56 Did we just find a Primordial Black Hole YouTube

A Door to Mysteries
791 followers
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThis video explores the mystery of dark matter and a recent scientific paper regarding \"Phoebe,\" a potential primordial black hole candidate. It discusses how microlensing was used to detect this low-mass object and analyzes three possible scenarios for its identity, concluding that it is a strong, though unconfirmed, candidate for a primordial black hole.
Dark matter is still one of the biggest unsolved mysteries of the universe today.
We know for a fact that galaxies aren't spinning the way they should be, as if there's a ton of
invisible extra mass surrounding them that we can't see or detect. This unseen mass, whatever
it may be, has been called dark matter. To be clear, we know with very high confidence that
dark matter exists. The alternative explanations that don't require its existence, like modified
Newtonian dynamics, have been shown to be inconsistent with how the universe looks,
leaving this invisible extra mass as the most likely explanation.
We know for a fact that there's something weird going on with all the galaxies,
but we don't know what's causing it. The mystery of dark matter isn't whether or not it exists,
because we know that something exists that's causing this, but the actual question is what
that something is. Dark matter is not the name of a specific type of material, it's a placeholder
term used for an unknown. We know this unknown stuff exists, we just don't know what it is.
That being said, there have been many proposed explanations for what this mysterious dark
matter actually is, one of them being primordial black holes. This theory proposes that in the
very beginning of the universe, as in the first second after the big bang, matter was so heavily
compressed that areas with an even slightly higher density than the surrounding space would collapse
into black holes without the need for supernovae. This should have resulted in huge amounts of small
black holes across the universe, most much smaller than stars and many even planetary in mass.
Depending on just how many of these primordial black holes formed and how big they are,
this could be a potential explanation for dark matter. If this is true, then the extra mass is
due to trillions of undetectable, untraceable black holes, most very small, that can only be
seen through the gravitational effects on surrounding matter. Exactly what we see with
dark matter today. Now this is still a subject of extreme debate, and the evidence for primordial
black holes is inconclusive at best, and there are many other competing theories that are equally
plausible. I'm not going to get into all the dark matter theories and their strengths and weaknesses,
because this video is but one specific recent paper, and not meant to be an overview of the
history of dark matter. However, the primordial black hole hypothesis is directly testable.
All we have to do is find them. Unlike other theories for dark matter, which involve unseen
particles beyond our current capabilities to detect, black holes are, at least by comparison,
fairly mundane objects. We've taken pictures of them before, and we know how to find them.
Except, primordial black holes would be planetary in mass. This means that they
will look very similar to rogue planets at first glance. Many rogue planets that don't emit any
light are detected through microlensing, where a rogue planet passes in front of a background star
and causes its light to slightly bend. Black holes could be detected through microlensing as well,
but it could be very difficult to differentiate between primordial black hole and just normal
rogue planets, especially because many primordial black holes will have the same masses as planets.
To figure out whether or not an object is a rogue planet or a primordial black hole,
some additional data will have to be gathered. Which is where a new paper comes in which claims
to have detected a new primordial black hole candidate somewhere. I say somewhere because
there's a large amount of uncertainty about where this thing is, which will be very important for
this video, but based on the microlensing observations, it's estimated to be somewhere
in the ballpark of the mass of the moon, which could either make it a pretty small rogue planet
or a very exciting candidate for a primordial black hole. So let's look at this paper and see
whether or not this new object, which the authors call Phoebe, is a rogue planet in the Milky Way,
the first exoplanet found in the Large Magellanic Cloud, or a strong candidate for a primordial
black hole, because it has to be one of the three. This paper analyzes data gathered over
a period of five nights in the direction of the Large Magellanic Cloud, the largest satellite
galaxy orbiting the Milky Way, and the fourth largest galaxy in the local group after Andromeda,
the Milky Way and Triangulum. And even before the data could be interpreted, they found something
pretty interesting. One of the fastest microlensing events ever detected, lasting about 60 minutes.
This event involved some object, which the authors call Phoebe, passing in front of a star,
which the authors call the Phoebe Star. Data from three surrounding stars confirmed it was a
microlensing event and not something else, because it only affected the one star. Additional data
about the star and its surroundings have also confirmed with high confidence that this was a
microlensing event, and one of the quickest ones ever. This also suggests that Phoebe is extremely
low mass, probably only a few times larger than the Moon, if that. However, there are some important
issues that make it difficult to confirm Phoebe's characteristics. First off, it's not known how
big the Phoebe Star is, which will affect the likelihood of this actually being a microlensing
event. The authors estimate that the Phoebe Star is roughly two times wider than the Sun,
and the reasoning for that is in the paper in the description, but there's also a possibility
that the microlensing event was actually just a stellar flare. While this is unlikely, the only
way to confirm it is to just keep watching the star to see if it does it again. And most importantly,
we don't know where Phoebe actually is. All we know is that its gravity caused the light of the
Phoebe Star to bend. One possibility that's been pretty much ruled out is that Phoebe is a planet
orbiting a star. If Phoebe orbited a star, there would have been two lensing signals as the planet
and the star passed by. However, only one was detected, strongly suggesting that Phoebe is
either a rogue object or a planet on an extremely wide orbit around a star. So we can be pretty
confident that Phoebe is a rogue object. The most likely option then is that it's a regular rogue
planet. So why am I saying it may have a good chance of being a primordial black hole? What
separates it from all the other rogue planets found with microlensing? This is because of the
second problem with not knowing Phoebe's location. We don't know what galaxy it's in. The telescope
that saw this event was pointed at the Large Magellanic Cloud, a satellite galaxy orbiting
the Milky Way. So it saw a section of the Milky Way, the LMC, and the space between the two.
This paper lists three possible scenarios. Scenario one is that Phoebe is located inside
the stellar population of the Milky Way. If this is true, it's almost certainly a rogue planet,
though one of the smallest ever found. If it is a Milky Way rogue planet, its mass is estimated to
be just 0.022 Earth masses, less than half the mass of Mercury, and roughly twice that of the
or for a third comparison, almost the same size as Jupiter's moon Ganymede. In this scenario,
Phoebe is located somewhere between 680 and 4,000 light years away from Earth.
In the second scenario, Phoebe is located inside the stellar population of the Large Magellanic
Cloud, which is about 163,000 light years away. This would again make it likely to be a rogue
planet, though five times more massive than the Milky Way scenario, making it about a tenth the
Earth, pretty similar mass to Mars. It would also be about 2,283 light years away from the star it
microlensed. In this scenario, this would be the first exoplanet discovered in another galaxy by
microlensing, and the first exoplanet candidate found in the Large Magellanic Cloud. However,
the third scenario might be the most interesting. Phoebe might also be in between the LMC and the
Milky Way, putting it inside the Milky Way's dark matter halo, the area surrounding galaxy where
most of the dark matter is located. In this scenario, it's somewhere around 59,000 light
years away, and according to this paper, virtually certain to be non-baryonic in composition.
As in, not made of normal matter, making it probably a black hole. This is because normal
matter makes up just 0.001% of the mass of the dark matter halo, making it extremely unlikely
that Phoebe is an object made of normal matter. It's extremely unlikely that we just got lucky
to find a normal object in the area where all of the dark matter is. In this scenario, Phoebe is
about 0.026 Earth masses, slightly more massive than Ganymede, making it impossible in a normal
stellar remnant black hole, which are usually around 5 solar masses. So, the three scenarios
are either that Phoebe is one of the smallest rogue planets ever found, the first exoplanet
and first rogue planet to be found by microlensing in another galaxy, or a primordial black hole in
Milky Way's dark matter halo. No matter which scenario turns out to be true, all three are
pretty interesting. However, there are some good reasons to believe the third scenario is the most
likely. For this, the paper estimates the optical depth of the microlensing event, basically the
odds that a star will be microlensed given the average density of objects in the area.
Based on the optical depth of this microlensing event, the dark matter halo scenario is estimated
to be 5 orders of magnitude more likely than the other two scenarios, due to the telescope's
specific line of sight with the dark matter halo. Basically, between the three scenarios,
Milky Way rogue planet, LMC rogue planet, or dark matter halo object, the third scenario is estimated
to be about 100,000 times more likely than the other two. However, this number may change
depending on some unknowns, like the exact stellar population density of the Large Magellanic Cloud.
We also don't know for certain how common microlensing rogue planets are,
which may change this number a lot. However, based on what we know right now, the scenario
where Phoebe is a primordial black hole existing in the Milky Way's dark matter halo is by far the
most likely scenario. But this doesn't mean it's confirmed, as all we know is that it could
potentially be likely to be a primordial black hole, and that's all based on modeling and math,
not actual observations of the object. We will need a lot more data to confirm this,
which we're unlikely to get, because now that the microlensing event is over,
we'll probably never see Phoebe again. So, this is a promising candidate for a
primordial black hole, which is both one of the potential explanations for dark matter,
and explains a lot about the early universe right after the Big Bang. And this isn't even the first
one. 13 other primordial black hole candidates like Phoebe have also been found by other telescopes,
but so far, none of them have been confirmed. But this does seem to show we may be on the right
track for the primordial black hole hypothesis for dark matter. While Phoebe is far from confirmed
to be a primordial black hole, and could very well just be a normal rogue planet,
it's definitely our strongest candidate for a primordial black hole yet.
Hopefully we can learn more soon, because confirming the characteristics of Phoebe
and other objects like it could finally put to rest the mystery of dark matter.
While there are some problems with the primordial black hole theory,
confirmed examples of them would be very good at putting them to rest.
But whatever Phoebe is, it's certainly an extremely interesting object.
Thank you for watching. If you enjoyed, check out my other videos about exoplanets and space exploration.
