May 2025 has brought a new paper which makes the best case yet, by far, of an independent domestication event in Africa. 4,000 years earlier than Near East Cattle migrated into Africa, and this video will synthesize this paper and several other ones from 2025 and earlier, to show that all the latest data seems to be pointing toward 2 new centers of cattle domestication, in East Africa and East China
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI Generated
Recent archaeological and genetic evidence challenges the theory that cattle were domesticated only in the Fertile Crescent and Indus Valley. Findings from Africa and East Asia suggest independent domestication events occurred approximately 10,000 years ago, indicating that cattle taming was a global, parallel process rather than a localized phenomenon.
For decades, the story of how humans first domesticated cattle seemed centered on just
two cradles of origin.
Archaeologists and geneticists agree that it all starts with Bos Taurus, the humpless
cattle around 10,000 years ago in the Fertile Crescent, around the Anatolia, Turkey, Iraq,
Syria region, while Bos Indicus, the humped Zebu cattle, were domesticated a bit later,
around 8,000 years ago, in the Indus Valley of South Asia, around the India-Pakistan border.
From these two primary events, domestic cattle spread across the globe.
The Near Eastern Tauran cattle reached North Africa by around 7,000 years ago, expanding
further across the continent by 5,000 to 3,000 years ago, and much later, the South Asian
Zebu made its main entry into Africa, around the 7th century AD.
And so while the cattle seen in Africa were always known to be a mix of different breeds,
when we're talking domesticated breeds, not the wild aurochs, which are much larger, but
actual domesticated cattle, there hasn't been a lot of hard evidence to prove a domestication
event happened independently in Africa.
But new archaeological studies and genetic studies are all converging to challenge this
tidy two-origin narrative.
Researchers working in Africa, but also in East Asia, have uncovered surprising evidence
that people in these regions may have begun taming local, wild cattle, surprisingly it's
almost exactly at the same time as the domestication event in the Fertile Crescent, like not even
hundreds of years apart.
What is confusing, and what I don't want people to take too far in the other direction, is
that the Near Eastern Tauran cattle is still dominant throughout the world, but that doesn't
mean that there still isn't a growing body of evidence supporting independent domestication
in East Asia and Africa.
Scientists suspect that hints of the lost local livestock might be detectable in ancient
bones, and even faintly in the genomes of modern cattle.
Genetic evidence can clearly detect the domestication of wild aurochs in the Near East, and we can
see them radiate in all directions out from this area, all occurring around 10,000 years
ago, from which all Taurine cattle on Earth are descended.
The timeline for the standard view has been that domesticated cattle only arrived in Africa
around the 5th to 6th millennia BC, and they came with a whole package of other domesticates,
including grains and other animals like sheep and goats.
Early 20th century archaeologists had conjectured that perhaps local hunter-gatherers in the
Eastern Sahara might have begun corralling or taming native wild cattle as the climate
shifted to drier conditions, a scenario where humans and thirsty aurochs herds were pushed
into closer contact around shrinking water sources.
But this local domestication hypothesis lacked hard evidence.
No clearly domesticated early cattle bones had turned up in Africa that were older than
the imported cattle of 5,000 to 6,000 years ago, so the idea was largely abandoned in
favor of the Near East origin story.
And this is something I have seen a lot on comments on this channel.
People think 6,000 years ago is really old, and they point to rock art in Africa and other
things as proof that domestication started in Africa since 6,000 years ago is so old,
but they just don't understand how old these civilizations were in the Near East, sites
around Gobekli Tepe and others.
These people were domesticating crops and animals 10,000 years ago, a whole 4,000 years
older than the evidence we had in Africa.
But this new paper from 2025, just a few months old at this point, and which has passed peer
review process, we have new evidence that does seem to push it back to 10,000 years
ago.
A Polish-Sudanese archaeological team digging in Sudan's Ledi Basin in the middle Nile
Valley recently made a discovery that has reopened the debate.
At a site dating to the very start of the Holocene, around 10,000 years ago, they uncovered
remains of cattle that show signs of early domestication.
New zooarchaeological discoveries in the middle Nile support the scenario that proto-pastoralist
communities arrived from the sub-Saharan region with large ruminants at the beginning of the
Holocene, suggesting that the cattle could have been domesticated independently in Africa
at almost the exact same time as the Middle East.
The evidence from Ledi Basin comes from multiple fronts.
Osteometric measurements of the cattle bones, in particular a cattle metatarsal or foot
bone, show an animal smaller in stature than a wild aurochs, but not as reduced as later
fully domesticated cattle, pointing to a possible transitional early domestic form.
An analysis of the age profile of the remains, which is where you look at the distribution
of ages at death, suggests a pattern consistent with human management.
It appears these early Holocene people were selectively culling cattle, not just hunting
whatever they could catch.
Dr. Marta Ossipinska, a lead zooarchaeologist in the project, explains that the site's inhabitants
quote, still hunted wild savanna animals, with only one exception, cattle at an early
stage of domestication.
All the other animal remains they found are consistent with hunting, usually just the
largest and no real discrimination between male or female, but these people had a set
of cattle that they were treating differently, protecting or herding them rather than simply
hunting them outright.
If you're actively managing a herd, you don't need as many males.
One male can do a whole lot of insemination, and the females are the ones giving you milk
and more cows.
And so one of the telltale signs is when you see them butchering a lot of young males,
and few females in general, whereas if you were just hunting whatever big ones you could
get, it would be a lot closer to a 50-50 split between male and females being killed.
And then there are some cultural items here too.
One of the most evocative was a small clay figurine of a cow found in the same layer
as the bones, and although the figurine's head was broken off, it's unmistakable bovine
form shows that these people felt a connection with this animal.
And the researchers note that similar cow figurines have been known from pastoralist
cultures all throughout Africa, like the Nuer people of South Sudan, who crafted cattle
figures as tokens of wealth and for rituals.
So they're not as big as wild aurochs, they're killing them in ways that are consistent with
managing herds, which is the first step to domestication, and they have these cultural
artistic creations which show that these people have a connection with the cow.
And so again, before this new discovery, the oldest hard evidence we had was from 6,000
years ago, which would be consistent with domestication just coming in from the Near
East, but this would push it back by 4,000 years to 10,000 years ago or 8,000 BC.
Even if these are off by a couple hundred years, most researchers think that would be
far too fast for it to be domesticates migrating in from the Near East.
And crucially, this African domestication was likely happening in the context of the
early Saharan Neolithic.
The people of Leti 10,000 years ago were not sedentary farmers, they were more like proto-pastoralists.
As Ossipinska describes, they quote, already knew ceramic vessels, used quern stones to
grind wild cereal grains, and so they can be called early Neolithic communities.
They were likely mobile, living on the edges of the desert and savannah, positioning themselves
at an ecological crossroads.
This region is called a Great African Intersection of Climate Zones.
The hypothesis is that African hunter-foragers here gradually forged a relationship with local
wild cattle, or rocks, as the environment changed, perhaps corralling them or managing
herds that roamed between the green savannahs and waterholes of an increasingly arid savannah.
Because the African Humid Period would be coming to an end around this time.
So if this is true, then why did Africa's independent cattle not end up dominating the
continent's livestock?
The most likely possibility is that later introductions of cattle from outside eclipsed
this early experiment.
The genetic profile of today's African cattle is overwhelmingly derived from Near Eastern
taurine ancestors, and in other regions they have a lot of zebu influence.
It may be that the descendants of the Ledi Basin cattle were absorbed into the incoming
taurine populations, which could have had advantages like disease resistance, or simply
came in larger numbers, leaving little trace of their unique origin.
Because modern African cattle carry a mitochondrial DNA haplogroup T1 that links them directly
to the Near Eastern founder herd.
And there is no completely distinct, African only, mitochondrial DNA lineages that have
been detected in any living cattle in Africa today.
Suggesting that if a local domestication did occur, its maternal lines might have died
out or been replaced.
Perhaps times got so hard that they had to start killing all of the females as well.
But most likely it's that there was some emerging domestication happening.
And then around 6,000 years ago with the migration of these Near East cattle, the taurine, just
like the African herders, the Near Eastern cattle experts were doing the same thing,
having way more females than males, and so when they migrate into Africa, they're bringing
way more females, to the point that today, all of them have that haplogroup T1 from the
Near East cattle.
But the growing body of evidence seems to be pointing towards something was happening
here.
At least the first steps towards domestication were at most a complete independent domestication
event, but which was overrun by the incoming taurine cattle.
Now what's really interesting is that way off in Eastern Asia, there is a very similar
story.
And so this is what I mean by the body of evidence seems to keep pointing towards this
being true.
These theories that were proposed decades ago but which lacked hard evidence, are getting
more and more hard evidence.
At least 4 domestication events in Eastern Africa, the Near East, India, and Northeastern
China.
Because thousands of kilometers away in East Asia, researchers have uncovered evidence
of a similarly ancient, independent attempt to domesticate wild bovines in China.
Archaeologists working in Northeastern China, specifically what is now the Liaoning province,
have found parts of a cattle jaw bone in a context dating back to around 10,660 years
ago, so around 8600 BC.
This is around the dawn of the Holocene, and again, if you look at our species as being
at least 200,000 years old, no stuff keeps putting it back to around 300,000, but let's
just say 200,000, we've been humans with the same needs for all this time and for some
reason we're having this explosion in domestication technology all at this same time 10,000 years
ago.
I love sticking to the hard science as much as possible, but I promise I'm working on
a very fascinating video exploring the idea of morphic fields.
The odds that this would happen independently are just so tiny, and it's of course not just
cattle but tons of other things.
It's a very interesting theory to explore that somehow all these human minds are connected.
Definitely fringe and not mainstream, but you'd be surprised at the amount of decent
research that has gone into this, and how if you look at history with this in mind,
it does map on really well.
But anyways, back to that cattle jaw bone.
The wear pattern on the teeth was highly unusual.
The molars showed a type of wear that researchers say is best explained by the animal having
lived a long time under human management, likely being fed or confined by humans, rather
than grazing entirely at random in the wild.
This pattern might result from being fed coarse fodder during winter or kept in pens, indicating
a level of care that wild animals of course would never receive.
In short, it looked like a domestic aged cow, and the fact that it dated to well over 10,000
years ago, in China, a region not traditionally thought to have an early domestic cattle event,
this was the first clue to look into this deeper.
And researchers were able to retrieve ancient DNA from that jaw, and when they sequenced
it, they discovered that this Chinese cow did not belong to the same genetic lineages
as the domesticated cattle of the Near East or from South Asia.
And so it wasn't some taurine cattle that somehow made it all the way from Mesopotamia
to Eastern China, nor was it some far off Indian trader bringing their Zibu.
This was a local lineage of cattle, and this points to a scenario where Neolithic people
in Northeast China were actively managing a native population of wild cattle, likely
a local subspecies of aurochs, and they began domesticating them around the same time that
cattle domestication was happening in West Asia.
So again, what became of China's earliest domesticated cows?
Much like the Africa case, they eventually faded into history as other cattle lineages
took over.
The primary cattle that spread through East Asia in later millennia were descendants of
the Near Eastern taurine, bringing humpless cattle into places like the Yellow River Valley
by around 5,000 to 4,000 years ago, so only 3,000 BC at the latest, and then the South
Asian Zibu, which only gets there around a few thousand years ago.
These imported cattle had their advantages and came to dominate the herds.
By the time Chinese civilization was flourishing, the cattle in use were largely mixtures of
those Western origin breeds.
Any legacy of the original Chinese domestication event was diluted by this replacement.
But scientists suspect that genetic echoes of those lost cattle may still linger in the
genomes of East Asia's bovines.
There are rare cases where they have identified mitochondrial DNA lineages in ancient East
Asian cattle that do not neatly fit the standard taurine or indocine profiles.
One of these lineages was dubbed haplogroup C, and that's what was found in that 10,660
year old jawbone, clearly distinct from the dominant haplogroups of the Near Eastern cattle.
While that is not seen in modern cattle in this area, there is another mysterious lineage,
haplogroup P, which occasionally turns up in East Asia, detectable in very few Japanese
and Korean cattle, despite being absent from most modern herds.
Haplogroup P was common in European wild aurochs, but nearly vanished in domesticated stocks.
Its sporadic appearance in some Asian cattle hints that local wild auroch genes slipped
into the gene pool along the way.
It's not a perfect analogy, but think of how recently divergent all hominins are from each
other, it's why you can have Denisovan and Neanderthal admixture in Homo sapiens.
A domesticated cow is far more genetically similar to an auroch, and so we can see the
lingering effects of local aurochs who are mating with some of the domesticated cows.
It's all the same type of evidence and logical story that we see in Africa and East Asia.
All of this together illustrates that the process of domestication is rarely a single
neat event, instead it involves multiple populations of humans and animals interacting
over millennia, with various starts, stops, and crossbreeding.
The cattle we see today are the product of not just the original domestication events,
but also the subsequent blending and hybridization of lineages as domesticated herds expanded
into new territories and encountered wild cousins.
And there's another recent study which supports this, showing the mechanism by which this
could happen.
Here it was focusing on Europe populations, which definitely got their domestic cattle
from the Near East, but the wild European aurochs didn't simply disappear when farming
arrived.
They found that modern Iberian cattle have roughly 20% of their genes from wild aurochs,
a persistent genetic legacy of ancient hybridization.
The fact that such a substantial chunk of wild DNA endured shows how robustly local
genetic contributions can persist in domestic animals, and so it just further supports the
idea that this was happening elsewhere.
In Africa, as Torin cattle from the Near East arrived, some would have been bred with whatever
local wild cattle or early domesticated cattle existed in this area, even if the maternal
lines of the locals didn't survive.
The native African female cows aren't exactly going out to force themselves on the males,
but the local males would force themselves on the female incoming Near East Torin.
Same story in East Asia, and that's what likely describes the odd genetic lineages
that pop up in Asian cattle.
Even in Africa, the Zibu there have Torin mitochondria because ancient African Torin
cows were bred with incoming Zibu bulls.
So even many of the ones that look like Zibu, with the humps, have deep Torin ancestry.
But again, the real breaking news to stress here, the new 2025 paper that makes all these
other discoveries even more interesting, and supporting the point of an African domestication
event, the evidence from Sudan's Ledi Basin, is that it all seems to point to human management
of cattle, at least the first steps to true domestication.