When studying the ancient Pre-Pottery Neolithic sites of the Fertile Crescent, Göbekli Tepe, Karahan Tepe, and Jericho receive the most attention — for good reason. They feature incredible architecture and are truly ancient, dating back between 10,000 and 12,000 years.
But there is one site that many people have never even heard of — one that is even older than those mentioned and arguably even more important. It contains truly magnificent examples of ancient stone architecture and artefacts: a Proto-Neolithic settlement that was continuously occupied for 2,000 years, with origins predating the Younger Dryas and occupation continuing throughout and beyond it. The site charts the evolution of the Pre-Pottery Neolithic in a single location.
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI Generated
Tell Karamel is a critical proto-Neolithic site in northern Syria, predating and overlapping with Göbekli Tepe. Occupied for over 2,000 years, it reveals a sedentary society that existed before the advent of agriculture, featuring monumental stone architecture, early metalwork, and a clear evolution of settlement patterns in the Fertile Crescent.
Hello everybody and welcome to Ancient Architects. Please subscribe now to get the latest ancient
history news and independent research from around the world. When studying the ancient
pre-pottery Neolithic sites of the Fertile Crescent, Gobekli Tepe, Karahan Tepe and Jericho
get the most attention, and yes for good reason. They display incredible architecture and are also
truly ancient, between 10 and 12,000 years old. But there is one site that so many have never
even heard of, one that is even older than those mentioned and one that is arguably even more
important. It displays some truly magnificent examples of ancient stone architecture and
artefacts. A proto-Neolithic settlement with continuous occupation for 2,000 years,
charting the evolution of the pre-pottery Neolithic in one specific place.
This site is Tell Karamel. As you can tell by its name, Tell Karamel is a tell, an archaeological
mound, 19 metres high and located in northern Syria, around 25 kilometres north of Aleppo
and 175 kilometres to the southwest of Gobekli Tepe. It's situated on the western bank of a river,
very much in the Fertile Crescent and is a site with truly ancient origins,
but experts have still only excavated a tiny portion of the site. Tell Karamel is located
in a fertile river valley and this has been an important trade route for millennia.
A railway still runs through the present day village as well as the archaeological site,
cutting through the ancient Neolithic landscape. The site's importance has been known about since
the 1970s, when a survey found evidence of settlement from the pre-pottery Neolithic A
all the way through to the Hellenistic period. After another survey in 1998, archaeologists
called Tell Karamel one of the most important early Neolithic sites in the northern Levant.
Whilst the later phases of occupation primarily focus on the mound itself,
the pre-pottery Neolithic archaeology is actually away from the mound,
to the south and southwest and covering a very large area. Only the northern part of the pre-pottery
Neolithic settlement seems to be covered by the mound, and this mound is made up of the
remains of younger occupation at the site. The early phase of occupation is what has gotten
Tell Karamel the most attention, and excavations began in 1999 by a joint Polish-Syrian team of
archaeologists. Although there has been 13 seasons of excavations, to this day, only six specific
areas have been investigated, and some estimate that only 1.5% of this site has been excavated.
The main reason for the slow progress is the political instability in Syria.
Excavations were suspended in 2011 due to war. I've read through 8 years of archaeological field
reports, as well as the few papers that have been released on this site, and I am truly amazed it
isn't more widely known about and spoken about. The findings at Tell Karamel are nothing short
of astonishing. The Neolithic layers are immediately below the topsoil, down to a depth
of around 2.5 metres. But this shallow archaeology does mean that regular ploughing of the land by
local farmers has destroyed a lot of the archaeology. Even today, the full extent of
the settlement is not known. But, as stated, archaeologists did make some incredible discoveries
before the work came to an end. We find the remains of dozens of ancient structures,
and all indications show that this was a permanent sedentary settlement, and also that it did predate
agriculture and domestication. More than 45,000 complete and fragmented animal bones have been
found, from all of the early occupation horizons, and there are no traces of any domesticated
animals. There was also a rich variety of cereals, grains, and plants, and they were
also of the wild variety, likely growing locally, naturally, because the soil here being close to
the river was prone to flooding, and hence it was well watered and fertile. So, in the earliest
phases of occupation at Tell Karamel, people lived a settled sedentary lifestyle, but they hunted
and gathered their food, which does appear to have been plentiful in the landscape.
But how old actually is it? Well, people lived at this site at the same time as Gobekli Tepe,
but the radiocarbon dates obtained so far do go back a lot further. It looks to have been a
settlement between 12,890 and 10,870 years ago, meaning it was active at the very beginning of
Younger Dryas, with continuous occupation during and after. So far, five specific
archaeological horizons have been identified, from H0 to H4. H0 is a basal epipaleolithic phase
comprising mainly flint tools. These date between 18,890 and 12,980 years ago, although the dating
is still inconclusive and more samples are needed. The Pre-Pottery Neolithic is identified
in phases H1 to H4. H1 dates between 12,890 and 11,670 years ago. H2 between 12,670 and 11,250
years ago. H3 between 11,820 and 10,710 years ago. And H4 between 11,310 and 10,780 years ago.
Yes, there is an overlap between the horizons, and this is because of the error margins in
radiocarbon dating, the complexity of the site, the damage from modern activity,
and also because different waves of occupation and building can and do overlap.
Phasing the excavated archaeology is a difficult task, but we know there was continuous occupation
at Tel Caramel for at least 2,000 years, with various waves of activity. It was an active
settlement at the same time as Gobekli Tepe and Karahan Tepe, but it has even earlier origins,
much earlier. But what makes Tel Caramel an extra special site is the discovery of
five round stone structures, which archaeologists have interpreted as the remains of towers,
maybe similar to the famous Tower of Jericho I discussed in a recent video,
also dating to the Pre-Pottery Neolithic, but much later than those at Tel Caramel.
Three of the towers date to H1 between 12,890 and 11,670 years ago,
with the most monumental tower built in H2 between 12,670 and 11,250 years ago.
This tower has a diameter of 7.5 metres, with stone walls being 2.25 metres in thickness.
The outer and inner faces of this wall were built using unshaped stones up to 80 centimetres in
length. The inside of the wall was filled with smaller stones set in a red clay. Inside,
the structure itself were large and small stones in brown loose earth. It was found
to have been damaged by fire in antiquity. It was speculated by archaeologists to be a defensive
tower structure, maybe part of a line of fortifications. In the next archaeological
horizon, H3, another tower was built over the ruins of the large tower just mentioned.
Interestingly, at the same time the final tower was constructed,
two exceptional structures were also built. The first is a monumental elongated building,
10 metres long and 5 metres wide, and divided into three different shapes and arrangements.
Experts believe it was a communal structure or shrine, and it is located next to four animal
and 24 human graves. It had two spectacular foundation deposits, a flint axe like what
we find at Jericho, and a complete female figurine that was made from soft limestone.
The second unique building is located to the north-east of the tower, a circular building,
inside which is a large stone stylisation of Uruk Bukhrania. Four real Uruk Bukhrania were
found in a round pit in the floor, surrounded by pebbles, and located inside the arch of one
of the stylised horns. Archaeologists also found the remains of an oval stone wall,
possibly a boundary wall. They also found a chalk and stone floor surface with two large
pits dug inside it. A lunar-shaped bone pendant was uncovered in one of the pits.
It had a hole in its centre and parallel incisions at both ends.
Domestic dwellings were also in abundance at Tel Karamel, ever since the earliest pre-pottery
Neolithic A phase and continuing into the pre-pottery Neolithic B, just as we're finding
at Gobekli Tepe. Astonishingly, more than 60 circular and oval houses with utility buildings
have been found. The dwellings were often built, repaired then rebuilt successively over time.
They sometimes had an area of 9 to 10 square metres, with hard clay or mud floors and often
with low benches around the perimeter. The walls have a thickness between 0.2 and 0.5 metres,
and the materials used in construction do vary. Some houses were built using large upended stone
slabs, leaning outward slightly and supplemented in the upper part by smaller stones. Others were
built with mud mixed with animal bones, pebbles and broken mud bricks, and these were set on a
small layer of pebbles. Associated with one of the dwellings was a pit filled with ashes and bones,
possibly with a fireplace in the upper part. Pestles, grinders, whetstones, beads and stones
in size with zoomorphic imagery were among the finds from inside houses. There were also hearths,
storage pits, waste pits and possible hiding places in the courtyards. There were also
numerous grave pits, with the deceased buried in the fetal position. The houses were either
semi-subterranean or built directly on the ground surface, and many of them had clearly defined
rooms. This pre-pottery Neolithic village also had open spaces or courtyards, and these were
in use throughout the long history. In the successive layers of the courtyard, huge
quantities of animal bones, flint, tools, earth, pebbles and ash were found. Archaeologists have
noted a clear evolution in construction styles at Tel Caramel, with buildings changing from
oval in H1 and H2 to rectangular in Horizon H3, like the later buildings of Gobekli Tepe
and Karahan Tepe. There was also a wide array of tools, ornaments and artistic objects found
across the site, including 351 specimens that have been decorated or represent humans and animals.
There are also beautifully decorated shaft straighteners, stone bowls, pendants, discs,
rings and plaquettes. Most decorative objects are made from chlorite pebbles, but on rare
occasions from limestone and mudstone. Two limestone human figurines are very similar
to what we find at Jericho Murebet, Nivali Churi and Jerf El Amar.
Zoomorphic figurines include snakes, a catfish, an animal hoof, one complete and one fragment
of a bird head with a massive beak and neck, two fragments of birds made from sun-dried clay
and so on. Artifacts are often decorated, incised with geometric patterns, and anthropomorphic
images. The most common are snakes and birds. We also see turtles, a porcupine being killed by
arrows, a gazelle with snakes, a leopard ready to leap, solar and lunar motifs, human figures
surrounded by trees and even humans dancing. Interestingly, a large polished copper nugget
was also found in H2 and this measured 52 x 40 x 26mm. This makes it one of the earliest
finds of metal at any archaeological site. Because malachite, aka copper carbonate has
been excavated at Tel Caramel, the copper nugget is believed to have been collected
from the malachite source, but this is still yet to be identified. It looks like an attempt was
made to drill a hole through the copper like what we see with ancient stone beads from the same time.
The tools found include flint scrapers, cores, bladelets, sickle blades and perforators.
Obsidian tools were also found but were far less numerous and these were likely imported
from Anatolia. As well as architecture and artefacts, as stated, human remains have also
been discovered. Some of them were found to have had their heads removed either by
cutting shortly after their death or maybe after decay. This could indicate a skull or
head cult as seen at other pre-pottery Neolithic sites like Jericho, Cheyannu and also maybe
Gobekli Tepe. Tel Caramel is arguably the most important pre-pottery Neolithic site
ever discovered, because here we see the continuous occupation and evolution of one
specific settlement, from the very earlier stages of the pre-pottery Neolithic and covering
2,000 years of history. We even know there is a poorly understood epipaleolithic layer below.
At Tel Caramel, we see the evolution and transformation to the traditional Neolithic
culture and this was by a long process that extended for more than a thousand years.
This may be the primary region for Neolithicisation in the Fertile Crescent and from here people
moved south towards Jericho and northeast into Anatolia. It shows the proto-Neolithic stage
in steps, with clear differences but also clear similarities to other sites in the Fertile Crescent.
Even though so little of this ancient site has been excavated,
the finds so far are breathtaking. How this site falls under the radar I don't know,
but popular authors and researchers must take note of Tel Caramel,
especially when trying to interpret the origins of human civilisation.
Thank you very much for watching this episode of Ancient Architects.
If you enjoyed the video, please subscribe to the channel,
please like the video and please leave a comment below. Thank you very much.