Trucking companies that have served the ports of Los Angeles and Long Beach for decades are closing. Family-owned operations that built their businesses one truck at a time are being squeezed by compressed freight rates and high diesel costs, and some in the industry say compliance has become a cost that not everyone is paying.
What is happening to the companies that tried to follow the rules is a different story than the one playing out in public.
Robert Loya, Chief Executive Officer of the Harbor Trucking Association and a 30-year industry veteran, joins the show to walk through how California's regulatory environment is playing out for the trucking companies that serve the ports, and what he believes is coming next.
00:00 - Intro 02:28 - Regulatory Hurdles and Clean Trucks Initiative 05:42 - Impact of ACF Rule and Business Decisions 15:46 - Transitional Technologies and Market Dynamics 27:40 - Impact of AB 5 and Compliance Challenges 38:43 - Enforcement and Equity in Regulations
California trucking is still in trouble. Have we hit rock bottom and will things turn around
for truckers in California? Today we sit down with Robert Loya, who's an industry veteran,
to find out why there are more trucks right now available than needed.
Is it really helping the environment if you're putting more trucks in circulation? Do we want
to convert? Yes, but you can't put the car before the horse. If there's no infrastructure and the
trucks can't make that run, that distance, to service all the freight that comes through the
then we're going to fail and the customers are not going to get their cargo.
I'm Siamak. Welcome to California Insider. Robert, it's great to have you on. Welcome.
Yeah, thank you so much for having me. I appreciate it.
You represent truckers in California. You've had your own trucking ventures here and you've been
in this industry for many, many years. Can you tell us what's happening with the trucking industry
here? I've been in the industry for 30 years. Started immediately right out of college and it's
a heavy regulated state for trucking. The economy is not good to us as a trucking community.
There's many challenges of operating a trucking company in California or nationally. A lot of
policies that are happening now in the federal government hopefully will help the industry
going forward. There's a lot to talk about. We can talk about the clean trucks and the
initiative of California. They're always pushing. They always want to be the pioneer
in that environment, in that area, regulating the emissions, which is great. I don't think
no one has any problems with it as long as it's done reasonably. The economy is not good even
though they're in our segment of the business, which is dredge. Some ports are reporting really
good volumes, but it's been so unpredictable over the last couple of years because of tariffs.
There's volume swings and it's hard to run a business in that kind of environment.
As I mentioned with the regulatory, it doesn't matter if you're a port or it doesn't matter if
you're just a trucking company in California. Regulations is probably the biggest thing we
deal with in California, whether it be misclassification of an employee or independent
contractor, whether it's just trucking in general of the model you run, employee or hybrid, meaning
you run employees plus you have independent contractors who work with you, supplement your
workforce. The gamut is there and it's very difficult to run business in California and it's
not for the faint of heart. California in general, we've always been, like I said, the leader in
trying to convert the trucking community to a cleaner burning truck. We've done an excellent
job. California, I wouldn't say everything we've done is terrible. There's been a lot of pain to
go through that, but I think at the end of the day, the amount of emissions reductions that we've
actually realized is significant, far greater than any state in the union. That being said,
in the port specifically, because it's technically called a drayage, it's supposed to be short haul,
it's much easier to control. Well, that's not necessarily the case and I think it's misleading
to believe that because the Port of L.A. and Long Beach service is such a wide span of territory.
Cargo coming through the gateway goes through the Central Valley, goes into Nevada, goes into
Arizona, goes down to San Diego and across the border. So the span is so much greater than
what a typical drayage definition means, but that's where the state always goes after first
and foremost. So they introduced, CARB did, the California Air Resources Board introduced
what was called an advanced clean fleet several years ago and they were signaling to the trucking
community, we're going to have this rule, we're going to make you guys go to zero emissions.
Mind you, throughout this entire time, we've been trying to reduce the OEMs, the manufacturers of
these trucks have been constantly reducing the greenhouse gas, right? And so it went down to
the, this diesel particulate went down to like, and don't quote me on this, somewhere in the
neighborhood of 0.15 or something of that nature. So they're trying to constantly make it cleaner.
Yeah, make it cleaner, right? And at the time... But still use diesel, right?
Yes, that's right. So the technology type or the engine type didn't change,
it was just making it cleaner, run more efficient. And there's only so much you can
squeeze out of that lemon. And that's where we were at before the ACF, the advanced clean fleet.
And so CARB's next step was zero technology, zero emission technology. Well, the only
technology now that's offering zero emissions is battery or hydrogen. And so they were signaling
to the trucking community, guess what? This is coming, this is coming. And we were having
discussions with CARB and saying, look, OEMs are constantly reducing the greenhouse gases
that the diesel's emitting. They're doing the best they can. I think it got down to, I think,
0.02 or 0.05, somewhere in that neighborhood. From where? Do you know?
I honestly don't know where we started, but I can tell you the basin, if you recall 10,
15 years ago, there was like a green cloud. That cloud is not as bad as it used to be and not
perfect by any means. And we're working towards reducing that cloud, but there's things you have
to do before you get there. And you can't put the cart before the horse in that regard. So
they were signaling, they're going to put this rule into effect. California Trucking
Association specifically is in direct communications with California Air Resources Board.
And they're the body that kind of negotiates with CARB for all intents and purposes,
for lack of a better word. But they're having discussions and saying, look, you can't force us
because the technology is not ready. There's no infrastructure to support
that kind of technology. So there's like no chargers.
There's no charging stations. And then it will take time to charge.
Right. I mean, we try to bring experts, we try to share with them. Look, to put a new
substation in an area that can't draw enough electricity to that area to begin with,
it's going to take 10 to 15 years. And there's a huge financial commitment that you as a motor
carrier have to make to the power utilities company. So all this stuff was not in place.
And the technology of the truck wasn't even going to service all the trucking,
what the dredge this market brings. So as I mentioned, you have cargo going to Central Valley,
you're going to the Inland Empire, high desert, you have stuff going to Vegas,
you have stuff going to Arizona. The electric trucks at that time when the ACF was being
rolled out was probably averaging 150 mile round trip, maybe at best. That's not going to take you
to any of those locations. And so we kept telling CARB, look, we're for it. We want clean air too.
But let's do it responsibly. Let's do it in a way so you can introduce the technology,
let infrastructure catch up. Then hopefully over time, the technology gets better,
more infrastructures in place. Then we could start spreading going further out because as
technology gets better, the range got better. Problems with electric trucks is they're heavy.
The batteries are super heavy. And we're talking a truck that could weigh 16,000 to 18,000 pounds,
a diesel truck, now weighing 25,000 to 28,000 pounds. Now you're going to tell the customer,
guess what? You have to reduce how much cargo you put in that container or that trailer
by almost 10,000 pounds. So that means more trucks to do the same amount of work.
If you look at that and you say, okay, for every four
containers today, I have to move one more with the electric truck. So is it really helping
the environment if you're putting more trucks in circulation that can't even go the full distance?
So there's a lot to play. There's a lot to go there. So eventually Cooler Haired prevailed,
CARB withdrew their waiver because California Trucking Association said, look, this is not
feasible. There's no technology. We call it the duty cycle. The duty cycle is like, okay,
what does a truck do every day? And can electric trucks do the same? Can it match it? And they
couldn't because the distances, the weight of the cargoes, the lack of infrastructure.
So at the time when this was being rolled out, we kept telling them it wasn't going to work.
Let's pilot. Let's do a small controlled environment where it might work. And we were
referring constantly saying, look, anything within 30 miles of the port round trip would
probably be your target market. Let's focus on that first. Let technology build, let trucks,
let infrastructure catch up. As over time, as we've now seen, Elon built this megawatt factory
in Reno and he could pump out 50,000 trucks. But this is three years after the fact of this rule
that was going to go into effect. So it's a big difference, right? And it wasn't ready.
And the infrastructure, we don't have enough of it as it is today to service what we currently
have. In the Port of L.A. Long Beach, there's roughly 624 trucks that are zero emissions,
624. There's a total of 18,000 trucks. Do we want to convert? Yes. But you can't put the
cart before the horse. As I stated, if there's no infrastructure and the trucks can't make that
run that distance to service all the freight that comes through the gateway, then we're going to
fail. And the customers are not going to get their cargo. We as consumers, we'll go to the stores
and there'll be nothing, right? People seem to always kind of forget now as we pass COVID,
there was problems during COVID, right? You went to the stores, there was no stuff going on.
That's how it would be if they would have forced us into a zero emissions environment.
Can you tell us what happened to certain companies that jumped on this electric?
So historically in California, CARB has pretty much always gotten a waiver when it comes to
any kind of new policy that they implement. They would go to the Environmental Protection Agency,
EPA, and they would submit their waiver for whatever new policy they wanted to implement.
Historically, they've always got it. And so when CARB told us they're going to put this ACF into
place, we're like, oh my God, we have to comply, right? It was January 1, 2024. Anything new going
into the port as far as registration, if you had an existing truck that had a certain lifespan,
and then you had to remove it. So as of January 1, anything new had to be zero emissions.
So because we knew we were going to, our business at the time...
At that time, you were part of a business.
I left a big private family owned company, a huge family owned company, over 1600 trucks plus
in LA, Long Beach, Oakland, Savannah, the East Coast, Midwest, big family drage company. I left
that company and went to a privately held small company in the Central Valley. That company,
he and I were really good friends in the industry. He and his father brought me on board as an owner,
part owner. But the difference with that was that our average run was 400 mile round trip.
And so when ACF was about to go into place, we're like, no electric truck can do this.
We're moving pure agricultural product. Those customers load out the container at 45,000 pounds.
So you're talking about 45,000 pounds. You're talking about a type of truck that can't even
do that to begin with because of the weight of the battery of the truck, right? 24, 26,000 pounds.
The current Teslas right now today, the 300 mile range one is, I think it's at 20,000 pounds.
And the 500 mile range is like a 23. And then you get a 2000 pound exemption in California for a
zero truck. So you're almost comparable to a diesel, but that wasn't in existence when we
made this decision and I was part of the company. So we went out and purchased over 30 trucks,
diesel trucks, no diesel because of the distance. And the reason why we did that was because we knew
we were going to have what was called a useful life. In SB1, there's a provision in there to
cause about useful life. So it gives you so many miles before you can no longer use that truck.
So it was a protection to the trucking companies that say, you're going to get your investment,
your return on that investment before you have to retire it. So what we said is if we buy these
before January 1, 2024, we're going to get up roughly 800,000 miles out of those trucks before
we have to retire them. And hopefully that time technology, the zero emission battery and the
hydrogen would develop enough that there's comparable to diesel as far as weights and the
distance. So we've said, we made a business decision. Looking back now, no one really
thought, as my good friend, Matt Schrapp would say, no one had Trump winning the presidency on
their bingo card. He loves saying that. And it's true. We didn't believe that Trump was going to
win. We didn't believe there was going to be a Republican in office and change the landscape
of the environmental policies that are happening in the United States, which included California,
which we all believe that they were going to get the waiver. Carbo was going to get the waiver to
allow them to implement ACF. So I know it gets a little technical and nerdy here, but it was
instrumental to our bankruptcy. So we had to go out of business because many companies did not
comply. They were gambling because California Trucking Association had a lawsuit against CARB
because California Trucking Association said, you have no right CARB to implement this policy,
this ACF rule, because now you're changing the technology. You're supposed to ask for a waiver.
EPA sets standards on new technologies, not California. But we live in California and it's
like almost like the United States of California here. We kind of do our own thing and it's always
been that way. And so we felt no different as a business that's been in business for 25 plus years.
That's how we've lived. This is the environmental regulatory world that we live in.
So we made those decisions and unfortunately it cost us. That company is no longer in business.
That's kind of what led me to this role today. So I know firsthand when you try to comply and
the rest of your competitors don't, there's a disadvantage, right? My costs are going
astronomically high. If they made a business decision not to buy new trucks and just maintain
with what they have, they ultimately won that gamble or that they made the right business
decision at that point because Trump came into office, California pulled their ACF waiver.
That regulation is no longer on the books. So we are living in a world that you can still run
your diesels. And so if I already own all my diesel trucks and I didn't have a new payment,
we had 32 payments of significant dollar amounts per month, per truck. Insurance cost is going
through the roof. So we were over our skis. We definitely overextended ourselves. It was a great
learning lesson for me coming from big companies where I worked for prior to a small family owned
50 truck operation. Going through what we went through, it certainly helped me in my mind,
be able to do my role here because I know how a big company runs. I know how a small company runs
and there's a huge dynamics difference. Financially, never had an issue with the big
company, different policies, different sets of running the business. Where a family owner is,
you're living almost as they say paycheck to paycheck, right? You're living tight. You're
highly dependent on your receivables, getting that money back from the customers immediately
because you're making payroll for your drivers. So it's a different world, different world,
but I've got to learn both sides of it from the biggest trucking companies to the smallest.
So I'm able to advocate on their behalf. It doesn't matter what size you are,
because I've been through both. In terms of these regulations,
what about biodiesel? We're hearing about biodiesel. Yeah, that's an option. I think
people are using that as a transition truck because there's nothing against using it.
It just wasn't an option for us at the time when ACF was being put in.
So it was like the mandate was all or nothing. Hydrogen or electric.
Hydroelectric, which is zero, or diesel. And there was no in between. We did advocate like,
why can't we get a transitional technology to get to zero instead of saying all or nothing,
right? And ultimately that's why the ACF failed. There was a lot of holes in it.
And we want to work with CARB. They're great partners of ours to this day. To this day,
we work on riding drives. We actually put on exhibits where we invite the trucking communities
along with CARB to try to educate the community about transitioning to zero,
learning how to plan for using grants to pay for the truck. So we're all in favor of clean air.
We live here. We want clean air. It's not like we want to run the dirtiest trucks. That's not true.
And I think there's a misconception on that because I think the general public
typically sees a truck on the road and they think that we're the polluting trucks and we're killing
everybody. Well, that's not the truth. At least in our world, the most dirtiest
emission source is not a truck. And when I say my world, I mean in the dredge,
the ocean ships that come in to our ports are the dirtiest in the emissions inventory.
And that has been proven because every year, ports of LA and Long Beach issue in an emissions
inventory of what their emission sources are and what those levels are. And they're the highest
pollutant emission source. And we have heard that they change their fuel once they get close.
Yeah. And they're doing it. I mean, listen, they're like, they have the same mandates we have.
They have to change just like we do, but no one sees vessels coming into the port.
They just see trucks on the road and they think the trucks are the bad guys.
That's not true. Over the last 15 years, we changed our technology as a community
and cleaned up the air more so than they have. Now, the cost is huge disparity, right? I mean,
we're talking about a 200,000 truck and then they're talking about $150 million ship. It's
a huge difference. But regardless, you want to come and bring cargo into our country,
you should have clean vessels and you should spend the money to get those vessels clean.
Just like we as Americans who own our trucking companies have to spend the money to change,
right? They have to do the same. If you like California Insider, we also have a new show
called Market Insider, where we are looking into the economy and what's happening with the economy,
real estate, stock market, and investment opportunities that are out there. You can
follow the show and the link below at Market Insider. Also, there's a sub stack which will
have exclusive content. This show is also available on Epoch TV and it's part of the
Epoch Times newspaper platform. Now, let's go back to the rest of the interview.
And are there rates going down? Are there a lot of other challenges for your space?
God, that's a tough one. It's tough because it's another part of our demise. My previous company
was during COVID, we called it the freight bonanza because there was so much cargo coming in during
COVID. You could pretty much call your rate. And what I mean by that, we had an increase of
trucking power into the ports. It was roughly 18,000 trucks. It went up to 23,000 trucks
just within the first year of COVID because there was so much cargo coming through our gateway.
You can name your rate. A normal rate that costs 500 bucks, I can name it. I can call
$1,000 and I was getting paid. So, post COVID, it's been what we call a freight recession.
Too many trucks, not enough freight. Did a lot of people get into the business?
Oh, yeah. Oh, yeah. Easily a couple thousand trucking companies came into the business,
over 6,000 more trucks into the port registry. So, we have 18,000. Right now, I think we're down
to like 17. It was at the highest 23,000. So, that's an additional capacity of over 6,000 trucks
that no longer exist today. But even in today's market where we have 17,000 trucks,
we still don't have enough freight to support those 17. So, as a result, what happens? More
competition. Rates go down because trucking companies are trying to survive in this
environment. And so, a lot of people are fighting for cargo. And what I mean by fighting is that
they're undercutting each other on the rates. So, even if I had a long-term customer, which I
thought it was a loyal customer that I had maybe for 20 years, if they can get that same cargo
moved for a hundred bucks less, guess where they're going? They're going to go to that other
trucking company. And that's the world that we live in today. It's not sustainable. I can tell
you that. Diesel prices, as you know, it's through the roof because of the war. And that's killing us
too. So, you have low rates, you have diesel prices are record highs, and customers not willing
to pay for that. So, that puts a lot more strain on the trucking companies. So, we've had a
significant amount of trucking companies go under over the last, not just mine personally, other
trucking companies who were members, both at the CTA level and HTA level, and also nationally.
I get those numbers every day. Like, oh my God, another five more went out of business. Oh my
God, another five more went out of business. It's been sad, to be honest with you, because a lot of
long-standing companies, family-owned companies for 30, 40 years, 60 years, going under business
because they just can't afford to operate in this environment. Do you think it's hitting the bottom,
or do you think there is more? I think we're very close to hitting that bottom, to be honest
with you, because the diesel prices, along with the low rates, are driving more trucking companies
out. And ultimately, what's going to happen is we're going to hit that bottom, and then you're
going to see where now there's more demand than there is supply. We're not there yet, and the
reason we track every month how many trucking companies and how many trucks are in the port.
So, at the highest, it was like almost 1,700 trucking companies, over 23,000 trucks. We're
down to 1,400 trucking companies, so that's less than 300 trucking companies and over 6,000 trucks
out of the port. If this continues in the same path we're seeing, where the rates are low,
the diesel prices are high, you're going to get to a point where the supply is no longer
greater than demand, and so we're going to have this problem. We're going to have it upturned,
and if regulations keep changing, depending on when that happens with clean trucks,
people aren't going to be able to afford them. And only those that have the money who can afford it
will be able to have those trucks, and those that don't are going to go out of business.
Do you think that's going to come back, the clean truck?
Oh, yes. Oh, it's not a matter of if, it's when. We all know we're pretty realistic that
the Trump era will end, and there very well could be a Democrat in the office, and all the
regulations that we were dealing with before, when Biden was in office, will come back. Now,
they may not come back in the same form that we were seeing it, maybe in a different context,
but we've been signaled already by CARB is that they already started their waiver request for
their new ACF. It may not be the same ACF. It may be ACF 2.0 or whatever, some new version,
but that's why we continually educate our trucking community, is learn about the green technology,
start planning and preparing. Even if you financially can't do it today, understand
what it takes to get new trucks, understand where you might want to fuel or charge up,
start planning today, because at some point, you're going to have to pull the trigger,
and you're going to have to start converting over to green technology. It's just a matter of when,
not if. It's going to happen. Do you think it's feasible with these new Tesla trucks? Do you
think there is a possibility for this to happen, or do you think it's still not feasible? Is it
hard like what you guys did with the diesel? Because you said you went through a hard time,
but it was worth it. I will tell you, the Tesla model and its competitor called the Winrose,
the range is there. HTA has a couple of members who have Teslas, and one of them has reported to
me that they're moving cargo out of the Central Valley at 44,000 pounds. That's almost the
equivalent as a diesel moving 46,000 pounds, because you have that 2,000-pound exemption,
and they're moving it to the port. Well, that was kind of like we thought that was never going to
happen. Now, mind you, they don't have a hill like the Grapevine. Oakland to the Central Valley is
pretty flat for the most part, but they're still doing it, and they're very happy with
this performance. It's going to keep getting better. Our biggest hope is that the battery
weight goes down a little bit more, so that way we can get more comparable to the diesel. So as
long as it keeps progressing like we're seeing it, yes, I think it'll happen. The infrastructure's
got to catch up. What about the fires? Sometimes there's potential with some fires. You're right.
We had a fire a few years back at the Port of Long Beach that took three days for a truck
to basically be extinguished. Not reported. Recently, I had a member whose truck went up
into flames. It wasn't reported publicly. The fire department did a good job of containing the fire,
and really it was after the truck was done. My member told me as soon as the driver plugged it
in, probably within five, 10 minutes, he started hearing some crackling, which was kind of weird
to him. He'd never heard it before as he was charging. Then as soon as that crackling started
occurring, he started smelling smoke, and then it went up in flames. It wasn't public. I haven't
seen it in any newspaper. This was just a couple days ago, and so that truck went up in flames,
unfortunately. But it's far and few between, and something had to have failed on that. So
is the possibility there? Yes, but it could happen with the diesel. It could happen with the CNG or
biodiesel. It could happen with any of the trucks. I think we're so concerned because of the hazardous
potential materials. Because it will take a few days. It takes a few days to burn out. You can't
just put water to it and it turns off, right? But also the fumes, because what the battery is
composed of, that is potential hot toxins. So I think that's more of the concern. Yeah, the three
days is a problem, right? You want something on fire for three days. But I think from a health
perspective, I can tell you it was reported that those fire departments immediately backed out,
went on, put some hazmat suits, and then went in there and tried to make sure that everything
around it was not going to catch on fire. So they were watering down the buildings, the trucks next
to it, everything, because they just had to let it burn. So fortunately, that was the only
thing that got damaged. Unfortunately, one of our members' trucks is no longer with us, right? It's
burnt up to crisp. But I'm wondering, I'm very interested, and I told them I would love to
know what happened. The OEM is going to do some testing to see how or what happened, what caused
the battery to ignite. So we don't know what that was. But that's recently, and that's only two
that I have known of since we started using electric trucks in our industry. And you mentioned
the contractor law impacted you guys a lot in California. Can you tell us how? So here's
another thing, right? Prior to the ACF, the zero emissions, right? Prior to that, California has
always been the tip of the spear when it comes to misclassification of a contractor. It's a labor
law, essentially. And so there was a case, I can't remember the year, that ended up essentially
creating what was called AB5. AB5 basically created a standard of how you can classify an
independent contractor as an independent contractor versus an employee. So there was three different
factors to that as a result of the court decision. You couldn't control the independent contractor.
They had to be able to market themselves as their own business. It was control, couldn't do business
with the same business, type of business. So a trucking company couldn't hire an independent
contractor because you do the same business. So that was the hardest one to comply with.
And then C, they had to market themselves as their own business. A and C, no problem. It was the B
problem. And so what ended up happening is that was normal course of business. After deregulation,
you had trucking companies always working with trucking companies. Maybe they were their own
independent contractor who they started as a mom and pop, maybe one truck, two trucks,
and they built their business that way. So with one or two trucks, you would get hired by another
trucking company because it's hard for you to get the customers. That's right. You don't have the
staff. You don't have a back office, right? So you're basically, it's American dream.
And in the port complex, that's how most companies started. As small mom and pops,
I own one truck, then two trucks and three trucks. Then all of a sudden now I got 10 trucks. Now I
got 15 trucks. Most of the trucking companies in the port of LA Long Beach, that's how they started.
And that's how they're currently are. They're family owned. And so this law, because somebody
misclassified them in this case, and it was absolutely ridiculous what they asked them to do,
an independent contractor, the court system, after being sued, this company being sued,
they created what was AB5, the ABC law. And there's been so much through that. But as a
trucking company, you want to comply with that law. And so we've always asked the courts,
how can we comply when a trucking company needs to work with another trucking company?
That B-prong is extremely onerous. How can we comply? It's impossible to bring on so much
drivers and not have any work for them. Just to have them just in case as volumes fluctuate. So
we need that flexibility to contract with other trucking companies because they might need work
too. So they only have a book of business, but sometimes their freight goes down. So that's
kind of how the industry worked. And it was able to help keep rates at a pretty decent level.
So AB5 essentially said, you can't do that. Can't work with another trucking company. So
there was a decision by a San Diego court judge by the name of Benitez said that
business could work with each other. You have to follow what is called business to business
rules. There's like 12 rules. So not only do you got to comply with ABC,
you got to comply with these additional 12 rules, but there's a gateway, there's a pathway.
Which was expensive. So you can't dispatch, they can't be parked in your yard. So the other
trucking company can't be in your yard. Two people can't be dispatching the same truck.
One's a company dispatcher versus a non-company dispatcher. There were so many rules, but a lot
of companies did it because they were like, I want to comply. I don't want a lawsuit on my hands
and essentially put me out of business. So we did the same and we ended up creating,
we had one company before, but when AB5 came around, we created three companies,
a management holding company, a brokerage company, and then our asset company.
And that brokerage is the one that did the contracting with the independent contractor.
As my company asset trucks couldn't handle the volume, that work would be then dispatched out,
parsed out or sold to the other independent contractor. And those dispatchers couldn't
be the same. They couldn't be in the same building. Oh my God. I mean, you're talking
about now I got to file three taxes. I got to have three P&Ls. I got to run different dispatchers
just because they're handling different trucks. So the compliance was so high and so costly, but
we did it because we had to, because we wanted to be around. We were a company like many others
who want to comply with the law. Unfortunately, what we're seeing is that you have a lot of
companies who don't, they fly under the radar, who aren't complying, still working as they work
today. And there's a lack of enforcement, unfortunately. And so what ends up happening
is they can offer lower rates because their overhead is not as high. They don't have the
three companies, the three insurance policies that we had. And a lot of companies have today.
So the environment is the haves versus the have nots. The haves are constantly have higher
operating costs than the ones that don't. And these guys fly under the radar because they're
so small. And this is why you have the Delilah Law. You have federal government issuing all these
new regulations to try to control, I almost call it wild, wild west environment. And so in order,
and in state of California, unfortunately we're in a budget deficit. We don't have the funds to
have a commercial division that goes out and enforces. It's only when a lawsuit is filed
that somebody gets looked into. And so typically they go after the big fish and the big fish are
ones that always have to try to comply because it's bigger, it's public. And so if a company
that has 2000 trucks gets busted versus a trucking company has two trucks, what's more sexy?
Storyline. No, I want to get the big non-compliant trucking company versus a small mom and pop.
But the small mom and pop run majority of the freight.
So from what you're saying, we're setting up rules that are hard to follow.
Right.
But then there's a lot of people that are not following them.
That's right.
The people that are following them, they're somewhat getting punished.
That's how I view it. In my personal opinion, that's what ends up happening because usually
it's sexier to go after a big company and those big companies know they're a big target,
so they comply.
So they will comply.
100%. I'm a big company that runs nationally. I have a big P&L. Guess who they're going to come
after me? There's special interest groups that specifically target those big companies. They
those other guys alone, but the other guys are running 40, 50% of the freight, but there's so
many and so they're not going to get the big bang for their buck when they go after these little
ones because what ends up happening today, why we're having these laws like the Delilah,
why FMCSA is implementing what is called the MODIS, their new platform to try to
stop what is called chameleon carriers.
I think I shared with you an article regarding chameleon carriers is a big deal.
Trucking companies come and they set up because it's so much easier under deregulation to set up
as a trucking company in this environment. They set up, they rack up all kinds of bills, don't
pay their drivers, don't pay fines, and they shut down and then they reopen under a new name.
Same owner, same truck, same everything.
And they get away with it.
And they get away with it. And so the good thing is that federal government is trying to
now put it under one website where you have to do everything, your MCS-150, your insurance,
your SCAD code, everything is going to be done on one website so it could be easily
monitored to see if there was a chameleon carrier now being created.
One shutting down, one reopening, same address, same business owner, but different names.
So those kinds of things are going to help the industry, police it.
But we still have a deficit of law enforcement and enforcement in the state of California.
Across the country, really, at the end of the day.
Like I said, we're really good at implementing regulations and laws, but terrible at enforcement.
So Robert, you really have a lot of passion for this industry.
Oh, I love this, yeah.
Can you tell us why?
Personally, I feel like there's a calling to it.
When you're in trucking, you'll know immediately this is for you.
And when I got into trucking, I immediately fell in love with it.
And throughout my career, I always had somebody, I was always under somebody's wing.
And I was very fortunate that many people saw whatever they saw in me, right?
As I was going through my stages of my career, where they wanted to teach me.
And maybe because I was so willing to learn and I wanted to learn, I wanted to learn more.
I was like a sponge.
And I was afforded many positions at different associations,
committees, representing the industry over my time,
that I became so passionate about helping others who didn't have the opportunities that I had.
And maybe that comes from my upbringing, to be honest with you.
Wasn't, you know, didn't come up with, you know, with a silver spoon in my mouth.
Always had to work for everything.
So no different than any trucking company.
I can promise you, I'm not, my wife always says this to me.
She says, I thought you were crazy.
Like, I thought you were just wacko.
And then I go meet your friends and they all act like you.
And I'm like, yeah, because, because that's, you know, once you're in this industry,
it's in your blood, it's in your blood.
And you know, when you're around your other people that are like-minded like you.
And, and I love it.
And to this day, even some of those people think I'm crazy because I love it so much.
And I've been accused many times of being a fierce advocator for the trucking community.
And I am.
And I, and I don't shy back away from it.
I want to make sure I represent the trucking community to give us equity in the market.
I want to make sure that we have a stake, you know, we're at the table.
We're talking about our issues, advocating to make sure that our voice is heard, right?
And, and because there's many companies, many families that use trucking to build their,
their, you know, to help fund their families and feed their families.
And I love that.
Like to me, it's like the last American dream to start your own business and be successful.
And I see it all the time.
And for those of us that are not in this space,
what do you see in it that creates this kind of passion?
It's a camaraderie, to be honest with you, with the like-minded person.
And I'm sure that other industries have that kind of thing.
But for me, whether it's a woman, whether it's a, whether it's a man,
it doesn't matter what kind of race you are.
You have that same passion and love for what you do.
And I see it with the folks that I deal with, my members alike, other associations.
I can go to any state.
And if I'm around trucking companies or trucking executives or whoever,
they have the same passion for their businesses as I do.
And that's what draws me to it and why I love it so much.
And I'm willing to share, if you're willing to learn,
I'm not going to chase you, but if you're willing to learn, I'll teach you.
And, and I don't, and I, because I need to pass it down as somebody passed it down to me.
That's how I feel about it.
Do you have any thoughts for Californians and the lawmakers?
Cause it seems like you guys are getting regulated at the same time.
Good players follow the regulations.
Some of them might go out of business because the regulation might not be feasible,
but then there's other ones that are not following the laws and they're doing okay.
And they're doing well.
Yeah.
If I were to say anything is, is if we're going to put a law into place,
they got to have some sort of mechanism to enforce it, right?
You can't just put a law and say people are going to comply.
Cause there's a lot of people that don't.
And it's unfair to those that don't, that, that are complying
to operate in an environment when the other ones don't.
So I'm not saying that I'm against putting any regulation,
certain regulations into place because I'm sure there's a lot of wise people
that created it and there was a reason why.
But what I'm saying that in order to make it equitable,
you have to have an enforcement mechanism.
And if you're going to keep putting laws into place that no one's going to,
no one's going to enforce, you're going to have this dynamic economy
and you're going to have companies that are trying to do the right thing,
end up going out of business.
And it's, and it's really sad to be honest with you.
Because those are the best players.
A hundred percent.
Those are the people you want to be running.
They want to buy the clean trucks.
They're going to comply with hours of service.
They're going to do everything by the book versus the companies that are not.
Cause they're not trying to spend extra money to comply,
to do the right things, to buy the right trucks,
to buy the right equipment, to comply with the weights,
the hours of service, the driver, you know,
they're treating their companies, their drivers the best.
And some of those other companies aren't.
And you hear these horror stories all the time.
And so if you're going to put rules into place,
enforce them.
However that may be.
And so that's kind of really the message more than anything else.
We just want equity.
We want to make sure that we have good companies continue to operate
because they're no different than me.
They're family owned.
They want to do the right thing.
They love moving freight for their customers.
Nothing gets me more happier than a satisfied customer.
When you go visit a customer and they're just happy to see you
because you've taken care of them.
They're taking care of their customers, et cetera.
So it's enjoyable to me.
And I get a lot of joy out of it, to be honest with you.
Robert Loya with Harvard Trucking Association.
It was great to have you on California Insider.
Thank you so much.
I appreciate the opportunity.
What do you think of this discussion with Robert on California Trucking?
Do you think things will turn around fast?
Or do you think we have a while to go?
Make sure to email us at siamakacaliforniansider.com or comment.
We read all of your emails and comments.
I'm Siamak Khorrami.
This is California Insider.
We'll see you next time.