Some Utah suburbs are charging you a Tesla payment for a commute and an HOA. And some of them, honestly? They're worth every penny. But there are at least three suburbs in this state right now that are wildly overpriced for what you actually get. And three more that almost nobody is talking about, that quietly deliver way more lifestyle per dollar than anything you'll see on the front of a magazine. Living in Utah and moving to Utah is all about finding the best places to live in Utah for you and this all comes to you from the top real estate agent and realtor in Utah, Scott Steele
A Utah real estate agent analyzes the Wasatch Front's suburbs, distinguishing between \"overrated\" areas driven by marketing hype and \"underrated\" gems offering better value. The guide evaluates locations based on infrastructure, commute times, and the balance between investment potential and daily quality of life.
Some Utah suburbs are charging you a Tesla payment for a commute and an HOA.
And some of them, honestly, they're worth every penny.
But there are at least three suburbs in this state right now that are wildly overpriced
for what you actually get.
And three more that almost nobody is talking about that quietly deliver more lifestyle
per dollar than anything you'll see on the front of a magazine.
I'm a Utah real estate agent and a Utah native.
I show these neighborhoods every single day to clients, and I'm about to tell you which
ones are overrated, which ones are underrated, and which one is going to make the comment
section absolutely lose its mind.
And look, here's the take you'll get from basically every Utah real estate agent on
YouTube.
It's all good.
Every suburb is amazing.
You can't go wrong.
Just buy whatever you can afford.
The market's hot.
Yeah, that's marketing.
That's not advice.
The real story is way more interesting.
Some suburbs in Utah have run up so fast and gotten so much hype that the price tag stopped
matching the actual lived experience a couple of years ago.
And some suburbs have stayed quietly excellent in terms of access, infrastructure, walkability,
drive times, just genuine livability.
And the rest of the internet just hasn't caught up to that just yet.
And look, I've been an agent and a broker here along the Wasatch Front for years.
I work with people relocating every single day, people moving from California, from Texas,
from the Pacific Northwest, from the Midwest and back East and even outside of the country,
you name it.
And after enough of those tours, you start seeing the same patterns play out the same
suburbs everyone shows up wanting to see.
And then their face changes about three stops in and the same suburbs they didn't know existed
that they end up buying in.
So here's the plan.
I'm going to walk you through three suburbs that I think are objectively overrated right
now.
Three that I think are objectively underrated.
And at the end, I'll give you the bonus pick.
The one suburb in Utah that is both overrated and underrated, depending entirely on who
you are.
So with that said, let's get into it.
Okay.
Overrated number one, let's go with Saratoga Springs.
Let's start with one of the more controversial picks I'm going to make today.
And that's Saratoga Springs.
It is the biggest sprawling community on the West side of Utah Lake between Lehigh and
Eagle Mountain.
It's a beautiful setting on paper, mountain views, lake views, brand new homes, parks,
schools, all of it.
And from about 2018 through 2022, it was probably the single hottest growth zone in the entire
state of Utah.
Everybody and their cousin moved out there.
Here's where reality starts to diverge from the brochure.
However, there is essentially one main artery in and out of most of the community, and that
is Redwood Road.
That's it.
And during commute hours, that road behaves exactly the way you would expect a single
artery to behave when tens of thousands of people, up to 70,000 people who live there
are all trying to use at the same time.
We're talking 50 to 70 minutes just to get to downtown Salt Lake City on a normal weekday
for a brand new bill that you're paying north of $600,000 for.
That math gets brutal really fast, especially if you came from a place where a 25 minute
commute was your worst case.
Then there's the lake.
And look, I love Utah Lake.
I'm not bashing Utah Lake at all, but anyone who's actually lived out there knows that
during certain stretches of the summer, the algae blooms turn what's supposed to be your
lakefront amenity into something that you can, well, let's just say smell from your
backyard.
That's not in the marketing videos.
That's a thing that actually happens typically in the late summertime.
And the infrastructure has not kept pace with the growth.
Schools are crowded.
Grocery options are limited for the population size.
To do anything real, anything beyond the basics, you're driving back over to Lehigh or to American
Fork or elsewhere.
Now here's the zoom out.
If you work fully remote and you got in on a great price three years ago, Saratoga Springs
can absolutely work for you.
The houses are really nice.
The parks are real.
The views are no joke.
But if you're commuting anywhere other than maybe to Lehigh or maybe just slightly beyond
that, you are about to discover that those gorgeous mountain views come with a daily
tax that the listing photos do not show you.
That's why it's on the overrated list.
Now look, I just purchased a home on the edge of Lehigh, just really close to Saratoga Springs.
I'm feeling this just the same as people who buy here and move here.
And the infrastructure is well planned out to the point where over the next three to
four years, this area is going to be transformed with respect to commercial development as
well as the infrastructure.
And I predict that this area will appreciate an additional 10 to 12% above what the market
does when that infrastructure gets built out.
I do think it's an incredible investment right now, but it's going to be a painful one for
some people, depending on where you move.
Now let's swing the other direction because this next one, almost nobody who's moving
in from out of state is asking me about, and that is Bountiful.
It's in Davis County, just north of Salt Lake City, climbing up the foothills onto the bench
to the east of I-15.
It's older, it's established, it has mature trees.
It's not flashy, not an Instagram.
Nobody's making thirst trap relocation videos about Bountiful.
And that is exactly the gap we should be talking about.
Here's what almost no out of state buyer realizes.
The commute from Bountiful into downtown Salt Lake City is shorter than Saratoga Springs.
Much, much shorter, shorter than most of Harriman, shorter than most of the Salt Lake Valley.
It's shorter than Daybreak, oftentimes much shorter than parts of Sandy and other areas
throughout the Salt Lake Valley.
You hop on I-15 and you're in the city in Salt Lake City in just minutes.
You're downtown in 15 minutes, maybe 20, depending on where you live in Bountiful.
The bench homes get those panoramic Salt Lake Valley views, the kind people pay seven figures
for in other states.
The lots have decades of maturity on them.
The schools have been stable forever.
And the price per square foot for an established neighborhood that close to the city is honestly
still a value compared to what a comparable established neighborhood on the south end
of the valley costs you.
Now, full disclosure, full honesty, because that's the whole point of this channel.
The inventory is older.
You're not going to find pristine new builds for the most part.
And if you do, they're going to be very expensive.
You're going to find homes from the 70s, the 80s, the 90s.
And yeah, you're going to deal with valley inversion in the wintertime unless you're
high enough up on that bench.
It's the same as the rest of the Wasatch Front and the Salt Lake Valley.
That's real.
But the trade-off that you're making here is older home in exchange for a commute that
doesn't ruin your week, mature trees that you literally cannot buy, and views that you
cannot find on the west side at any price point.
Bountiful is for the buyer who'd rather own a slightly older home in a location that's
already grown up instead of a brand new home in a location that's still figuring itself
out.
It's a quietly excellent suburb that gets ignored because it's not new and shiny.
That gap between the actual quality of life there and the attention it gets is exactly
why it lands on this underrated list.
Okay, real quick before we keep going, because this is exactly the kind of thing people email
me about and call me about every single day.
If you're watching this from out of state or even from a different part of Utah, and
you're trying to figure out where you actually fit in in Utah or along the Wasatch Front,
I put together a powerful guide.
It is something you can download.
You'll find a link for that in the description below.
You can even place it on the home screen of your phone and use it just like an app.
And it does give a lot of valuable insights as to what you want to know if you're making
the move to or within the state of Utah, whether that's points of interest, things to do, or
things to know if you're making that move.
So the link is in the description.
It's completely free.
No email gymnastics, just the guide.
Grab it before we keep going so you can just take notes as we hit the rest of these points
in this video.
All right, let's keep the spice going.
The next overrated pick is going to make some people mad.
Eagle Mountain sits south and west of Saratoga Springs.
Massive geographic footprint, one of the largest cities by land area in the entire state of
Utah.
It's the data center city where Meta has already planted roots, and Google has purchased a
big chunk of land there as well.
All the big tech infrastructure plays are happening in Eagle Mountain.
New builds are everywhere, bigger lots than most of the Wasatch Front, and mountain framing
on basically every side, depending on where you're looking, and prices that, on a sticker
basis, look way cheaper than Lehigh or Draper.
Here's the catch nobody puts on the listing, however.
Eagle Mountain is the suburb where, when I show out-of-state buyers homes there, I have
to start the conversation by saying this, do you actually understand what your commute
is going to look like?
Like, before we drive out there, do you even know what that looks like?
If you work at one of the data centers, it's fantastic.
You're already there.
You won.
Congratulations.
But if you work anywhere else, if you have to drive into Lehigh or anywhere beyond that,
especially in the Salt Lake Valley, or anywhere in Utah County that's not right there in
Lehigh, the time from Eagle Mountain to downtown Salt Lake City during rush hour can hit 70
to 80 minutes one way.
I've sat in it, I've made that drive, and my clients have sat in it as well.
That's two and a half hours a day in the car every single weekday before you've done
anything else with your life.
For people moving from a denser metropolitan area where they were used to a 25 minute commute,
this hits really, really differently when they actually start doing it three weeks in.
Then there's the lifestyle question.
Eagle Mountain is still developing.
There's a Smith's.
There's a grocery store.
There's some chain restaurants there.
But if you want a real grocery selection, a real restaurant scene, real retail, you're
driving back up to Lehigh or Saratoga Springs or even much further.
That's not necessarily a deal breaker, but the brochure makes it sound like a complete
community, and the reality is it's still becoming one.
Here's the kicker, the price story.
Three years ago, you could buy a brand new build in Eagle Mountain at a meaningful discount
to Lehigh or Draper.
That discount has narrowed dramatically, but it's still a discount nonetheless.
You're not getting the same value cushion that you used to get, but it's still a great
value.
But you're still paying the commute tax regardless.
So the math here has shifted and not in your favor necessarily.
Eagle Mountain works for a very specific buyer profile.
Fully remote, big lot, more house for the money, doesn't need urban amenities for
everyone else.
The math has stopped making sense for so many people, and that's why it's on my overrated
list.
Now we're switching gears because the next underrated pick is one that I personally cannot
believe doesn't get more attention from out-of-state buyers, and that's Mill Creek.
It sits right in the middle of the Salt Lake Valley towards the east bench to on the east
side between Holiday and Sugar House.
It's mature, it's walkable in some ways in some spots, and it's tucked right up against
the mouth of Mill Creek Canyon, which is one of the best canyon access points anywhere
along the Wasatch Front.
People drive an hour to get to a trailhead like that.
In Mill Creek, it's your morning.
It's right there in your backyard.
Here's what you get in Mill Creek that almost no other Salt Lake County suburb gives you
in this combination.
You get canyon access in like 10 minutes, hike before work, bike after work, ski up
Big Cottonwood Canyon within a 20 to 30 minute drive depending on traffic.
You get a real commute to downtown Salt Lake City within 15 to 20 minutes.
For most of the city, you get trees, actual large mature trees planted decades and decades
ago, the kind you can't buy at any price in a new development.
And you get a price per square foot that, for that level of access and that quality
of established neighborhood, is still meaningfully below comparable east bench, holiday, or sugar
house inventory.
The catch, and there's always a catch, I'm not pretending there isn't, is the housing
stock is older.
You're going to see mid-century ramblers, split entries, maybe some tutors, the occasional
craftsman remodel.
If you require new construction, this is not your suburb.
But if you're open to a home with character or you're open to a remodel project, the
bones in Mill Creek are excellent and the location is genuinely top tier.
There's also been a really interesting quiet boom in mixed use infill along the main
corridors.
So you're seeing new walkable developments, you're seeing restaurants, coffee shops,
that kind of thing, but without losing the established residential character.
That blend, older established residential plus thoughtful new walkable infill, is genuinely
hard to find in this state right now.
Mill Creek is the suburb for the buyer who values where they live more than what year
their house was built.
For canyon access, downtown access, tree maturity, and total commute quality, on a
price per square foot basis, it's still doing way more work than its reputation lets on.
That's why it's so underrated.
Okay, quick pause.
Because the next two picks are the spiciest ones I've got, and before I drop them, real
talk.
If you're sitting there going, okay, this is helpful, but I actually need to know where
I personally should be looking, that's literally my job.
That's what I do every single day.
If that's you, if you're looking to make the move to or within the state of Utah, my
team and I are here to be your real estate resource of choice.
Reach out to us and let's start that conversation.
You can also book a video call with me in that link that you'll find on the pinned
comment on this and every video.
We can dial in a personalized conversation to make sure we find out what is best for
you in your particular situation.
So with that said, let's get right back at it.
Okay, here it is.
The next overrated pick.
This one is one I'm probably going to get the most heated comments about, and I'm ready
for it.
Bring it on.
And I'm going to say Lehigh.
And even though I just purchased a home in Lehigh, this is the area that you think of
first as Silicon Slopes.
The tech corridor straddling Utah County and Salt Lake County right at the point of the
mountain.
Adobe campus, Ancestry, the Microsoft footprint, all of it, all of the tech companies that
have come and established and planted roots right here in Lehigh.
New construction is everywhere.
Master plan communities, brand name amenities, the entire pitch deck.
And here's the thing.
If you work in Silicon Slopes and you can find a home that lets you stay east of the
freeway and not cross I-15 in your daily commute, Lehigh is amazing.
That is a very true statement, and I'm not walking it back.
But that's what 15% of the people who actually end up buying their experience.
Everybody else is paying the Silicon Slopes premium and then commuting somewhere that
defeats the entire purpose of the premium they're paying for.
Lehigh pricing for new construction has run up to the point where you're now paying
closer and closer to Draper prices, close to Sandy money on the west side of the freeway
in some areas in a community that was a farm 15 years ago on roads that were not built
for the population that it now serves.
The point of the mountain area at rush hour, if you know, you know, if you don't, here's
the short version northbound in the morning, southbound at night.
It is some of the worst congestion in the state, especially if you're traveling west
from I-15 over towards the west side of Lehigh and into Saratoga Springs.
There are very limited workarounds for the traffic when it hits.
The state is doing some serious freeway expansion work right now to keep up, and the infrastructure
is very well planned out in this area, which means you're driving through construction
zones for the foreseeable three to four years.
That's the tax that you pay for the address.
Add to that the lot sizes for what you're spending.
Oftentimes shock people coming in from out of state.
You're not getting a big lot.
You're getting a really nice home on a smaller footprint surrounded by other really nice
homes on small footprints as well.
And the open space that was in the marketing video is on the other side of a four lane
road.
Look, Lehigh as a city has done a lot right.
It's a real city now.
The amenities are real.
The schools are real.
The job density is real, and it's phenomenal.
So I'm not saying don't live in Lehigh.
I'm saying the gap between what people think they're buying when they say, I want to live
in Silicon Slopes versus what they actually receive once they are closing in on it has
gotten really wide, and the price is no longer compensating for that gap.
That's why of all the picks today, Lehigh is the most overrated suburb on my list.
Come at me in the comments, if you will share your thoughts or even call me a hypocrite,
because I just purchased a home here as well.
But I did so knowing that the pain is only going to be for the next three to four years.
And beyond that, this particular area is going to appreciate at a rate that I think is going
to outperform the market by 10 to 12% in addition to what the market is doing.
Okay, deep breath.
Last one.
This is the underrated one.
And this one, I'll defend it in court.
It's Ogden up in Weber County, north of Salt Lake City.
It sits right at the mouth of Ogden Canyon.
It has a real and a charming downtown area has a real historic district and an art scene.
And it has a university.
It has Hill Air Force Base anchoring a huge piece of the regional economy to the south
and has access to outdoor recreation that is honestly second to none in this state.
And that is saying something here in Utah.
Here's why I think Ogden is the single most underrated suburb in this entire state right
now.
You can buy a renovated historic home in the Ogden downtown area or a new build in the
surrounding suburbs like North Ogden or Pleasant View or West Haven for meaningfully less per
square foot than equivalent inventory in Salt Lake County.
Sometimes 20, 25 or even 30% less depending on what you're comparing.
That is not a small gap.
That is a real structural sticker price gap.
What do you trade off for that?
Well, some commute if you work in Salt Lake City, of course, realistically 35 to 45 minutes
depending on time of day and exact location.
That's not nothing.
I'm not going to pretend it's nothing.
But here's the thing.
If you work in Ogden or you work hybrid or you work from home, that trade goes away entirely
and you're just sitting on the value.
And what do you get in exchange?
You get snow basin, Powder Mountain, Pine View Reservoir, Ogden Canyon itself, some
of the most accessible world-class skiing, mountain biking, hiking and water recreation
in the entire Wasatch Front.
And the resorts up there are not in the lift line nightmares that you can run into down
south in Park City.
The downtown area has revitalized in a really meaningful way over the last decade.
Restaurants, breweries, a walkable historic stretch on 25th Street, a real arts presence
and real character.
The new construction options on the periphery are growing as well.
North Ogden, West Haven, Pleasant View, even up into the Eden and Huntsville side of the
buyers who want the higher elevation lifestyle with that more expensive price tag.
There's a range here to look at.
The thing that nobody mentions is air quality on inversion days can be tough, same as the
rest of the Wasatch Front.
So that's a real consideration to make as well.
But if you were already considering Salt Lake County, you're dealing with that anyways,
sometimes worse in some pockets of the valley.
So it's a wash in that regard, not a deduction.
Ogden is the suburb that 10 years from now, the rest of the state is going to be saying,
we should have bought there.
We should have considered it at least.
The combination of price per square foot, outdoor access, downtown character and runway
for appreciation, given how compressed the rest of the Wasatch Front has gotten, it makes
it well, in my honest opinion, the most underrated place to buy in Utah right now, full stop.
All right, quick recap, because we covered a lot.
Now I want you walking away with a clean list.
Overrated in my opinion, Saratoga Springs for the commute and the infrastructure gap,
Eagle Mountain for the commute combined with a price discount that's quietly evaporating
and Lehigh slash Silicon Slopes for the gap between the marketing and the lived experience
for everyday users who don't actually work west of I-15.
And on the flip side, the underrated options, in my opinion, include Bountiful for the criminally
good location to price ratio that nobody's talking about, Mill Creek for the canyon access
and the tree maturity and the walkable infill, and Ogden, the address I think is the most
underrated in the entire state of Utah right now.
And now, as promised, here's the bonus pick that I promised you at the very beginning.
The suburb in Utah that is both overrated and underrated, depending entirely on who
you are, that's Park City.
I know, I know, but hear me out.
If you're buying Park City as a primary residence and commuting to Salt Lake City every day,
you are about to pay a luxury premium for a commute that gets stupid in the wintertime
and never quite stops being a haul.
Overrated.
But if you're buying Park City as a hybrid lifestyle play, work from home plus part-time
Salt Lake City, plus actually using the mountains, plus tapping into the rental market in the
pockets where that still pencils out, then for what you're getting, it's still doing
more than people give it credit for.
Same address, two completely different ratings, depending entirely on your life.
So that's the list.
None of these are objective truths.
They're my opinions based on a lot of tours with actual clients, a lot of price comparisons,
and a lot of clients who've called me a year later and either said, you were totally right
or I was completely wrong about a particular spot.
I'd much rather you make your own informed call than just take mine.
So if any of this has stirred something up within you, drop a comment.
Let me know your thoughts.
Tell me which suburb I got dead wrong.
Defend your hometown.
I read every single comment.
I respond to most of them.
And if you're actually trying to make a move and you want a real conversation about where
you'd fit in, my team and I are here to be your real estate resource of choice.
Reach out to us.
Let's start the conversation and make sure that we guide you in that process to finding
the perfect place for you and making that move as smooth as possible.
And as always, if this content helps you, please subscribe to the channel for more videos
like this.
It will definitely help you have more clarity as you make decisions moving forward.
And as always, if you're looking to learn more about life in Utah, check out these videos
next.
And until next time, thanks.