What Movies Lose When They Use "Blender Cutting"

Fantastic behind the scenes
10 followers
1 Video View·May 29, 2026
I came across this clip of Thelma Schoonmaker quoting Scorsese recently about the loss of "the shot" to what she calls "blender cutting" and thought it would be fun to try to dive into what separates these two while highlighting what makes the shot.
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThis video examines the cinematic shot as the fundamental unit of storytelling, contrasting intentional composition and movement with \"blender cutting\"—the modern trend of rapid, mindless editing. It argues that true visual engagement stems from deliberate choices in perspective and motion rather than superficial speed or technical shortcuts.
Do you know what I mean if I say blender cutting?
That's Thelma Shoemaker, the editor of most of Martin Scorsese's movies,
and one of the greatest editors of all time.
You can find examples of this that are so extreme they've become memes.
Fast editing itself isn't necessarily the problem, even Thelma uses quick cuts effectively at times.
So what's really missing here?
The shot begins as they drag the prisoner to a hospital bed.
FBI agent Carl Hanratty, played by Tom Hanks, has finally caught up with Frank Abagnale,
and he's not about to let him die before they can go to trial.
As Carl confronts the prison warden, the camera pushes in for a dramatic two-shot.
Suddenly, the warden notices something.
The camera pans to follow his gaze.
The warden and the viewer have the same thought,
as the camera is already lining up the composition for a dramatic reveal.
As the chase begins, the camera pushes in on Hanratty's amused face.
This is the shot.
We swoop down past prisoners cheering and pounding against the chain-link fence to reveal
Frank as he stumbles forward in his desperate escape attempt.
As he forces himself onto his feet to continue,
he looms over the camera before falling to his knees in front of us.
This is the shot.
Finally caught at the end of the line, Frank falls backward into feet.
Now the camera looms over Frank.
There's nowhere left to go.
The camera drifts upwards.
And even though this is the start of the film, we know we've flashed forward to the end of the story.
This is the shot.
And the shot is what's lost when blender cutting is used.
A shot is the fundamental unit of filmmaking.
But what's the difference between a shot, I mean any old shot,
and what Thelma and Scorsese are calling the shot?
For me, one of the undisputed masters of the shot is Steven Spielberg.
There are many directors who excel at crafting the shot in different ways,
but I think what draws me to Spielberg specifically
is that he has a way of crafting an incredibly engaging shot that kind of
sneaks up on you a little bit.
Here's what I mean.
This shot from Jaws is so deceptively simple yet brilliant.
If you look at a still frame, there may not appear to be much going on.
It's just a camera on a tripod on a ferry.
The scene runs for a minute and 42 seconds as a single shot.
And here the mayor is confronting police chief Martin Brody about his decision to
shut down the beaches to protect people from the killer shark.
In the original screenplay by Peter Benchley,
this scene takes place with the character standing on the beach.
But Spielberg makes the simple yet brilliant choice of placing it on an active ferry,
adding additional visual interest to the scene through the constantly changing background.
Spielberg could have been like, hey, this is cool.
That's all we need to do.
But he takes it even further.
He's also blocking the characters within the frame in a way
that varies their height and groups them together into triangles
using rules of composition that go all the way back to classical painting tradition
in order to create a sense of balance and visual interest in how the characters are staged.
Chief Brody looks and feels cornered on the ferry.
He literally and figuratively in this scene has his back against a wall.
And even though the shifting background already adds interesting movement to the scene,
Spielberg still uses blocking to change the composition
and break up this single shot into smaller chunks,
essentially getting three different compositions out of this single shot.
This is the shot.
You never have to cut.
It's never boring because your eye always has something fresh to look at.
The setting and motion keep the visuals interesting,
and the staging of the characters reinforces the emotional conflict of the scene.
If you pay close attention to Spielberg's filmmaking,
you'll often find these kinds of attributes in his shots.
Movement that creates visual interest
and compositions that change and develop throughout the shot,
along with staging that expresses the emotional conflict of the scene.
Even for something as simple as this two shot at a table in Jaws,
he adds a swinging lamp overhead to create movement in the shadows
and then uses the blocking of the characters
to create all these different compositions within a single take.
Spielberg definitely wasn't the first and certainly isn't the only director
to use these kinds of layered developing compositions.
He's just particularly good at it.
You can find more great examples of this kind of unfolding shot
in movies like Robert Altman's Three Women.
Here, a single shot develops across three individually interesting compositions.
For a more contemporary example, check out this shot from Tar,
which uses both mirrors and depth to add visual interest to a completely static shot.
And I've seen a lot of people talk about this long take from Tar,
which uses developing composition very well,
but there are many examples of this kind of thing on a subtler scale throughout the film.
This simple scene unfolds across one unbroken take,
which develops from here to here, then from this to this, before finally landing here.
You could, of course, construct these kinds of scenes
in a way that allows you to cut between each of the compositions,
and that might be the safer option.
But the movements between each composition adds a sense of visual interest
and lends the scene a sense of space and continuity that you lose when you cut.
I should probably point out that when I talk about developing composition,
I'm not just talking about movement.
There are plenty of movies I see these days
where movement is used within a shot to change the composition.
But frequently, these shots don't feel as interesting and satisfying as,
say, for example, Spielberg's.
But what actually makes the difference?
As usual with filmmaking, the devil is in the details.
Great developing compositions usually have a sense of precision in how they unfold.
Movements are smooth and well-timed,
and the compositions the camera moves between
are just as intentionally composed as any static shot.
In contrast, much of what I see from, let's call it the default style of movement today,
has a kind of jello-y mushiness to it.
On top of that, there's often very little variety in how the camera moves.
Instead of a combination of zooming, panning, tracking, tilting,
and booming that have provided expressive variety to camera movement throughout film history,
these days I frequently see the camera just kind of floating along at eye level.
This, of course, is mostly due to the rise in popularity of steadicams and gimbals,
two tools which make handheld camera work much smoother
and which have come to replace the dolly or crane as the default for camera movement.
These tools are by no means bad.
They've produced incredible work.
Many of the long takes we've talked about would have been impossible without them.
I also understand why productions are drawn to them.
They take less equipment and setup time than dollies or cranes,
saving time, money, and creating a lot more flexibility on location.
But I think this flexibility often results in a lack of intentionality,
and because of the way these tools work, less variety in types of movement.
I don't want the takeaway here to be steadicam bad, dolly good.
Ultimately, it's about choosing the right tool for the job and how you use it.
The best directors and cinematographers I know of understand how a tripod,
steadicam, handheld, or dolly shot all have their own unique feeling
and use that specificity of feeling to help tell their story.
There's a shot I've thought about a lot from Martin Scorsese's movie,
The Last Temptation of Christ.
Here, Jesus is walking alone, and he thinks he hears someone,
perhaps God, walking behind him.
He turns to look, and the camera pushes forward, as if it's moving towards something.
But there's nothing there.
It pans back to Jesus as he starts walking again,
and then he and the camera turn to look once more.
Who's that? Who's following me? Is that you?
When moving the camera, it's common for directors to have the camera
follow the action within the scene.
This is called motivating the camera movement.
Often you'll want to match the speed and rhythm of the camera with the object it's tracking,
or if you change direction or start a new move from a static point,
you do so because the camera picks up the action of someone or something moving past.
All of this helps the camera work to feel more seamless and invisible,
as if it's reacting to or simply a part of the movement within the frame.
But here in The Last Temptation of Christ, the camera goes beyond following an action.
It has a life of its own.
It doesn't just turn when Jesus turns.
It also moves forward for a closer look.
It's as if the camera itself and the mind of the film are asking a question.
This is the shot as expression.
The camera isn't just trying to create visual interest or convey the action
and dialogue of the scene in an interesting way.
It's trying to use the language of its own movement and perspective to communicate something.
Sometimes we can get a clear idea of what the symbolism of a specific shot is expressing,
but we don't have to for a shot to be expressive.
Sometimes the expressiveness of the camera is more mysterious, poetic, and lyrical.
Is this beautiful shot from Charlotte Wells' After Sun
expressing the relaxed haziness of a summer vacation or a more detached disassociation?
It might be both.
Wells herself doesn't necessarily need to have a concrete idea of what the shot means
for the audience to find the shot meaningful within the context of the film.
She might.
But intention can just as easily mean a well-developed intuition for
the emotional landscape of a shot within the overall visual language of a film.
Sometimes it's the camera's perspective that's expressing something.
This can be both intentional and unintentional.
I know you're familiar with the male gaze,
and someone like Alfred Hitchcock both embodies this
and at times made movies that were drawing your attention
to the voyeurism the movie itself was providing.
But what about the gaze of death?
In The Sound of Falling, there are many shots that seem to come from some perspective.
But as the film continues, you begin to feel that this perspective
isn't inhabited by any of the characters we see in the film.
Instead, it seems much more likely to be the perspective of
a ghost or something that's haunting the film,
which the characters within occasionally perceive.
There's a nearly endless number of things a shot can express,
or ways that a shot can express things.
Many of the shots in Sometimes I Think About Dying
seem to express how disconnected and cut off the main character feels from the world around her.
This shot from Agnes Varda's Cleo from 5-7
expresses what the character is feeling after receiving a diagnosis from her doctor.
There's no set of rules for how to express something using a shot.
It's quite literally an art, not a science.
And not every shot needs to express something,
but using the shot to express a feeling or idea is yet another way of creating the shot.
When we think of a great shot,
I think there are two common types of shots that immediately spring to mind.
The first is a shot with incredibly bold, striking, or beautiful imagery.
These are the shots that stand out and become iconic,
sustaining our attention and lingering in our memory
simply on the basis of their visual impact alone.
These kinds of shots are very popular in the internet age
because you can often capture what's impressive about them with a single static frame.
These shots help you avoid blender cutting,
simply because you don't need to cut away to keep people's attention.
Our interest is held by the sheer beauty of the shot itself.
The features that make for these kinds of beautiful shots in film
are as varied as the elements that create beauty in paintings or photographs.
They often feature vibrant color, intense contrast,
chiaroscuro lighting, dramatic atmosphere,
or compositions that are either extremely balanced
or which have a lot of angular graphic contrast.
You might use maximalist complexity to create visual interest
or minimalist simplicity.
You might use a vibrant array of colors or a muted monochromatic palette.
Sometimes beauty is simply found in the quality of the light itself
or by placing the camera in a surprising or unusual location.
Park Chan-wook is the master of this right now.
There aren't really any rules for creating this kind of shot.
I'm often amazed just how much a little bit of depth,
some well-composed reflections,
or subtle movement within the frame can add to a shot.
Whatever you can do to make something beautiful or eye-catching will work.
But while this kind of beauty and eye candy
certainly are some great examples of the shot,
I don't think this kind of iconic shot is the only thing Marty and Thelma had in mind.
Iconic imagery is just one way to create visual interest
and hold an audience's attention without cutting.
But it's possible to do the same thing in other ways,
and I don't want to overlook the shots that might seem less impressive
based on a single frame,
but which really come to life when we see how they unfold over time.
For example, I often see people reference this shot from Fargo,
and don't get me wrong, it's beautiful.
But I think this other shot from the film is just as great.
Yet what makes it interesting relies more on the movement within the frame,
and it's less likely to be cited as a single frame example of a beautiful shot.
Some of the most evocative shots of all time rely on movement.
This shot from Tarkovsky's The Mirror is a favorite of mine,
and it's beautiful if you look at a single frozen frame,
but the true magic comes to life when you see it in motion.
The gust of wind is so ethereal that when I first saw it,
I assumed it must have just been one of the luckiest accidents ever caught on camera,
but it was totally intentional and incredibly well planned out.
What's creating the wind are helicopters sitting just out of frame to the right,
spinning up their blades.
Let's talk about the other kind of dramatically impressive shot
that usually comes up when we talk about this subject.
The polar opposite of blender cutting.
Long takes have been a fascination of filmmakers since the medium was invented.
The rise of their popularity in the last several decades has been
to some extent influenced by digital cameras making them easier to pull off,
but I also think the trend of long takes has been a creative reaction
against faster cutting becoming more of the stylistic norm.
Like the iconic shots, I also love the long takes.
Scorsese has used them to wonderful effect,
and many filmmakers from Alfonso Cuarón to Alejandro Iñárritu
have pushed this kind of thing much further.
Yet I had kind of started to think that maybe the super long take
was getting a little played out, until
I saw this 36-minute take from Begon's criminally under-talked-about Resurrection.
It's one of the most impressive examples of a long take I've ever seen,
proving that there's still room for innovation in the long take.
And while long takes exist on a spectrum from effective and immersive
to somewhat performative gimmick,
overall I'd usually much rather watch this kind of thing than a generic blender cut scene.
But simply refusing to cut isn't necessarily what makes the shot.
I've seen examples of longer or medium-length takes recently
that feel to me just as generic as more traditionally cut scenes.
This long take from Moonlight, for example, works well because
there's a lot of variety of composition and movement throughout.
It starts as a frame that doesn't feel like a tracking shot,
it then evolves into one,
before spinning into something much more evocative and expressive,
and then finally landing back at a much more traditional composition.
But there are even long takes on a tripod that work,
so the real risk of the long take is that it feels incidental rather than intentional,
as if the filmmakers are doing a long take just for the sake of doing it.
If cutting just for the sake of cutting is ineffective storytelling,
then I'd say not cutting just for the sake of not cutting is also ineffective.
The key is intention and whether the creative choice works for the scene or the story.
But if it's not sheer iconographic beauty or the lack of cuts that makes for the shot,
then what's the secret?
Like most artistic endeavors, it's hard to define any concrete attributes.
I'd even argue it's impossible to come up with a formula because part of what
makes something creatively interesting is its ability to surprise us with something new.
So as soon as you make a set of rules,
some filmmaker is going to do something creatively interesting by breaking them.
Shots come in all shapes and sizes.
The shot can last for less than a second or extend for the length of an entire film.
A shot can be static and neutral or it can convey a frantic energy.
The shot can be actively searching for something or passively
reacting to what is happening in the scene.
A shot can develop with intention or it can aimlessly drift through space.
Ultimately, the shots I enjoy most are the ones that feel like what they're doing
and why they're doing it is an intentional choice that helps communicate the story.
You don't want static neutrality when you're trying to engage the audience in propulsive energy.
You don't want explosive movement if you're trying to get the audience to step back and
reflect contemplatively on the scene.
But most of all, you don't want the shot to do nothing,
to just exist with no intention but to collect one of many possible images of the subject
that will then be tossed into an editing blender later on.
I mean, you can make a movie this way.
Plenty of people do and some of them make a lot of money at the box office.
But from my perspective, this style doesn't use the full potential of film as a storytelling medium
and is ultimately less enjoyable to watch.
Blender cutting relies on a cut to hold our attention.
This works because every time the frame is reset by a cut,
our brain is momentarily busy looking for some new information on the screen.
Faster cutting doesn't really give your brain time to take everything in
before it moves on to a new frame.
And so your brain is constantly searching for new information.
This can be very effective at grabbing and keeping your attention,
but it's also a little bit of a hack.
And it's sometimes used to smooth over a lack of intentionality that exists in the shots,
choreography, editing, or performances.
To me, it's kind of like the Doritos of filmmaking.
There's nothing wrong with it ultimately, but it's a way of hacking your brain's
dopaminergic reward centers to create something tasty
without really having to provide real nutrition.
When the editor doesn't cut as quickly,
the shot itself has to be interesting enough to sustain your attention for a longer period of time.
This presents a challenge for the filmmakers,
but if they step up and meet that challenge, it can be incredibly rewarding to watch.
This evocative shot from My Father's Shadow uses a slow rotating pan to build suspense
and immerse us in the dramatic environment that surrounds the characters in this moment.
My Father's Shadow was one of my favorite movies from last year,
and it's currently available to stream in the US and many other places on MUBI,
my sponsor for this video.
MUBI is an online hand-curated streaming cinema
with incredible movies from all around the world.
In addition to My Father's Shadow,
you can also watch Masha Chelensky's beautiful and haunting Sound of Falling.
Check out those two films and explore the rest of their incredible catalog.
You can get 30 days free of MUBI at mubi.com slash thomasflight.
That's m-u-b-i dot com slash thomasflight.
Thanks again to MUBI for sponsoring this video.
