And Jesus said,
there will be false prophets. There'll be false messiahs doing miracles. And well, if the miracle
is what confirms you should read this book, then they can write their books. If that's the
epistemological level at which we make decisions. Yeah, that's a good point. It gets me thinking
about how can Christians determine when the spirit of God is at work or say unclean spirits
or wicked spirits? Because that sometimes is a point of contention. The Bible tells us in 1 John
4, 1, believe not every spirit, but try the spirits, whether they are of God. And I recognize
that within that context, we're speaking of a spirit of antichrist, where they preach that
Christ is not present or that he has not come. But I think that there's kind of a dual application
of understanding that we should kind of test and try and make sure that the things that we see,
which this is why I appreciate your view, Elijah. I haven't met too many people that
kind of adopt that theology, but just extremely rational as you are when you're talking about
trying to bridge those two, the intellectual and the supernatural. I believe that you do it well.
There are a few. Dallas Willard has done it well. Michael Heiser has done it well. And there are
many that I believe as the church looks at Orthodox Christianity, there needs to be this
love of the mind and the heart and serving God with the wholeness and trying to detach ourselves
from sometimes those lenses that we put on, so to speak. So how do you determine it personally,
Elijah? And then for those viewing, how can we as Christians do a better job at discerning spirits?
Okay. So I steal from Jonathan Edwards because he had this problem where people are literally
shaking and falling down in his meetings. And he goes, how do I tell if this is a move of God?
And so he lists these. He wrote an essay called Distinguishing Marks of a Work of God or a Move
of God. I can't remember. It's about 20 pages, and I recommend it to everybody. It's definitely
a 10, and he works through scripture in it really well. But he said, there's a lot of stuff that's
not going to tell you if God's at work in a revival or a church or a meeting. If a pastor
sins, well, God could still be at work in that church. Or people don't exegete a text right,
or there's a lot of hype or whatever. But he said, if you want to see if God's at work
in something, he said, use 1 John 4, 1 through 7, which you were referring to. And he said,
there's five things the devil will never do and humans can't generate in themselves. And the first
is the promotion of Jesus. And by Jesus, I mean the hypostatic union, son of God came in flesh,
died, resurrected Jesus. The second one is love, legitimate kingdom love is manifesting.
The third is a hatred of sin. I want to say the fourth is a hatred of worldliness. And the fifth
is a desire to learn scripture and live it. And if you see those things at work in people's lives,
you see the spirit of God doing that because our hearts are sinful. We don't love God in
ourselves. And so it is only by his grace that any of those begin to manifest.
And so that's always been the criterion. And so what happens in revivals throughout history
is the devil's at work in some parts and the spirit of God is at work in some parts.
And we need to learn to eat the meat and spit out the bones and go, hey, when I see these things
happening, great God, I love when people are falling in love with Jesus and reading the word
and loving and renouncing sin and worldliness. But what happens in revivals also, and this
happened in the great awakening, is they become too experiential and that they might shut off
their intellect or shut off the word. And then the cults come in afterwards and say,
we'll give you all the experience you want. And so after the great awakenings, the Mormons go
through the burnt area of New York, the theosophists emerge, and they're pulling
ex-great awakeners into their spiritual experience. And so I'm trying to communicate
to parts of the charismatic movement, like watch out, the devil's been at this longer than you.
And if you go toward pure experientialism and you throw out the mind and you throw out the word,
generation two of whatever's going on in your church is going to become very toxic very fast.
And so you've got to bring the two together, is my heart. And I hope that's answered your question.
It does. Yeah. And I know I would love to probably talk to you on a separate live stream,
just about miracles and signs and wonders, signs and wonders, really. You focus so much on
miracles in general and prayer in your film. And I want to get to a little more about that,
because we can spend so much time in this area, just kind of talking
about wonders and signs and things of that nature. But in your film, you talk about
spontaneous remission. And what does it mean? And why doesn't it seem to be a reasonable
explanation of what Christians call miracles? Sure. So spontaneous remission is when something
just fixes itself, sometimes over really long periods of time. And that's most cases of
spontaneous remission. So the cancer goes away slowly without treatment. Sometimes though,
it can be fast or at least seem fast to us. The difference between the two is one's a naturalistic
cause and one is the father or the spirit or the son intervening and taking things in a different
direction. And these are noted most often after prayer events in Jesus name. That's one marker.
I think another is, we know, have some knowledge of the type of cases that have spontaneous
remission and those that don't. I'm not sure of arms being broken and then them ever spontaneously
removed. And so one of the things I found that as I had to do this documentary,
is I would hear things like, oh, the placebo effect is real. Your mind can heal yourself.
Okay. And then I would have to study, well, in what cases does that normally happen? And in
which cases does it not? In what cases does spontaneous remission happen? Which cases do
they not? And then you can go take any miracle that occurs and go, do we even have a spontaneous
remission case of this? And so there are naturalistic things that people mistake for
miracles. It's just because they exist. Michael Shermer says this, be skeptical of your skepticism.
And so what happens is people just project, well, it logically could be spontaneously,
spontaneous remission. Therefore it is, if you're a skeptic, rather than go,
has that ever even happened before? And so it takes a lot of critical thinking in this.
Yes. And it's difficult. When I watched your film for the first time,
I was laying down in bed and tears started coming to my eyes. And I'm not a very emotional person.
I like to think of myself as being pretty Stoic Baptist, rational. This is how I am.
And it started filling my eyes because there's a story that I don't talk about a lot,
whether it's personal or at church, but I was a childhood cancer survivor.
And when I was five years old, I went through 18 months of chemotherapy and I endured three
surgeries. And one of the surgeries was a result of a seizure that I had. And all I remember,
of course, is hearing stories about it, but the fluid started rushing to my brain and
they had to drain the fluid. And still to this day, I have a scar on the top of my head.
And my parents tell me of this time where they thought they were going to lose me during the
surgery and they went to the chapel that was there at the hospital. And we were not a church-going
family. I went every once in a while, but to hear my parents say that they prayed for me was just
an anomaly. And when they said they prayed for me at that moment, I recognized that they were
probably praying for me more than I realized. And they said when they came back, it was sort
of unexplainable that I had stabilized. And of course, my parents always said, the Lord's going
to use you and it's going to be just something that we can't explain. And we don't know what
to say other than God was with you. And I know to this day, they still are probably one of the
strongest supporters of ministry and health and they try to stay active. But I really believe
it was during those early days when I was young and God showed them something and showed me
something. And I just recognize that you can call that naturalistic and you can say that there was
chemo involved, that there were surgeons involved and I'm okay with that. But I also want to say
that my God's the maker of those surgeons. He guides hands and he uses people and there's
countless examples in scripture where he even will use someone that's unsaved for his glory.
And so I tend to think of even naturalistic explanations as being categorized as miracles,
you know, and it's interesting. Yeah. And that's a biblical model is God can answer prayers
in multiple ways. And, uh, you know, if he uses an entirely naturalistic process,
thank God. Um, if he uses partially naturalistic and here and there he tinkers,
thank God, like, uh, I asked you for something and it occurred in your sovereign. And so,
yeah, I don't want to throw out any type of miracles. I just want to say there's cases
where the, to the best of my knowledge, there's not good naturalistic explanation.
That's good. You're kind of shifting gears here. I saw that you had interviewed a wide
array of, of people. It looks like some that, um, you know, such as Bill Johnson,
as well as Heidi Baker. And so, like I said, I, I may have some disagreements and I'm still
kind of a skeptic in regard to some of those things. Um, but I saw that you also had interviewed
some academics as well as some skeptics. What was, um, some of the, some of your favorite
interviews that you had? Oh, they're, they're all phenomenal. I mean, I had William Lane Craig, uh,
Craig Keener. Um, I think the most interesting ones, um, I think Roland Baker was an excellent
one. Uh, he, I didn't expect him to be so theologically solid. Um, I think JP Moreland,
I probably watched that one 30 times, um, because he explains epistemologically, um,
the process of gaining knowledge with miracles. And he's really helped me a ton on discernment.
Um, I, I would say I gained so much from reading, uh, what is it? Philosophical foundations of
together. Um, and I, I think this, I hope to open charismaticism up to thinking about it.
So do you feel it's lacking then? Um, do you, are you, do you know of any other voices like you that
are coming out and really, uh, talking about epistemology, the theology of the charismatic,
uh, church and, uh, really just trying to strive for some balance there?
Um, I think of myself, I think JP Moreland's a great example. Um, I think Paul King,
he wrote a book on discernment called, is it of God? Um, he's doing some stuff. Um,
what I think has happened is we have separated these two since the great awakenings,
the intellect and the supernatural. And just before it, it was more normative to me. Um,
we may agree, disagree on some points of church history, but, um, like I, I, I think,
how do I put it? I am concerned about charismaticism that if it doesn't turn its
mind on, it can become super unhealthy, especially in a post-truth culture. And especially,
um, yeah, right now it's, it's a tender point and, you know, I think the fact that we have
a more ecumenical, uh, church where Baptists and Presbyterians and Methodists and charismatics can
talk, I think is a great starting point where charismatics can say, Hey, these are some of
my experiences. And people can say, Hey, here's some things to think about scripturally. And we
need the body of Christ to communicate. That's good. Hey, by the way, if you're just joining us,
I know some might be hopping in. We're talking about miracles today on actual faith. We have
Elijah Stevens with us. We're talking about his new film, send proof. You can go to sendproof.com
and learn more about it. I encourage you to watch it. Uh, we're right now just kind of digging into
miracles, talking a little bit about his film. Now I want to tell you something that, um, I think
just as much as charismatics might be a bit indifferent to say rational explanation or
philosophical understanding on the opposite side of the coin, myself as a pastor and ministering
I'm also a chaplain for a local fire department. So I'm around death, uh, a lot and I pray for
people. And, uh, one of the things I just don't know what to do is how to respond to people who
don't experience healing, or how do we help people who have, they have a family member in ICU.
We're going through a pandemic right now and it's, it's very real. And how do we comfort them? I
my first couple of years in the ministry, um, I was trying to comfort a family and I went to the
hospital with as much faith as I could, um, muster up whatever that means right at that time. And I,
I pray and I, and I really felt like based upon the naturalistic explanations, it sounded like
mom was going to be okay. Uh, and explaining to the teenagers that were my youth group and the
from what I understand. And, uh, you know, when I said things were going to be okay,
I felt like the Lord was with them. Uh, she ended up dying within a week and it was, uh,
it was devastating to the reality of my theology at the time. And it created some apprehension.
It's almost like I want to have faith that God can heal and will heal through a circumstance.
But how do you, you know, I know plainly speaking, somebody might want to say sort of like what
Pascal said, you know, like make a wager, hedge your bet in some way theologically. And I'm not
interested in hedging my bets. I'm interested in knowing and how I can know and what we can do.
And so how do you approach that? Um, I think in a hierarchy, um, the most comforting thing is that
Jesus is alive and we can have confidence in that knowledge. Um, and if Jesus is alive,
that no matter what pain we go through in this life, we will be resurrected from the dead.
Those who believe and be transformed into, um, you know, we, we won't send anymore,
have the effects of sin. And so he's defeated sin and death. And our hope is not in miracles. Now
my hope is in the resurrected savior. That's a powerful statement. Yeah. And, um, I think
sometimes in the charismatic movement, we lose sight of that because we're like, we've got to go
after God healing people. And I'm like, okay, I will pray. I will fast. Um, but what I will
also do is become like Jesus through the process at every moment of our lives, no matter what pain
we're going through, God is at work and he's inviting us to know him in that moment. And so
a good question to ask is what's God trying to reveal to me about myself or to me about himself
during this time. And how can I trust him? Cause the purpose of life is to be conformed into the
image of Christ to, um, you know, and by that, I mean, learn to live like Jesus through these
processes and, you know, suffering's real. And I, if, if you're suffering, I'm, I'm so sorry.
Um, but I know that if you put your trust in Jesus and by that, I mean, live like he's true,
um, you, you will not regret it in the age to come. Elijah. I love that. I wrote that
statement down. Our hope is not in miracles. It's in Christ. And I feel that that's important for
every listener, every Christian, I mean, across denomination, that is so important because,
you know, that's what Paul speaks of. That's what he encourages the churches all throughout
the letters that he wrote. He speaks of the suffering. He speaks of what he learned through
suffering and that, uh, you know, not all suffering is necessarily evil. It's character
building, it's spiritual formation. And there's so much that goes on and we can't always expect,
you know, a, um, a miracle, you know, or hail Mary, you know, just thrown last minute to save
the game. Uh, and if that's the kind of Christianity that people are after, of which I think that
some that might be taking my theological approach, um, might view it as that way because, uh, we just
don't know. But the reality is that we have people in all sorts of churches that, that aren't genuine
and we can't always know. But, uh, I get the sense, Elijah, that, uh, you really are seeking
the Lord and doing all that you can to be used of him. And I, I sure appreciate that. Um, yeah,
absolutely. You know, I think about also this sort of divide that you bring up quite a bit
between medical science and the spiritual realm. It's sort of this dichotomy. Um, I mean, can both
exist within a Christian worldview? I know we touched on a little bit earlier, but maybe talk
to me about that. Well, uh, most people don't know this about the church, but, um, after the
about the three eighties, when Christianity became a legal religion, we planted the first
hospitals in every town that had a cathedral. And it was because Jesus taught the story of the good
Samaritan in which, um, which is revolutionary at the time that you would give medical aid to those
in need, even at a cost to yourself. And so throughout church history, um, priest were
trained as physicians. Um, and so they would send priests into rural areas or missionaries,
and they would also practice medicine, naturalistic medicine, you know, there's
magic medicine back then. And the church was certainly against that. Um, and so we produced,
we produced the scientific method. Francis Bacon was a Christian. Uh, Galileo was a Christian,
remained a Christian. Copernicus dedicated his works to the Pope. Um, the Vatican had a
observatory in 1588, um, so that we could study the universe. And so we have always been pro
science. We have always been traditionally, um, you know, Newton was a Christian. He was a heretic,
but he was a Christian. Um, and so this idea that somehow medicine and faith don't go together
just isn't true. It's, it's our entire tradition at every point has had, you know,
we trained medical professionals. And so, um, it's only a myth that has emerged post-enlightenment
that, um, faith and medicine don't go together. Um, I think another thing that brought tears to
my eyes watching not only kind of on a personal aspect, but I, I saw some of the medical
professionals that are Christians that gave testimony to healing and to believing that God
uses them in some way, the same way God uses me really as a shepherd or a counselor. Um,
they recognize their ministry. And I think about today that there's this divide even amongst
Christians and the medical community or Christians in the medical community serving people with
diseases or disability. What would you say to Christians, um, in the medical community that
are serving people and also to Christians on the outside? I mean, trying to find a balance,
do you have any words for them? Yeah. Um, one of the people I interviewed in the film was,
and I couldn't put this in, it's in the bonus clips. So there's like a main video on Vimeo
and there's some bonus clips being sold as well, uh, was a doctor named Dr. David Levy. And so
what he would do before he would intake patients into his office or do a surgery,
he would just leave a form out while they're filling out their information that just says,
some people like prayer, would you mind if I pray for you? Um, and there, these people would
tell him stories, they would feel the peace of God. Um, and, and it was a radical transformation
in their lives. And I think one of the best things Christian doctors can do, you can't
force prayer on people. And it's weird to bring it up, but to just offer that as a part of
treatment and you will find deep connections with your patients and many, many will report, uh,
better, um, like, like treatment results. And that's not a promise. It's just, there's a high
correlation between the two. And so I, I encourage doctors who would like to, to just pray for
people. And I encourage people not to see it as a lack of faith to go to the doctor. Um, because,
um, since, since, uh, okay. So there was a time when Jews would not practice medicine.
Um, and it was magic medicine of the Canaanites, like put an amulet on and then we'll
leap flee or whatever. Um, they did after Hippocrates came up with naturalistic medicine.
And so the reason for this is they saw God is creator. The world is good. And therefore
it's aligning with his desire to heal people. And so if we want to become like Jesus,
we have to have a heart or the healing of people. And God would not withhold healing simply because
we're taking medicine. There's no example in scripture where Jesus said, stop taking medicine
or whatever. And while I was interviewing for this film, I actually got to go to churches
and this isn't in it of people who withheld medicine and you know, babies died. They had
leaders on, on their necks. Um, and that just is not biblical.
Yeah. Thank you for highlighting that as well. I think, you know, everyone falls on this continuum
of how God interacts in the spiritual realm. And I think that we all given the choice would want
God to act on our behalf rather than not, but we do need to somehow, uh, use common sense,
be thankful for the, uh, technology that we have and thank God for it, but recognize in the end
that he is the great physician. And that's why I like to categorize almost anything that allows us
to have breath that we need to be thankful for that, realizing that life in and of itself,
sustaining of life is a miracle. And there's so many things that we can thank God for in that way.
What, uh, I mean, how do you respond to skeptics that don't believe in miracles? I know that we
hear their voice quite a bit in your film. So you're trying to create this crossfire of opinion
as well as scripture and really let the film speak for itself. But I mean, how do you respond
to skeptics that just, they don't believe in miracles? I mean, well, I'm going to God
something that happened at Biola to me that transformed my life. Um, when I went into
apologetics, I wanted that argument that was so strong that Richard Dawkins would fall to his
knees crying and repent. Um, and so that's the goal of a lot of apologists, um, and then reach
the church and then read apologetics for myself. And when I went to Biola, I pushed pause while I
was getting my education on trying to reach skeptics and trying to even change the church.
And I was like, I want to work through these arguments as skeptically as I can
so that I have knowledge at the end. And so I shifted the apologetics for my, uh, research for
myself. Like I imagined that you remember when those Muslims were cutting off Christian's heads
with the orange jumpsuits. Um, I thought if someone ever came to me and said, I will kill
your wife. If you don't denounce Christ, how confident am I in the resurrection? And so I
studied that and studied that and studied that. And what I realized is healthiness is my pursuit
of the truth. And so if skeptics don't accept it, I'm okay with that because I'm trying, my goal
isn't to convert skeptics. If I I'm not the Holy spirit, I can't change a heart. What I can do is
present the information and look at truth and speak truth the best I know. And when I let that
go, it's like, okay, I'm trusting God with the information that goes out. And if some come back
with questions, I, because Jesus wants us to be oriented toward truth at all times. And so I can
make mistakes. I'm free because I'm, my identity is found in Christ. It's not found in whether I'm
this great argument or that it's flawless. It's found in me trying to know who I am in because
of Jesus's resurrection and to learn to live kingdom because of what he's done for me.
And so that's maybe, I don't know if that answered your question, but that's the perspective I've
tried to take with this because I share in the movie, like I was beat for hours at a time. And
so I have severe PTSD. And so this whole process has been me. And whenever you have PTSD, you're
so afraid of rejection. And so being on camera right now, talking to you, talking to these
skeptics, like there was just parts of my heart I had to like, okay, I give this to you, Jesus,
and I trust you with it. And I fully transformed me through that process.
And thank you for being transparent about your childhood. I know that you did mention,
you kind of made full circle about your childhood and how the Lord has used you.
Were there any other specific reasons why you mentioned in depth about your childhood?
I think it shaped how I think about miracles. It really early on established
there's hypocrisy. And then there is like con artistry in the church. And I live with that
awareness. And I understand how people have that lens about any type of miracle claim today.
And I have compassion on those people. And I also want to be the person that little child
needed to other people, which is I can walk you through this and tell you my journey and what I've
discovered along the way so that you can find legitimate cases. Because I feel what seeing
miracles does and seeing good case studies does is it puts in on us the evidence that we need to
pray. Yes, God can do miracles. And I think sometimes things are so dark. You need to
remind yourself of that testimony that God has done miracles in the past and he can do them again.
And I'm all about knocking on the door until the judge opens it. And so I pray with extraordinary
hope. Sometimes it doesn't happen. Lots of times it doesn't happen. But that's who I want to be,
I guess. Yeah, that's good. So you make this statement in the film, you say, I want to show
the world there's evidence for miracles. Sure. Now, why are you hoping Christians will send
medical evidence or proof of healing? Is this wanting evidence, sort of a lack of faith?
Talk about that. I think what it is is I think the burden of proof is on us if we're claiming
miracles happens today. And so I think there's good cases and we have to take them to the highest
level, get them in peer-reviewed medical journals, and then take them into peer-reviewed theological
journals to argue that these are, in fact, miracles. And so I want to be able to see,
my heart's desire is to see 100 case studies in the next 10 years published,
because I think that can challenge this naturalistic lens that we're talking about.
As you produce more and more and more of these case studies, people will have to go,
well, there's something going on, rather than these things never occur. And they become
increasingly hard to dismiss. And then it becomes harder to dismiss the ideas like the resurrection
or design in nature or a creation event. Well, Elijah, do you have any other thoughts that
you'd like to share with the actual faith community, those that might be viewing
now or later? Any other thoughts about your film or anything that you'd like to leave us with?
Take risks. I always encourage students to do this. Make it a habit to step 1% out of your
comfort zone each day. So if you're thinking about sharing Jesus with people in dark places
and you don't smile at the person at the gas station and say, hey, have a good day,
that's your first step. And so what happens is we hear these amazing missionary lifestyles
where people go to Africa and pray for sick people, but you don't realize it's baby steps
over time. And faithfulness in that stretches your ability to follow Christ at levels you
couldn't imagine five or six years ago. But if you don't make it a habit of taking baby steps,
you're not going to be praying for people in your church. But it's weird. It's weird to go up to
people and be like, can I pray for you? I always tell people the kingdom of God is sometimes
past awkwardness. It's past awkward conversations and you just have to get used to weird.
Yes, absolutely. And I want to thank you for being our guest on Actual Faith. I have no doubt
that God is working miracles in the lives of people. And I would just encourage everyone
that's watching to be a diligent student of the Bible and a disciple of the Lord Jesus Christ.
And just make sure that your doctrine matches reality. And that's what Actual Faith is all
about. It's about trusting and believing the unknown because of the known. And I'm thankful
for students, friends like Elijah, followers of the Lord Jesus Christ. I'm thankful that you
have contributed to the body of Christ in this way. And as I mentioned, there may be differences
that we have theologically in areas, but one common ground that we share is that God is at
work. He's doing miracles and we need to be aware. We need to raise our awareness of the fact
that there is a spiritual realm and that God is working in that spiritual realm, but there's also
an enemy that works. And we need to put on the whole armor of God as we've all heard, I'm sure,
if you grew up in church from a little kid. And if you didn't, it's not just a cute saying or a
story. It's a reality that we must live in. And so I hope that you have a blessed day and I'm
thankful that you're on with us today, Elijah. And I just want to encourage you again, go to
SendProof.com, Elijah's new full-length documentary film. You can purchase it and watch it on your
mobile device, on your laptop and share it and give them some feedback. And I hope that you will
be encouraged to pray more for people, that you will seek God. And I hope that this has been a
help to you and I hope that you'll share this stream as well. Thank you.