A wealthy New York City investment banking executive, Patrick Bateman, hides his alternate psychopathic ego from his co-workers and friends as he delves deeper into his violent, hedoistic fantasies. This audio-visual film commentary has been extensively edited, dubbed and transformed by Serious Feather in an original and thoughtful manner for historical, cultural and educational purposes.
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI Generated
This discussion examines the controversial journey of Bret Easton Ellis's *American Psycho* from a reviled novel to a celebrated film. It analyzes the work's postmodern satire of 1980s consumerism, the strategic creative choices made during its cinematic adaptation, and the psychological parallels between the pathology of serial killers and the cutthroat culture of Wall Street.
Bret Easton Ellis' third novel, American Psycho, arrived in 1991, accompanied by a flurry of bad press, protests, and even death threats.
Originally slated to be published by Simon & Schuster, the American Psycho novel was hastily dumped amid brewing controversy a month before it was set to appear in bookstores.
It was subsequently bought by Random House, who published the book in its Vintage Contemporary series, where it quickly sold 250,000 copies.
It intrigued me because I had read the book a few years ago when it came out, and I had read it not having any idea of a film adaptation.
If someone had asked me, you know, wouldn't this make a great movie, I would have said, you're out of your mind.
The 27-year-old author had already encountered controversy with his debut novel, Less Than Zero, which was published in 1985 while Ellis was still an undergrad at Bennington College.
I had worked with a writer named Joe McGinnis on a book that became Fatal Vision when I was an editor at Delacorte.
And when in 1982 I moved as a young senior editor to Simon & Schuster, Joe called or wrote me that fall and said,
I have the most extraordinary student writer that I've ever encountered, and he's a freshman.
I usually only allow juniors or seniors into my classes at Bennington.
He was teaching at Bennington at the time.
And he said, I really think you should meet this guy.
I think you should take a look at some of his work.
And he sent me some pages that ultimately became Less Than Zero.
The novel's detached vision of the sordid decadence enjoyed by a group of Los Angeles teens prompted the first criticisms of Ellis.
And I first met Brett that Thanksgiving of, I think, 1982 was his freshman year at Bennington.
Not only was he frequently assumed to be like his characters, but he was chastised for a sense of irony and for his fascination with surface over depth.
In short, for embodying the characteristics of a postmodern sensibility.
I remember when I read the pages that were at that time, I'm not sure they had the name Less Than Zero, but of just being startled by what an original voice.
And I was 26 or 27 at the time.
He was 19 or 18 or 19.
Ellis and his contemporaries, Jay McInerney and Tama Janowitz, were subsequently dubbed the Brat Pack and members of the Blank Generation.
The sense of disdain and suspicion in the designations had shrouded Ellis's career ever since.
Less Than Zero, of course, was published to great acclaim and people saw it as a sort of startling, fresh and original voice.
In 1987, two years later, Ellis published The Rules of Attraction.
But the book, along with a poor film adaptation of Less Than Zero, failed to ignite much interest.
But they commissioned what was to be a third book.
And that was the book that became American Psycho.
And I remember in the years that Brett was working on that book, I knew that he was exploring some very difficult terrain in terms of what he was doing because it was really taking a toll on him.
However, with American Psycho, Brett Easton Ellis was once again back in the center of the maelstrom.
I remember there was some controversy and a publisher dropped the book and it was supposed to go in a hardcover and it didn't.
And then it came straight out in paperback.
Simon & Schuster decided not to go forward with the publication.
At the time, I had started a little imprint called Morgan Intricate Books that was an imprint of Atlantic Monthly Press.
I offered to publish the book and very much wanted to publish the book.
But by this point, it had become enough of a sort of public hue and cry that there were intimations that the National Organization of Women were going to try to take a stand against it, possibly filing obscenity suits around the country.
Feminists were among the book's most ardent critics.
The National Organization of Women threatened boycotts of bookstores that carried the novel, dubbing it a how-to manual on the torture and dismemberment of women.
There was a huge scandal already in America over it and it arrived with all these horrified protests.
And I started reading it on the subway and as soon as I read it, I was like, this reads like Evelyn Waugh.
To me, it reminded me of Vile Bodies, which is this great surreal kind of black comedy about the bright young things of the 20s.
And another feminist group established a hotline featuring readings of the book's more gruesome passages the day it was published.
You could talk to Becky Irvin and Brett Moore about this, but they decided to publish with Vintage, with Sunny Meta.
And as disappointed as I was that I couldn't publish the book, I understood the decision because I had a very small, basically two-man operation at the time.
And I probably wouldn't have been able to handle it.
And I think also the book probably needed the imprimatur of Knopf Vintage and that kind of infrastructure to support the attacks on it.
Feminist Tara Baxter was arrested for trespassing after reading passages from the novel aloud in a B. Dalton bookstore.
She proudly recounts later visiting San Francisco bookstores where she poured blood on copies of American Psycho.
One of the sad things about that book is that a lot of people passed judgment on it without reading it.
Even Gloria Steinem voiced her concern, warning that Ellis would be responsible for women killed in the manner described in the book.
I remember reading various defenses of the book. I seem to remember there was one by Norman Mailer.
I thought that the defenses, the attacks on the book were stupid, and I thought to a large extent the defenses on the book were stupid, too.
Ellis was also skewered as a bad writer, with critics lampooning his supposed lack of talent and originality in reviews that were disingenuous at best.
I don't think the book is a very good book. I don't think it's a book that...
I think it's a book that's kind of interesting maybe as a kind of artifact of a moment.
But I think, you know, as a work of literature, I really don't think people are going to be talking about it in 50 years' time.
What's very ironic now is that the book now seems to have almost become part of the canon of late 20th century literature.
I heard, this is now five, eight years ago, I heard that it was taught in a course at Yale on the subversive novel that started with maybe Tristan Shandy,
and then Madame Bovary, and then Ulysses, and I don't know what else in between, but ended with American Psycho.
And I think rightfully so. I think that if you look back, I think that book has stood the test of time.
And if you look at it, it makes a profound statement about our time and those times, that decade, the 80s.
However, as many subsequent critics have pointed out, the novel was widely misread, due in part to the fact that it embraced a thoroughly postmodern stance.
It fits into a whole kind of literature that is, you know, transgressive, I think was a word that a critic, Michael Silverblatt in L.A.,
I think once coined or some other critic used of grouping writers like Ballard and Burroughs and Saline, you know, going back some,
but then with more contemporary figures like Dennis Cooper, Will Self, Darcy Stanky, Dale Peck, you know,
some of those writers that are exploring the kind of extremes of human behavior.
Rather than boasting a new and unique literary genius, the book is a self-conscious pastiche of other vapid texts,
from fashion and porn magazines, to self-help books made famous during the me generation,
to the often overly indulgent film, music, and food reviews that pass for literary writing.
The chapter in Huey, you know, Lewis and the News, this sort of textual exegesis of, you know,
it's, I mean, I was crying tears of laughter when I was reading that chapter.
I mean, it, and the extreme violence is almost like a comic book violence, almost like a manga comic kind of violence.
This book had such a reputation as being this, you know, unreadable, extreme, sort of, you know, amoral, repellent work of fiction,
and the book is much more extreme than the film, partly because it's much easier to write about these sort of things
and let the imagination create them than to actually show them, you know.
American Psycho is a book like Naked Lunch where you can't actually film it. It's pretty impossible.
You know, at some point I was just like, what the f*** is this guy's problem?
That's what I said when I met Brett. I was like, what is your problem, dude? Why did you write this?
He's like, I thought it was really a feminist book.
Brett Ellis was genuinely hurt and surprised that his book got all this feminist, negative feminist attention
because he really thought he was writing a feminist novel, and I think that Mary and I saw that in the book.
It's very clear that the heart of the book is a pretty liberal, you know, classically liberal humanist heart.
He's not saying these things are good. He's saying these things are bad, you know,
and I think that Brett fell victim to a lot of panic about representation.
Is it representing something is as bad as doing it or is endorsing it?
And my feeling is, you know, and I got flack for doing the film at all, of course.
I was aware of the book when it came out, but I didn't read it until the year of the L.A. riots.
I was living in L.A., watching television with people, you know, rioting and stealing television sets,
and, you know, the book hit a nerve in that environment.
And that started a long winding road to finally getting the film made.
I was in Cannes at Hotel du Cap, and there was a discussion with a Christian Halsey Solomon,
and he told me that Ed Pressman and Johnny Depp and a director named Stuart Gordon were interested in this book,
American Psycho.
I just opened it up and I started reading, and, you know, there's this hissing sound coming out of the brain,
and it was like, wow, this is good. I'm in.
And Johnny Depp actually was out in the bar area by the pool, and I met him a few minutes later.
I think the first director we talked to was Stuart Gordon.
The first director that we ever actually formally attached was David Cronenberg,
and we'd send it out to De Palma, and, you know, a lot of people, Renny Harlan, they declined,
although there'd been some, you know, honest interest, and Stuart Gordon was interested,
and Johnny Depp loved Re-Animator.
But he had an idea of doing the film in black and white, X-rated, and really sticking close to the book.
I called my wife, Roberta, who was back here, and said, boy, I just saw this great movie.
I shot Andy Warhol. Mary Herron did it.
And, you know, I got that Warhol thing really well. I liked it.
It's going to give us, like, some competition, you know, for the awards at Sundance.
And then my wife said, wow, why doesn't she do American Psycho?
I'm like, oh, come on. I mean, there's no connection.
I went to Mary because she had done her movie, I Shot Andy Warhol,
which is arguably a sympathetic portrait of someone who's psychotic and, you know, shoots Andy Warhol.
And then I thought, wow, she did, you know, I heard, and, you know, we discussed it,
she'd done some, like, BBC or Channel 4 music documentaries, and I liked it.
And then I discussed with Roberta, well, you know, there might be an angle on it,
because what if American Psycho was almost like a document, a documentary of a period?
My first thought when I was, when they called me about American Psycho was,
oh, you know, just enough time has passed from the 80s that you could actually make a film about them now.
You could make a period film.
By 1992, 93, when we obtained the book rights, we already referred back to that period,
which was, like, 87 through 89, maybe up to 1990, as a period piece.
It was a strategic move just to get a woman at the helm of the movie,
simply because then that's where all the feminist backlash is going to be absorbed or directed, at any rate.
I met Mary Harron, who had a very clear idea of how to approach Brett's work as a film,
which was very much in line with what Brett and I had been talking about.
I'd gotten to know Brett, and I think the term we used for a filmmaker was cosmic irony.
That was a term I think Brett had.
And the epitome of that was Stanley Kubrick and Dr. Strangelove as a reference.
I was working with Mary Harron on a movie about Betty Page, and we were A, stuck, and B, broke.
And this was 96, whatever.
And so Mary said, you know, I'm really actually interested in doing this project.
And I'm like, American, huh?
As just like I was Betty who?
And she said, read this book.
And she's like, but she's handing it to me, like, but, you know, keep an open mind, OK?
In adapting Ellis' novel into a screenplay, Mary Harron and Gwyn Turner faced a huge challenge.
Not only did they need to cut the novel's 400 pages down to a form manageable in a 90-minute feature film,
but they needed to find a way to convey the book's voice of flat irony,
as well as the increasingly crazed raving inside Bateman's head.
The whole point of it is that it slides between genres very disconcertingly.
And one of the most, you know, compelling things about it and disconcerting things about it
is that it stays totally in the mode of brilliant social satire, you know, social comedy,
and then with no bridge will just plunge you straight into a scene of complete horror,
right into the middle sometimes of a scene.
The transitions in the book are very abrupt.
And I wanted to, that was something that I was very taken with, and I wanted to mirror that in the film.
Yeah, it gets into this really kind of intuitive kinds of conversations
where we have to agree what the essence of the book is, what we like about it, and then move from there.
But it's hard. And I have to say, it really bums me out because you'll meet people,
particularly people who don't work in movies, who'll be like, oh, it was a book first.
Like you just copied it into script form.
When Gwen and I started working on the script, I wasn't thinking about casting.
I didn't have anybody in mind for Bateman.
And the only sort of role model that there is for Bateman that's in the book is he keeps talking about Tom Cruise.
Tom Cruise is this running theme.
And, you know, Bateman lives in the same building, apartment building as Tom Cruise,
and it's a hilarious scene where he gets into the elevator with Tom Cruise.
And he's so impressed, he doesn't know what to say. He says, I loved you in cocktail,
which is like the stupidest thing anyone, you know.
Well, the first Pat Bateman, as we've pointed out, was Johnny Depp.
But he was way, that was like six years later, six and a half years later.
And the first Pat Bateman for Mary was Billy Crudup.
There was a long casting process because a lot of young guys wanted to play that role or were intrigued by it.
So, you know, Gwen and I ended up having lunch with lots of very handsome young actors.
And there were people who were very good actors, but it was hard.
Nothing was really right.
One of the problems I had with a lot of the actors I was meeting was that they always wanted to discuss the role psychologically.
They wanted to know who Bateman was.
They wanted to find out what his motivation was.
And they were approaching it, as young American actors tend to do,
very much in methody, you know, terms of psychological realism and finding the motion and finding the character.
And when I met Christian, it was, oh, such a relief.
Suddenly we were talking the same language, is that he saw it as I did,
which was that the character was a construct, that there was a lot of comedy in the role, a lot of satire.
And also the character was not a cool guy, that you could find the patheticness.
And Christian just went for that like a magnet, the patheticness and the absurdity.
He saw something hilarious in it.
At the same time, he wanted to really go all the way with it and see it from that character's point of view.
Sometime after we had set the film up at Lionsgate,
the idea of making an offer to Leonardo, this was right after Titanic had come out, was suggested.
And I think we all went along with it because we thought it was unlikely to happen.
And I think the offer was $10 or $12 million, which at the time was unprecedented.
I'm sure everyone has their own version of this story, but I got a phone call one day saying,
are you sitting down? And one of the producers said,
they want to make Leonardo DiCaprio $20 million to make this movie.
But they still want to make the movie for $6 million, so it's going to be like a $26 million movie.
I said, that is the stupidest idea I've ever heard. It's completely insane.
And I admired Leonardo DiCaprio very much as an actor, but I felt he was not right for the role.
He was too young, too poetic. I had already cast Christian.
I had already said I wanted to cast Christian. I felt completely committed to him.
I felt he was the person who could make this work.
Because the Titanic was blasting away, they decide what the hell,
we'll send the script over to Leonardo, just see what happens.
But nothing's going to happen. We'll just move forward.
That was on a Friday, and I got all these phone calls.
First from Mary Heron's agent at William Morris, and then from Mary Heron herself.
Like, what's going on? I'm the director.
You can't just go up for the film to any actors without my approval.
That wasn't my vision or anything like that.
And I said, listen, I didn't have anything to do with it, Mary.
But between you and me, there's no chance at all that DiCaprio's going to jump into this movie.
I mean, think about it. And they were like, all right, all right.
But to everyone's surprise, Leonardo responded positively.
And I know his father and others around him at first supported the idea.
So on Monday morning, Rick Yorne, his manager, calls up and said,
he's in. He wants to do this movie.
If you pay an actor $20 million to be in a $6 million movie,
I mean, it's all about the actor and his stardom.
And I felt very strongly that they would have to rewrite the script.
They would have to rewrite the movie, that the movie was just too dark and too crazy.
You couldn't take the hero of Titanic, the idol of millions of 12-year-old girls,
and have them play Patrick Bateman in the script and the movie that I intended.
It just wasn't possible.
They would have to try and rewrite it and make the character more likable,
which I think is what they tried to do.
So I didn't want to do it that way, and they didn't want me to anyway.
I think once it became a project on that scale,
I mean, it was whether I quit or was fired,
but anyway, I left the project in a sort of mutual disagreement over casting.
And he actually agreed to do the film and to announce it in Cannes that May.
That night at the Leaving Las Vegas premiere, which I attended,
everybody was, you know, the news hit like that.
I mean, it was, you know, the biggest star in the world
had just attached himself to the most onerous, decadent, cruelest, horrific literary property
that the world had ever seen, you know.
And there were bids from Japan for $16 million.
There were bids from Berlusconi for $60 million for International.
And it spun out of control.
That was a whole trip unto itself, just in terms of the frenzy.
To this day, people are like, can you get a script to Leo?
And I knew that Christian had it right, you know.
And Christian didn't want to make the character more likable.
He knew what he wanted. It was what I wanted to do.
You want Bateman to be absurd, ludicrous, pathetic monster.
And no redeeming features, and no psychological backstory.
All those things, I was afraid if you bring in a huge movie star,
they're going to give it psychological motivation, and it just wasn't what I wanted.
So, I have to say, most difficult thing that ever happened to me in my working life.
Placed Mary Heron in a bad spot, because DiCaprio hadn't been given her name on the list.
And he had, you know, strict approvals.
But anyway, Lionsgate, everybody was smart.
And they went pair play with Mary, basically anyway, just in case.
And they'd pay her off the movie if she didn't make it to the finish line.
And it was very rough.
And I think a lot of people thought I was insane.
But, you know.
You know, I think I suggested that, like in all fairness, let's not play with fire here.
He could end up back with Mary.
And we don't want her to walk now.
I mean, you know, if you've got all this money circling around the project,
at least guarantee to pay her no matter what, so that she has to do the movie
if you decide that she should be the director.
I felt like it wouldn't be my movie anyway.
And it would just ruin it.
The pressure on it would have destroyed it.
Went through a whole sequence of director approvals.
Ultimately became Oliver Stone.
We had readings.
And DiCaprio, you know, kept saying, but this isn't like the book.
The ending's different.
You know, this I didn't get direct.
But there was a reading where he made that comment.
And, you know, Cameron Diaz read with DiCaprio.
I mean, it was offered Oliver's office.
And, you know, it was a big deal.
Oliver wanted to do the movie.
But DiCaprio went off, did the Danny Boyle movie.
A friend of mine said, you know, I went to a WNBA game with Gloria Steinem.
And Gloria Steinem said that she took Leo in her office and said,
you cannot play Patrick Bateman, you cannot, you know,
and you cannot do this movie because, you know, you just did Titanic
and your fan base is 13-year-old girls and they're really, they're all going to be,
you know, it's just not going to be a good place to take them.
And so, according to legend, that's why Leonardo DiCaprio didn't do the movie.
But the funny thing to me was that when she told me that,
I was like, wow, if you had told me when I was like 22
that Gloria Steinem was going to be personally crusading,
that something that I wrote didn't get made, I would have burst into tears.
We had to go out and make a movie.
So we paid Mary, we got Christian Bale, we cast it, and we went and made it.
And I think in the end, everyone came to agree with me on this,
we all came back together on this,
was that it was such a difficult project to make work.
It had terrible baggage of already people up in arms over it.
It was considered this dreadful misogynist, there was no more hated book of the 80s.
But I felt that if we kept a very rigorous control of tone
and really knew what we were doing, I felt I could make it work,
but that it would not be a big blockbuster mainstream movie.
It had to be like an art movie, it had to just be really careful with it.
The only thing is, I don't think the world really realizes
how difficult it was to take a book that had been self-banned
by 70% of the bookstores in the United States
for no constitutional reason, just their opinion about the book.
I do think you can see the film as an extreme comedy of manners,
because so much of it is about social status and how people interact
and social one-upmanship and social anxiety,
and a great deal of it is about these transactions that go on
between businessmen or between men and women
in a rather elevated social world that's removed from day-to-day reality.
American Psycho is one of those rare films that is very slippery.
It's hard to put your finger exactly on what it's trying to do.
The humor can be very over-the-top, the horror can be very extreme.
You're not sure if this is being satirical, if it's being sympathetic.
You're not sure when you're in reality, when you're in hallucination.
It's constantly slipping away from you,
and it's a quality that's, I think, very rare in film in general.
In a way, it's the introduction of that element, the kind of horror element
or the element of the sort of serial killer violence
into a kind of a genteel, polite world
where whatever the sort of underlying sentiments people have towards each other,
which I think, again, are very true to Reaganism in that it's very cutthroat underneath.
But that's something that's a real tradition in social satire, going back to Molière.
I mean, there's always the kind of surface politeness
and the surface kind of manners and grace,
and underneath the really kind of primal kind of human urges,
which are usually sexual.
But here, money, sex, they're kind of interchangeable, I guess,
in a certain kind of way of looking at the 80s.
Money was kind of the erotic object.
It was the sort of source of eroticism in the 80s.
I think you could make a case maybe that the times have caught up with the movie.
I think the movie was maybe a little bit ahead of the times
in terms of its sensibility and in terms of a certain kind of satiric edge
and a certain kind of willingness to kind of go, sort of go there, go a little further.
The book and the film were often defined as, you know,
a book and film about the 1980s.
But, you know, the 1980s did not invent greed,
did not invent commodity fetishism,
did not invent a society that is so obsessed with perfect surface.
I mean, to me, a lot of what the book is about
is taking certain impulses in American life,
the obsession with perfect things, perfect surface,
and the anxiety and rage and pain, you know,
that people experience because things aren't like that.
And in a way, the whole character of Bateman is one who rips it.
The surfaces are not enough.
He wants to create perfect surfaces and he rips them open
in an effort to find something, I don't know, meaning or whatever, some feeling.
It's so interesting to me.
I've met guys, only men really, who say like,
Oh, you were in American Psycho? I think that movie's so cool.
Man, I am Patrick Bateman.
I'm like, wow, and you're a big dork.
Because if you're going to say I am Patrick Bateman,
then A, you didn't get the movie, because I don't think that was a very...
I mean, above and beyond the fact that he's a serial killer,
he's not very cool, you know?
So I'm always looking at them like, really?
So are you saying you're a dork or a serial killer?
I think one reason why we're fascinated by serial killers
and why the whole cult of the serial killer came out of the 80s
was that we're looking for a story.
We're looking for a narrative with an actor.
And with a serial killer, every murder tells a story.
And he's constructing a beginning, middle, and end.
And he's trying to present himself as this master of the universe,
just like the masters of the universe down on Wall Street.
Well, part of the propensity of a serial killer is the urge to be caught,
and that represents his third act.
Whether they're aware of it or not,
if you string together murders like beads on a necklace,
what you're doing is you're sort of hurtling towards this climax
of justice, of retribution, of punishment.
And I think that's their end goal,
unconscious, conscious.
This has been widely recognized in FBI profiling,
that serial killers have this unconscious urge
to come to terms with their own acts.
And I think that's present in Wall Street, too.
There's an underlying sense of guilt and of the apocalypse
and the sense on Wall Street that I just want to get mine
is the same sort of focus of the serial killer.