Same Vintage, 6 Iconic Regions - Which Wine Developed Best?

World of Fine Wines
5 followers
May 24, 2026
AI Generated·May contain errors
Hi everybody this is Agnes from No Sediment and today we're going to taste six red wines
from six different winemaking regions all from the same vintage to see which one actually has
developed the best. There are certain wines that immediately come to mind when talking about great
aging potential. Bordeaux certainly never next to it. So today I have decided to put some of these
iconic age-worthy wine styles and regions side by side and see which one shows the best aging
potential. And yes some styles may still be missing but instead of feeling upset about what
is not included suggest to me which region or wine style you would like me to taste next against
today's winner. Of course of course we have to understand that wine's aging potential does not
solely depend on region and its terroir. We also have to talk about grape varieties and their
characteristics such as acidity and tannin. Wine style including sugar level and alcohol content
will also have a significant influence on wine's ability to age. And we cannot forget the overall
balance and quality because you and I we can discuss tannin and acidity aiding in wine's
lifespan but in reality all these structural elements don't do very much if the wine is lacking
in overall quality and balance for development. And of course we have to understand that we are
discussing a single vintage across the globe. Sometimes there is a significant difference even
between villages in the same region let alone between wines from very different climates
thousands of kilometers apart. In addition to that we have to understand that each grape variety
reacts differently to weather and indeed each grape variety prefers different weather conditions.
For example 2017 was not particularly great year in Champagne but Chardonnay did so much better
than Pinot Noir which is why when choosing wines from that specific vintage in Champagne
I would be focusing more on Chardonnay producers and Chardonnay based wines. Some grapes but earlier
exposing themselves to an increased risk of late spring frost while others require a long
maturation period that can be disrupted by unpredictable autumn weather. Grenache withstands
drought and heat better than Syrah or Merlot for example. So no this is not a perfect experiment
but if we really want to compare how these wines develop with age we have to taste across all
regions with a single vintage in mind and if we really want to talk seriously about development
and aging capacity then we need wines with some real age on them at least 10 years. Now there's
no question that great aging potential is not exclusive to red wines. Whites, sparkling wines
and most certainly fortified wines can also age gracefully but today we are focusing on red wines
alone. Shall we taste and see which region comes on top? Like I said all six wines come from six
different winemaking regions and the same vintage that unites them is 2012 so the wines are around
14 years old. I have quite classic winemaking regions here I have Verdeux, I have Napa, I have
Amarone, I have Barolo and I think I have Stellenbosch and there's also one wild card that I entered here
and I'm not going to tell you from which region or grape variety it is made from but as always
these wines are poured by my cameraman so I don't know which one is which and I guess you will have
to guess or make educated decisions on the wines with me. So let's start with wine number one.
All right so this is not the deepest colored wine it does show some age as well because we do have
that brownish or brickish rim but in the core it is still garnet and not that inky. Nose is still
dominant by black and blue berries they are maybe slightly dryish in a character but definitely
there's still a lot of energy and the berries are so prominent and so intense this wine is really
inviting however on the very beginning when I nose the wine it was it had that smoky character
to it you know maybe slight hint of meatiness and now as this wine is opening up I feel
I feel some green olive maybe or some rosemary or thyme like dried herbal characters. It seems
very inviting and very charming on the nose let's taste it. Wow the acidity is elevated lively juicy
it adds a bit of freshness to the wine to that really ripe fruit profile but definitely not
overripe and what I really love about this wine is that chalky tannin texture it just covers your
palate it adds seriousness it adds grown-upness to the wine and to the really ripe fruit profile
that I was describing in the beginning if the alcohol is elevated here in this wine it is
perfectly integrated within the fruit within the body of the wine I don't particularly feel it
neither on the first sip nor on the finish on the finish it is actually that chalky tannin texture
that slightly wilted black cherry skin that I feel and I will give this wine 92 points I think
for 14 year old wine this wine is holding its ground quite well let's move to one number three
two let's move to wine number two all right so this one is that much more intense on the color
yeah it is deep and inky and and if I would have to guess the vintage I would not say that this is
10 plus years old wine because you maybe only start to see that slightly orangey brickish
character you know that tone on the on the rim but it is overall quite deeply colored
wine showing no signs of aging at least in the color on the nose you have that really intense
ripe black currant bush I am saying bush because it is all the berries that you have on the bush
and you also have those you know when you when you crack the bush the the woody part of it it's
also very very aromatic you feel it a lot so there's hint of that pyrazine character as well
there's some sweet spices some vanilla to the wine and of course if I would have to speculate
about the grape variety it screams cabernet sauvignon because we have that black currant
we have that cassis we have that slight pyrazine tone but it is quite earthy and spicy as well
yeah I've been talking a lot about its nose so let's taste it all right when I smelled the wine
at first it was so open and it screamed cabernet and I had the question in my mind could it be
from Napa but when you taste it it is actually so much slimmer and it has that really chalky
that elevated slightly grippy tannin texture definitely not as powdery as maybe with wine
number one here you really can feel that backbone of cabernet sauvignon you also have that elevated
acidity that together with that really slim body is rarely found in Napa I will give this wine
91.5 points let's move to wine number three wine number three you are really interesting you're
quite pale quite pale color gives you indication of grape varieties that could follow and it is
not particularly fruity wine there's some smoke and some mushrooms and earthy elements of turned
earth and forest floor and autumn leaves somewhere in the background you have dried strawberries
those summer strawberries and raspberries now this is mysterious on the nose this is spooky
this is fog I don't know like you know when you just see the shapes of forests and animals and
trees instead of the like whole colored picture okay so the way my mouth is pulled together by
the tannin it screams a certain grape variety of course the color helps here and the elevated
acidity helps so this wine definitely tells where it is coming from despite the fact that it is 14
year old wine it is really interesting because the wines as they age in a way sometimes they get
similar to each other and at some point when they're really really old there might come situation
when the old has overpowered the terroir expression or even grape variety in this case the
impressive mouth coating completely drawing tannin texture that really elevated acidity
that is still watering my mouth while I speak with you says or whispers to me that this is Nebbiolo
there is one thing that is missing in this specific wine for me personally at least
is the mid palette and Barolos can have this really charming generous mid palette but here
I feel like the tannin made the frame and there's not a huge or highly beautiful or colorful picture
in the frame within so I will give this wine 90 points let's move to wine number four wow this is
interesting wine on the nose because I feel a lot of toasty elements but toasty elements like coffee
bean like black chocolate they're spicy this is so interesting and unique and the fruit
maybe some dried black cherry or dried plum character this wine is puzzling my mind because
as I nose it it maybe slightly evaporates and start to show some of that fruit as well
but in general I would say that that toastiness really dominates the nose let's move to the
tasting yeah this is this is interesting wine there is at first sip that you feel there is slight
sneak peek of some sweetness you know or fruit ripeness but it just evaporates quite quickly
leaving that really fresh but still quite ripe fruit profile and those fruit are those black
raspberries those forest berries blueberries and blackberries the nose still puzzles me
because of that toastiness but that toastiness not like you know that beautiful sweet toast
character coming from oak but that maybe almost slightly burned character that is interesting
even though on the palate you have that really beautiful juicy acidity and it's so masterfully
integrated within the wine and the tannin is just you know masterfully playing on the cheeks
instead of covering you know or overpowering your palate I will give this wine I will also give this
wine 90 points I think I think this wine confuses me but it will be interesting to reveal it and
come back to it so let's move to wine number five another deeply colored deeply colored red wine
inky red wine wow on the nose we have such a generous intense character we have blueberries
and blackberries and ripe black cherries plums here and that fruit is really intense and just
showing off however it also has that spicy earthy character slightly toasty sweet toast
character that adds you know a bit of a bit of shape to the fruit or a bit of frame to the fruit
as opposed in comparison to wine number four where that toastness was slightly irritating my nose
you just smell this wine and you know it's going to be big and opulent and and quite
generous with everything let's taste it wine number five is the slightly naughty child
playing you know on the edge of the rules and see how far they can go I think that this style might
not be particularly fashionable nowadays because it is luscious and it is rich and full-bodied
and it has beautiful acidity but it is more that ripeness of fruit that shines on the palate and
of course it also shines on the nose but it is really really charming wine number five is like
one of those people that are beautiful in their own unique way and maybe they're a bit rude or
maybe they sometimes say things that are not appropriate but you love them anyways and they
have this kind heart so this is what wine number five represents to me I love the really sweet
tasting tannin here in this wine and it just makes all together a really beautiful albeit
not completely fashionable but really beautiful picture and I love it for it I will give this wine
95 points I love it let's move to wine number six by the way wine number five not a lot of age
it showed maybe I feel you know slight hint of I don't know dried autumn leaf or some earthy
character to it but it definitely didn't show a lot of age it felt really youngish
wine number six all right so wine number six actually does show some age it is brownish
specifically with significantly brownish rim and wine number six it shows that really significant
red berry driven flavor on the nose but those cherries those strawberries and raspberries we
are talking about they're dried there's some leathery note character to it some dumb earth
there is some earthiness to this wine let's taste it I think wine number six has similar charm as
wine number five it is rich and opulent but it has some reservations there is this earthiness as with
number five this wine was really you know all about fruit all about luscious ripe sometimes
even overripe fruit profile but wine number six it has that unapologetical european soul so it is
not all about fruit yes fruit is part of its being but it has that earthy that forest floor that
dried fruit character character that leathery element to it and it also shows that complexity
on the palate for me it shows really long aftertaste yes wine number six shows that
slightly sweetish tasting throughout you know its development on the palate but still it is those
dried fruit that I feel on the aftertaste it is that really beautiful really ripe type of tannin
on the palate I think this wine is quite magnificent as well interestingly it shows
way more age than maybe other of the wines that we tasted did but there is still a lot of charm
there yeah I think this wine is really lovely and and I quite enjoy it in this early morning
I will give this wine 93 points shall we reveal the wines all right we will start with the lowest
scored wines and that was wine number four and one number three let's start with wine number four
no way no this guys this guys this was the wild card I have tasted this wine on several occasions
and I usually really loved it and I am surprised that I did not enjoy it as much this time oh my
all right this is interesting anyway this is Birgit Braunstein Blau Frankisch Ried Tennau
so a single vineyard single site from Burgenland Leithaberg if I'm not mistaken this is 2012 vintage
I usually love this wine quite a lot maybe it is an issue of bottle variation you know as the wines
get older it could be the case but Birgit makes some of the top top Blau Frankisch in Austria
and there is no doubt about it and I will still fight for it saying that Blau Frankisch can age
beautifully all right let's move to wine number three I think we are up for a lot of surprises
so wine number three it also received 90 points from my side yeah with wine number three I kind
of knew that this was Barolo it was Nabiolo it had that unique color that you know that signature
tannin on the palate so this is 2012 2012 was not particularly easy vintage it was quite challenging
and we are with Rivetto within the Serralunga village Serralunga makes these fuller bodied
wines more expressive in a way you know more structured that can age really gracefully and
you know I love Enrico Rivetto and his wines but this wine yes as I told you I felt that
maybe on the mid palate this specific bottle was slightly lacking but I think it is still
interesting to see how Barolo and Nabiolo has developed over the age anyway let's move to
the wine number two which I gave 91.5 I give 0.5 Chateau Phelan Segout 2012 Sainte-Esteve
some of you might say and I would agree that I did not do justice to Bordeaux because in all
honesty Bordeaux probably is one of the first winemaking regions that come to your mind
when you think about wines that can age and by justice I mean some of the wines that I have
chosen for this tasting they are quite expensive and of course Phelan Segout might not be playing
on the same level however I do think that Phelan Segout makes beautiful wines and especially
starting from you know 2009 and 2010 onwards and they have really upped their game so 12 was a
complex vintage in Bordeaux it was not as easy as with 2009 and 2010 of course you know where you
can buy whatever wines more or less you want to or you can find and you sure will get some really
good bargains 12 you really should have looked for good producers but I think despite the fact
that this was not the highest praised estate it still did so good within the tasting and it was
not awkward or you know dragging its feet behind with its you know lost breath of air it was still
you know playing with the big guys so let's move to wine number one I think which I gave 92 points
now we are in South Africa Stellenbosch Ken Forrester wines the Gypsy 2012 so Ken Forrester
is actually known for their Chenin Blanc they make amazing Chenin Blanc their Chenin Blanc has been
I think on my top 10 wines of the year I make top 10 as well and I really enjoy his
winemaking style he is also a character as a personality and I'm really looking forward to
interview him one day hopefully that will come and this wine is made from Grenache and Syrah
from old vineyards old vines in the area and I mean I was so impressed by this wine
it had the issue it had the problem to be the very first wine on the early morning that I'm
tasting and doing this video I might have given it a bit higher mark as well I still remember that
chalky tannin texture I really enjoy it but I also wanted to show you something for all of you
skeptics out there you see it has a screw cup you cannot open it but it has a screw cup
and it has lived under the screw cup for 14 years less probably because it was aged in oak
for a while so maybe 10 around 10 years it aged beautifully it didn't show a lot of you know that
aged character and it still hold its fruit quite well so screw cup you can buy wines
under the screw cup and you can still age them let's move to wine number six
how many points I gave this wine did I think I gave this wine 94 yes I was I was asking myself
could this be Amarone della Valpolicella from Praa Morandina and when I was asking myself when I was
tasting this wine one of the questions that I asked was I think this is Amarone and I think
Amarone usually has really high alcohol levels and this one has 16.5 I didn't feel it it is so
well integrated and this is the crime and punishment of Praa wines of Praa Amarone specifically
because they taste so good the alcohol is so well integrated within their wines
you enjoy them you taste them you drink them you love them and then you notice that you're
completely drunk afterwards they just taste so well and to be honest I was really skeptical
about Amarone being one of those wines that could age a lot of you people have suggested
in the comment sections on other of my videos saying that Amarone can also age I never included
it in one of my videos but in reality this tasting shows that it can age one of the hesitations that
I usually would argue about Amarone and its aging is it because it is made from dried grapes
and already during that drying process you know you get some might get some disease in the fruit
you might get some volatile acidity a bit more so of course I always questioned myself could it
really age that well afterwards but Praa has showed that it can age magnificently it is interesting
to know that Praa is actually a white wine maker so they they focus more on their Suaves but this
is amazing I've never been disappointed about their Amarones and wine number five with whopping 95
points that charm that you know flesh I already know which one we don't have
Inglenook Estate Napa Valley Rutherford California Rubicon 2012. I bought this wine at the winery
long long time ago when I was visiting the estate it is beautiful place to be I also quickly looked
uh and seeked any information about the vintage and apparently it was really good vintage it had
no heat spikes and no drought periods and no uh no not not a lot of rain so it allowed grapes and
wines to mature you know in that harmony and uh this has resulted in really beautiful wine it is
carbonate dominant I think but there are other grape varieties included wow I have waited quite
a long time to open it and who would have known that I will open it on YouTube channel and tasting
with you guys it is really really beautiful wine I really liked it it is jolly wine as well but I
think there was a lot of seriousness about it as well guys if you like this video I would appreciate
a lot if you would also subscribe if you haven't already it really helps the channel and I think
it also helps you a bit if you want to keep up with the no sediment wine videos please let me
know in the comment section below if you would like me to continue similar videos to these
which regions and which vintages I should cover next and make sure to continue watching
no sediment with this video
