The Law Academy is a project designed to provide legal education for students studying law in the UK. Subscribe for more content.
Jurisprudence is the philosophical study of law. It encompasses the examination and analysis of legal principles, concepts, and theories, aiming to understand the nature of law, its origins, and its underlying philosophical foundations. Jurisprudence explores questions about the essence of law, its purpose, and its role in society.
M. Freeman, Lloyd’s Introduction to Jurisprudence (Sweet & Maxwell, 2014). R. Wacks, Understanding Jurisprudence: An Introduction to Legal Theory (Oxford University Press, 2020). J. Penner & E. Melissaris, McCoubrey & White’s Textbook on Jurisprudence (Oxford University Press, 2012).
Disclaimer:
At no point are these video lessons intended to provide any sort of legal advice. These are for educational purposes only!
Image(s) Copyright: This Photo by Unknown Author is licensed under CC BY-SA
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI Generated
This lesson transitions from the theological foundations of natural law—specifically the works of Augustine and Aquinas—to its role in modern jurisprudence. It explores the shift from ontological questions about the nature of law to substantive concerns regarding morality, law-making, and justice, particularly in response to 20th-century atrocities.
In this lesson we're going to move away from looking at the theological influences of natural
law theory, looking at people like Augustine and Aquinas within the sort of early middle ages and
the high middle ages, and we're going to start to talk about how natural law exists in today's
jurisprudential conversations, whether or not natural law still does exist and what the modern
theories of natural law actually are. So, so far our study of the natural law tradition within the
broader philosophy of law has gone from looking at the historical developments, beginning with
the ancient world of Plato and Aristotle, and then talking about how Plato and Aristotle were
influential on the religious influencers, people like Augustine and Aquinas. This lesson we're
going to talk briefly about the impact of these classical theories before turning to look at an
introduction at more modern natural law theories, and we will then spend the final two lessons on
natural law looking at those two theories in more detail. So, we've spent a lot of time and a few
weeks exploring classical natural law. We've been talking about the way in which it is elucidated
through the ancient thinkers of Plato and Aristotle, at least influenced with a limited
amount of hinting, essentially, with Plato not placing too much emphasis on the importance of law
and Aristotle placing a little bit more emphasis on the importance of law, specifically within the
idea of the nature of the human condition. But it's only really where we see the early church
fathers and the sort of high middle ages with Saint Augustine and Saint Thomas Aquinas that we
start to see the the true elucidation of what we would understand natural law theory to be to this
day. It's for that reason that many people when studying natural law probably don't think that
much about Plato and Aristotle, even though in reality those were the two influential
Greek philosophers that really had such an impact on the way in which Catholic doctrine
and religious doctrine in the medieval period actually operated, and things like scholasticism
as a movement and the sort of the rediscovery of the classical world. We've seen these theories
situate themselves within the broader question of ontology, talking about the ontology of law
more generally, i.e. what is law itself? What actually is it to call something law? What does
that actually mean? When we talk about law, why do we describe some things as law and some
things are not law? And one of the issues that was had by these classical natural law theories
is whether or not it is sufficient in proving more substantive analyses behind some of the
critical issues within jurisprudence. So the question that was asked and the question that
seems to be most pertinent for those of the classical natural law theorists is what makes
something law? With the religious influencers they argued that it was adherence to some higher
authority, some eternal rules such as the law that is created by God, or some kind of adherence
to a higher objective morality, i.e. biblical morality or some kind of natural law that is
more of a moral theory rather than just a theory of law. But these are questions of ontology,
these are questions that are essentially asking if we have a set of all things that are
called law, what does it require? What does it require for something to be a part of that set
essentially? So the more substantive issues like the process of law making, the administration of
law, the concepts of justice, aren't necessarily as influential in these classical theories of
natural law. And so as a result of which we think about the impact of these classical theories,
these are theories which are impactful on the basis of their ontological influences over law.
But the concept of procedural law making and the concept of administration of law and the concept
of justice are things that we're going to have to think about when we look to the modern theories
of natural law. Now the thing about modern natural law is that for the longest of time
it was relatively niche as a movement owing to the growing importance and the growing
popularity of legal positivism. And so there are various social cultural and philosophical reasons
why the interrelation between law and morality became less and less popular during the sort
of enlightenment period and even in today's understanding of jurisprudence to an extent.
However certain things that takes place that takes place in the early 20th century
actually brings back this question of law and morality. And things like for example the
atrocities that took place in Eastern Europe in the 1920s and the 1930s with the Soviet Union and
Nazi Germany gave this question of law and morality and the reconciliation between the two
more and more importance. So more and more people were asking questions as to how is it the case
that law has been able to allow for things like war and genocide to take place in such a
flagrant and brutal way. So the development of law in this case surely should bring with it
reference to morality owing to the fact that under legal systems that existed in the western world
at least within Germany things like genocide was able to take place and dictatorship was able to
grow and fester. Now while legal positivism doesn't necessarily avoid or refuse to talk
about the conceptualizations of law in relation to the concept of morality within the traditional
legal definition at least it does relegate issues pertaining to morality to the periphery of the
core concepts within legal jurisprudence. So whereas natural law takes moral philosophy and
makes it a central thesis within its general theories of jurisprudence, legal positivism
takes moral philosophy and has sort of leaves it to the peripheries and as a result of this
the resurgence of more modern forms of natural law begin to increase in popularity owing to
the clear moral questions that had to be asked at the end of the second world war and
and continue to be asked even to this day. So with all of this context given let's think about
what the two modern natural law theories that we're going to focus on in the next two lessons
are. We're going to talk about procedural natural law a theory which was developed by
philosopher Lonnell Fuller and then we will also talk about a theory of natural rights which is a
development theory which is developed by Finnis. So Fuller and Finnis are arguably the two most
prominent modern natural law theorists and we'll talk about what procedural natural law is in the
next lesson and then we'll talk about what the theory of natural rights entails in the lesson after.