The Russian people do not take kindly to walls! Up and over comrades! Be sure to take a look at Dan Carlin's awesome podcasts here: http://www.dancarlin.com/hardcore-his... Check out the rest of my channel for more Total War content including massive battles, warhammer gameplay, and historical documentaries
For Massive Battles be sure to check out this playlist: • 11,000 Man Siege of Cyrene (Massive Battles)
For documentaries on classical antiquity check out this playlist: • Classical Antiquity (Documentaries)
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI Generated
Russian and Austrian forces coordinate a brutal siege against an Ottoman star fort, utilizing heavy artillery and elite infantry to overcome formidable defenses. The engagement serves as a springboard for a broader discussion on the nature of military command, the brutality of historical Russian leadership, and a critique of siege mechanics in strategy games.
Hey, what's up guys, it's Oakley and this is gonna be a really cool battle. I don't play too many of these
This is gonna be a Napoleon siege and it is gonna be on an Ottoman fortress up on the hilltop here
So we have a Russian and an Austrian force laying siege to it and the shelling is commencing
I have two unicorns facing off against the opponent to watch my build here
So the unicorns one of them is gonna be unlimbering or relimbering I should say
In order to get a better
Angle of fire on the opponent. This one is getting a couple shots off on the knees image you need up there
Meanwhile, my main force is going to be approaching. Oh push any
Russian Jaegers and musketeers hidden over in the forest. I do have a couple more infantry units the
Semenov ski lifeguard, which are an excellent force for melee
So that's my main assault. I have two more musketeers flanking on the left three musketeers flanking on the right
The Austrian player or sorry the Ottoman player has a lot of these as ours cheap units
semi-genocerys
Ringing around the perimeter. So he has a lot of these guys in a good position to
Avoid fire from our guns, but over here
There's been a massive assault from the Ottomans pushing for trying to seize our guns on this flank
So the Austrian player is actually gonna send for some of his cavalry
It's managed to charge this blob in the back, which is good
He hit up some of the swords. They're gonna be very important to take out and then from this side
It's gonna be charging with the German
Grenadiers, but I would have done is use actually the grenades
In this engagement, but perhaps he thought timing was of the essence and the Grenadiers are actually very strong in melee
So they're gonna be moving up
You know
This is gonna buy more time for the Grenadiers to move up other forces start pushing up and the Austrian player has a ton
of German fissures trying to push up the enemy
We can zoom in on the fortress right there is manning the cannons and so they're shooting down
You know with their barrels straight into this massive group of infantry
so this means we really need to push forward quickly, which is I guess why the
Ottoman player decided to charge forward knowing that they had to delay this as much as possible
Looks like he's gonna get another charge off into the rear but these
I'm using a shitty infantry. The rifles are still in square
So we're not gonna be getting very far but by keeping them in square it is keeping them from getting proper shots off against us
Grenadiers are down to 50 men. Just not doing too well
I looks like that's why two of the there was a banshee bazooka and a semi genocide
So that's a lot of melee infantry. So there goes our force is gonna be melting away
But we have brought up some reserves Hungarian Grenadiers
Presumably holding fire to not shoot their friends in the back, but they should unload soon
This banshee bazookas are gonna be the first wave to charge into us
I don't think we should be able to beat him back
But and they really need to send in more reserves on this front because look more of these swordsmen are charging down
And this isn't this is an epic actually view
Of the fort in the foreground more Ottomans pouring into this fight. So it may be a focus
Of gunnery player to knock out the Austrians. So he's gonna be washing up against us
He's almost gonna be at the guns position back here. And this is really what we need to break down these walls
otherwise you're left kind of with
Hooks to throw up but up against the the walls here and then you know
You walk up and if you don't have an entry elsewhere
Then you're just gonna walk up to murderous fire from the inside to counter charges from melee infantry
So we really need our guns up and running
My main force is continuing to push up
Thankfully, there isn't much returning fire
So as my troops start to push up the hill slowly, but surely it takes a long time to get up here
We're not gonna be taking enemy incoming fire
There are a couple units up on top
But most of the enemy defensive force is gonna be pouring out to meet the Austrians in the field
These news images idiot have a perfect firing angle at these units up here. I'm not quite sure why they're not firing
It's like a couple of them are caught reloading
But if I were if I were this player
I would have sent more of my guys to man the cannons up here
Look, this would have been five cannons perfect position to just shoot up these German fissures
But nonetheless, I mean these so many chance areas are gonna tear it
This is what they're meant for
Give them a little bit of supporting fire and they could probably destroy this entire Ottoman army
They're sorry Austrian army
We're still fighting in this bloody grove on the side on now some of the fire gonna be coming in
Do we have a howitzer on our side? Yes, we do have a seven-pound howitzer finally deploying
So this is what the Austrian forces desperately need
Is to be able to take out those heavy forces
But it looks like one of those bombs coming dangerously close to hitting one of our own troops
So we really need to focus fire on these semi-genocerous
This is pretty cool
This fortress is so cool
Just the star fort and the intricate intricacies of the terrain
I mean, this is the kind of stuff that we need in total or warhammer
Can you imagine if the Empire had star forts and you had green skins flying units attacking this?
I mean this would not be hard to pull off
Even making the approach to city something like this with big, you know cliffs
Different approaches like this make it way more intricate make it hilly make it, you know
Nooks like this hilltops
Which are key to securing for your artillery positions all kinds of cool stuff. They desperately need for warhammer
I have no idea why they dumbed it down
Any case we've gotten ourselves
Up here by the cavalry mounted rifles
They're also gonna be shooting at our guys who have managed to get up on top of the wall
But like I said the second we get up here we get countercharged by health infantry units
You know all we can watch the approach on this front where the enemy
Riflemen are gonna be firing down at our guys, but I have a ton of dudes pouring
Their bodies into this fight now
One of the downsides of this is I do have my artillery trying to fire
Up over and my target was to hit these nice juicy clumps of infantry
Haven't done much damage
But most of the shots are actually gonna start to fall short and they're gonna come dangerously close to peppering my units
I have to be careful about that one of them here seemingly hitting the militia
I'm having a very hard time taking out those guys on the walls. It just does no
damage apparently
But can you imagine if we had this type of combat with orcs?
Down there and Empire troops firing down. This is the kind of stuff. I really hope we're able to see in the future
And it's one of the biggest lacking parts of Total War warhammer. I believe is the sieges
Pushing up on this flank. I was able to force the enemy back inside and see them stream back through the gate
They did not want to have to deal with my forces I have two musketeers and our three musketeers
I thought this was a lifeguard, but no
It's just a simple musketeer force
And so we're gonna be locking down the enemy preventing them from pushing forward and what I'm gonna try and do is isolate certain sectors
So for instance here, I'm starting to break down the walls
I'm ready on this flank to perhaps start a swarm
And I'm gonna start to again
Unlimber my guns and start inching them forward because they don't have the best line of fire
I really want to hit these juicy targets being back here, but somehow the angle is just not working out for me
For the Austrian player looks like they have finally
Silenced the attacker or the defenders here
This is like a Civil War era battle, which is corpses littering and a little little round talk so to speak in this case
So we're gonna be
Waiting it out
Allowing artillery to now start battering down the walls and our force that was previously up here. Just got you know eviscerated
so now we're gonna be focusing on the walls we've set up in the
artillery positions that we want and so now finally we can begin the
artillery and bombarding bombardment phase of the siege
And I have these awesome unicorn guns which are really great in open field battles
They can hammer infantry positions, but in the case like this
Perhaps it would have been better for just some
Straight-up artillery because the exploding shells just not doing the damage
We need to it's gonna take a long time to puncture these walls then again. They are super big walls
Oh, what do I hear uh-huh so it's like we're gonna get our grappling hooks ready
And why don't they do something like this for Empire or sorry for Warhammer?
I mean if Empire could pull it off. Why couldn't Warhammer pull off something as simple as this give the orcs
grappling hooks
give the you know vampires or you know spiders or other goblins the ability to climb walls like in Shogun the
Pocket gliders, it's just so arcadey. I wish they would get back to some of the realism of you know that we have in this case
Guys are gonna start to push up
I'm a little wary to tell them to move across this area because it is getting torn to shreds
And just as I get up here
The enemy is gonna be counter charging us so in the distance look at all those swords charging up
They're gonna meet our musketeers
Up on the walls as I start to get up just like I said this is gonna be very hard to do you get a
Couple units up and all of a sudden. They're gonna be overwhelmed and surrounded
So there's not much. I can do I mean my guys can try and fire from these positions, but I really have no
No line of sight on the enemy as you've been seeing over here
I have the clue the best line of sight you could imagine and still
This war is only having lost 12 men after the entire time shooting at them
So there's really no way up here besides shooting it with artillery and so that's why some of my Russians are gonna be coming back
Down they know that is not where they want to be
Up to 66 percent damage, so I'm hoping to create a hole in here
And I do have some uncontested musketeers up on top
I'm gonna try and get them in a position where they can start firing down into the enemy ranks
When it looks like we did blow up another one here, so my enemy or sorry my ally doing a much greater job
Here with the 12 pounder that probably should have done this this is much easier for focus firing on the walls
Meanwhile the howitzer here they staked it up. That's a good idea just to make sure it's secured
It's gonna be targeting this wall over here
Infantry gonna start staging and now we're gonna start pulling up with some Hungarian fizz ears
Find the smoke and rubble where we're gonna get ready to send some men into action
On this front I've deployed my musketeers. We are standing atop a crumbling wall
69% damage so what I was hoping to do is actually bait the enemy into committing here
And what I was hoping to do is you see how many troops are having in the backlog
I was gonna hope to take you know a two-for-one
With them continue to focus this and maybe collapse the whole wall with both of us in there
But that's only if my troops can last long enough. It looks like they're gonna be just
Getting slaughtered once again the Russians are good in melee defense and melee attack, but still not holding up
More troops gonna be mounting excuse me mounting the walls
It'd be really cool. If in the future they get to the point where you could actually have like you know small squad based
Tactics for units that get up on the wall so for instance a couple guys start laying down
Suppressive fire more guys coming up here a couple go ahead, and you know this would be too much realism
But the ability to grab these cannons turn them about and start firing into the fort itself would be really cool
Couple more of our guys gonna be hoisting themselves on this front when we did destroy another wall
So we're gonna get ready for that assault there
And start getting some firing on either side
My troops as they deploy are gonna get shot up by the Azhar's which are kind of a regular loose formation units
This is not good so as my guys start getting suppressed
What are they running from well?
Swordsmen up on the walls and so we can watch those units
So they're gonna be running all the way around chasing my guys away
So that is why I'm having such a hard time clearing these walls all the Ottoman infantry. Just gonna be beating me back
I'm not even able to shoot away the defenders
So there's really not much choice for me
But to sit tight and wait for a hole to be created and it is taking a long long time with these unicorns
I'm gonna sacrifice another one of the musketeers my other force here is gonna try and deploy
What it's trying to do and I did give it a movement order here was to deploy
In this position so that I could start getting shots on these semi Janissaries because what this meets are trying to do is
What camp out this little area here?
But once again the unit controls being a little gimmicky these men are not gonna fire until they're completely lined up
Which means the Azhar's can pick them off, and it means that my force in the back here
Actually looks like I did finally take out the wall, so that's gonna be the little break
I needed but here you have triple swordsmen gonna break this force before I can even I think get
My troops to line up, let's see if they do get a volley off
The Austrians here teaching me Windbush Jaegers that
You know the guys this is how you fire the Russians obviously not taking heat of those actions
And what this makes me think is actually a Dan Carlin
Series that I watched on the first world war ghosts of the Aspen very much recommend you talk about it
It's as I said
about the first world war Eastern Front
Russians against Germans and the reason I mentioned that is because a portion of that really talks about the Russian chain of command
Where they started getting very very brutal at a portion of the war just the complete surprise early on in the campaign
Meant that Stalin was well the Russians were sent ruling kicked back and Stalin had to enforce draconian rules
You know not a step-back comrade type of mentality
And what happened is their purges throughout the ranks and what would happen if you did if you didn't hold your ground if you sacrifice
Any ground if you yielded in any way the general the officer could be held in contempt
It could be you know executed and so what happened is you had
Troops would not think for themselves officers who would not think for themselves scared for their own lives
They would follow orders to a tee and so as you saw my guys here
They had orders to station themselves on the walls
But not orders to fire and so the officers did not tell them into fire and what Dan Carlin talks about in this podcast
In I believe it's episode 2 or 3
He talks about literally there would be times where
Massive amounts of troops would be told to advance along a front and you know on a map
You would have generals giving orders from well behind the battle line saying you know
I want this division to move up here on this division to seize the hill
I want this division to cross the river and so what ended up happening
according to this anecdote that Dan Carlin shares is that there's a
Regiment that's told to you know the general he gave the order you must cross the river no excuses
But the officer who gets the river it's rapids they have no way to cross the river they weren't given any supplies
They have no rafts and so this officer not wanting to be executed for not taking you know that crossing has no fire
No one's supposing him only nature in his way
And he orders his men to swim across the rapids and they end up losing
the entire unit essentially in these rapids and this just goes to show the sheer craziness of what happened in that war and
That was a bit of a tangent of what happened
Just seeing these Russian troops not firing taking orders literally
But if this is if this is something that interests you I definitely recommend checking out
Dan Carlin series ghosts of the Ostron on the first world war and if you like the second or sorry
Even more of the first oh, sorry
Ghosts of the Austrian what am I saying it is on the second world war excuse me
If you want his duck his series on the first world war
That is gonna be blueprint for Armageddon, which is equally good very very
entertaining
But very very depressing I listened to that series and came out just man
I needed to take a break from that after a while. It was super depressing
So first world war stuff definitely. I mean history bus very interesting period of history and for me
You know the the death of misery and all that stuff is very sobering
very lucky to think that we live in this day and age, but it's just
It's it's always interesting to me to see what conditions
Man will put themselves in and the extent to which the human body the human mind the conditions
That's what Dan Carlin talks about the extremes of the human condition man's inhumanity to man and in those extreme cases
You know you see the brilliance of humanity shine through the heroism the camaraderie, but also the worst of man
And so that's why I think history and military warfare can be sobering but also a lesson
Into kind of what it means to be human, but it's a big tangent. This is starting off from a bloody assault
So what you've been seeing me is kind of looking around where I've gotten clobbered on this flank, but it doesn't matter
It's it's a two versus one scenario
So we're just here as the Russians always do and that is churning out men sending them into the fight
So I've seized this area and now what I have is musketeers
But they're gonna be reinforced by another group and we're gonna slowly start chipping away at these sweet genocides
I'm gonna start pulling in some of the heavy hitters. So my Semenov ski lifeguard and my grenadier
So they're gonna start pulling up. We've been able to
Pull the enemy away from this front get a lot of them caught in the mix
And now I have three units finally around the flank. My Austrian friends are gonna start pushing through here
We did send a couple into the mix got charged by Calvary got charged by infantry
It looks like we sought refuge inside the enemy
Tower here. And so from within this tower, we're actually getting shots off at the enemy
But the lower area is gonna be countercharged actually by enemies trying to reclaim this area
So this is a ridiculous battle taking place
My lifeguard foot here tearing it up
But they are somewhat being shot in the flank so you can see all the corpses here on my right flank
Just being due to the clever position our opponent. So he definitely knows what he's doing
He's holding, you know to the last man here. Definitely making me pay for with my life and
the lives of the Russian foot soldiers, we've Hungarian grenadiers gonna be charging into the mix and
What should normally be done is not necessarily getting into combat
They should have used their grenades once again
And this is normally supposed to be cover for more troops to be pushing in
Which is gonna be the case with Hungarian fuzzier's a couple of my Russians came back from retreating
So they're gonna be pushed back into the fight
Look at what I've pulled up here. I now have my grenadiers in the mix
And so I'm gonna show my ally how it's done with these grenadiers
We're gonna get up really close. I'm gonna switch to our secondary our weapons, which is gonna be these grenades
And so from the point of view of the as ours
They're gonna be firing away very happily and all of a sudden they're gonna see the Russians priming
tossing these little grenades in the mix dig dig dig dig
So it doesn't do as much damage as you'd think it's mostly like a
morale shock to this unit
You would have thought that would slaughter that force. But anyway, it's gonna take the morale down
It's gonna debuff them and then here come my grenadiers
Which are also good in close quarters combat charging into the as ours
And the as ours are not gonna be good in close quarters
One of the few units from the Ottoman army here that is gonna be able to be taken out by my men
Lifeguard foot great stats gonna be standing somewhat toe-to-toe with these pretty tired and exhausted
Janissaries. Oh
God more troops charging out of the building into our unit. So we are being beaten back. I would say on this front
We've somewhat lost it
My lifeguard foot has been broken, but we have pushed through the center. The enemy infantry here has been taken out
Rather costly. This was like two three musketeer forces
Down in the in the mix. I have some of my musketeers charging the enemy holding the center, but the Seminov ski lifeguard
These guys are the tippy-top of the Russian troops. And so watch their their great tactics
As they take out these remaining very tired semi Janissaries and they were exhausted and shattered with that last blow
So now I can pull down with my infantry
This building is still kind of contested looks like the enemy has retaken the top we do have some men left
Oh, they're at the bottoms
This is and I do not want to be a unit fighting in the close quarters of this this building
Troops getting shot left and right, you know stabbings taking place in the center this crazy action in there
I've redeployed some my musketeers. What I'm gonna try and do is actually focus fire
I'm gonna change my target to be on the right side over there
What I'm trying to do is free up my grenadiers who have taken a beating
My sub not skier gonna be pulled down
Artillery gonna be firing up on these to meet Janissaries who have cleaned up again another flank
But now that I have my general Prince de Tully
And he's gonna be pulled into this position
I'm gonna actually charge forward with my sub not ski or we're gonna be doing is a nice heroic Russian charge
And it's gonna come into this
Group of units that has been roughly, you know beat up and now with this final Calvary charge
It should be the final blow
decisively here
Yeah, there you go. They're breaking
I'm gonna be careful with the stakes and make sure I pull out to that side. And there you go
We broke them grenadier still alive. There are a couple more semi Janissaries. They're winded 71 men left 70
But I have some nasty lifeguards and musketeers. So the lifeguards themselves could take him out
Now it's just the case of overwhelming numbers. So we're gonna seize this position
My artillery finally getting some nice shots off at the enemy in the distance
And so they're gonna try and pull themselves back down. Some of them had to repel back down
And they're gonna be met with a lot of infantry but still for two versus one
Considering there was only one army defending. Look, we've got almost nothing. My ally has what one infantry unit left
First regiment of the Emperor's own and his general that's it. I have one two
You know two healthy units and two scrap units and then the artillery that's it
So our opponent did a really really good job. I would have to say in this battle
In the Ottomans pretty hard to do poorly when the enemy comes right into
melee range with you
I think if he'd been a little bit more conservative with his assaults outside of the walls
Way more damage, but nonetheless it was an epic fight an epic stand two versus one don't get to see that too often
And yeah, I think I'm definitely gonna start breaking up the Warhammer content with some other games
So let me know what type of other games you'd like to see. Is it gonna be Napoleon total war?
Is it gonna be Empire?
Shogun Rome to Attila
Or even older stuff medieval to so definitely leave your recommendations for stuff below and definitely make sure you check out Dan Carlin's
Ghostly the ass front Eastern Front of World War two definitely worth it and also the blueprint for Armageddon
Which is gonna be about the First World War
hope you guys enjoyed and
Yeah, see you the next one. Peace out
Storming the Star Fort! (Total War: Napoleon Battle #192) | Gan Jing World