P.S. This is not professional medical advice and should not be taken as such. The creator of this video is not held accountable for your health. Consult your doctor first.
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI Generated
This video analyzes various High-Intensity Interval Training (HIIT) protocols to determine the most effective methods for improving VO2max and cardiovascular health. By comparing scientific research with practical application, the creator evaluates several methods based on their efficiency, sustainability, and overall impact on heart health and athletic performance.
High-intensity interval training is one of the most powerful forms of exercise you can do.
It's the fastest way to improve your VO2max, cardiovascular fitness, and heart function.
And in some studies, it's been even shown to make the heart functionally resemble
a heart that's 20 years younger. But here's the problem.
There are a ton of different protocols out there.
Sprint interval training, the Norwegian 4x4 method, Tabata intervals, ReHIT,
shuttle runs, the Gibala method, and probably 20 more variations people argue about online.
So which one's actually the best?
I decided to try a bunch of the most popular HIIT methods for myself.
And while doing that, I dug into the research behind these methods
to see which one has the strongest evidence,
and which one is the most practical or realistic for average people.
So in this video, I'm going to compare the most popular HIIT methods,
show you which ones I like the most, which ones felt terrible,
and which ones seem to offer the best balance between effectiveness, efficiency, and sustainability.
The idea behind high-intensity interval training, or HIIT, is quite simple.
High-intensity exercise for a short period of time, which is the interval.
They can last anywhere from 15 seconds to several minutes.
Recovery interval at low intensity or at no exercise.
Repeated for multiple rounds.
High-intensity interval training, or HIIT protocols,
are usually done at an intensity of 85-95% of your maximum heart rate.
So those are zones 4-5.
You could also do it at lower intensities, but the 85-95% range is true HIIT.
In practice, you're going quite hard.
Not an all-out sprint, but you're going fast and hard.
Think of it as your one-mile run speed.
The duration of your intervals can vary a lot, and it's not that important.
They can all improve your VO2max and your overall fitness.
But longer intervals appear to be better than shorter intervals in research.
The first interval training we're going to cover is one of the most famous ones.
It's called the Tabata method.
It's created by a Japanese professor, Izumi Tabata, in the 90s.
In his 1996 study on Olympic speed skaters,
he showed that very short, ultra-high-intensity intervals on the bike ergometer
can increase VO2max as much as longer periods of steady-state cardio.
The steady-state group had a higher VO2max at the end,
from 52-57 mL per kg per minute,
whereas the Tabata group went from 48-55 mL per kg per minute.
The percent increase was similar,
but the Tabata group exercised only 4 minutes per day
compared to 60 minutes of the steady-state cardio group.
Arguably, the Tabata group had a greater total increase in their VO2max.
7 points versus 5 points for the low-intensity group.
But it's a bit easier to increase your VO2max if it's lower,
if you're starting from a lower point,
because it's harder to make progress the higher your VO2max is.
The protocol was 20 seconds of ultra-intense exercise,
up to 170% of VO2max,
followed by 20 seconds repeated for 4 minutes,
with 8 rounds in total.
They trained 4 times a week for 6 weeks,
whereas the steady-state cardio group trained 60 minutes a day
for 5 days of the week, at 70% of the VO2max.
It's important to keep in mind that 170% of your VO2max
is not the same as 170% of your maximum heart rate.
These are completely different things.
170% of VO2max refers to 170% of power output that corresponds to VO2max.
Basically, it's supra-maximal effort.
It's super hard beyond what you're capable of.
This is what it looks like in practice.
If your power at VO2max on a bike is 250 watts,
then 170% would be 425 watts.
That is the kind of effort you can hold only very short periods of time,
not even for minutes.
Here's my experience doing the Tabata on the bike ergometer.
It's very hard, like super hard,
and even though it lasts for 20 seconds, you can barely make it.
Because it's so short, you need to be going super hard for it to be effective.
Half of the time you're wondering if you're going hard enough,
and the other half of the time you're half-assing it,
because it's so difficult.
Overall, my rating for the Tabata method is 3.5 out of 5.
Not that it's not effective,
it's because it's so hard and most people aren't able to pull it off.
Most people will never be able to reach 170% of the VO2max,
even if they try to,
because you need to be literally going all out and then some.
If you're not an athlete, then you're just not trained for that.
You don't know what your maximum is in the first place,
and you don't know what's beyond the maximum.
So for most people, if they try to do the Tabata method,
they end up going around 80 to maybe 110 or 120% of their VO2max,
which is still going to give them some results,
but you're missing out on a lot of the potential.
So what I think is that it makes sense to reduce the intensity,
but increase the duration.
There's no reason the interval needs to be only 20 seconds.
It can be 30 or 60 seconds.
You reduce some of the intensity,
bring it down to 100% of VO2max,
and go for a 60 second sprint.
You're probably going to get better results,
or at least the average person will be able to adhere to that.
I want to take a quick break to tell you about the Bonchart Infrared Sonar Blankets,
my go-to way of getting 20-minute sonar sessions on the go
without needing to spend an hour to warm up a regular sonar.
Taking the sonar is, in my opinion,
one of the best things for your overall health and heart function.
Studies show that taking a sonar regularly
is associated with 63% lower risk of sudden cardiac death,
63% reduced heart disease mortality,
46% lower risk of hypertension,
and 40% reduced all-cause mortality.
This is mediated by an increase in body temperature
and increased heart rate
that mimic a cardiovascular workout
while at the same time improving arterial stiffness,
endothelial function,
blood flow,
immune system function,
blood pressure,
and metabolic health.
It doesn't matter if it's a traditional wooden sonar,
an infrared sonar,
an infrared sonar blanket,
or anything else that elevates your body temperature above what's normal.
Bonchart Infrared Sonar Blankets
have the advantage of shining far infrared light
that can penetrate deeper into your tissues than regular sonars can.
It warms up in 2 minutes to the optimal temperature of 70°C
and it's low in EMF.
You can get a 15% discount by heading over to
www.bonchart.com
forward slash seamlunt
and use the code SEAM for a 15% discount.
Alright, back to the video.
The Norwegian method is one of the most infamous
high-intensity interval protocols out there.
It's called Norwegian because it was developed and popularized
by researchers Jan Hoff and Jan Helgerud
at the Norwegian University of Science and Technology in the 1990s.
The Norwegian method is also one of the most brutal hit protocols.
4 minutes hard at 85-95% of max heart rate,
3 minutes easy between bouts,
repeated for 4 rounds.
The biggest difference between the Norwegian protocol
and other hit protocols is that it's unusually long.
4 minutes is unusually long,
not for the entire workout session but just for one interval.
And the intensity is also very high, 85-95%.
Now, there is a scientific reason for that,
why it is 4 minutes.
And that's because longer intervals appear to be better
than shorter intervals for increasing VO2 max.
A 2019 meta-analysis of 53 randomness control trials
found that short intervals less than 30 seconds,
low volume less than 5 minutes,
and short-term less than 4 weeks
are an effective and time-efficient way to increase VO2 max.
However, to maximize VO2 max adaptations,
long intervals that last over 2 minutes,
high volume over 15 minutes in total,
and moderate to long-term over 4 to 12 weeks
were better and more effective.
Another 2016 randomness control trial on overweight and obese people
showed that the Norwegian protocol for 6 weeks
was superior to 10 1-minute intervals
as well as 45 minutes of moderate continuous training
in increasing VO2 max.
So high frequency and longer intervals
are better than shorter intervals
and shorter frequency and shorter duration overall.
Now, the reason is obvious,
you just spend more time doing the interval,
you spend more time at the 85-95% of your max heart rate
and therefore you're going to get more gains in your VO2 max.
That's why the Norwegian method
is considered to be one of the most effective HIIT protocols
for athletes especially.
It's hard, most average people aren't going to be able to do it,
at least untrained individuals aren't going to be able to do it,
but for athletes it's brutally effective.
Something analogous to the Norwegian training method
has also been seen to reverse the structural age of the heart
by 20 years in 50-year-olds.
However, they incorporated multiple different training methods.
The first 1-2 months,
they did 3 30-minute steady-state cardio sessions per week
at 60-75% of their max heart rate.
At months 3-10,
they added the 4x4 Norwegian protocol
and by month 6,
their weekly workout plan looked like this.
2 interval sessions for HIIT,
1 long base session over 60 minutes at low intensity,
1 moderate base session for 30 minutes,
2 strength training sessions per week
and 1 recovery day.
Here's my experience doing the 4x4 Norwegian method.
This is one of the most brutal HIIT methods,
but it's also the most effective.
You're dying the first few times doing it,
but you feel that your cardio and VO2 max
is improving every workout.
Because it's so intense,
you're very dependent of the recovery.
If you slept bad or you're a bit sore,
you'll immediately notice it while doing the 4x4.
The first interval is always the hardest
and weakest in terms of performance.
If you can get the first 4-minute interval done,
then the second and third ones will be more bearable
and you even start enjoying it a little bit.
I think that the Norwegian method
is definitely the most difficult,
but probably also the most effective HIIT protocol.
Most people aren't going to be able to do it consistently.
They might try it once a month or something like that,
but there are going to be a few people
who'll be able to pull it off every week.
But I don't think that you even need
to do the Norwegian method every week.
Because it's so effective and intense,
doing it every two weeks or once a month
is already going to be quite good.
My overall rating for the Norwegian method
is 4.5 out of 5.
The reason is because it's very effective
and it's not dependent on necessarily
going all out with your intervals.
Even if you don't go 85% to 95%
of your max heart rate with the interval,
if you stay like 80% of your max heart rate,
it's still going to be very effective.
The reason for that is because
the intervals last for 4 minutes.
Whereas with the Tabata training,
the intervals are only 20 seconds.
So you need to make them count.
You need to go all out in those 20 seconds.
Sprint interval training or SIT
was pioneered by Dr. Niels Wollard
at the University of Stirling.
You basically sprint all out for 20 seconds
and do a few rounds.
A 2017 meta-analysis of sprint interval training
found that 2-3 sprints may be enough
and 4-7 sprints could be more than necessary
to increase VO2max
as long as the sprints are done at all-out effort.
Doing more sprints increases fatigue
but they may provide diminishing returns.
In this 2016 study,
they compared sprint interval training
to moderate-intensity continuous cardio
and found that it can be a time-efficient way
to get similar results.
The sprinting workout consisted of
3 20-second all-out sprints
with 2 minutes rest between sprints
done 3 times a week.
The cardio group was 45 minutes continuous cycling
at 70% max heart rate for 12 weeks in total.
Both groups saw improvement in VO2 peak by 19%.
Both groups also saw improvement in incident sensitivity
but with no statistically significant difference between them.
The same for mitochondrial content and body composition.
The difference is that the sprint group
trained in total 30 minutes per week
whereas the moderate-intensity cardio group
trained 50 minutes in total.
Here's my experience training sprint interval training.
It's very quick and efficient.
You don't need to have as high expectations
as with the Tabata method
and the sprints are more bearable.
It's good to think of sprint interval training
as a skilled training
rather than VO2max training
because the sprints require good form
as well as technique
to be able to do them safely and effectively.
You should try to get better with each sprint
in terms of speed.
Don't focus on getting your heart rate elevated.
Focus on running faster
and getting your form right.
My overall rating for sprint interval training
is 4.2 out of 5.
It's a great time-efficient way
to increase VO2max
and it also has the technique element of sprinting
which is underrated.
The Gibala method is made by Professor Martin Gibala
and his team at McMaster University in Canada.
The idea is basically
one minute near maximum effort
at 100% peak power output
followed by 75 seconds of rest
repeated for 8 to 12 cycles.
It's sometimes also called the little method.
In a 2010 study,
Gibala and colleagues
show that this method done for three times per week
on a stationary bike
resulted in significant improvements
in markers of mitochondrial biogenesis
and cycling performance.
Here's my experience doing the Gibala method.
The intervals are long enough to get exhausted
if you're going all out
but they're short enough to not die while doing them.
The sprints are also manageable enough
if done repeatedly
so the overall workout is less intimidating
than the Norwegian protocol.
Compared to the Tabata method
then I think the Gibala method
is a little bit more sustainable
and realistic for average people.
First of all,
Yes, the Gibala intervals are one minute
compared to the 20 seconds of the Tabata method
but because the intensity is lower
they're going to be more effective
at the one minute interval.
Most people won't maximize the benefits
from the Tabata method
because they're not going all out
beyond their maximum.
And funny enough
most people who will try to do the Tabata method
will end up doing the Gibala method.
It's just that
they're going to do 20 second Gibala intervals.
They are going all out
but they're not going beyond their maximum
so they're going Gibala method
but they're only doing 20 second intervals
so you should try to go for the one minute intervals instead.
My overall rating for the Gibala method
is 4.8 out of 5
and the reason is because
I think it's the most practical
and realistic for most people.
The intervals aren't super long
the intensity is manageable
and you don't need that much recovery time.
Re-hit or reduced exertion
high intensity interval training
was developed as an even more time efficient version
of sprint interval training.
The protocol is simple
a 10 minute bike session
done three times per week
mostly easy cycling
with just one or two very short all-out sprints
for 20 seconds.
In the original 2012 study
this approach improved aerobic capacity in sedentary adults
while also improving insensitivity in the male training group.
It shows that even extremely small doses of intense exercise
can produce measurable metabolic benefits.
This re-hit is a relatively low effort
and low volume type of high intensity interval training
and I think that it suits mostly absolute beginners
or people who are very unfit.
I don't think it's adequate training volume for athletes
or people who are above average in terms of fitness.
A 2016 study found that
a single 20 second all-out Wingate sprint
done three times per week for four weeks
with no warm-up or no cool-down
wasn't enough to increase VO2 peak
so just a single all-out sprint isn't enough
and you need multiple rounds of all-out sprints.
That's why the Gibala method
or sprint interval training
is better than re-hit
for people who are slightly more athletic.
Here's my experience with re-hit.
I was doing re-hit while cycling in the summer outside
and I think it's good on a long one-hour bike ride
and then every 5 to 10 minutes or so
you do a sprint for 100 meters.
It's very manageable and easy
because there's no expectations for the sprints
and I think that it's a great healthy way to do cardio
but it's also less effective.
My overall rating for re-hit is 3 out of 5
just because it's not that effective
at least for more athletic or fitter individuals
but if you're just starting to do exercise
it can be a great way to start.
Next we have 30 second all-out sprints
with 30 seconds of rest.
This protocol was investigated
by Jorge Zuniga and colleagues.
In his 2011 paper
he saw that in 12 recreationally competitive triathletes
30 second intervals
beat 3 minute intervals
for total session oxygen consumption
session duration
mean oxygen uptake
and heart rate
while also producing lower lactate levels.
90% of maximum power output
beat 100% power output
for total oxygen consumed
and total exercise time.
In the original study
the athletes were told
to do as many of these intervals as they could do
30 seconds on 30 seconds off.
In practice it ended up being 30 rounds
so 30 minute workout in total.
Here's my experience with the 30-30 intervals.
They're quite difficult actually.
The first 5 to 10 sprints are gonna be fine
but after that
they become increasingly more difficult.
The last sprints will be quite exhausting
if you've kept your speed high.
If you start running slower and slower
with each passing sprint
you're not doing it correctly.
The point is to run as fast as possible every sprint
not slow down.
My overall rating for the 30-30 intervals
is 3.5 out of 5.
The reason is that
I think the intervals are a little bit short
and because you're gonna half-ass most of the sprints
by the end of the workout
you're missing out on some of the potential.
I would rather do something like the Kibala method
or even the Norwegian method.
Another strategy to improve your cardiovascular fitness
is to include exercise snacks into your day.
These are also called
It's been found that
vilpas lasting for 1-2 minutes
done 3 times per day
are associated with a reduced risk of all-cause mortality
by 38-40%
and cardiovascular disease mortality
by 48-49%
compared to no vigorous daily activity at all.
Exercise snacks in insulin-resistant individuals
have been seen to improve glycemic control
as well as improve VO2max.
I like exercise snacks
running up the stairs for a bit
or just sprinting with my dog.
I do those a few times a day.
I think everyone should incorporate
some form of exercise snacks into their day.
Doesn't have to be an all-out sprint
or something else very intense
but just move every few hours.
My overall rating for exercise snacks is 4 out of 5.
They're simple, they're short
and they're not that difficult.
Overall, I think like 95% of people
will benefit from some form of
high-intensity interval training
especially if they're not doing
any form of steady-state cardio.
If you're doing frequently zone 2 cardio
or some other low-intensity cardio
then you might not need to do
additional high-intensity interval training.
But if you're not doing any cardio at all
then the HIIT cardio can be a time-efficient
and short way to increase your
VO2max and cardiovascular fitness.
Here's the final rankings for
all the HIIT protocols I tried.
Tabata, 3.5 out of 5.
Norwegian, 4.5 out of 5.
Sprint interval training, 4.2 out of 5.
Gibala method, 4.8 out of 5.
ReHIT, 3 out of 5.
30-30 intervals, 3.5 out of 5.
And exercise snacks, 4 out of 5.
So if I had to choose
I would do something like
the Gibala method,
Sprint interval training
or the Norwegian protocol.
I think these are the most
time-efficient ways
and the most effective ways
in terms of the intensity
and the expectations you can get.
There are many exercises out there
that are worth doing besides HIIT.
Check out my video
where I rank 100 exercises
from worst to best next.