Sam Harris on why meditation tells you nothing about the Big Bang — but everything about why you're suffering.
In this segment, the neuroscientist and creator of the Waking Up app draws the cleanest line I've heard between the contemplative tradition's first-person discoveries and the metaphysical inflation that usually rides on top of them. He breaks publicly with Deepak Chopra on exactly where that line sits.
What we cover: - Why "levels of consciousness" is the wrong frame, and what changes when you switch to contents - The optic-blind-spot analogy for finding the self — a falsifiable experiment you can run on yourself - The difference between changing what you think about and changing the witness that thinks - Why nearly every state of psychological suffering is anchored to a sense of self that disappears under inspection - Where Harris parts company with Chopra on what meditative experience can and cannot tell you about the cosmos - The claim that wisdom is nothing more profound than the ability to take your own advice
The argument matters because it's empirically tractable. Either the felt sense of "I" survives close phenomenological inspection or it doesn't. Run the experiment.
Sam Harris is a neuroscientist, philosopher, five-time New York Times bestselling author, and creator of the Waking Up app: https://www.wakingup.com, It's my 'operating system for the mind' that I use every day [unsponsored!]
Timestamps: 00:00 Why You Can’t Find Your Brain 01:03 The Mystery of Consciousness 03:08 Wisdom Is Taking Your Own Advice 05:18 Meditation Isn’t Self-Improvement 07:06 Where Sam Harris Breaks From Deepak Chopra 09:10 You Are the Universe Seeing Itself 12:31 The Meditation Experiment That Changes Everything 15:00 What Happens When the Self Disappears
🎯 Support Into the Impossible on Patreon — get my weekly M.A.G.I.C. Message, unfiltered bonus content, and live monthly Office Hours with me: https://www.patreon.com/drbriankeating
Sam Harris explores the intersection of neuroscience, consciousness, and meditation. He argues that while the mind is a product of biological processes, meditation allows individuals to recognize the \"self\" as an illusion. By shifting from the contents of consciousness to a state of pure awareness, one can dismantle psychological suffering and break dysfunctional mental routines.
When you're meditating, you can't even tell that you have a brain.
The existence of your brain is not among the things you can notice while meditating.
I want to get your reaction to a quote by you.
So the first one is something you said.
You said, wouldn't it be really good, since all you ever have with you is your mind,
to make a friend of your mind?
I want to compare that quote with this one from Einstein, who said,
no problem can ever be solved from the same level of consciousness that created it.
And so I guess the question is, what does it mean to make your mind into a friend?
And if you can explain that, does that also couple into maybe what Einstein was saying?
How could you transcend the brain, quote-unquote, our conscious experience?
How could that even be practical?
In other words, are we not doomed because we're locked inside of our brain?
But maybe not, according to Sam Harris, because you could make your mind your friend.
So how could you reconcile what Einstein said with what you said, perhaps?
Or use what you said as a tool to help transcend the level of consciousness we're born with?
Yeah, well, I certainly wouldn't say it's a matter of getting outside the brain.
I mean, you know, again, I think we can be agnostic with respect to the metaphysics here.
I mean, just the ontology, just how is consciousness and mind related to matter?
At what point does it emerge?
I think with mind, in terms of its functionality,
I mean, things like perception and memory and the association between ideas,
the inability to abstract ideas, reasoning,
all of that is clearly a matter of what our brains are doing, right?
Because we know we can disrupt all those functions by damaging or impeding certain processes in the brain.
And all of that is increasingly well-mapped.
And the outstanding mystery here is that it should feel like something or be like something
to be associated with any of that processing, right?
Which, i.e., the mystery of consciousness.
So I think it's unclear how consciousness emerges
and what are the necessary and sufficient conditions for the lights to come on.
But for things like vision and language processing, etc.,
we know this is a matter of information processing in the biochemical system of our brains.
And I think there's every reason, just to connect back to the AI conversation for a moment,
there's every reason to believe that that is substrate-independent, right?
There's no reason to think that there's something magical about a biological system.
We should be able to process that same information in silico and those same functions happen,
as we see in the intelligent machines we've already built.
It's not a matter of getting beyond the brain in any way.
There are different levels to it.
One level is just thinking differently, right?
I mean, just having new ideas and reaping the benefit of their consequences,
framing things differently, telling a different story about your experience.
I mean, being able to triangulate on yourself and see yourself as others do,
or see yourself as you see other people.
I mean, one thing I've said on this topic is that, on some level,
wisdom is really nothing more profound than an ability to take your own advice, right?
I mean, we all are pretty good at giving advice to other people.
If your best friend sat down with you and said,
listen, I'm really unhappy, you could probably give a lot of great advice there.
And if you only took that advice yourself, 100% of it,
you know, you would be living your best life too, right?
It's probably not very different from the advice you would give yourself.
It's operationalizing and executing all these good ideas that is really the challenge.
Everyone knows how to lose weight, right?
There's no mystery anymore about how to do that.
You know, this really is just physics,
even if there may be some ways that are better than others.
You know, it's not a matter of cutting off your limbs, right?
You know you have a certain energy balance,
and if you eat less and exercise more and you do that consistently,
you're going to change the shape of your body eventually.
And yet many, many people, virtually everyone,
who's not marketing their accomplishments on YouTube,
finds this very difficult to do, right?
And so that's the problem. I think with Einstein's quote,
the one place I would demur is that I don't tend to think of levels of consciousness.
I think of consciousness as a single condition,
and the real differentiator is in its contents, right?
I mean, there can be consciousness with, you know, basically zero contents,
and there can be consciousness with contents of a sort
and capacities by virtue of that contents that we can't even imagine.
Creativity and insight that is so far beyond what is normal for us
that we would find those disclosures, if put into English, fairly unintelligible, right?
But everything, you know, all of our personal changes
with respect to what we do and what we want and how we think about our lives
is a matter of changing contents.
However, the real benefit of meditation and the way one engages it
is not so much a matter of addressing contents as contents,
it's recognizing contents, whatever they are,
and learning to kind of drop back into this condition of a purely witnessing experience
and discovering an intrinsic freedom there that is native to consciousness,
whatever its contents, right?
So the thing that's very interesting about meditation is that
its benefits are not dependent on changing the character of your experience in any specific way.
And I mean, this can sound paradoxical because recognizing this more and more
does have a tendency to change the character of experience,
but the freedom you find in meditation, the freedom from self, the freedom from reactivity,
isn't in and of itself a matter of changing the contents of consciousness.
It's a matter of just recognizing, simply witnessing experience without reacting to it,
without grasping at what's pleasant or pushing what's unpleasant away,
and recognizing the intrinsic freedom of just that open awareness and its ultimate non-duality.
I mean, this is where it can sound a little spooky,
but the sense that there's a self, a subject that is aware of objects
is the thing that ultimately you're interrogating with meditation,
and that's the thing that breaks down,
and you begin to experience a freedom from that contracted feeling of self
that's constantly appropriating experience and reacting to it and trying to improve it.
It's a project that is somewhat orthogonal to this other project of improving experience, right?
Which is a story of the kinds of changes you can make to your experience
based on behavior and ideas and relationships
and all the good stuff you can find in life and all the bad stuff you can successfully avoid.
Right. Well, let me take some pains to differentiate my approach to this from Deepak's,
because it is quite different.
I mean, if we're talking about meditation and awareness and consciousness,
we can sound like we're saying some similar things,
and we might actually, in fact, be saying similar things about the nature of meditative experience,
but we're not drawing the same kinds of conclusions metaphysically from them, right?
So, you know, I tend to not draw any conclusions about the cosmos
from what one can experience in meditation.
I just think it's unwarranted.
There's no necessity to do it,
and I just don't see the intellectual basis by which to do it, right?
You can make profound insights into the nature of mind from the first-person side while meditating.
And again, psychedelics are also another tool here, which have been useful for many people.
They're different, and we can talk about the difference as I see it,
but there's no question that perturbing your nervous system in this way
by changing how you pay attention or by, you know, pharmacology
or, you know, by many other experiences can show you, at a minimum,
that it's possible to have a very different experience of yourself and the world.
Some of those experiences are transformative at every level, you know,
whether it's in your relationships or in just your relationship to yourself
or in your very sense of what a self is.
I mean, it goes very, very deep and can be very, very interesting and rewarding to explore.
And yet, when you're meditating, you can't even tell that you have a brain, right?
I mean, like, even your own existence of your brain is not among the things you can notice while meditating, right?
Much less its significance, right?
If you can't draw any direct first-person conclusions about your own nervous system,
how is it that we can imagine that you can say anything about what happened before the Big Bang
or, you know, any other, you know, answer any other question of cosmology, right?
And that's a move that Deepak tends to make, right?
He will talk about the pure consciousness you can see in the darkness of your closed eyes.
That is the very thing that preceded the Big Bang, right?
All of a sudden, you're doing physics by meditating.
That is now...
It's not to say that in the limit, as we, you know, approach something like a completed science of the mind
and something like a completed physics,
we might discover something interesting about the ontology there of mind and matter,
which links things up in a profound way and maybe there's a place where they touch.
But it's just obvious that for most of us, most of the time,
there's no reason to pretend to know anything about the universe on the basis of what you can experience directly,
just paying attention to what it's like to be you.
But what you can know a lot about is what it's like in your corner of the universe.
I mean, you are part of the universe.
You are this physical system that is illuminated by consciousness for some reason where you sit.
And in this corner of the universe, only you are seeing the universe.
I mean, you're the universe on some level seeing itself from this position, right?
I mean, there's no real boundary between you and the universe physically that's important
or that ultimately demarcates you from, you know, the rest of things.
I mean, the boundary of your skin is nominally where you think you start and stop.
But even there, you know, you're exchanging matter and energy ceaselessly with the world around you.
And the truth is, when you look closely at your subjectivity,
you don't tend to bound yourself at the boundary of your skin, right?
Most people don't feel identical to their bodies.
They feel like they have bodies.
They feel like they're riding around in bodies as a kind of passenger.
You're in relationship to your body in some strange way, right?
And, you know, that's from a scientific point of view that doesn't make a lot of sense.
I mean, if you're a materialist or a physicalist
and you think that everything about you and even consciousness itself
is just an immersion property of your nervous system,
well, then you're going to think, well, it's important that your nervous system be embodied.
Well, then you are coterminous with your body.
You are your body, right?
It's just important to recognize that most people don't feel that way naturally.
The default sense is that there's a kind of an inner subject,
a kind of ghost in the machine that is aware of the machine
from someplace inside it.
But strangely, your body is almost part of the world, right?
You're aware of the world, you know, with your open eyes,
you see your visual field and much of what you see is not self, right?
And your body is an appearance, your physical body that you can see
is an appearance in that same space.
You can see your hands, you can see your legs.
You can't see your head, but you can see everything else.
And, you know, you're aware of all of that from some point of view inside your head,
which feels like this unchanging sense of self,
this I, or me, that is riding around
and is carried through from one moment to the next.
Amid all of the changing data of experience,
you know, changing sights and sounds and sensations and thoughts and moods and emotions,
everything's changing.
There's this full display of energy,
and yet there's this sense that there's a subject in the middle
that is in some way unchanging, right?
This sense of I, this sense of self.
And that's the thing that ultimately, I mean, in the beginning,
you don't really start out targeting that,
but, you know, relatively quickly, at least over in Waking Up,
the app, you know, we instruct people to look closely
at this seeming starting point of being a subject
that can pay attention to sounds or the breath,
let's say, as an exercise, or a mantra.
If you're doing Deepak's method TM,
you know, you're repeating a mantra with the voice of your mind,
and part of you is hearing that.
You know, part of you seems to be saying the sound,
and part of you seems to be hearing it.
And there's still a sense that there's a meditator in the middle of all of this,
doing the thing and noticing changes.
But the claim here, and it is a scientific claim,
it is a, you know, you can entertain it as a scientific hypothesis
and try to, you know, and just look into it for yourself.
The claim is, if you look closely enough at this sense of self,
what you're calling I, this feeling of being a subject,
you won't find it.
And you won't find it in a way that is conclusive,
which is to say you'll find its absence.
You'll no longer feel its presence when you look for it closely enough.
And you'll then feel what consciousness is like prior to a sense of self.
And you'll be able to inspect this kind of boundary condition of the self,
sort of reasserting itself and then disappearing and reasserting itself
and disappearing in a way that becomes very, very precise and very clear
and really no longer a circumstance of any kind of doubt.
And the analogy I tend to draw here, it's not a perfect one,
but it's pretty close, honestly, with respect to several of the key variables,
is to looking for the optic blind spot,
which, you know, many of our listeners will be familiar with,
and this is usually introduced at some point in high school.
You take out a piece of paper, you make two marks on it,
you know, you make like a fixation cross and then you put a dot to one side
and you close one eye and when staring at the fixation cross,
you move the paper, you know, into a position where the dot you've drawn disappears
because, you know, there's an area in your retina where you're just not getting any data
because the optic nerve transits through the retina and there's no photoreceptors there.
Imagine.
The insight there is that this is, through your own first-person experience
and with very little setup, I mean, just a little bit of guidance,
you can do this experiment which reveals something about neuroanatomy
that you wouldn't otherwise be able to inspect directly.
You know, you're not going to find it by accident, right?
There's this deliberate experiment that you have to perform on yourself
and yet it's available and the insight is not deep within you,
it's actually really right on the surface, right?
It's almost too close to you to be noticed without performing this fairly precise way of looking.
And meditation on the nature of the self is analogous to that.
There's a way of looking for this sense of self.
It's harder than this and you can't really use a piece of paper and a pencil to help in quite the same way.
But it can be confirmed, the sense of absence in the same way that, you know,
it becomes uncontrovertible with the optic blind spot.
I mean, you can perform that experiment enough so that you really do confirm for yourself
that you can't see the dot, right?
It's like there is an absence of data there and you can move it in and out of existence
and you can resolve your doubts about it.
And if ever you get those doubts again, you can look at it again and it's there to be seen.
There's something similar with respect to the nature of the self and, you know,
much more importantly, you begin to notice that this sense of self is really the anchor
for virtually all, if not all, of your states of psychological suffering, right?
And when you drop out this sense of self, there's a profound relief in the midst of
whatever negative emotion may have arisen a moment ago on the basis of you being lost in thought, right?
So you could have been angry or impatient or fearful or whatever it is
and you look closely for the self that is suffering that emotion and when it drops away,
there's a profound feeling of relief.
And so that's why it's, you know, that's why it's worth doing and worth looking at
beyond just the intellectual interest of it.
It's just the real doorway into an interest in meditation tends to be, you know,
you feel worse than you want to feel much of the time.
You know, you notice that you just feel crappy.
You're talking to yourself all day long about what you want and what you wish you had
and what you almost had and what you might have had and what you regret and what you're anxious about.
And your bandwidth is just gunked up by a fairly unhappy routine of self-talk,
which strangely no one gets bored of.
You know, it's like you have endless openness to hear yourself rehearse this argument you had
with your wife yesterday for the 15th time this hour and, you know, you don't get bored.
But if you were externalizing these thoughts to a friend, you know, for the 15th time that hour,
you know, he or she would look at you like you had just lost your mind
and certainly not keep your company any longer, right?
So we have very weird standards of reality testing in our own minds
that if you imagine exporting them to human conversation, you know, you'd be branded as a madman.
And meditation is a way of getting some perspective on that and changing your routine.
.