The Harry Potter HBO Max series was announced to very mixed reviews. I am not keen on the idea of already going back to the well when the films are so beloved still. The actress who plays Ginny Weasley won't be going back to the well either. As she has left the new Harry Potter series after just one season.
Narrated by: Adam Olinger Edited by: Adam Olinger #movie#review
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI Generated
The speaker criticizes the upcoming HBO Max Harry Potter TV series, viewing it as a cash grab that unnecessarily remakes a beloved film franchise. While acknowledging the potential for entertainment, the speaker argues that the original movies are nearly perfect and that a reboot is redundant, especially given early concerns regarding casting and production aesthetics.
You're a reboot Harry!
There's a brand new HBO Max TV series on Harry Potter reliving the magic of the movies that
aren't even that old and really no one wants to see again on the small screen,
but it's happening regardless.
Because Warner Brothers and HBO desperately needs that cash money and J.K. Rowling needs
a 85th mansion or whatever the hell she's doing over there.
We've already seen a large chunk of the cast so far.
The main trio Harry, Ron, and Hermione all have kind of a surreal look to the original cast.
Something's just not quite right.
We have the legendary actor John Lithgow who's just fantastic and everything.
He's playing Dumbledore.
That's easily the best casting of this thing.
I almost said John Leguizamo's playing Dumbledore and that would have been...
That would have been quite the different performance I think.
But yeah, everything seems pretty straightforward from what we know before.
You have your Dumbledores.
You have your Harry, Ron, Hermione.
You have Black Snape, of course.
Everybody knows Black Snape.
Nothing's really off here.
But it turns out there's already a little drama behind the scenes as the actress who plays
Ginny Weasley not returning for season two.
The reason given, and I quote, due to unforeseen circumstances.
What could that possibly mean?
I don't know, but let's wildly speculate.
I'm guessing she's racist and saw that Snape was black and said,
Or maybe the actress was an absolute diva on set,
throwing food at the different cast members from the crafts table,
refusing to say certain lines of dialogue.
Or maybe she and her folks saw the dailies and said,
Yeah, we're gonna go ahead and pass on season two.
All of that is probably wildly off.
All that is certain is this little actress, Gracie Cochran, is a one season and done.
Now let's get to the important part of this.
My unsolicited thoughts on this whole fiasco.
I hate when actors are replaced.
I did not like it when Dumbledore was changed.
Granted, the original actor died.
So I suppose that's fair.
And I certainly don't think it's a good look when the girl playing Ginny Weasley
is already out for season two.
That doesn't necessarily spell trouble for the production.
I mean, we don't even know what the hell's happening behind the scenes.
But it's not a positive.
I know that.
But it never really was going to be a positive for me,
because Coch's on the table, as the expression goes, of course.
I'm not a fan of this whole Harry Potter TV show idea.
And I've gotten pushback on that from some folks that said,
Hey, this is for a new generation.
Your old ass time is done.
The movies don't hold up anymore.
To which I reply with a scoff.
Are you serious?
Sure.
Some of the CG, a little wonky.
A tad dated.
But it has charm to it all the same.
And I really do think they could not have cast any more perfectly outside of the dead Dumbledore
than they did in that original set of films.
The locations, the John Williams theme song, the set design, the clothing.
Like everything was about as perfect as you could get.
They really brought the books to life.
Knight elevated the books.
And so to me, the TV series has to top that.
And I just do not see how that's even remotely possible without going back to the well.
Reusing that theme song again, pretending it's your own.
Reusing a lot of the same assets, the look of Hogwarts castle, the look of the clothing.
And yeah, I suppose you kind of have to, right?
Because the book's descriptions are that.
And that's what you're going off of.
You got JK in the wings, giving people pointers about how things should look,
how people should talk and so on.
But those Harry Potter movies didn't come out in the 1950s.
Hell, Deathly Hallows part two finished up in 2011.
That was only 15 years ago.
To me, there are certain movies that aren't untouchable by any means,
but they should be preserved for as long as humanly possible.
There's a reason we haven't had a remake of Casablanca.
There's a reason we haven't had a remake of Jaws.
Back to the Future remains intact, thankfully.
Lord of the Rings.
They've kept that trilogy pure.
Yeah, they've tried some garbage things like rings of power and whatever that Gollum ---- is,
but the trilogy remains intact.
And not only that, the Emma Watson's, the Daniel Radcliffe's, the Rupert, I guess,
who's probably working at Universal Studios on some of the rides right now.
I don't know what that guy's doing, but they are the face of these characters.
You go to Universal Studios theme park, they're on the rides.
You actually see them show up.
The actor who played Hagrid, poor one out, he...
Actually, a lot of the Harry Potter cast is dead now, which is honestly depressing,
but you see them on the merch, on the toys, in the theme parks.
So what does that mean for this new TV series?
I don't think there's a chance in hell they're going to remove those actors and replace them.
It's the same thing with the live-action Disney movies.
You still go to those theme parks.
It's all the animated stuff we grew up with.
The live-action movies have almost no presence at all
when you go to a Walt Disney World or an Animal Kingdom.
It's always the animated Lion King, the animated Aladdin.
So I ask you this, if this is a modern retelling of Harry Potter for a new generation,
why is it then they're always familiar with the originals?
And if history has shown us anything, they only exist on the TV.
You never see it translated anywhere outside of that.
It's always going back to the originals.
And I have the answer for you.
You may not agree, but it's because it makes money.
The balance between making money and art seems to be highly skewed towards the money side of things.
Whereas with that original run of films,
you could see the passion and dedication in every scene by every performance.
And to the naysayers that say, don't watch, that's fair.
But I'm going to, of course.
It's more or less, they could have done anything else with the Wizarding World.
Yes, they failed with the Fantastic Beasts
because I think that was just kind of a stupid route to take the whole thing to begin with.
But there are so many interesting aspects you could go.
Why not focus on the auras?
Why not do a series on the wizards who hunt down the bad guys?
You could do something more adult and more dark for fans that have grown up with this franchise.
And all of this bitching aside, that doesn't mean this won't be a good show.
It is very possible it will be entertaining.
It will actually hit it out of the park.
But what I've seen so far from the trailers is not hitting me at all.
The look of it is very dingy.
It doesn't have life to it.
It does not scream magic.
It has that David Yates stank from the later movies,
which it made sense to do in the later movies because everything is very somber,
very depressing.
We have Lord Voldemort rising up.
He's taking over the school.
So you want that magic peeled back.
You want it to have this kind of really depressed look to everything.
But for the first couple seasons of this show, I expect some energy.
I expect some awe and some fantasy and some goddamn whimsy.
And with the announcement that Ginny Weasley's actress is leaving already,
it's just another small knock against the show before it even comes out.
I have no doubt it's going to do massive numbers for HBO Max,
so they're already getting what they're putting in.
That doesn't mean I have to like it, but we'll see.
I'll give it a shot.
Maybe it will blow me away and do everything I think it's not going to do.
Let me know your thoughts, though, on this Harry Potter fiasco.
Are you in?
Are you excited for a new interpretation?
You're going to get to see Peeves, hopefully, right?
Everybody's been waiting for Peeves the ghost to show up or something that's missing.
Let me know.
Please think of subbing to the show.
Adam Does Movies.
I'm on YouTube, Spotify, Apple Podcasts, wherever you watch or listen.
You'll find me and hopefully I find you in the next video
where I'm going to be talking about the boys finale that's coming up.
Thanks for watching the video.
Since you're still here, I got to give a special shout out to my Patreon supporters
at Patreon.com slash Adam Does Movies.
There are three tiers you can support the channel at.
These are the silver and gold members right here.
Just a beautiful group of people.
If you didn't know, Adam Does Movies is a passion project for me.
It's a second job for me.
So making this happen is incredibly grueling.
Over 300 exclusive videos just for signing up at the bronze membership.
Every month, I add more exclusive videos for silver and gold members.
So there's always new stuff happening over there.
So anything you can do, I would appreciate.