‘Billionaire CRISIS’: How the country's wealthiest are 'bankrolling' U.S. politics

World News
2 followers
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThe video examines the systemic rise of economic inequality in the United States, using Jackson Hole as a symbol of how tax policies and deregulation have empowered a billionaire class. It argues that extreme wealth concentration has eroded democratic stability, creating a \"rigged\" system where the ultra-wealthy wield disproportionate political power and legal impunity.
In 1829, a fur trapper named David Jackson was making his way through the American West,
one of thousands of working men who fanned out across the frontier to hunt and trap and survive
off the land. Jackson kept returning to one particular valley in what is now Wyoming.
It was a deep, wide valley, completely ringed by mountains,
so enclosed, so dramatic that you don't just enter it, you descend into it.
His trapping partners Jedediah Smith and William Sublette noticed how much time he spent there,
and so they named the valley after him. They had a specific word for valleys like this,
valleys so deep and so completely swallowed by the mountains around them that it felt like
falling into the earth itself. Valleys like that were called a hole, and it became Jackson's Hole,
a working man's valley named by men who went there to work.
For the next 150 years or so, that's more or less what it remained, a rugged, remote,
spectacular corner of Wyoming. Ranchers and outfitters populated it, and a ski town grew
out of it. Jackson Hole continued to be a place where people came to experience something wild
and real, but over the last few decades, things began to change. Slowly at first, working ranchers
sold to out-of-state buyers. Luxury lodges replaced old outfitter camps. The wealthy
discovered Jackson Hole, and the ultra-wealthy and the private jet set discovered it.
Now, Wyoming had never had a state income tax, so word of that got around, and by the time the
21st century rolled around, Jackson Hole had already become one of the most exclusive addresses
in America. But then came 2017, and what had been a slow transformation became something else
entirely. When Donald Trump signed his tax cuts into law that December, Wyoming became one of the
most attractive wealth destinations in the entire country. The new federal rules made it dramatically
easier for the ultra-wealthy to shield their assets, to establish trusts, and to relocate
their fortunes. Billionaires descended on Teton County, where Jackson Hole sits, the way David
Jackson's fellow trappers once descended into the valley itself. But these new men had not come to
work the land, they came to own the land. The transformation was as swift as it was staggering,
and for the people who had always called this place home, it was devastating. Teton County has
become something that economists and sociologists and political scientists are increasingly pointing
to as a warning, not just an example of inequality, a preview of it, a window into where this country
is heading if nothing changes. The numbers, which I like to dwell on, are almost impossible to
comprehend. The top 1% of households in Teton County now earn 221 times more than everyone
else who lives there, not twice as much, not 10 times as much, 221 times as much. The median home
price, which means half of all homes sell for more and half sell for less, has surpassed three
million dollars. What does that look like on the ground in the actual lived human reality of that
valley? It looks like this. The people who make that place work, the dishwashers, the landscapers,
the lift operators, the hotel housekeepers, many of them cannot afford to live anywhere near the
town where they spend their days. Some of them are sleeping in their cars. In Jackson Hole, Wyoming,
the richest country on earth, it was named for a working man, by working men, where working
men can no longer afford to live. So here's a question I want you to sit with this morning.
What if Jackson Hole isn't the exception? What if Jackson Hole is a bellwether for what's coming?
Because the same forces that turned one of America's most breathtaking mountain towns
into a place where working people cannot survive, those forces are no longer contained to one zip
code in Wyoming. They are reshaping this country, all of it, top to bottom, and those forces have
a friend in the White House. Nearly half of Americans today don't have enough savings to
cover a single $1,000 emergency. In the richest country on earth, millions of families are
essentially one car repair away from financial ruin. That's not a talking point. That's current
data from Bankrate. Even those who do have an emergency account, the average balance is now
about $5,000, roughly half of what it was last year. More than 40% of Americans say they've got
no emergency fund at all. None. A third of Americans say they couldn't cover even one
month of living expenses if they lost their income. A majority, 59%, say their savings
would last no more than three months. Forget about being a billionaire. Forget about even
being a millionaire. In Trump's America, millions of people are lucky, genuinely lucky, if they can
count themselves thousandaires. A report just this week found that more Americans than ever are
rating their 401k retirement savings, the money they set aside for retirement, for their retirement,
for their dignity in old age, just to cover mortgages and everyday bills. Not a lavish
vacation, not any kind of splurge. Their mortgage, their groceries, their gas. Here's what makes all
of this so striking. It isn't happening in a vacuum. It isn't happening because of bad luck
or some unavoidable force of nature. It's happening at the exact same moment that the people at the
very top of this economy are accumulating wealth at a pace that would make the robber barons blush.
Between 2017, the year of Trump's tax cuts, and 2025, the wealth of America's richest households
didn't grow. It exploded. According to a recent New York Times report, the net worth of the top
one percent grew by an astonishing 120 percent. The number of American billionaires jumped by
roughly 50 percent. That's the real divide in Trump's America. It's not red and blue. It's not
urban and rural. It's the people sleeping in their cars in Jackson Hole and the people who own the lodges
that they can see from the parking lot that they're sleeping in. That gap, that chasm, that's the story
of this moment. And this morning, we're going to follow it from one working man's valley in Wyoming
all the way to the halls of the United States government. Trump ran as a populist. He stood at
rallies across this country. He promised to fight for forgotten Americans, the workers, the veterans,
the people who felt left behind. But his signature economic policy, the 2017 tax cuts,
delivered its biggest rewards not to those forgotten Americans, but to corporations and
the wealthiest households in the country. Those tax cuts helped fuel a stock market surge that
minted hundreds of new billionaires. A huge share of those gains flowed upward as corporate taxes
were slashed and companies spent billions buying back their own shares. The people who already
owned most of those assets, the people who already possessed great wealth, became vastly richer. The
people who were already struggling, they're still struggling. In many cases, they're struggling
more. Which brings us to the part of the story that goes beyond economics. Because when wealth
concentrates this dramatically, when the distance between the top and everyone else becomes this
vast, it doesn't just reshape the economy. It begins to reshape power itself. In the last election
cycle, for every dollar donated by billionaires to Democrats, $5 went to Republicans. Much of that
money came from ultra-wealthy tech and finance figures who aligned themselves with Donald Trump's
tax cuts and deregulation agenda. And boy, did Trump deliver for them. At least a dozen billionaires
were given roles inside the Trump administration itself. Let that sink in for a moment. Not just
donors, not just advisors calling in from the outside, people who appear on the Forbes billionaires
list are running federal agencies, shaping federal policy, sitting inside the White House.
And it's not just at the federal level. Across this country, billionaires are pouring unprecedented
sums into races that most Americans barely know are happening. State Attorney General races,
county commission seats, increasingly the courts themselves. Think Pennsylvania's recent race for
State Attorney General. Nearly 90% of the outside money supporting that campaign came from one
single billionaire, the richest man in the state, who spent tens of millions of dollars backing his
preferred candidate. In Wisconsin, a state Supreme Court election last year became the most expensive
judicial race in American history, as billionaires from across the country, including notably Elon
Musk, flooded the race with millions of dollars. Elections that used to be decided by voters
are increasingly becoming contests measured by the billionaires who are bankrolling them.
Former Montana Governor and Republican National Committee Chairman Mark Rasico told the New York
Times he remembers a time when wealthy donors hesitated to give too much money to political
campaigns. They worried it might look like they were buying influence. How quaint.
Roughly three quarters of Americans want limits on how much money individuals or organizations
can spend on political campaigns. More than half of Americans, 53%, say billionaires themselves
pose a threat to democracy. Nearly 70% say the ultra-wealthy should play a smaller role
in American politics. 71% of Americans support some form of a billionaire tax. And almost everyone,
94% of Americans, agree that the wealth gap in this country is getting wider. That 94% should
be 100% because that's not an opinion, it's a fact. I want to be clear about something because
this argument gets mischaracterized. Most Americans are not angered by success. This
built on the idea of pulling yourself up by the bootstraps, on the promise that hard work and
ingenuity can take you anywhere. But that ideal assumes a level playing field. What Americans
resent, what they're telling us in poll after poll after poll is a system where the ultra-rich play
by one set of rules and everyone else plays by another. A system where wealth doesn't just buy
comfort, it buys wholesale impunity. Scott Ellis, a former technology executive and a member of a
group called Patriotic Millionaires that advocates for higher taxes on the ultra-wealthy,
put it with striking clarity, quote, at some point, there's nothing you can spend money on
that actually makes your life materially better. So money simply becomes power. The question for
us is not how much wealth we want other people to have, but how much power, end quote. How much
power? That question is at the heart of everything Americans are grappling with right now. And for
many of them, the Epstein scandal has come to symbolize exactly that kind of system.
One where immense wealth and powerful connections appear to place certain people
permanently above the rules that govern everyone else. The scandal pulled back the
curtain on what some lawmakers now call the Epstein class, a network of ultra-wealthy elites
whose status has time and again appeared to insulate them from any consequences whatsoever.
Or as Congressman Ro Khanna, a crusader for justice in the Epstein case, recently put it,
Most people don't begrudge people who do well and build wealth, but they begrudge the fact that if
they have a different set of rules and they begrudge the fact that they can't have a secure
economic future for their families. And I bring up the Epstein case for a reason. At last month's
hearing on the Epstein case, the attorney general, Pam Bondi, was asked a direct and specific
question about the case and the investigation. And this is what she said. None of them ask
Merrick Garland over the last four years, one word about Jeffrey Epstein.
How ironic is that? You know why? Because Donald Trump, the Dow, the Dow right now is over,
the Dow is over $50,000. I don't know why you're laughing. You're a great stock trader as I hear
Raskin. The Dow is over $50,000 right now. The S&P at almost $7,000. And the NASDAQ smashing
records, Americans 401ks and retirement savings are booming. That's what we should be talking about.
That's what we should be talking about. What officials like Pam Bondi appear not to understand
or perhaps understand perfectly and simply don't care about is that stock market numbers are cold
comfort to the one-third of Americans who couldn't survive a single month without a paycheck. They
are cold comfort to the families rating their retirement savings to pay rent. They mean nothing
to the workers in Jackson Hole, Wyoming, who are sleeping in their cars. There is now a resounding
sense across this country that the rules of the system have been rewritten quietly, deliberately,
and very much on purpose for a very small group at the very top. The same forces that reshaped
one working man's valley in Wyoming are reshaping towns and cities and counties across the United
States of America. As the midterm elections get underway, the question on voters' minds
is not complicated. In fact, it's very, very simple. Who does the American economy and our
democracy really work for anymore? The title for the event, the tour, Senator Sanders, that you've
been on called the Fighting Oligarchy Tour. This is one of those stops. I think one of the people
I think that you would consider an oligarch, and I think probably fits the textbook definition,
would be Jeff Bezos. Of course, one of two richest men in the world, depending on what
the stock is doing that day. And there's been an interesting debate that's opened up about taxes,
about tax fairness. Particularly different Democrats have had different proposals about
tax fairness. And I want to play something he said about his own tax verdict and get your response,
Mr. Plattner, and yours, Senator Sanders. This is what he had to say about the idea of doubling his
taxes and that it wouldn't really help very much. Take a listen. If people want me to pay more
billions, then let's have that debate. But don't pretend that that's going to solve the problem.
You could double the taxes I pay, and it's not going to help that teacher in Queens. I promise
you. Mr. Plattner, what do you think of that? No, I think it's abject nonsense. I think that's
what somebody says when they don't want to see their taxes go up. There's absolutely no question
that if we target the wealth where it has been hoarded, frankly, for decades at this point,
and we pull it back into our system and put it into social programs like health care, like child
care, like paying teachers what they are worth, we will absolutely improve the lives of working
Americans and, quite frankly, improve our society as a whole. I think what he is pitching is
propaganda. It's meant to protect himself and protect his crony friends. And we're going to
come after them for it. Senator, he also pivoted to an idea of like cutting taxes. No one in the
50 percent would pay any taxes. There have been a lot of Democrats, interestingly, proposing things
along that line, big exemptions at the bottom. I think Senator Booker has a version. Senator Van
Hollen. People, I think, who talk about this progressive. Congresswoman AOC has come out
against it, saying, look, the best way that we build a kind of society and tax system that works
for all is that everyone's paying in and everyone's benefiting, more like what we see around Social
Security, Medicare, more we see in Europe. Where are you on that? Well, what I know is that today
we have more income and wealth inequality than we have ever had in the history of this country,
much worse than the so-called Gilded Age. And I know that at a time when the top 1 percent
owns more wealth than the bottom 93 percent, when people like Bezos and Musk own more wealth
than, you know, so many Americans combined. Musk himself owns more wealth than the bottom 53 percent
of American households. Meanwhile, the effective tax rate of billionaires is lower than that of a
nurse or a truck driver. So, of course, we need to demand that the wealthiest people in this country,
the billionaire class, start paying their fair share of taxes, which is why I've introduced
legislation calling for a 5 percent annual tax on the wealth of billionaires. That's less than
1,000 Americans. And, Chris, if we do that, we raise enough revenue to provide a $3,000 check
for every man, woman and child in families under 150,000. We can make sure that everybody who is
thrown off of healthcare by Trump gets reinstated. And we could do enormous things for the American
people. The point is, there is so much inequality right now that taxes on billionaires can transform
life for the working class of this country, which is right now struggling to pay the bills.
Mr. Plattner, you're trying to make the case to the folks in your home state of Maine
to vote out a five-term incumbent, someone who's been a real, I think it's fair to say,
institution in Maine life and comes from a sort of political family and has been there for a very
long time, probably has name recognition north of 99 percent, I think it's fair to say, in Maine,
who has beaten back other challenges. What is different this time? What is the case for why
Mainers should turn away from someone who has been such an institution in that state through
Democratic and Republican institutions? Well, I mean, quite frankly, because as an institution,
she has overseen the deterioration of material conditions for working people in this state.
I mean, where we are today is worse than where we were when she entered the Senate. We have fewer
hospitals. We have fewer schools. Housing has become an abject nightmare for younger people
in the state and elderly, for that matter. We have seen people living on fixed incomes,
see their benefits continue to stay small while the price of everything else goes up.
She has been in the U.S. Senate through all of this. And more importantly, she has votes on her
record time and time again that show that she is not willing to go out of her way to either stand
up to Donald Trump, stand up the Republican Party or stand up on behalf of the working people in
her state. She had a charade for a long time that she was an independent. I think that charade is
very much come to an end because of the reality that we're living in. But it's not going to keep
the people that support her from dumping in as much money as they possibly can. The billionaire
backers of Susan Collins, they know the stakes of this race. Any road to a Democratic Senate
goes to the state of Maine. They're spending accordingly. And I will say for those watching,
if you want to help out, grant for Senate dot com, we can really use it.
Senator, your thoughts as someone who's known and worked with, you know, I mean,
obviously across the aisle, but you're you know, you're one state over. You've known
Susan Collins for a long time. What do you think about Mr. Plattner's chances?
Well, I think Graham is going to win and I think he is going to win because the people in Maine,
the people in Vermont, people all over this country understand that right now the economy
is totally rigged. So what's going on right now? People on top have never, ever had it so good.
While working families struggle, our elderly people can't afford their prescription drugs,
while young people, everything being equal, have a lower standard of living than their parents.
So what kind of economy is that? And the people also understand, as Graham just said,
that the political system, campaign finance, totally rigged. Does anybody in their right
mind think that it's a good idea for our democracy that billionaires can pour unbelievable amounts of
money to defeat candidates like Graham or other progressive candidates around the country?
That's a corrupt campaign finance system and nibbling around the edges and establishment
politics and a little bit of this and a little bit of that. We're beyond that right now.
The system is broken. The system is corrupt. The system is dominated by the billionaire class.
People want real change in Maine, in Vermont and all over this country.
That is why Graham is going to win.
I saw an article yesterday, we were starting to get some of the money filings for these
independent expenditures. Who are the biggest donors in this cycle? Mark Andreessen, who's a
big right wing tech guy who is one of the most zealous boosters of AI and right wing politics
and says things on podcasts like no one should ever engage in self-reflection. It's an actual
quote. He's actually the number one donor in this cycle so far. I think it's $115 million he's given
so far. Senator Sanders, the last thing for you, because you've been spending some time
talking and thinking about AI in ways I found interesting. I've watched some of your videos.
I've listened to some of what you said. The Pope, first American Pope Leo, had a very interesting
address on AI, talking about the possibility and the peril of it and comparing it to the
of a biblical tower of Babel. How do you think about that interest as it sort of lingers
over this campaign? I think it's a huge issue. I think every American should be thinking,
what does it mean when the very wealthiest people in this country, Musk, Bezos, Zuckerberg,
Ellison and others, are spending hundreds and hundreds of billions of dollars to develop and
implement AI and robotics? What does it mean when Jeff Bezos is putting together a hundred
billion dollar fund to quote-unquote automate factories? What it means is that tens of millions
of jobs in the next decade will likely be disappearing. And what happens to the working
class of this country then? What it also means is that we have to worry about our politics,
putting stuff on television where people or on social media, people will not know the difference
between what's true and what is made up and false. We got to worry about the existential threat,
Chris, because scientists tell us that as AI becomes smarter than human beings, it could become
independent of human control with potentially catastrophic results. It is a huge issue. And
the billionaires and big tech say, hey, we don't want any regulation. And Trump says, we don't want
any regulation. Let us do whatever we want. The hell with what happens. Well, I think the American
people disagree. It's an issue of great importance in this campaign. In fact, final little note is
that last week they're going to put out their first ever regulation on it, which is going to
be voluntary. And the president's number one AI man, David Sachs, called him at the last minute
because industry didn't want it. And they canceled it. Lo and behold. So that did not get it as well.
Yes. Vermont Senator Bernie Sanders, Maine Senate candidate Graham Plattner here on this Memorial
Day, and they will be doing that rally later today. I appreciate you gentlemen making time for
us on this day. There is no problem of racist speech on campus. There is no problem with racism.
There is no problem with sexism. These or to the extent there is a problem, it is not very big.
One of the reasons multiculturalism was able to get off the ground in the first place is that most
college age students and especially those who are attending our top universities are not bigots.
There are very few who are. And so I think one of the really big problems we have to come to
grips with is this sense in which the reason we have racial tensions in our society, the reason
we have other kinds of tensions is not because there is a problem with racism and other forms
of oppression, but because people are looking for these things too much. That was then 28 year old
Peter Thiel promoting his book at an event hosted by the Heritage Foundation in 1996.
The book was titled The Diversity Myth, Multiculturalism and the Politics of
Intolerance at Stanford. Thiel co-authored the book with David Sachs, who is the focus of an
extensive piece out this week in The Atlantic titled The Venture Capitalist Populist, how David
Sachs and the New Tech Right went full MAGA and captured Washington. And we'll talk in a minute
about how that actually may not be good for MAGA in the long run. But with us now again, the author
of that piece, staff writer at The Atlantic, George Packer. Back by popular demand, George,
the kids were crying out like voices in the wilderness, more Packer, more Packer. So here you
are. I wanted to talk about three people, David Sachs, who you've profiled, Elon Musk and Peter
Thiel, all of them either from South Africa or spent formative years in South Africa. I know you
don't piece them together that way, but I just think it's fascinating that three people either
from or people that spent formative time in South Africa would have such a powerful impact. And also
all three, and we can go through it specifically, are harshly critical of Western democracy and do
not think that liberal democracy is the preferred form of government. Talk about
David Sachs and his views and the others as far as you're comfortable talking about them.
Well, I've spent quite a bit of time with Thiel some years ago when I was writing about him. And
you're absolutely right that Thiel has famously said freedom and democracy are incompatible,
meaning for him to be able to live his life as he wants and make money as he wants is impossible
under a liberal democracy where people who have the vote who don't believe in his libertarian
views. Sachs is not very interested in political philosophy. In my research, he is an entrepreneur
and a venture capitalist, and he is mostly interested in making money. So he and Thiel
go way back to Stanford. They were at the Stanford Review together, which was a conservative
publication Thiel founded. They then were at PayPal, which Thiel co-founded with Musk,
and where Sachs played an important part. They have a long history. And now what's really
interesting, Joe, is how having kept their distance on Washington, because they really
didn't believe in any role for government in their industry, in technology, they now have
kind of captured the Trump administration. And Sachs spent a year as Trump's AI and crypto advisor.
And in that year, he essentially aligned government policy with the wishes of those industries,
and not with what I would consider more the public interest. And so in a way,
they've now come around having been hardcore libertarians all their lives, to a view that
government can actually be useful to their financial interests, their business interests,
and their sense that really the world should be ruled by a small number of very smart,
very wealthy men, which is, I guess, a word for all of you.
Well, you know, they believe in capitalism when it comes to single mothers, who they think should
pull themselves up by their bootstraps. But when it comes to tech billionaires,
they're all for socialism, all for the federal government giving them money and helping them out.
Well, Sachs didn't. I mean, Sachs hasn't, he said, accused the United States of provoking Putin
into war with Ukraine. And again, in other ways, again, sort of aligned himself with Putin,
Orban, and sort of that anti-liberal democracy, right?
He has. And for a long time, I couldn't understand how someone who really does
seem to care about facts and about logic and is a very good debater on his podcast
could end up sympathetic to the Russian role in invading Ukraine and trying to destroy that
country and absorb it into the Russian empire. To be charitable, he's pretty ignorant about the
history of that region and the politics of that region. But the way I came to see it was of a
piece with his approach to business, which is essentially, there's no moral calculation here.
It's not about whether Ukraine has the right to sovereignty, whether we should support
a democratic country under siege from an authoritarian empire. None of that seems
to come into play. And so once you take away the moral analysis of that war, you end up thinking,
well, Ukraine's a risky bet. As Trump once said, they don't seem to have the cards,
although actually right now they do have some cards. And you end up sympathizing with Putin
and Russia because morality has been replaced by a cold calculation of where your interests lie.
And maybe if you're afraid of escalation toward World War III, well, that's going to be bad
for your portfolio. And so let's tone this down and give Putin what he wants.
That's my best analysis of how Sachs is in the ridiculous position that he holds.
It is a ridiculous position, Claire McCaskill. But here you have, and of course,
we haven't even talked about Elon Musk from South Africa, but yet another person whose
formative years were influenced in South Africa, having a disproportionate influence
on American government right now. These sort of billionaire tech overlords who see themselves
as sort of gods who are beyond reproach. And with Elon Musk, you have somebody who
will tell you that was not a Nazi salute. It certainly looked like a Nazi salute to
most of the free world. But he regularly calls Democratic allies tyrants. He promotes
the most extreme far right groups that have ties to fascism. He promotes conspiracy theories and
hate speech on X. And again, just generally seems to be a skeptic of Western democracy,
of liberal democracy, of the democracy that has been responsible for the American century,
and I will say also responsible for the liberation of more people out of poverty
than any other political system. Yeah. And the interesting thing about these
tech bros is that a lot of the people who have bent the knee to Donald Trump that were in
positions of power in various institutions, law firms, universities, they did so out of fear.
But I think George has hit on something here that I think we don't underline enough.
These guys are bending the knee because of opportunity. They see a guy who can be moved
easily with flattery and wealth and coming in with a lot of bravado. And they've used those
positions to get what they want out of Donald Trump. Now, the problem for him is politically,
what that does to the MAGA base. Because when I saw those billionaires surrounding him at the
inaugural, and when I look at the omelet line at Mar-a-Lago and who is surrounding Donald Trump
there, and all the gold and all the guilt, at some point, the MAGA base, which does not look
anything like Peter Thiel or Sachs or Musk, they begin to go, wait a minute, is this guy really
for me because he doesn't even understand that gas prices are killing me? Talk about how this
romance is hurting Donald Trump with his base. And I think one evidence is just yesterday,
the White House announced that after claiming that all the concerns about AI safety were just
Biden-era wokeness, they abolished his safety institute, AI Safety Institute.
They're now backtracking and saying, actually, we are going to have AI models report their safety
tests to the government. Why? Exactly as Senator McCaskill has said, because their base, their
populist base, mostly working class, is afraid of AI. The numbers make that clear. And they don't
see it quite the same way that David Sachs and Peter Thiel do. One more thing I wanted to say,
Joe, you mentioned Western democracy. These guys use the phrase Western civilization
as a kind of flag that they're waving when they criticize the European democracies.
But what do they mean by it? That's the real puzzle. Because if Donald Trump, who tried to
overthrow an elected government, is the embodiment of Western civilization, it doesn't mean to them
what it means to me and maybe to you. Well, I mean, it's what's so bizarre. They talk about
Western civilization as a code word. I don't know if there's some racial aspect to, quote,
Western civilization. But the great irony is Western civilization is defined Churchill, 1940,
Battle of Britain, U.S. troops scaling the cliffs of Normandy to save Western civilization,
to save Europe from Soviet tyranny. And now they reject, when they're talking about Western
democracy, the freedom fighters in Ukraine and blame everybody but Vladimir Putin. It is truly
bizarre. George Packer, thank you for coming back on Morning Joe. George Packer, The One Man Show,
will continue on Morning Joe indefinitely. But right now you can read his new piece online.
It'll be in this month's issue of The Atlantic magazine. George,
thank you so much. We greatly appreciate it. Should billionaires be taxed based on their wealth?
A new ballot initiative in California says yes, but the Democratic governor out there says no.
Joining us, former California Democratic Senator Barbara Boxer, professor of public policy
and economics at the University of Michigan's Ford School of Public Policy, Betsy Stevenson,
and politics reporter at Semaphore, Dave Weigel. Dave, lay out the foundation of this for us. What
exactly is this California initiative asking for? Well, you set it up pretty well. It's asking for
a tax on wealth, not income taxes. The question of how to tax wealth, which has been around for
quite a while, which Elizabeth Warren really attacked in the 2020 campaign, was what to do
about the capital and pieces of wealth owned by billionaires, how to get some revenue from that
for the state. The referendum would do that, would come up with a way to do that, and they've
attracted, by my count this morning, it's still coming in with tens of millions of dollars into
a PAC funded by billionaires to stop it. The argument being that the state benefits right
now from having billionaires in it. It benefits from the IPOs they create, the taxes the state
gets from those. You'd waste that all if you just come up with any mechanism to take their
wealth away because they can quit. And California, you've seen Gavin Newsom's role in this. Newsom
doesn't like this idea because California is competing with other states. They can promise
zero taxation of the resources and assets we're talking about to these billionaires.
So doesn't he have a point, Barbara? We've seen in other states that have tried to pass a wealth
tax or who have passed a wealth tax, those billionaires, those very rich people, move to
friendlier places. Lots of movement, for instance, to Florida. Absolutely. And it's happening right
here, right now, before the vote. A couple of the founders of Google. I mean, it makes me really sad
that people are so interested in building so much wealth that they can't even stay in the state that
made them wealthy. But that is the fact. I have a tremendous amount of respect for Gavin Newsom.
I know he sees where the taxes are coming from. We don't want to lose high-income people. I just
want to say one thing in closing this. Let's look at the big picture. This has to be done at the
national level. I agree with Elizabeth Warren, and I agree with her bill, and I would be a
co-sponsor of it. There's only 75,000 individuals worth $50 million or more in this country.
They are paying, on average, a lower effective rate than a teacher or a nurse or a truck driver.
And then you put on top of that the big, beautiful bill, which gave these people even more.
We need to do something. It ought to be at the national level. Otherwise, people will move around
and states will get hurt. Betsy, how do you get at it, though? Because I think the senator's right
to bring up the federal aspect of this, that people can just move around. It's got to be a federal
bill. But how do you actually get at the wealth fairly? Because a lot of these CEOs,
one of the reasons why they pay such a low tax rate is that they don't have an income,
or they have a very low income on paper when they're actually accumulating quite a bit of money
through stocks and equity, et cetera. How do you get at that fairly?
Well, I mean, one thing is that we have designed a system that allows them to pretend that they
have very little income, even though they spend as if they have a lot of income. What they do
is that income stays tied up in stocks that are appreciating in value. So they can see on paper
they're getting wealthier. They go to banks. They structure financial deals so that they can borrow
against that. I want to just emphasize for people the difference between thinking about
millionaire tax, like think about Washington state that's trying to introduce an income tax
only on the amount of income people earn above a million, and a tax on billionaires.
If you're a millionaire in wealth, you could spend $100,000 a year and you'd be out of money in 10
years. A billionaire can spend $100,000 a year for 10,000 years. So that is a long time that
they get to spend a ton of money. And one of the things that makes me sad is that people would
leave a state like California because they don't want to pay 5% in taxes when they can't actually
spend that wealth in their lifetime. And what they're basically saying is-
Why don't they want to? What's the holdup? Why?
I think it's because of their ego. They think that they know what to do best.
And so that's really about power more than it is about spending. And I think if we're going to be
in a democracy, they need to give some of that power back to the rest of the voters, to the
government that the voters have elected, to provide the things that the society wants.
So there are some federal moves to try to get this done. Congress has been working on a few
different proposals. There's also a proposal by a couple of Democratic senators, Dave,
that doesn't talk about taxing billionaires, but instead talks about taking away income tax
from people who make- I think in one of the scenarios, it's less than $80,000. And in
another scenario, it's a little bit less than that. So there's an effort being made here.
I think there are people in Congress who realize that this is a political necessity and perhaps
something that they can win with in the next election cycle.
It's a very chaotic debate inside the party because- I can't even limit it to two factions,
but let's say generally there's one faction of Democrats who say we need to get elected and
it's worth paying taxes in order to get better health care, to get better transportation,
to get better services, etc. And there's the other faction of Democrats that are worried
that just doesn't work. It's too easy to demagogue their failures in big cities sometimes.
Sometimes there are failures that people are paying a lot of money for. You ask somebody in
an expensive part of San Francisco if they're getting services as good as somebody in a good
part of San Jose. There are real debates inside the Democratic Party about whether that works.
What you're seeing from Chris Van Hollen, Cory Booker, and in California from Katie Porter
is this promise from Democrats that we're going to shrink the tax base, get more people who are
making less money off of it so they pay nothing and they can spend money on themselves, and tax
the the ultra-rich more. It's very contentious because to a lot of Democrats that says you're
never going to get the kind of welfare state that a lot of them joined the party to create
if you tell people that taxation is inherently bad, you're better off if you're not paying it,
but if you make too much money, if you're a billionaire, then you should be paying for
everybody else. They worry that's a very slippery slope and you lose the argument that makes people
want to vote for Democrats in the first place. I think people would love to pay more taxes
given no one wants to pay more taxes, but I think it would be easier to swallow if services were
rendered for those taxes, good services were rendered, and I think you bring up a good point
that even in places where taxes are very high, the services can feel a little wanting. Dave,
always good to have you. Just to be on the record so I don't mess it up, Van Hollen's
proposal is no income tax for individuals under $46,000, married couples making under $92,000.
Senator Booker, the number is slightly different. It's for individuals under $3,500,000
and for married couples under $75,000. All right, Dave Weigel, Barbara Boxer,
thank you guys so much for joining us. For more on this, maybe he's got an answer.
Matt Stoller joins me. He's the director of research at the American Economic Liberties
Project. He's also the author of Goliath, the 100-Year War Between Monopoly Power
and Democracy. Matt, welcome to the show. Thank you for being with us.
Hey, thanks for having me.
Matt, I'm beginning to think that this is one of those things that is going to start to dissolve
around party lines because a whole lot of people who validly supported Donald Trump because he said
he would make things fairer for them understand what everybody else understands, that nothing
has become fairer for the working person in America. Yeah, I think that's right. We have
a billionaire crisis and that's pretty obvious to everyone. And I think you hit it on the nail
on the head when you talked about the Epstein class and brought that up because the Epstein
class really signifies, for the first time that I've ever seen, that the culture war that we've
usually had between the left and the right, working people on both sides, is now actually
tilted towards the billionaire class because people are starting to realize that billionaires
are seizing control of our politics while life for ordinary Americans is getting harder. And
billionaires are even ruining our industry. So this is a crisis and it's something that I think
people are now increasingly aware of. And look, I want to be clear. This has been going on for a
long time, decades, not just a couple of years. But the 2017 tax cuts and last year's big,
beautiful bill did things to accelerate this in. I mean, it's supercharged the billionaire class.
Yeah, I think you can. I mean, in 1980, there were less than a handful of billionaires. And
today there are thousands of billionaires. And it's not because inflation increased and so
the same net worth is just a little bit higher today. No, in fact, what has happened is we
have structured our economy around creating billionaires and something like the Trump tax
cuts, both versions of it, but also a whole set of policies, regulatory policies, enforcement
priorities, facilitates the increase of wealth at the very top. I mean, you can look at something
like, you know, on Monday, the Trump administration tried to settle and effectively pardoned the
company Ticketmaster, which is run by someone who is near a billionaire, maybe a billionaire.
And when that happened, the stock popped by 7% and the CEO, who is the largest shareholder,
his net worth pretty dramatically increased in a different example would be Paramount is now trying
to buy Warner. And that is going to lead to huge layoffs. There's all sorts of political scandals
about it. But the CEO of Warner Brothers, David Zaslav, is going to earn 500 to 600 million dollars
in the transaction and become a billionaire. So it's not just that, oh, sad people are becoming
wealthy and these policies help increase their wealth. It's also that our jobs and our welfare
is worsening precisely because our wealth is being stolen and appropriated by these
extremely wealthy guys and the political leaders who are abetting them.
And one of the things you write a lot about is that monopoly is not a it's not an economic thing.
I mean, it's thought of as economics, but you discuss how the monopoly is a democratic problem.
Right. A monopoly is just basically a dictatorship of an industry,
right? It's political control. And it just happens to be in the economic sphere.
But if you talk to somebody who works in any monopolized industries, increasingly,
most of our industries are controlled by a small group of either one company or a small group of
them. If you talk to people in that industry, they are scared of that that dominant player.
They won't talk about it because they are frightened. And that's not just a question of,
oh, their bank account shows a certain number of zeros or not. That is a function of their liberty.
And I'm you know, look, poor people are afraid to speak out. But at this point,
even wealthier people, if you're not super wealthy, even wealthier people are afraid
to speak out because of the level of control in our economy and everything from meatpacking
to entertainment to, you know, to row crops, you know, whatever, wherever you look,
it's it's dominant control. And so when you start to see more authoritarianism coming into politics,
it's because people have gotten used to that authoritarianism in their daily life,
in their their way they work and who they sell to and who they buy from and so on and so forth.
Well, it's an important conversation because everybody's leaning into the conversation of
affordability. But it's not a matter you solve unto itself. It is a policy issue that has to
be discussed that will result in greater affordability or at least greater wealth for
working and middle class people. We'll have that discussion another time. Matt,
thank you, as always. Matt Stoller is the director of research for the American Economic
Liberties Project and the author of Goliath, the 100 Year War Between Monopoly Power and Democracy.
