The Law Academy is a project designed to provide legal education for students studying law in the UK. Subscribe for more content.
M. Freeman, Lloyd’s Introduction to Jurisprudence (Sweet & Maxwell, 2014). R. Wacks, Understanding Jurisprudence: An Introduction to Legal Theory (Oxford University Press, 2020). J. Penner & E. Melissaris, McCoubrey & White’s Textbook on Jurisprudence (Oxford University Press, 2012).
Disclaimer:
At no point are these video lessons intended to provide any sort of legal advice. These are for educational purposes only!
Image(s) Copyright: This Photo by Unknown Author is licensed under CC BY-SA
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI Generated
This lesson examines the ancient origins of natural law, focusing on the transition from Plato to Aristotle. It explores the intersection of law and morality, contrasting natural law with legal positivism, and analyzes Plato's vision of the \"Philosopher King\" and Socrates' arguments regarding the moral obligation to obey the state even in the face of injustice.
In the previous lesson what we did was introduce our first major jurisprudential theory, and
this is of course the theory of natural law. Natural law often comes first when we discuss
and when we're studying jurisprudence for a number of reasons, one of them being obviously
is the oldest of the major theories of law that we can think about. And now this lesson
is going to start to talk about some of the ancient origins of natural law. So we're really
going to be dividing our lessons of natural law into three main time periods. We're going
to be talking firstly in this lesson and in the next lesson about the ancient origins
of natural law, talking about the likes of Plato and then more importantly and specifically
Aristotle and his influence over the natural law tradition. And then in the second set
of lessons looking at the history and the development of natural law, we're going to
talk about the impact that theological thinkers have had on the natural law theories. So we'll
talk firstly about Augustine and how Augustine takes something of a Platonic interpretation
of natural law, and then we will talk about St Thomas Aquinas who takes more of an Aristotelian
interpretation of natural law, mainly because of course Aristotle's writings had not been
discovered when Augustine was writing, but they had been discovered by the time Aquinas
was writing. And then finally we'll talk about the modern interpretations of natural law,
the most important being that of Fuller and Finnis, and we have the sort of procedural
natural law theory, and then we also have a theory of natural rights. And then we will
move on to looking at legal positivism. So, like I mentioned, the previous lesson introduced
the subject of natural law. It also gave some basic definitions of what we mean when we
talk about the idea of natural law, examining the relationship between law and morality,
this inherent relationship that exists within natural law theory that doesn't necessarily
exist in other jurisprudential theories such as that of legal positivism. That's not necessarily
to suggest that legal positivism does not take into account morality at all, but just
it exists on the peripheries of their legal theories compared that to natural law. This
lesson, like I've said, is examining some of the origins of the natural law theory,
talking about its ancient development in the Greco-Roman period. Now, in terms of theories
which become natural law theories that we know today, we find their origins mainly within
the antiquity of ancient Greece, specifically within the kind of classical period of ancient
Greece, or sometimes known as classical Athens, or classic Athens, which is of course the
period where we have events such as the Peloponnesian War, we have events such as the writings,
the lives, well, the life and therefore and also the trial and death of Socrates, as well
as the founding of the Academy with Plato and Aristotle, all of these different ideas.
And this is where natural law develops, specifically develops firstly with Plato and then more
so with Aristotle in the next lesson. So, the reason why we're beginning with Plato
is because while Aristotle is considered to be the key founder of the natural law tradition,
Plato would be a heavy influence on pretty much all of Aristotelian thinking and Aristotelian
thought, not only for areas and ideas where Aristotle appears to agree with and take on
board some of the Platonic ideas within philosophy, but also because Aristotle in a lot of instances
disagrees wholeheartedly and almost completely contradictory against that of Plato's ideas.
And so these two ideas and these two philosophers can sort of bounce off each other in terms
of how we understand the development of ancient Greek philosophy.
So let's think about Plato's theory of law. Now, what Plato's understanding of law looks
like is something akin to something of a moral obligation. And his theory of law is
very similar to his ideas of moral obligation. It has a number of different elements to it.
We have this idea of the concept of law and the sort of substance of law as articulated
in the Republic. And then we also have another period of his life that is important to understand
and the influence that this period of his life has over his theory of law. And this
is the idea of the death of Socrates and the impact of the death of his tutor, who was,
of course, Socrates. Now, before we continue in any great detail, I would just like to
make it very clear that Plato's writings are in, for the most part, a dialogue format,
in a kind of response, question and response kind of format. They are viewed as conversations
often between Socrates and a number of other thinkers. And so the Republic is a debate,
it's a dialogue. And it's very, very fun for new philosophy students to actually engage
with Plato's dialogues because you can sort of do it like a play. You can have one person
speaking, playing one role, another person playing another role. And the idea here is
the kind of question and answer back and forth that eventually leads us to conceptualizing
different philosophical ideas. So, really, Plato doesn't necessarily write in the first
person as himself, he writes conversations between Socrates and other individuals. Now,
we're going to try and spend more time looking at the philosophy and jurisprudence rather
than the specific history of ancient Greece and the specific histories of Plato and Socrates.
So, for the most part, all we really need to know for these lessons is that Socrates was
the tutor and the mentor of Plato, Plato was then the tutor and the mentor of Aristotle,
and then Aristotle would go on to become the tutor and the mentor of Alexander the Great,
interestingly. And so you can see the kind of development and influence of different
philosophical ideas through this chain of causation. The Republic, however, is the one
of, if not the most famous, of the Platonic dialogues. For the most part, if you were to
ask an ancient historian, you would say that Plato does not use his own words in his own
writings, he doesn't write in the first person. There are some debates as to whether or not
certain texts which are attributed to Plato are actually attributed to Plato and actually
are Plato's own writings, but for the most part the dialogues are not his own first-person
writings, they are more conversations between others. So we would write in the form of a
dialogue between others, as I mentioned, so most of the time it being Socrates debating
various other members of the group on various different topics ranging from metaphysics to
ethics to the philosophy and politics of the of the Athenian state. And in the Republic
specifically, Plato presents a debate about what is the proper functioning of the state,
talking about the Greek city-state in this regard. So we're talking about ancient Athens,
we're talking about Sparta, for example, and other sort of Greek city-states that existed.
And he talks about the ways in which we can organise the state and the best methods for
doing so. And he came to the conclusion that the best way to organise the state was through
the implementation of what is known as a Benevolent Dictatorship. And this informs
his theories and ideas of where the positive law fits into this broader conversation. He
believed that people ought to be trained from birth in the art of politics and statehood,
as well as within philosophy, and become what are known as Philosopher Kings, who exist
as dictators within the city-state system and will rule the people and will have the
correct and proper qualifications to rule the people in this way. So the Philosopher
King would be one which is not necessarily incumbent by the legalistic modes and formalities
that are in place to tie them down. Contrast this, however, with the way in which we understand
or at least one of the ways in which we understand law as it operates in the world today. So
the law of a state not only implements modes and methods by which individuals should behave
and be regulated within society, but it also regulates the ways in which the leaders within
society ought to behave, especially within some of the civil law systems or even within
the codified constitutional systems of, for example, the United States, where the US Constitution
has very, very straight, very, very clear rules on how members of Congress or the Executive
Branch or the Supreme Court may be able to behave, and if they don't behave, the kinds
of consequences that are in place to deal with them, essentially. And so what Plato
argues is that with the idea and the implementation of benevolent dictatorship and the implementation
of the Philosopher King, you would not need to have these legalistic modes and formalities
in place, and so the law would not be around to be able to essentially limit the ability
of the Philosopher King to do things, to make decisions. And so in this regard, we can get
an understanding of how Plato understands law. He takes something of an anti-legalistic
interpretation of jurisprudence, so essentially what this means is he does not factor the
law too much into his broader normative framework, the broader framework about what ought and
ought not be done when it comes to the proper functioning and regulation of the city-state.
If we look at this passage here, we see that no legislator ever seems to have noticed that
in spite of it being open to them to use two methods, compulsion and persuasion, they never
mix in persuasion with force when they brew their laws. It seems obvious that the reason
for the legislator giving persuasive address was to make the person to whom he promulgates
his law have a greater readiness to learn. This is a very interesting passage. The reason
why this is a very interesting passage is because what it does is it positions the law
not necessarily as a method of coercive control, something that people are forced to follow
but not necessarily wanting to follow, but instead as a tool for the education of individuals
in virtues of lessons in philosophy, in the education of political functionings, the effective
functioning of the city-state and lessons in virtue more specifically. And so as a result
of this, if Plato believes that laws can be utilised to teach the masses about the nature
and value of wisdom, they must be in and of themselves good. And this is quite an interesting
point because when we get to the trial and the execution of Socrates within Plato's life,
we see that Plato has to reconcile with the fact that there does exist legal mechanisms
and legal methods that are implemented and instigated which are considered, at least
in his opinion and in the opinion of many, to be unjust and immoral. So if he believes
on the one hand that the laws ought to be utilised not for coercive control but to teach
the masses about the nature of wisdom and the value of philosophy and virtue, then they
must therefore be good. How does he then reconcile that with one of the most pertinent events
in his life, which is of course the execution of Socrates, whereby the process by which
Socrates was executed, the trial and the execution of Socrates, was one that is considered to
be unjust and immoral. So that's why the death of Socrates plays quite heavily as a factor
in his life. Ultimately, Socrates was put to death following a trial with accusations
being made that he had been effectively corrupting the youth. He was found guilty and as part
of his execution he was forced to drink hemlock, which is a type of poison. It's believed he
was supposed to drink hemlock. Now what's quite interesting about the death of Socrates
is that essentially he did not necessarily have to be executed. In fact, some of the
individuals who are in part or at least part of the process by which he was tried and found
guilty of his accusations would have sufficed with sending Socrates into exile. It's actually
the fact that Socrates himself chose death that is quite valuable and interesting. And
the death of Socrates can be seen in various different dialogues and writings from Plato.
We see, for example, in his Apology and also the dialogue of Crito. We see the full extent
of Socrates' trial and the impact that it had on this idea of the obeying of legal rules,
even if they may be coercive, unjust or immoral. And it appears from the trial that Socrates,
if he were to comply, he could have escaped execution and taken punishment by exile. And
as noted in this dialogue, what Socrates does is present an argument which seems to purport
to this idea that one ought to oblige and have an obligation to follow the positive
law. So even where law may be particularly unjust or immoral, there is this idea of following
the law regardless. You have an obligation to obey legal rules, positive legal rules.
Now Socrates uses three main points, I believe in Crito, to make this argument, to show that
one ought to obey the positive law. He makes an analogy to that of a parent versus a child,
arguing that people are like children, they ought to obey the parent, and in this regard
the parent is situated as either the sort of ethereal concept of law or maybe the lawmakers
that are in charge of the city-state, and they should do so out of a sense of gratitude
to the law and the maintenance of the system of the state. Socrates also makes the argument
that by staying in the state where there exist certain laws that you may disagree with, which
may even be unjust or immoral, you are implicitly accepting obedience towards such structures.
So this is essentially a roundabout way of saying if you don't like it, you can always
leave, as a way of being able to understand how the obligation to follow the rules exists.
If you wish to essentially challenge the law that you believe is unjust or immoral, you
ought to either push to have it changed through legal and democratic means, or you can just
simply leave, essentially. And given these two purposes, the person who disagrees with
the law can either persuade to a reform to the law or move to some place else, or the
final option is to simply just obey the law and exercise your obligation to obey the law.