Why Diesel Locomotives Never Turn Off

Machine Engine
3 followers
A diesel locomotive can burn seven gallons of fuel every hour while sitting completely still in a rail yard, going nowhere. Across North America, that adds up to more than twenty million gallons of wasted diesel every year.
#machine #Equipment #Engine
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedNorth American diesel locomotives frequently idle to avoid the risks of cold starts, coolant freezing, and air brake pressure loss. While traditional practices prioritize operational reliability and regulatory compliance, the industry is transitioning toward energy-saving technologies like AESS and APUs to reduce fuel waste and emissions.
A diesel locomotive can burn seven gallons of fuel every hour while sitting completely still
in a rail yard, going nowhere. Across North America, that adds up to more than 20 million
gallons of wasted diesel every year. But railroads aren't doing this out of laziness.
So what is actually stopping them from turning these engines off? The answer involves frozen
water, compressed air, federal safety regulations, and an industry that spent decades choosing the
lesser of two very expensive problems. The diesel engine inside a modern freight locomotive is not
anything like the engine in your truck. It is closer in scale to the kind of engine you would
find bolted to the deck of a small cargo ship. The most common prime movers on North American
railroads are EMD 645 and 710 series, massive two-stroke V16 diesels originally designed by
General Motors Electro-Motive Division. Each cylinder in a 645 series engine displaces 645
cubic inches of volume. That is more than 10 liters per cylinder. Multiply that by 16 cylinders and
the total displacement of one of these engines exceeds 10,000 cubic inches. For comparison,
a large pickup truck engine might displace around 6 liters total. The locomotive engine is roughly
28 times larger. These engines do not use spark plugs. They are compression ignition diesels,
meaning the fuel ignites when air inside the cylinder is compressed to such extreme pressure
that it reaches ignition temperature on its own. In a warm operating engine, this works beautifully.
The metal is at operating temperature, the lubricating oil flows freely, and the turbocharger
is spinning at thousands of revolutions per minute. However, when one of these engines sits
cold in a rail yard overnight and the temperature drops below freezing, everything changes. The
lubricating oil thickens into something closer to syrup. The massive pistons and connecting rods
resist movement because the oil can no longer reduce friction effectively. The starter motor,
powered by a bank of lead-acid batteries, has to overcome all of that resistance to crank the
engine, and those same batteries lose a significant portion of their output in cold weather,
right when you need them most. Even if the starter manages to turn the engine over,
the cold cylinder walls may not allow the compressed air to reach ignition temperature.
The engine cranks and cranks, but it refuses to fire. When a cold locomotive does finally start,
the process is not instant. Depending on conditions, it can take 10 to 20 minutes
of careful warm-up before the engine is ready for service. The cooling system must reach operating
temperature gradually to prevent thermal shock, which can crack cylinder liners and warp the
engine block. During that entire warm-up period, the locomotive cannot be loaded to full throttle.
AGE patent filing noted that in cold weather conditions, there may be a delay of more than
one hour after starting before the engine is capable of operating at full power. For a railroad
that needs a locomotive ready to move freight within minutes of a crew arriving, that kind of
delay is not acceptable. But what if the cold start problem were the only issue? Could railroads not
solve it with better batteries or block heaters and call it a day? They could try, but that is
only the first reason these machines stay running. The second reason is something that surprises
almost everyone who learns about it, and it involves water. Unlike the engine in your car,
which circulates a mixture of water and ethylene glycol antifreeze, large North American railroad
locomotives use plain water as their engine coolant. Not a water and antifreeze blend.
The coolant is water, sometimes treated with corrosion inhibitors, but fundamentally nothing
more than that. Why would any railroad do this? A locomotive cooling system holds anywhere from 200
to 600 gallons of coolant. Filling that volume with antifreeze would cost several thousand
dollars per locomotive, and the expense repeats every time the system is serviced or flushed.
Beyond cost, the engines themselves were not originally designed for glycol-based coolants.
Railroad maintenance crews discovered over the decades that antifreeze mixtures caused problems
with certain gasket materials and internal seals. One railroad attempted to switch its fleet to a
water-glycol cocktail, and the result was a maintenance nightmare. Microbes grew in the
jacket water system. The glycol's lower heat transfer coefficient meant the engine ran hotter
without producing more power, and standby circulator pump seals failed so frequently
that a locomotive had to be pulled from service nearly every week. Water, by contrast, is cheap,
transfers heat more efficiently, and poses no environmental hazard if a hose fails
and the coolant spills onto the track bed. But the trade-off is obvious. Water freezes.
And when several hundred gallons of water freeze inside the intricate passages of a locomotive
engine block, the expanding ice cracks, cast iron, splits cooling passages, and destroys the prime
mover. Replacing a cracked engine block is not a routine shop visit. It can take a locomotive out
of service for weeks and cost hundreds of thousands of dollars. So railroads adopted a
simple operating rule for their locomotive fleets. When ambient temperatures drop below about 35
degrees Fahrenheit, 2 degrees Celsius, the engines stay running. In extreme cold, in places like
northern Minnesota, Montana, and the Canadian prairies where winter temperatures regularly fall
to minus 20 degrees Fahrenheit or minus 30 degrees Fahrenheit, locomotives are not idling
at their lowest setting. Crews set them to run at notch three or four, burning even more fuel
because the engine at idle cannot generate enough heat to keep itself warm against that kind of cold.
The alternative is draining the entire cooling system, which is time consuming and creates its
own cascade of problems when the locomotive needs to be refilled and returned to service.
How do you dispatch a drained locomotive on short notice when a crew is waiting and freight is
falling behind schedule? In practice, you do not. You keep it running. Now there is a third reason
locomotives stay running and it might be the most critical one of all. This one has nothing to do
with the engine or the coolant. The third reason is all about the brakes. Every freight train in
North America uses an AIR brake system. The brakes on each car in a 100 car consist are powered by
compressed air supplied through a continuous brake pipe that runs the full length of the train.
The source of that compressed air is a compressor mounted on the locomotive driven directly by the
diesel engine. While the engine runs, the compressor maintains pressure throughout the
system. When the engine stops, the compressor stops too. Here is the part that catches people
off guard. Train brake systems leak constantly and this is considered entirely normal and expected.
Every coupling between cars, every hose connection, every valve and gasket in a 100 car train allow
some small amount of air leakage. If you have ever stood on a station platform and heard that steady
hissing sound from underneath a parked train, that is brake line air escaping. Federal Railroad
Administration regulations set specific limits on acceptable leakage rates, but the leakage never
reaches zero. As long as the locomotive engine is running and the compressor is cycling, this leakage
is continuously replenished. The system stays pressurized and the brakes remain ready. However,
if the engine is shut down and the compressor stops, the brake system begins losing pressure.
After about four hours without air according to Federal Railroad Administration rules,
the air test performed on that train is no longer valid. Before the train can move again, a crew
must perform a new Class 1 air brake test. For a long freight train, that means a conductor walking
the entire length of the consist, inspecting each car and confirming each brake cylinder responds
correctly. On a 90 car train, that walk alone can take over an hour. The full test process can consume
several hours and tie up a crew that could otherwise be running a train. Inspecting every
car is time consuming and this is not a corner case. Trains sit in yards and on sidings constantly,
waiting for crew changes, track clearance or loading operations. Every time a locomotive
engine shuts down with a train attached, that clock starts ticking toward a mandatory retest.
For a railroad managing hundreds of trains per day across a network spanning the continent, those
retests do not stay isolated. They ripple outward, delaying connections, backing up traffic at
junctions and pushing already tight schedules past their limits. If you are enjoying this look
behind the scenes of how railroads actually operate, hit subscribe. We cover locomotive
history and railroad engineering every week. Now let's talk about the real calculation happening
inside every railroad operations center. The cost of the diesel fuel burned while the locomotive idles
is less than the cost of the labor, the operational delay and the cascading schedule disruptions
caused by a full air brake retest. But which cost is actually bigger? Railroads looked at both
numbers decades ago and the answer was not even close. They chose to keep the engines running.
Those three factors, the cold start problem, the water coolant dilemma and the air brake system
explain why idling became standard practice from the very beginning of the diesel locomotive era.
The decision was not born from carelessness or waste. Idling was a calculated choice and for
most of railroad history it was the right one. But the costs kept climbing as fuel prices rose
and environmental regulations tightened across the country. Communities near rail yards filed
complaints about the constant noise and exhaust fumes from idling locomotives at all hours of
the night and the sheer scale of the waste became harder to ignore. The Environmental Protection
Agency estimated that switching locomotives alone consumed 60 million gallons of diesel fuel per
year while doing nothing but sitting still. So what changed? The industry started developing
alternatives and the first major technology was the automatic engine start-stop system
known as AESS. These systems monitor a locomotive's coolant temperature, oil temperature,
air brake pressure, battery charge and ambient conditions. When all parameters are within safe
limits the system shuts the main engine down. If any reading drifts outside its threshold
the engine restarts automatically. Canadian Pacific was among the first railroads to install them
aggressively, rolling out a system called Smart Start across large portions of its fleet. Early
versions were timer based. Modern versions use microprocessor controls that can track dozens
of variables simultaneously and make restart decisions in seconds. AESS works well in moderate
weather when locomotives sit in temperate rail yards. In spring and fall the system can cut
unnecessary engine idling time in half. But does it solve the problem in January in Saskatchewan?
Not entirely. When coolant temperatures drop quickly in sub-zero air the system restarts the
engine so frequently that the fuel savings shrink. And in extreme cold below minus 10 degrees
Fahrenheit or below minus 15 degrees Fahrenheit many AESS systems are programmed not to shut
the engine down at all because the risk of a failed restart is too high. That limitation led
to the development of the auxiliary power unit or APU. An APU is a small separate diesel engine
typically around 25 horsepower installed in the locomotive nose compartment. When the main engine
shuts down the APU takes over. It drives a small generator to keep the batteries charged and the
electrical systems powered. The APU also circulates heated coolant through the main engine block to
prevent freezing and it runs a small compressor to maintain brake line pressure. All of this at a
fraction of the fuel consumption. A locomotive APU burns roughly three liters of diesel per hour
compared to the 25 liters or more that the main engine consumes at idle. The savings are real.
Indian Railways reported projected annual savings of over 60 crore rupees after fitting auxiliary
power units to their diesel fleet. North American railroads have documented annual fuel savings in
the range of several thousand gallons per locomotive. A New York State study found that
diesel fired warming systems could achieve payback in as few as one to three winter seasons. But if
the technology works, why has not every locomotive been converted? The answer is partly mechanical and
partly human. Auxiliary power units add another diesel engine to maintain with its own oil changes,
belt replacements, and reliability concerns. Maintenance departments already stretched thin
are not always eager to service auxiliary systems that are not considered mission critical.
And then there is the human factor. Locomotive engineers who have spent their entire careers
knowing that you never shut down a diesel have a deep trained reluctance to trust an automated
system. If the APU fails overnight and the main engine cools to dangerous temperatures, the
engineer arriving at five in the morning faces a locomotive that will not start and a train that
cannot move. More than one crew has quietly disabled the automatic engine start stop system
or the APU to eliminate that risk, accepting the fuel waste as the price of certainty. Can you blame
them? When your job depends on a locomotive being ready to move at the moment a dispatcher calls,
the consequences of a failed restart are not abstract. They are a missed freight window,
a congested main line, and a supervisor asking why the train did not leave on time.
The old way, keeping the locomotive idling, never produced that phone call. The tension between
tradition and efficiency is real and it plays out in rail yards across the continent every night.
But the economics are shifting in ways that even the most cautious engineers can't ignore.
Diesel fuel isn't getting cheaper, railroad profit margins are under constant scrutiny from
shareholders, and environmental regulations carry real penalties now. The EPA emissions standards
for locomotives have tightened through multiple tiers and idle reduction isn't optional for
railroads that want to meet their sustainability commitments. Looking forward, the landscape is
shifting in ways that go beyond idle reduction gadgets. Battery electric locomotive prototypes
are entering trial service on short line railroads and in yard switching operations,
where the duty cycle of frequent starts and stops makes electrification most practical.
Hydrogen fuel cell locomotives are in early research stages for longer hauls where battery
weight becomes prohibitive. Energy management systems like Wabtec's Trip Optimizer and New York
Airbrake's Leader System are optimizing not only how locomotives haul freight, but how they manage
energy while sitting still. Some railroads are also experimenting with shore power connections in yards,
plugging locomotives into external electrical sources, the way you would plug in a block
heater on a truck in Manitoba, keeping the engine warm and the systems charged without burning a
drop of diesel. The diesel locomotive won't disappear overnight. There are thousands of them
in active service across North America and they're built to last 40 years or more. Many of the EMD
645 powered SD42 locomotives that entered service in the 1970s are still hauling freight today,
their engines rebuilt and their frames showing no sign of retirement. The 645 and 710 prime movers
remain among the most durable and maintainable large diesel engines ever mass-produced and
they'll be rumbling through rail corridors for years to come. But the practice of letting them
idle indefinitely is slowly fading. Not because anyone suddenly realized it was wasteful, the
railroads always knew that. It's fading because the alternatives from auxiliary power unit engines to
shore power hookups in modern rail yards are finally reliable enough and affordable enough
to change the math. The next time you drive past a rail yard at night and hear those engines
rumbling in the dark, you'll know what's actually happening. It isn't carelessness, it's a compromise
between physics, economics and the relentless demands of keeping freight moving across a
continent. A compromise that took decades to build and one that is only now beginning to change.
