Homo Sapiens Were Everywhere Before "out of Africa" | 150k Years

Ancient Civilizations
15 followers
8 Video Views·May 24, 2026
Long before the successful Out of Africa migrations, there were countless waves of homo sapiens ventures into Europe, Asia, and the Levant into Arabia regions, starting from 210k years old in Greece, 180k in the Levant, 100k in China, at least 85k in Arabia. These finds are fascinating, and crucial to understanding claims about other hominins around the world.
AI Generated·May contain errors
Modern humans, homo sapiens, did not suddenly explode out of Africa in one single wave.
They had been venturing out of their African homeland in small groups long before what we
call the major out-of-Africa migration, about 60,000 years ago, the one that gave rise to
all non-African people today. Fossils and artifacts from Europe, the Middle East, and Asia
show that early homo sapiens were exploring these regions tens of thousands of years earlier.
These pioneering humans left behind bones, stone tools, and even hints of symbolic culture like
ochre pigments and beads, and we have a really good picture of these failed early dispersals
that preceded the successful OOA dispersal. So this video will cover everything known across
all the different disciplines, what we know about these oldest homo sapiens that got out of Africa
before OOA, when and where they lived, what tools and art they made, and how they compare to other
hominins, and what ultimately became of them. Let's start by understanding that the entire
old world had been filled with our earlier hominin relatives for millions of years before sapiens
became distinct. I've seen people claim that some hominins made it all the way into the Americas,
but at least for now that still seems to be a more fringe theory, but definitely something I want to
cover in another video. The consensus still has this restricted to the old world, basically
everything besides the Americas. So around 2.1 million years ago, the earliest hominins ventured
out of Africa. Stone tools from the Shangchen site in China date to about 2.12 million years ago,
telling us that some human ancestor, likely an early form within the homo genus, reached East
Asia far earlier than once thought. These primitive toolmakers predate the oldest known human fossils
outside of Africa by over 250,000 years. Now what's really weird is that no hominin bones
were found at Shangchen, but of course these tools show a presence. About 1.8 million years ago,
Homo erectus, or a closely related early human, lived in Eurasia. Fossils from Dmanisi, Georgia,
are the oldest human remains outside of Africa. The Dmanisi hominins had small brains, about 600 cc,
and used very primitive stone tools. Homo erectus soon spread across Asia, reaching Java and
Indonesia by 1.6 million years ago, and into Europe by about 1.2 million years ago, like
what's called Homo antecessor in Spain. This species wielded the Acheulean hand axe, a teardrop
shaped stone tool, and was likely the first to master fire and long distance travel. About 700
to 300,000 years ago, a new wave of hominins left Africa, often termed Homo heidelbergensis,
or archaic humans. They gave rise to Neanderthals in Europe and Denisovans in Asia, and by about
400,000 years ago, Neanderthals, descended from those migrants, were now thriving in Europe,
and their cousins had spread all over Asia. These groups had big brains like ours and used
middle Paleolithic stone tools, like prepared cores and flakes, and around 500,000 years ago,
Homo erectus in Java carved a zigzagged engraving on a shell, the oldest known abstract engraving.
This shows that even pre-sapien humans had some symbolic or artistic behavior.
About 300,000 years ago, in Africa, Homo sapiens was emerging, becoming a distinct group within
the Homo genus. Around 210,000 years ago, the first known Homo sapiens reached Europe.
A partial skull from the Apidema cave in Greece, called Apidema I, has been dated to 210,000 years,
making it the oldest Homo sapiens fossil outside Africa. And what's really important is that it
was found alongside a Neanderthal skull, which was dubbed Apidema II, but which was dated to
around 170,000 years ago. So these two are about 40,000 years apart, but are found in the same
cave. This points to an early sapiens group that reached into southern Europe, but died out.
And Neanderthals later reoccupied this cave. Around 180,000 to 130,000 years ago,
Homo sapiens expanded into the Levant. A jawbone from Meslia cave in Israel has been confirmed to
be around 177,000 to 194,000 years old. This was shocking proof that humans were in the Near East
much earlier than expected, nearly three times older than the Out of Africa migration.
Later, during a warm interglacial period, about 130,000 years ago, populations of modern humans
lived at skull and copse of caves, also in Israel, around 120,000 to 90,000 years ago.
These early movements into southwest Asia were intermittent. Humans may have entered
the region during climate-friendly periods and retreated when conditions worsened.
About 100,000 years ago, Homo sapiens reached East Asia. Fossil evidence in China suggests
fully modern humans were present here. Like in Fuyan cave in Daoxian, within southern China,
they found 47 modern human teeth that are said to be over 80,000 years ago,
with experts saying it's likely from around 120,000 to 100,000 years ago.
Another site in China, Zhendong, preserved a modern-looking jaw, also over 100,000 years old.
The finds imply a southern dispersal route that modern humans may have traveled along
through South Asia into China well before the main OOA migration.
Then we have at 85,000 years ago, Homo sapiens in the Arabian Peninsula. At Al-Usta,
within Saudi Arabia, scientists found a fossil human finger bone dated to about 85,000 years old.
Around it were over 800 animal fossils and 400 stone tools, excavated from sediments of an
ancient freshwater lake. This lucky find, a single finger digit, confirms modern humans
had spread into Arabia, indicating multiple migration pulses out of Africa.
Arabia's climate was much greener then, with lakes and grasslands supporting animals like hippos.
It would feel like a continuation of the African Green Sahara.
And our ancestors clearly followed these habitable corridors into these new territories.
60-50,000 years ago is when we have the major OOA migration. Genetic evidence shows that
virtually all non-African humans today descend from a migration during this period.
Starting around 60,000 years ago, modern humans expanded along the coasts of South Asia,
reached Australia by about 50,000 years ago, and entered Europe by about 45,000 years ago,
eventually replacing Neanderthals. This was the truly successful globe-spanning dispersal
that led to the populations we see around the world today.
All of those other excursions out of Africa show that it was obviously possible,
that all of these other hominins within the Homo group, we've all just had this need to keep
exploring, to keep pushing out as far as we can, but though these are really interesting,
they all ended in either extinction or assimilation.
So let's dive deeper into those examples, starting with Apodema Cave.
In the late 1970s, researchers found two fossil skulls encased in brachia side by side.
For decades, they assumed both were Neanderthals, but more recent analysis
proved Apodema I is actually a modern human, confidently dated to around 210,000 years ago,
meaning it predates the next oldest Homo sapiens in Misalia Cave by about 30,000 years,
and rewrites the human timeline in Europe. Apodema I is just the back half of a skull,
but its shape clusters with the Homo sapiens, not Neanderthals. Apodema II,
dated around 170,000 years ago, is confirmed to be Neanderthal.
And to really prove that these are not neat migration timelines,
it's younger than the modern human skull, showing that sapiens reached Europe earlier,
but their settlements did not last, and Katerina Havarti, who led the study,
notes that there are no living descendants of that Apodema group. It was likely a dead end,
a population, quote, replaced by Neanderthals soon after. It's unknown if they died from
shortages or disease, or warfare, being slain by those Neanderthals.
And unfortunately, we don't know much about their culture. Apodema I was found isolated in a niche
with no associated tools or artifacts. The cave deposits had been disturbed over millennia,
so we lack the archaeological context. But its very presence could shake the paradigm,
asking the question, could some of the stone tools in Europe from about 200,000 years ago,
previously assumed to be Neanderthal made,
could those actually have been crafted by these Homo sapien pioneers?
Archaeologists have found Middle Paleolithic tools in Greece from that time,
but without direct association to Apodema, we can only speculate. But whatever the case,
Apodema I stands as a testament that our species explored into Neanderthal territory
far earlier than once believed, even if that incursion was brief.
And we should really stress that it's 200,000 years old,
which was always about how old we thought Homo sapiens were as a species entirely.
In other words, most people say the Homo sapien species is only 200,000 years old,
and yet we found a skull that's about 10,000 years older than that in Greece.
I'm not saying that's a point against out of Africa, I've covered the genetics on that endlessly,
but it reinforces the idea that those 300,000 year old human fossils found in Morocco
were Homo sapiens, and that modern humans had been all over the continent of Africa
coming into contact with Arabia or the Levant and also the Mediterranean near Spain.
And if they built ships, like I covered in the earliest seafarers episode,
you put all that together and I think you just have a much more complete idea of these
early human migrations. Now we should look towards the Levant, which was always a key
crossroads for early human expansions, going out of Africa and back in countless times over these
300,000 years. At Meslia Cave on Mount Carmel in Israel, archaeologists unearthed an upper jaw
with 8 intact teeth. Testing, and a whole bunch of retesting, confirmed its age at 177,000 to
194,000 years old. Again, ironically, and this is the best part about peer-reviewed science,
because this goes against the norm, you know this find was challenged extensively.
And yet that dating was confirmed, blowing past the previous record and showing Homo
Sapiens were present in the Levant almost 200,000 years ago. And there's no question that these were
anatomically modern, no debate over this like there is at the site at Jebel Arut. And this site
also yielded a trove of stone tools and other remains. Burnt flint blades found near the jaw
were dated to around 179,000 years ago, which match up with the fossil's age, and they were
made using the level wall technique, a sophisticated stone knapping method involving prepared cores
where you strike off these sharp flakes. Level wall technology was common in Africa's middle
stone age and was also used by Neanderthals, suggesting that Meslia's people carried African
tool traditions into the Levant. The cave also held animal bones and evidence of fire,
other burned objects, showing that these early humans were successful hunters or scavengers
living in the region's grasslands and woodlands. Meslia cave had been sealed by rockfall for over
160,000 years, and it worked to excellently preserve this snapshot of early Homo sapien
encampment. We can jump ahead to the last interglacial period, about 130,000 to 90,000
years ago, and we again see Homo sapiens in the Levant, with the Skol and Kofza caves.
These sites were excavated in the 1930s and yielded the remains of at least 10 individuals
in Skol on Mount Carmel and 15 at Kofza in Lower Galilee. The Skol layer was dated to around 81
to 119,000 years ago, and Kofza is confidently put at 95,000 years ago. I'll agree they are
anatomically modern humans, even if they still have a few primitive traits. This is why they
were once classified as a separate paleoanthropus species, but today almost all experts agree that
they are firmly within the Homo sapien group. And these caves give us an incredibly rich picture
of early modern human life. At Kofza cave, excavations found multiple intentional burials
of adults and children. Kofza XI was a young adolescent laid to rest on their back,
with deer antlers placed on their hands and chest, or fire pits, abundant stone tools,
animal bones, and symbolic items. The stone tools are mostly middle paleolithic mostyrian tools,
like sidescrapers, points, disc cores, and flakes. So in other words, the Skol and Kofza people were
making tools similar to those of Neanderthals in the region, but their symbolic behavior sets
them apart. Archaeologists recovered a collection of seashells, specifically Glycomeris bivalves,
those are found in Kofza cave, in layers predating most of the burials. These marine
shells came from the Mediterranean coast about 35 kilometers away, but show wear that suggests they
were strung together, like a necklace. And some shells had traces of red ochre pigment on them,
so it looks like early humans were using these seashells as personal adornments,
painting or tinting them with ochre, behavior that isn't directly connected to survival,
this falls under art or symbolic culture. Red ochre chunks were found in the caves as well,
and one limestone flake had an incised crosshatch design, possibly just a doodle or some sort of
symbol, but it's all evidence that by about a hundred thousand years ago, Homo sapiens in the
Levant had rituals, they were burying with grave goods, they had body decoration or jewelry,
and had unique artistic expression. And to stress that this was a very different area at the time,
the presence of gazelle, deer, horse, ox, and even rhinoceros bones show a broad diet of game
animals in this Ice Age Galilee region, and the Skull and Kofza populations appear to have
coexisted for a time with Neanderthals in the region. Nearby cave sites like Tabun held Neanderthal
remains from 120 to 60,000 years ago, and some layers at the Skull and Kofza and Neanderthal
caves overlap in time, raising the possibility of encounters or even cultural exchange between
the groups. Obviously there was genetic exchange. Ultimately though, like the people of Meslea,
the Skull and Kofza populations seem to have been a failed dispersal. Genetic studies suggest they
left no surviving lineage today, and that's the same story, their caves were later reoccupied by
Neanderthals, but eventually they would be replaced by the wave of modern humans after 60,000 years
ago. Now we can look across Asia, from Arabia to China and beyond. Some have proposed that
our ancestors took a path up through Africa, out into the Levant, and then back down into the
Arabian Peninsula, which at times had a wetter climate and rich savannas. Dramatic proof of this
came in Al-Wasta in today's Saudi Arabian desert. In what was once a lakeside, researchers have
found a diminutive fossil, a single finger bone, that could only belong to an anatomically modern
human. It was a middle finger phalanx, just 3.2 centimeters long, but its shape clearly matched
homo sapiens and no other hominins. Using several dating methods, like uranium series on the bone
and the hippo tooth, and luminescence on the surrounding sediment, they determined the bone
is about 85,000 years old. It was just insane to find this human and needle in a haystack in the
food desert, where they also found 800 plus animal fossils, including hippopotamus remains,
and 380 plus stone tools, made in the middle Paleolithic style. These tools were likely
crafted from local chert, and resembled those from northeast Africa, supporting the idea that
modern humans moved through a green Arabia, where rains expanded the lakes and grasslands.
This Al-Wasta discovery, quote, supports arguments that humans left Africa in multiple waves,
and it's a pretty good rule of thumb that if humans could move into areas, they did. And there
isn't much more known about these sites, some speculate that they just kept moving and never
really established permanent populations, true nomadic adventurers, and they would have become
isolated as climate changed, as deserts again overtook these areas. Now what's really interesting,
but it hasn't been confirmed to be a direct connection, but it's just everything else
seemed to point to this, is that there are very similar stone tools found in Oman and the UAE,
dated to around 100,000 years ago, and so it's likely that they had been here for far longer
than 85,000 years ago, I wouldn't be surprised if it was closer to 200, as everything shows us
that humans expand rapidly, just tens of decades at most, and the Misliya cave in the Levant was
around 200,000 years ago. It's just they can't say for sure, because these are just tools,
and not human fossils. For actual human fossils in this area, we just have that single finger bone,
so humans were here at least 85,000 years ago. But what might be the most surprising,
is that Homo sapiens reached East Asia long before 60,000 years ago. For decades,
the consensus has been that modern humans only reached East Asia with the out-of-Africa migration,
the main successful one 60,000 years ago, but Chinese fossil finds are changing that story.
In Daoshan, China, at Fuyuan cave, excavations between 2011 and 2013 found 47 human teeth
that are indistinguishable from those of modern humans. Small, with slender roots,
and no heavy Neanderthal ridges. These were found alongside abundant animal fossils of species of
around 120 to 80,000 years ago, and what's really crucial is that a thick flowstone,
a stalagmite layer, sealing this deposit was dated to at least 80,000 years ago,
meaning all the humans and faunal remains beneath are older than 80k. The likely range for the
And this makes Fuyuan cave's teeth the oldest, fully modern human remains in East Asia.
They significantly predate the famous Taiyuan man, a modern human found near Beijing,
who was around 40,000 years old, and perfectly within the timeline of that out-of-Africa
migration. Another site in southern China, at Xirin cave, would give us part of a jaw
and teeth initially dated to greater than 100,000 years old. While some researchers contested its
dating and whether it was truly Homo sapiens, testing over the years has now confirmed that
our species had reached southern China long before the main exit from Africa. This implies
a possible southern migration route skirting the Indian Ocean, and you can see how it lines up with
all these other finds, with around 200,000 in Greece and Levant, a little later in Arabia,
and then a little later still in East Asia, but still within tens of thousands of years apart,
so in a way it's the same pace as the out-of-Africa migrations, and when you zoom out to hominins in
general, it's just something that all of the humans, all of the species within the homogenous,
they just seem to always be expanding. Some die out, just to be replaced by later migrations.
Some think these pioneers may have island-hopped through South Asia, maybe even reaching Southeast
Asia, and some experts have even proposed that modern humans would have gotten to Borneo or
Sumatra, but were wiped out by the massive Toba volcanic eruption about 74,000 years ago. I lean
in support of this, again especially when you consider that Homo erectus had already spread
throughout this region a million years ago, but for Homo sapiens, the genetic and archaeological
support for these early presences in Southeast Asia is still debated. What is odd is that at
Daoshan's Fuyan cave, no stone tools were reported, but like we've seen, finding anything at all is
impressive, so most researchers think that whatever tools they did have simply weren't
preserved. There's every reason to assume that they would have had Middle Paleolithic toolkits,
just like those in Africa and the Levant. And what's really interesting is that there is genetic
evidence of these early pre-OOA migrations, the genes of those people do live on in us,
which you might think, wait, doesn't that disprove that we're all descendant from the
out-of-Africa migrations? And no, it's really complicated. It's that within Neanderthal DNA,
there's evidence of interbreeding with those early modern human groups around 100,000 years ago.
Specifically, a Neanderthal in Siberia had a Homo sapien ancestor, a small percent but still
detectable, and it must have come from these early migrant groups. So though these pre-OOA
migration people left no direct descendants today, a trace of their legacy lives on in the
genomes of Neanderthals and Denisovans, and because those Neanderthals and Denisovans
then also mixed with the out-of-Africa people, they are indirectly in our genome,
going from sapien to Neanderthal, then back into sapien. I really think that's just one
of the most fascinating parts of all this. That gene exchange also matches up with the
taq exchange, as the Levelois technique is seen with Neanderthals as well as humans.
Around 200 to 100,000 years ago, there was a convergence in stone tool technology across
different human species. Those earlier pre-OOA Homo sapiens did not yet have the upper Paleolithic
toolkit, no long blades, bone tools, stuff like that, no bows and arrows, things that later waves
of modern humans brought after 50,000 years ago. And it's unknown if the modern humans had expanded
out of Africa first, if they were actually using this first form of ranged weapons. If not, it
might explain why they died out, if they simply lost wars to Neanderthals. And people tend to
think that because the human migrations were pushing out Neanderthals, they were there first,
so they must have been the first to do everything. But there is a bit of an odd timeline on artistic
expression. We saw in Cofsa that they were using pigments and wearing shell jewelry by about 100,000
years ago. There's pieces of ochre engraved with crosshatch patterns from Blombos Cave at 75,000
years ago, and marine shell beads in Morocco at 142,000 years ago. But Neanderthals are a bit
after us. There's a set of eagle talons from the Krapina Cave in Croatia, dated to around 130,000
years ago, having cut marks and wear that shows that they might have been strung into a necklace
or for a bracelet, so jewelry. But I wouldn't be surprised if these iconic cave paintings in Spain
end up having some pretty reasonable theories that these might have been made by Homo sapiens.
It's been assumed that because they're over 64,000 years old, they must be Neanderthals,
because the OOA migration of modern humans didn't reach there yet. But like we know now,
there have been Homo sapiens in Europe for over 200,000 years, and like also mentioned in the
earliest Seafarers video, getting to Spain was one of the easiest routes to go. There are times where
you can actually see the other shoreline. Right by the Straits of Gibraltar, everyone could stand
in Africa and see the shores of Europe. And the oldest evidence we have of Homo sapiens is in
Morocco, around 300,000 years old. So I haven't seen this overturned yet, but it seems very
reasonable to me. Now saying all that, I know some people in the comments are going to take it way
too far. Even under what I'm saying, they're still coming out of Africa. It's just before that. When
we say the pre-OOA groups, obviously that's still OOA. It's just we know that when we say the OOA,
the out of Africa group, we're talking about the group, the 60,000 year old group that populated
the world. Because like lead researcher mentioned before, paleoanthropologist Katrina Havarti says,
she obviously knows all these points too, she stresses within her work that all humans living
today outside of Africa still trace their ancestry to the big dispersal about 70 to 50,000
years ago. We are not direct descendants of these earlier adventurers. The Levantine early human
groups seem to have disappeared by around 80,000 years ago. And same story in China and other parts
of Asia. They had been completely replaced by waves of Neanderthals or Denisovans who moved
into these areas. Again, either they lost via warfare or died out due to whatever else you can
think of. Disease to famine and everything else. But I still just find it so cool that the gene
flow from those early modern humans made it into Denisovan and Neanderthal DNA. And even if they
did die out, a bit of their material lived on in us, eventually coming back into us when homo sapiens
did eventually take over the entire world. Maybe even getting payback for our ancestors. Please let
me know what you think of all this in the comments down below. And please hit that like button, it
really does help me out. But I'll see you in the next one.
