The Law Academy is a project designed to provide legal education for students studying law in the UK. Subscribe for more content.
M. Freeman, Lloyd’s Introduction to Jurisprudence (Sweet & Maxwell, 2014). R. Wacks, Understanding Jurisprudence: An Introduction to Legal Theory (Oxford University Press, 2020). J. Penner & E. Melissaris, McCoubrey & White’s Textbook on Jurisprudence (Oxford University Press, 2012).
Jurisprudence is the philosophical study of law. It encompasses the examination and analysis of legal principles, concepts, and theories, aiming to understand the nature of law, its origins, and its underlying philosophical foundations. Jurisprudence explores questions about the essence of law, its purpose, and its role in society.
Disclaimer:
At no point are these video lessons intended to provide any sort of legal advice. These are for educational purposes only!
Image(s) Copyright: This Photo by Unknown Author is licensed under CC BY-SA
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI Generated
This lesson introduces legal positivism, a dominant theory of jurisprudence that emerged in the late 19th century. It explores the fundamental distinction between law and morality, the etymology of \"positivism,\" and the theory's rejection of natural law. The session sets the stage for future discussions on key thinkers like Bentham, Austin, and Hart.
Welcome back everybody to our studies in jurisprudence. In this lesson we're going to
take an introduction to the next of our major topics, this one being an investigation and a
study and an examination, if you will, of legal positivism. What we'll do in this lesson is
essentially introduce, which is something that I introduce, sorry, arguably one of the most
important of the theories of jurisprudence, at least of the last century or so, given the fact
that, as I've mentioned in previous lessons, specifically looking at modern natural law
theories, that the introduction of legal positivism sort of usurps the growing popularity
of natural law. Natural law seems to wane in terms of its popularity going into the 20th century,
especially so as well because of some of the horrendous events which takes place in the early
20th century. Things like the Holocaust, things like the horrors of Nazi Germany and Soviet Russia
and even Communist China. And so, as a result of which, there is a less of an interesting
amount of support and defence for the view that law is inherently tied to some kind of objective
morality and a natural law theory, especially given the fact that it was law and legal systems
that can allow things like the Holocaust to take place in the first place. So that was one of the
reasons why natural law theory sort of falls off a little bit, but legal positivism arguably usurped
natural law theory a little bit earlier than that, in the late 1800s and into the early 1900s.
So that's why I've said here that it is arguably one of the most important theories of jurisprudence
in the last century or so. It is incredibly influential and any series of lessons that
looks at jurisprudence will spend a lot of time examining legal positivism. We'll take an
introduction to the subject of legal positivism in this lesson. We'll outline the structure of the
lessons that we're going to be doing on legal positivism, but we'll also talk about some of the
main and early considerations that we can sort of get out the way straight away before we start
to look at the various different varieties of legal positivism. Before we start to talk about
and we can talk about, for example, Dworkin and all these different people who have engaged in
conversations and debates about legal positivism. So let's just very quickly and very easily define
what legal positivism essentially is. Now because this is a philosophical theory of law, of course
it's not necessarily easy to just define legal positivism using a simple dictionary definition,
for example. Instead we'll talk about what legal positivism is, looking at the etymology of the
phrase and looking at the way in which it was derived from the Latin. But then we can also
talk about what some of the main considerations of positivism are and how positivism differs in
some ways to natural law. And so rather than coming up with just a single one sentence definition
of what legal positivism actually is, you can sort of situate your understanding of legal
positivism in conjunction with your understanding of natural law theories, something that we looked
at in previous lessons. So the word itself, positivism, derives from the Latin positum
and it is, broadly speaking, refers to this idea of law being laid down or specifically, as you
might understand, law being posited. And so legal positivism essentially argues that the validity
of law, law's validity and the acceptance of certain laws, is determined objectively with
reference to some verifiable source. We will talk about what this verifiable source ultimately is.
People like Austin and Bentham argue that it is deference to the sovereign, for example,
a sovereign authority, that they create the law and the law becomes valid and the law becomes
correct owing to their creation of it. It is objectively defined by some verifiable source.
It rejects the natural law view that the validity and the existence of the law, almost
the ontology of law, can be determined externally to human nature. And so when we talk about the
idea of natural law theories, we posited, at least with some of the earlier interpretations
of natural law, people like Augustine and Aquinas and even Aristotle, to an extent,
they argued that there was this idea of an objective law of nature, which is a sort of
moral code as well as a legal code, that we can defer to. And people like Augustine argued that
there was this difference between the eternal law, the law that is passed down by God through
biblical revelation and scripture, and the positive law, the law of man, the law
that is created by human beings, and that it is only valid when it is in conjunction with and
aligned to this eternal natural law. Positivism, of course, rejects this view. Positivists also
reject a number of other things, the majority of which would reject the idea that law and morality
are necessarily connected. Unlike natural law theory, which is not only a theory of law,
but it is also a theory of ethics, of normative ethics, and also a theory of morality,
legal positivism does not accept this view, that there is an inherent connection or a necessary
connection between the idea of law and the idea of morality, the idea of moral philosophy and ethics.
Now, as I've mentioned in previous lessons, again, this is not necessarily going to suggest that
a positivist does not take into account morality at all in their considerations,
that morality is not mentioned and is completely and wholeheartedly rejected
as a consideration for any kind of legal argumentation, but only that it will exist
on the periphery of a positivist's argument. In reality, positivism does not think about morality
in the same way as natural law theories do. Natural law theories really place the concept
of morality and moral philosophy front and center in their considerations of what makes a law just.
Now, one of the reasons why this is particularly popular, especially in the early 20th century,
is because, of course, it became difficult to reconcile law and morality when it was legal
systems such as the Third Reich that actually led to things that we would argue are wholeheartedly
immoral, things like the Holocaust and the Second World War, and so this idea that law can be and is
inherently legitimate if it is moral and adheres to some kind of moral law, the natural law,
was rejected on the basis that people were trying to argue, on the one hand, that there was a
legitimacy of the law in the Third Reich, at least it was in and of itself a law, an illegal system,
but it was something that perpetuated some of the grossest and most heinous immoralities that we've
ever seen in human history. So that's one of the reasons why there was a sort of rejection of this
inherent connection between law and morality in the early 20th century, and more of an acceptance of
a sort of morality-blind view of the philosophy of law, of jurisprudence. It also seeks to separate
the legal concepts from things like sociology and history, and any kind of sociological or
historical interpretations of the law, which we'll get to in future lessons time, are not to be
factored in in any meaningful way in this discussion. Again, just like with morality, however,
a positivist does not necessarily oppose the use of sociology and history as examples or even as
making some kind of subsidiary arguments, but the idea of them being central in their considerations
is something that is rejected. And we'll get to how society and historical interpretations
can actually influence legal theories in the future, when we talk about people like Durkheim
and Max Weber, and we talk about people like Karl Marx looking at historical and sociological
theories of law, but for now, when we talk about positivism, the idea of sociology and history is
not necessarily important for our considerations. While we're going to get on to the positivism,
the origins of positivism, in the next lesson, it should be noted that we're going to begin
looking, when we start to look at the key figures and the key thinkers within legal positivism,
we'll begin with the works and the likes of people like Austen, John Austen, and also John Stuart Mill.
Now, the final thing I want to do before we start to outline the next few lessons is to talk about
this connection, or should I say a lack thereof, a distinction that is made between the idea of
what ought to be the case and what is the case. So, looking at how positivism interprets normativity.
So, one of the most important things that a positivist will avoid and seek to avoid
is the idea that their considerations are not focused on what the law ought to do, from any
kind of perspective. I've written here from a moral perspective, but from any kind of perspective.
Moral perspective is obviously the easiest to understand because the idea of something ought
to be something else is often viewed through the lens of morality. So, positivism does not look at
the oughts, it doesn't look at what ought to be the case, it doesn't necessarily take a view on
what is morally desirable in the structure and content of the law either. It instead looks at
what the law is, not what the law ought to be, and makes a clear distinction between these two
things. What is and what isn't law is different to what ought and what ought not be law. These are
different things, we'll get to what these things mean in future lessons. So, finally then, let's
just look at the structure of these lessons as we go forward in the next few weeks. We're going
to be taking a look at a number of different legal aspects of positivism. We'll talk about
the origins of legal positivism, the kind of foundations and the key foundations in the
history. So, we'll talk about some historical developments, looking at the developments of
things like revolutions in the 17th and 18th centuries and the development of legal positivism
in conjunction and almost as a response to these different kinds of overthrowing of sovereign
authority of the monarchies. We will then start to look at Bentham and Austen, looking at Austenian
positivism before we look at more modern theories of legal positivism, more accepted theories as
well, looking at the works of people like HLA Hart and then we'll talk about some of the responses
that were levied against people like Hart with the works of people like Ronald Dawkins
and his interpretations of legal positivism as well.