Crochet vs Knitting [Fact vs Fiction]

Knitt & crochet
23 followers
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThis video evaluates common beliefs comparing knitting and crochet through timed experiments and measurements. By analyzing speed, material usage, cost, and fabric properties, the creator determines which claims are facts and which are myths, while discussing the impact of yarn choice and the possibility of mechanized crochet.
If you've been around the crafting world for more than a few minutes you've
probably heard these opinions. Knitting is harder than crochet.
Crochet uses more yarn. Knitting is much slower than crochet. But
crochet is cheaper. Knitting can be made by machine but
crochet can only be done by human hands. So today we're putting these
claims and others you may not have heard of
before to the test. And we're going to decide if they are
indeed fact or just fiction. If I had a dollar for every time I've
heard that knitting takes longer than crochet I
would be rich. Maybe not rich but I would have a little pile of money.
But this is a very common statement and if I'm honest it's one that I've said a
time or two. Crochet does feel faster and knitting
feels kind of slow. End of story right? Well instead of going
with what it feels like let's put it to the test. I'm
going to use the same yarn. I'm going to make the same
size sample a four by four inch square. I'm going to use single crochet for the
crocheted sample and stockinette stitch for the knitted
sample. And then I'm going to time myself making
both and let's see which one actually takes longer. So I'm going to be
using a yarn that I've used many times before and this is Premier
Basics Worsted. And it recommends a five and a half
millimeter crochet hook and a five and a half millimeter
knitting needle. But the problem is I don't have five and a half millimeter
knitting needles. So I've dropped down to a five millimeter
crochet hook and a five millimeter pair of needles. So let's set the
timer. I don't want to waste any time having to pull out yarn so I'm
going ahead and doing that before we get started. And now I've lost
the end. Oh no! Oh no. Okay here we go. I also have a
little gauge ruler that is a four by four inch
square and I'm just going to use this as my measuring tool. That way I can
easily make sure that I'm on track. I've stopped the clock and we're at
just around twelve and a half minutes. Now
my square is just slightly wider but it is pretty much
the same height. So we're calling it good. Crochet sample is done and now I've got
my five millimeter needles and let's knit this
one up. I'm almost at the twelve and a half
minute mark which is where I finished my crochet sample.
And this is where I'm at with my knitted sample and I have a feeling I'm not
going to finish it in the next 20 seconds.
This was super interesting and I was surprised that our times
were not even close. They weren't even in the same
ballpark. Our crochet piece took twelve and a half minutes
and the knitted piece took 22 minutes. It was
almost 10 minutes longer. For the crocheted piece
I made 17 single crochet across and there was
one turning chain at the end of each row and I ended up making
17 rows in total. For the knitted piece it required 21
stitches across and I ended up doing 22 rows
in total and I think that's a clue. Let me do a little math here for a minute.
In total my crocheted piece took 306 stitches to make and the way I got
that was I made 18 stitches across because
remember we had 17 single crochet but we had that turning chain on the end.
That's 18 stitches in total and we did 17 rows and 18
times 17 is 306. Now for the knitted piece we had 21
stitches by 22 rows and that's a total of 462
stitches. So if we do our math 462 minus 306 is 156.
The knitted piece took 156 more stitches to make the same
four by four sample. So I'm calling knitting takes
longer than crochet fact. It's not fiction.
Now I know some of you are getting ready to type into the comment section that it
took me longer to knit this sample because I was doing English knitting. For
English knitting you throw the yarn and that does take
longer. I am not disagreeing with you on that.
Continental knitting where you are eliminating that movement
definitely would save some time but I'm sticking with my guns on this and I do
think because it took 156 more stitches to make the
same sample size that knitting truly does take longer than crochet.
Our next fact versus fiction statement is that crocheting
uses more yarn than knitting. So now that we've made our two swatches
the same exact size with the same exact yarn
using a five millimeter crochet hook and a five
millimeter knitting needle this is the perfect time to test this claim.
So instead of guessing we're actually going to measure
each one of our samples and what I'm going to do
is I'm going to trim down the tails to make sure that our
beginning tail and our end tail are the exact same length so
that everything should match up perfectly and
then we'll weigh them on my little tiny kitchen scale.
So we're going to measure this in grams and I hope that you can see that this is
zeroed out with my little bowl here and let's go ahead and
measure our knitted piece. We are at eight grams.
Our crocheted piece is 11 grams. So the statement that crochet uses
more yarn than knitting is a fact. It's not fiction and one of the reasons why
crochet uses more yarn than knitting comes down
to how the stitches are actually made. Crochet stitches are taller and more
structured. Each stitch is completed as you make it
which creates a thicker fabric and it uses more yarn to cover the same
amount of space. Knitting stitches on the other hand are
smaller loops and they sit closer together and this creates a
thinner more flexible fabric and this usually means that you're using
less yarn. When you see the samples side by side
you can actually see that the crocheted sample
is thicker and there's a lot less stretch.
The knitted sample is so much thinner and look
at all of the stretch that this piece of fabric has.
Crochet doesn't use more yarn because it's inefficient. It uses more yarn
because it builds the stitches completely
differently than knitting. Crochet and knitting
definitely aren't the only areas where you're going to hear some facts and
maybe a few statements of fiction and that's why I
wanted to take a moment to talk a little bit about skincare because there
are a lot of myths out there. One of the biggest myths that I've been hearing a
lot recently is that anti-aging needs to be complicated,
aggressive, or about trying to look younger than you are
and that's one of the many reasons why I started using Meaningful Beauty.
Meaningful Beauty was co-founded by supermodel Cindy Crawford
and French dermatologist Jean-Louis Seba. They created a line of skincare
products built around simple effective skincare that helps you feel
confident at any age. It's not about defying aging
but supporting your skin as it changes and as a 50 year old woman
I really appreciate that. Their deluxe seven piece face and neck
system is a fully curated routine so there's no
guessing or complicating things. Everything works together to hydrate
firm and care for your skin and what really
sets Meaningful Beauty apart is their antioxidant rich melon extract
which has this advanced delivery technology
and this helps the ingredients absorb more effectively so your skin
actually gets the benefits and right now there's a really great offer.
You can order the deluxe seven piece system and get 25%
off plus two free full-size gifts. That's a $300 value for $59.96.
If you're looking for a skincare routine that's simple and
easy to stick with make sure to check my link in the description box
and thank you so much to Meaningful Beauty for sponsoring today's video.
Another claim that I hear all the time is that knitting is more
expensive than crochet and you may be thinking wait we just proved that
crochet uses more yarn than knitting so wouldn't
it be logical to think that crochet is more expensive than knitting?
Well there's a little more to it and let's break down
why this might not be the case. When it comes to crochet the cost of tools
is pretty straightforward. You can buy a standard set of crochet hooks for
a fairly reasonable price. For example one of my favorite crochet
hooks of all time is Clover Amour and you can buy
a set of 10 hooks and they range from 2.25 millimeter
up to 6 millimeter and it usually costs somewhere around
$50. And for a lot of us crocheters that range of hook size
is going to cover most of the projects that we want to make but if you want to
buy crochet hooks that are smaller or larger for different projects that
range may be anywhere from $4 up to $15 per crochet hook and that is
excluding super budget-friendly and luxury crochet hooks. Knitting on the
other hand can get a little bit complicated. You can
buy a set of knitting needles but you're going to need to decide
if you want straight needles, you want circular needles, or do you need
double-pointed needles. And you're not just going to need to
think about the size of the needles you're also going to need to think about
the length especially when it comes to circular
needles. For example, the knitting needles that I used to
knit my sample are a 5 millimeter but I also have to take into consideration
that these are a 24 inch cord and there are lots of
different cord lengths and it will depend on what type of
project how long your cord needs to be. I have personally found as a crocheter
and a knitter that I need more knitting needle sizes than I do
crochet hook sizes because crochet hooks are pretty standard. There are also
other accessories that you may need when it comes to crochet and knitting and I
also think that there are more accessories needed for knitting than
you do for crochet. This could be stitch holders, needle
toppers, stitch markers. So with all of that
evidence, do I think that knitting costs more than crochet?
Actually, I think that is fiction and the reason why
is that crochet and knitting can be as expensive or as affordable as you want
them to be. A lot is going to depend on what types
of yarn you buy, if you can get some of your supplies
used or for a very reasonable price, and if you will take care of the tools that
you have they can last you a very very long time. Another statement
that I hear all the time is that knitting is harder
than crochet and for me personally that was true because crochet just came
really naturally to me. It just clicked in my brain. It felt
really easy in my hands but I know that's not the case for everyone.
Where crochet can be harder is that when you are learning how to crochet
many times people find that trying to hold the hook and the yarn
and getting that tension just right can feel
very frustrating. People's stitches can either be
too tight, too loose, or just super inconsistent
and that alone can make crochet feel really frustrating
in the beginning. Where knitting can feel easier at first is because
knitted stitches are held on the needle. They're
unfinished and that can make finishing those stitches
a little bit easier as well as getting that tension right from
the beginning. But here's where most people agree
is that knitting mistakes are harder to correct
than crochet mistakes. With crochet when you make a mistake it's pretty
straightforward. You just need to rip out those stitches.
That's really it. But for knitting there can be a variety
of different ways that you can correct the mistake. The first and the one that I
use most often is to unknit or to tink and that's a
skill all on its own that can take some time to learn.
There are literal classes on how to fix your knitting mistakes
and you probably would never have that in crochet because
it's pretty straightforward. You just have to frog the work
or rip it out. So is the statement knitting is harder than crochet fact
and to be completely honest I'm on the fence about this one. But I
have to say that in general we're generalizing here. Crochet is thought of
as easier than knitting. So we are going to say
that this is a fact. But I have a little caveat here
because this really is so individual because
I know lots of people that knitting clicked for them right away
and crochet felt fumbly and weird and the exact opposite
as well. So I really think that this is when it's beneficial to try
both crafts because you never know what's going to click with your brain
and your hands. This next statement is going to be
a little controversial and that is knitting
is better for making garments than crochet. And honestly
in the past I would have said this is true because
knitting was associated with making clothing, sweaters, cardigans,
cowls, scarves, and crochet was thought more of for
blankets and toys and home decor accessories.
But recently that old way of thinking has been completely turned on its head.
Today you're going to find some of the most gorgeous crocheted clothing and
you're also going to find beautiful knit blankets and toys. I really
think that the idea that one craft is for clothing and the other
is for all the other things really is outdated. But with that said
knitting does have some built-in advantages over crochet.
The first and I think the most important point is that
knitting has more natural stretch than crochet. And let's look at our samples.
This is our crocheted sample and when we pull it from side to side there
isn't much stretch. And even from top to bottom
there is more stretch. You can actually see that. But side to side
it's pretty stiff. With our knitted sample you can see
that side to side there is a ton of stretch.
And up and down there is stretch but it's not quite as much.
And this mimics our clothing more closely.
We do have a lot more stretch side to side than we do
up and down. Knitted fabric is naturally stretchier because of how those stitches
are constructed. Knitting creates rows of interconnected loops that sit
on top of one another. And that forms a thinner more flexible fabric that
stretches easier especially that side to side. Crocheted
stitches on the other hand are much more structured. The loops are pulled
through completed stitches which creates a
sturdier thicker fabric. I've even heard people refer to crocheted stitches as
knots rather than a stitch. And that structure is
amazing for things like blankets bags and toys.
And it can be challenging for garments because there
is less stretch naturally. Another natural advantage
of knitting for garments is drape. Drape is what makes clothing
hang on the body nicely instead of looking stiff. And you can actually see
this if I just put it over my finger here
you can see that it actually has that drape. It naturally wants to
just go right over my finger. And four crochet
actually could just sit straight across like this. I actually
have to push it down to get it to have that drape that the knitting has.
This is where things get really interesting. One of the most important
choices that you're ever going to make whether you are knitting or crocheting
a garment is the choice of yarn. Actually that's going to make the
biggest difference when it comes to drape.
If you want a beautiful drapey sweater you're
probably not going to use a thick heavy acrylic yarn. And you could see that
with my sample. And it doesn't really even matter
whether you're doing it with crochet or knitting.
It's just going to create a stiffer fabric.
For that drape you're going to want thinner yarns. You're going to want more
natural yarns. You might lean toward wools, silks, linens,
cottons. The fiber content and the yarn weight are going to matter
so much more when it comes to drape than whether you're holding a crochet hook
or knitting needles. And this is why I think modern crochet garment designers
deserve so much more credit than they're actually getting. These are not the
type of garments that we used to see back in the 70s and 80s that looked
stiff and uncomfortable and scratchy. Crochet garment design has come
a long way. So is the statement knitting is better for garments than crochet
fact or fiction? That is pure fiction. When you choose the right yarn for the
right pattern you are going to end up with
something you love whether you crocheted it or
knit it. One statement that I think I hear more
often than any other is that knitting can be done by a machine but crochet can
only be done by human hands. But let's find out if that's fact
or fiction. There have been knitting machines for over a
century and what makes knitting machines pretty straightforward is that they
create loops in rows and a machine can do that
pretty easily. Crochet as we know is done with one hook
and each stitch is completed on its own. And this is the
And that level of individual control is why crochet was
always considered something that only human hands could do.
But recently that statement has become not
entirely true. Researchers have developed a prototype crochet machine.
This isn't just speculation or a theory or a
rumor. It's been documented in a peer-reviewed textile engineering journal
It's called Communications in Development and Assembling of Textile
Products. This machine can actually crochet a
flat fabric following digital stitch directions.
It can only do a few basic crochet stitches like the slip stitch,
single crochet, and half double crochet. And this machine can actually create
crocheted fabric. Not knitted fabric that looks like
crochet and you're going to see that out in fast fashion shops where maybe a
looks like it was crocheted but if you look really closely it was machine
knit. This machine can actually make a crocheted fabric. With that said
machine crochet is still very different than
hand crocheting. I'm going to leave a link for this journal in the description
box in case you want to read this for yourself. And I read
over the abstract and from what I can understand
is that this machine can crochet only one side and it works from one side
to the other. And as crocheters if we're crocheting something flat we will work
the front side and then we flip our work over and work the back side. And that's
not how this machine works. And it seems like this crochet machine
is at a very early stage. It's very experimental
and I don't think that we are likely to see this popping up in factories
anytime soon. So is it true that knitting can only be done by machine
but crochet cannot? Well that statement used to be fact but
now I think it's fiction. Were any of these a big surprise to you?
I actually was pretty surprised that crochet really does take
longer than knitting. That one actually kind of blew my mind.
But the other one that really surprised me
was that crochet basic crochet can be done by a machine now.
I did not know that before I started making this video but I would love to
hear from you. Let me know in the comment section
which of these fact versus fiction statements were the most surprising to
you. And if you've heard any others that I
didn't include in today's video. But I hope you have a great rest of your
week. Stay safe and happy stitching.
