The Law Academy is a project designed to provide legal education for students studying law in the UK. Subscribe for more content.
Citations & Further Reading: M. Freeman, Lloyd’s Introduction to Jurisprudence (Sweet & Maxwell, 2014). R. Wacks, Understanding Jurisprudence: An Introduction to Legal Theory (Oxford University Press, 2020). J. Penner & E. Melissaris, McCoubrey & White’s Textbook on Jurisprudence (Oxford University Press, 2012).
Disclaimer:
At no point are these video lessons intended to provide any sort of legal advice. These are for educational purposes only!
Image(s) Copyright: This Photo by Unknown Author is licensed under CC BY-SA
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI Generated
This lesson provides an introduction to natural law theory within the field of jurisprudence. It explores the fundamental relationship between law and morality, the definitions of descriptive and normative morality, and the core premise that law should be derived from intrinsic human values and moral standards rather than existing independently of them.
In this lesson we're going to talk about natural law. We're going to introduce this major
first topic within our subject of jurisprudence, just taking a general introduction to the subject
of natural law theory, before going into some of the more important details, history and modern
interpretations of natural law theory in future lessons time. So, like I said, we're introducing
the first subject of our philosophical inquiry. This is the interpretations of law as described
through the lens of the natural law tradition. We're going to look at what law is in relation
to this idea of morality, the necessity for a theory of natural law, as well as some of the
early origins of natural law theory. And then in the next lessons we're going to talk about
the ancient origins of natural law, deriving out of some of the Platonic and Aristotelian writings,
and then focus on arguably the most important period where natural law really flourishes,
which is of course in the early medieval period of the theological doctrines of people like
Augustine and Thomas Aquinas. So, the first question that could be asked, and ought to be
asked, in the context of any conversation about not just natural law, but just the theory of law
and the nature of law, is the question of how law is linked to the concept of morality. Some of you
might think that it is. Some of you might think that law and morality are inextricably linked
together in some kind of way, and you could be correct in making that assumption. You are definitely
not alone in making that assumption. And the reason for that is, in a lot of cases, you could
make the argument that law regulates moral principles. Why is it the case that murder, for
example, is considered to be wrong? Well, it's considered to be wrong because of its immorality,
and obviously murder is regulated by law, so you can make that connection. This is not to suggest
that there is a one-to-one comparison, or that law only regulates morality, but just that there is
somehow, potentially, some kind of link that exists between the idea of moral principles and moral
philosophy and the idea of law and legal theory. According to the philosopher, the legal theorist
H. L. A. Hart, who we're going to get to in a lot of detail in future lessons time, he argues that
the concept of law is, or at least in the concept of law, he argues that, and asks the question,
how does legal obligation differ from, and how is it related to, moral obligation? So how are these
things both interlinked, and how are they different? What is the differences? What are the similarities?
Now, the question that we have to ask before we respond to the question that H. L. A. Hart proposed,
the question about whether or not law is linked to morality, what are the similarities and differences?
The first question we have to ask in trying to tackle the answer is to think, well, what is
morality? And if we're going to talk about the nature of law and its relationship with morality,
then we probably ought to think about what morality is, and this is really where we start to see and
derive some of the principles of the natural law. Because in the broadest sense, what we talk when
we understand what morality is, is just an understanding about acts and omissions which are
said to be right or wrong, or good or bad. It's putting a value on your act and or omission, it is
putting a moral value, it is putting a moral value about whether or not that thing was
good or bad, or whether it was right or wrong. Now, morality is delineated between the descriptive
and the normative. Now, what does this mean? Essentially, morality and moral philosophy
have inherently within them both descriptive and normative dimensions. Now, when we talk about it
as being descriptive, we say that morality is descriptive in the sense that it seeks to explain
what it takes for good and bad behaviour to be identified. So, if I was to
outline and see an action that is committed by an individual, I can then put a label onto that as to
whether or not it was good or bad. If I see a murderer, or I talk about somebody who has committed
a murder, I can label that action as good or bad. I will often label that action as bad, and so
therefore I have put a descriptive identifier on what the morality of that particular action was,
or that particular person. That person is immoral, that person is bad. It then also has
normative dimensions, in the sense that this description then guides one to develop answers
to how we ought to behave. So, we're not just describing what an action is or isn't, whether
or not an action is good or bad, we're also then saying what actions ought to be described as good
or bad, how we ought to behave on the basis of our understandings and preconceptions of morality.
All these ideas, and the interlinking between natural law and moral philosophy, and the idea
of what morality ultimately is, brings into the fold this idea of the natural law. When we talk
about natural law theories, we note that these theories will place a certain amount of moral
weight to the ideas and principles which are then further encoded within the law and the legal
systems. Lawmakers and legal scholars are subjected to a set of moral values in the creation,
development and interpretation of law, and so what natural law notes, natural law essentially
notes that the law ought to do more than just simply exist outside of the confines of morality.
Natural law theory, as applied to jurisprudence, doesn't just tell us that law and morality are
separate. They argue that essentially there ought to exist law within the specific confines of moral
philosophy. It ought to contribute to the development of moral standards, and that this morality is that
what we utilize to define what law is. So when we think about another first introductory
question within jurisprudence, the question of what law is, when is a thing law, according to
natural law theory, we would say that it is law if it adheres to the moral principles and standards
which are consistent with the natural law. According to Finnis, who is a more modern natural law scholar
and who we will get to in future lessons time, he broadly defines natural law as a system of law
which is based on a close observation of human nature and based on values intrinsic to human
nature that can be interpreted and applied to the positive development of law. This is a little bit
of a wordy and convoluted description, but this is essentially what natural law theory tells us.
Now there are different variations and different influences of natural law theory which we're going
to get to in the future lessons on this particular topic, but for now let's just finish by talking
about what this definition is really telling us. It is a system of law, and that the system of law
and the determination of what constitutes law is based on the close observation of human nature
and is based on values which are intrinsic to human nature, and so we have to see that there
is a certain amount of objectivity here. There is an intrinsic value, moral value, which is placed
on human nature, which the natural law subscribes to, and that we interpret this intrinsic value
and apply those moral principles to the creation of new laws
and the development, the positive development, of law in the future.