Pick-Up Test: Ford Ranger vs Toyota Hilux vs VW Amarok

Luxe Auto Hub
7 followers
4 Video Views·May 30, 2026
Double-cab pick-up trucks are under fire in the UK, now being classified as cars for tax purposes. So, with prices up, how do the most powerful versions of the nation’s favourites compare, and do they offer any benefits versus a normal car?
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThis video compares the Toyota Hilux, Volkswagen Amarok, and Ford Ranger Raptor, evaluating their utility, off-road prowess, and financial viability. While the Hilux is the ultimate utilitarian tool and the Raptor a high-performance \"Baja monster,\" the presenters suggest that for most users, a high-end estate car remains the most practical daily choice.
Today we test pick-up trucks, three of the best to see which is best.
It's going to be an intense couple of days of pulling, comparing, loading and off-roading.
Talking about tax. HR have warned you before.
And someone gets a bit excited.
Raptor!
Right, let's meet our contenders and we are starting, of course, with a proper top gear
a Toyota Hilux, because of course it is completely indestructible.
And this one is in invincible X specification.
No idea what the X stands for, but I do know that this engine is not much of a superhero.
It's only 201 horsepower from a 2.8 litre four-cylinder turbo diesel with some mild hybrid
boost. Still, this is the cheapest truck here at less than 50 grand.
Then we have this, the Volkswagen Amarok here in Panamericana spec.
Now, this one's a little bit more fruity because it's got a three litre V6 by turbo diesel
and 37 brake horsepower more than the Hilux.
It is, however, 58 and a half thousand pounds.
God, these things aren't cheap, are they?
No, they are not, my smooth headed friend.
This, last but not least, is the Ford Ranger Raptor and it is the wannabe
American June bashing Baja monster truck of the three with a 295 brake horsepower
turbo petrol V6 under the bonnet.
It looks chunkier than a KitKat Chunky and because Ford and Volkswagen build their trucks
as a joint venture these days, there's a lot more German under the skin than you might think.
But that means that the price isn't very Ford.
This is 62 and a half grand.
So let's get straight to it.
One of the reasons people buy pickup trucks is to do practical things like tow.
So we thought we'd have a go.
So this towing challenge means spinning the truck round, hitch up to that trailer,
reverse park it in two parking spaces and heading for the finish line.
You make that sound so simple.
It is.
Let's go.
First up, the VW.
Three, two, one, go.
So I'm going to take this quite easy because I've got it just in too high.
I don't think we need four wheel drive at this point.
I'm still getting a little bit of wheel spin.
Maybe I should have done that.
The thing is, when you get an Amarok like this, you do get...
Ah, look, I've got a tow ball camera.
So if I do that and I just aim straight back here, I think I can get this underneath it.
Right, so do that.
Jump out, chocky wheel like this, like that, bring that up there like this,
wind that back on and then that will go straight onto there like that.
Has that gone on?
No, it hasn't.
Come on, you old git.
Right, here we go.
So I'm going to go to the far one first.
Now I want a different camera.
So we'll go like this.
Oh, I've done that wrong already.
Oh, I've jackknifed it.
No, I've done it wrong again.
Oh no, this has all gone terribly wrong.
Am I going to hit the cones?
That was terrible.
That was so bad.
This is much more difficult than it looks.
Yeah, that's in the bay.
That was terrible.
Okay, so the Amarok's all right, but that was difficult.
Next up, the Ford.
The major disadvantage here is me.
I have, hand on heart, never towed in my life.
I've never hitched up a trailer, let alone reverse parked one.
I don't think I've ever even been a passenger in a car that was towing a trailer.
Okay, so I've got cameras popping up immediately.
There's the towing one there.
I probably selected that a fraction too early.
I'm going to come back out of that.
Oh, I'm a bit offline, aren't I?
Let's come in a bit straighter.
And then let's select the towing.
Oh, that's not too bad.
That's pretty useful.
I'm going to quit it there.
Right, now surely I can just lift that over there.
And then apparently if I like bang this handle, does it just...
Is that going up or down?
It's going up.
Right, let's go that way.
I think it's on.
If only we could pretend that that was going to be the most difficult,
most embarrassing part of this.
Oh my God, I'm towing.
Hit the camera button.
Wook used too much speed and power.
Now I've got all the power here, but I've also got all the patience.
I'm going to call that in.
Yes.
Next.
A bit embarrassing this for Wook really.
Somebody's never towed in their life and they just do it on the first attempt.
I may have spoken too soon.
I've no idea where the entrance is, but...
Oh no, I'm in.
I'm in the space.
I'm definitely in.
Yeah, that counts.
Yeah, come on.
Come on, the Raptor.
Come on, towing.
Come on, youth.
And now for the Toyota.
First of all, we need to turn around and everything just feels that bit more normal.
I've got an actual stick, so I just throw it around and then, yep, got my cameras on.
So I just need to reverse towards me old thing.
It's got a line in there, which means that I can actually try and make that really close.
And I think I am going to be right on top.
In fact, I've touched it.
Brilliant.
Handbrake on.
Safety first.
Oh, how perfect is that?
Basically, I need to tuck that in there and then drop that on there.
Drop that on the jockey wheel like that.
Pull that up like that.
That's lovely.
Really far over.
Drop that on.
Oh, that's simple in the Hilux.
In the bay.
Lovely job.
Weirdly, I feel much more comfortable in the Hilux.
Oh my God, this is so much easier than the Amarok and just feels much more simple
when you're doing jobs.
The Amarok, I got quite confused in it.
That's strange.
So the Hilux came out on top for terrific towing because it felt so small and easy to use
and it has trailer sway control.
The Amarok came second thanks to that easy peasy torque from the big V6 diesel and the Ford third.
But the Raptor also gets an aura deduction for actually being a bit weak when it comes
to pulling things more lifestyle than load lugger.
Both the Hilux and the Amarok are much more suited if you're towing on the regular.
Don't forget that everyone can now tow up to three and a half tons without passing an
additional test, which you used to have to do if you passed your test after the 1st of January,
1997.
That's something that I had to worry about, but granddad license over there never had to.
Ollie, I want to talk to you about tax.
HR have warned you before.
Why?
Well, there's a thing about pickup trucks, right?
Up until recently, these cars were taxed as vans, which meant that you got really good
benefit in kind and good capital allowances.
Essentially, you could register it on the business and you got the vat back,
which is excellent for being frugal.
The thing is, as of the 6th of April, 2025, HMRC has decided to tax all double cab pickups
as cars, so you can't get the vat back.
Suddenly, they are very, very expensive.
They are.
In fact, the Raptor never qualified for any tax breaks because it doesn't have enough
payload capacity.
The reason for that is that instead of a nice, hardy leaf spring at the back, it has coils
and a watts linkage because it's meant to be more about the Baja than the builder's merchant.
Which is why I felt that I ought to introduce you to this, the best car on the planet,
the Skoda Superb Estate.
You're only saying that because this is your daily.
Yes.
And I still believe that it is the best car in the world.
And it does 99% of all of the things your pickups will do, except better.
Do you want to know why?
I'm sure you're going to tell me.
Well, this car is a two-liter diesel and it will do 800 miles to a tank on a motorway
or 650 normally.
It is the four-wheel drive version and it's slightly raised and it has smaller wheels
and winter tires.
It will go across the wet field that you can't get across in a Range Rover.
But the best thing about it is it does everything better than a pickup.
So it handles better.
It's more aerodynamic.
It steers better.
It has a nicer interior.
Look at this.
I know it's a complete CID spec, so it looks like a cop car.
Look at that.
Oh, yes, Tan.
Leather.
It just looks beautiful.
And the seats are slightly canted back, so it's more comfortable.
In the back of a pickup, they are like church pews.
They're straight.
Also, on my headrests, I have these little things like airline seats.
Built-in pillows, lovely.
Built-in pillows.
I've got some things in the back.
Even better than that, when you come to the back, if you do this, look, no hands,
under the O of the Skoda, look at this load bay.
I mean, there is an echo in there and you can reach all your stuff after you've braked.
It's also covered and it's secure, so you don't get people nicking stuff
out the back of your pickup at the traffic lights.
This is the kind of car that does everything you need it to.
You don't need a pickup.
So there we go.
There you have it.
Let's not test these.
This is the car to buy.
Why would you have a pickup truck?
Well, there is one thing that pickups do better than a Skoda Superb.
What's that?
Extreme off-road.
Right.
Let's load some of these boxes.
Why are we doing this?
Well, the idea being that if you've got to drive across a job site,
you may well be delivering something.
So this will give us an indication of whether the ride and the off-road ability is any good.
If you lose boxes, it's obviously not that great.
Or one of us is a really useless off-road driver, as the comments will tell us.
I think that is probably likely, but it ain't going to be me.
And one final thing, a bucket.
That is perfectly loaded.
That's definitely staying there, isn't it?
So here we have a course which takes in some of the things you might need to do
if you have a pickup and actually use it.
Move a load around a job site or get across a field or two.
So we're going to load the boxes and then run the course
to see which pickup makes it look the easiest.
It's a toss-up between speed and load retention.
Okay, obstacle one, the steep, muddy ruts.
Now, this is not a timed challenge, so I'm going to be gentle.
Got it in mud ruts.
This is not a particularly challenging bit of off-roading,
but this is why people want the pickup trucks, right?
Because they want to know that their school-run vehicle can conquer this kind of thing
even if they don't plan to on a daily basis.
I think a couple of boxes may have escaped, but no real problems.
Just maintaining a five-mile-an-hour crawl.
So we head up the steepest part now, slightly loose surface.
I'm going to trust that the diffs have got this.
A few more revs, bonnet pointed straight at the sky.
Can't see the ground.
There goes some paintwork.
Easy peasy.
Ah, fear I may have lost some cargo.
I can't believe how much this thing's scraping.
I thought it's meant to have ground clearance.
Oh, that's a big scrape.
Oh, yes, and again, that bottomed out suspension.
Yes, maybe this isn't as competent as off-road as I'd hoped.
Oh, no.
Oh, that sounded expensive.
I really don't fancy fishing the boxes out of here.
I hope we don't lose them.
I mean, it does keep on trucking the Amrock.
It keeps going, but it just sounds like it's eating itself underneath.
It's a reluctant off-roader, this.
Can do it, not happy about it.
No effort from me at all.
Oh, just scraping.
Next, and for a final flourish, this very gnarly-looking set of axle articulators.
It's not happy.
Oh, that bottomed out.
Sorry, car.
Right, the Toyota Hilux, back to the 90s in here.
Oh, yes, it's rock hard.
And you've got the horrible old broken wrist gear selector,
but very simple switch to put it in high range for not lock the diffs.
Terrible driving position.
No real steering wheel reach adjustments.
You can see that's kind of catching on my legs.
But I've just got a sense that this is going to have unstoppability about it.
It's not going to be electronics that keep us going.
It's just going to be metal and brute force.
But I think that was even more effortless than the Volkswagen.
I've got heavier steering in the Toyota, definitely.
It feels like the visibility is better.
It feels like the bonnet is, I don't know, it's just easy to see over.
It's scraping less, even though it's beeping more.
I didn't think that the Hilux would be a more effortless off-road car, but it is.
I mean, you can see how much the steering wheel is just moving around its own accord.
It definitely gets deflected more than the Amarok did.
The powertrain and the suspension feels like it's working less hard than the Volkswagen.
Oh, imagine how good it'd be if my knees fit under the steering wheel.
Oh yeah, that's going to scrape.
Come on, let's give it a bit of throttle through here.
Oh yeah, I love a Hilux.
Love it.
Smells of countryside.
Poo.
Yeah, I don't think this is quite as happy here as it has been on the other bits of the course.
Screen went black.
Yeah, that felt pretty brutal.
I'm a bit surprised by that.
The Hilux has taken everything in its stride so far, but that seemed to upset it.
I wonder how many boxes we lost.
I don't know if you can see this, but the screens have gone slightly mental.
What's going on?
So here we go, Ranger Raptor on the off-road course.
And actually, I don't think we've got any problems here because this thing is built to off-road.
Easy.
The thing is, until we get to the really technical sections,
this Raptor can go a little bit quicker than everything else because the suspension is just so
good.
If you go a bit slower, this thing just does what it needs to do.
And one of the big things about this car is it sounds great.
So I can go through all of this stuff and I'm not even worried.
I mean, look how easily the suspension is coping with this.
It's beautiful.
Of course, if you were properly driving off-road...
Sorry, I don't understand.
That makes two of us.
Of course, if you're properly driving off-road, you would go slow.
You would make minimal impact.
But we're on an off-road course, so we can go a bit silly in the Raptor and it's
not going to cause any more damage.
See, that's one of the good things about having that rear suspension being independent on a
watch link, so it's a located multi-link and decent tyres, is that you can go that
little bit faster and everything just feels a bit smoother.
Look at this.
It's absolutely monstering it and we're not losing any boxes.
Bit of water here.
Just going to drag that tow ball into the water, keep a nice bow wave going.
Absolutely beautiful.
Little bit of a water splash here.
I wonder what that's going to do.
To be honest, it doesn't seem to matter what mode you have this in.
It just does it all perfectly anyway.
So we've got a hill climb here and we just go through it.
I have to say, this Raptor is so good off-road, I've been playing with some of the settings.
It doesn't seem to make that much difference unless you're in low range and you're
crawling.
This thing will pretty much go through anything you want it to without even messing around
too much.
See, where the other cars are kind of workhorses and getting through it, I think the Raptor's
just more fun.
It's like a giant rally car.
And now I've got the elephant's feet, so I'm going to go a bit slower this time and I'm
going to open my window for extra sort of technical points.
And then if we just drop this in and let it find its way, it should be absolutely fine.
Up and down.
I've got a rock stuck in my brake disc somewhere.
So what are we saying then?
Well, now the tax rules have changed, I think if you're going to have a double cab pickup,
you need a real reason to want to buy one.
Though I will say that all three of these vehicles did more than 99% of people would
expect or need.
Yeah, capabilities not in doubt, but you are going to end up paying a lot of money for
kind of a compromised road car.
And then if you don't want that, you could just go and have Escoda Superb all-wheel drive
because I love that car.
Anyway, listen, I love the Ranger.
I think it's brilliant.
It's got great suspension, but it's very expensive and it is a little bit bougie.
The Panamericana, I just...
It's a badge-engineered car.
What's the point of it?
Just have a normal base-spec Ranger.
There's nothing Volkswagen-y about it.
And it does work, but I kind of can't get any mental traction.
It's a bit like Teflon, it's disappeared.
I forgot.
However, this thing, in the towing thing, it felt so comfortable.
It was so easy.
It's slightly smaller, but just as capable.
Easy to drive, mighty off-road.
It just has that brilliant kind of unpretentiousness.
It feels built for anything you could throw at it.
Nuclear apocalypse, zombie war.
Yeah, I'd absolutely have that one to take home.
There's only one caveat.
I would have it in white as a free colour on steel wheels and just use it for work.
So we're agreed.
Hilux is best as a UN peacekeeper.
Yes, I'm having the Hilux.
And you?
Well, my head says Hilux.
My heart, I just want the fastest truck with the biggest tyres.
So I say Raptor.
