"Facts About Zhuge Liang That Romance Of The Three Kingdoms Doesn'T Tell You "

History & Culture of East
10 followers
35 Video Views·Jun 10, 2026
Explore the practical political calculations of Zhuge Liang when he chose to support Liu Bei instead of more powerful forces. BATTLECRY analyzes the military strategy and geographical limitations that affected the Northern Expeditions.
AI Generated·May contain errors
For long, Zhuge Liang has been a symbol of wit, strategy, and righteousness.
Yet, from a historical perspective, he was first and foremost a politician.
Why did he choose to serve Lu Bei? Perhaps not just for the Han cause.
Why didn't he emerge sooner, choosing a more powerful lord than Lu Bei?
There are many historical questions about his motives that intrigue descendants today.
Welcome to BattleCry Chinese History.
Choosing Lu Bei, Zhuge Liang's first winner.
Zhuge Liang claimed to seek only survival, yet he harbored grand ambitions.
He once told his friends, Shi Tao, Cui Zhou Ping, and Meng Jian,
that they could attain the rank of provincial governor or prefect.
They asked him, and what rank would you attain, Zhuge Liang?
Zhuge Liang only smiled and did not answer.
Why that smile and silence?
Because mere governorships were never his true goal.
His grand ambition was not something to be shared lightly.
Yet in the late Eastern Han, the court was in chaos.
Warlords rose everywhere, and many declared themselves rulers.
Chao Chao, Yuan Shao, Yuan Shu, Lu Bu, Lu Biao, Sun Tzu, and Lu Bei.
All held ambitions to sweep the land and unify the empire.
With his intellect, heralded as peerless in the Three Kingdoms.
Was he really incapable of matching them?
Was he destined only to be a subject and never a sovereign?
Regrettably, he emerged far too late.
He was at least 20 years behind Chao Chao, Yuan Shao, and Lu Bei.
Before he left Longzhong, Chao Chao already had a massive army.
Controlling the emperor to command the other warlords.
Sun Quan held Jiangdong for three generations, with strong defenses and loyal subjects.
And was supported by many talented advisors.
Other warlords like Lu Biao held Jingzhou.
Ruling vast lands with an army of over 100,000.
Lu Zhong occupied Yizhou, while Zhong Lu held Hanzhong.
And Ma Tang, Han Sui, and others controlled Guangzhou.
The 13 provinces of the Han were carved up by various warlords.
Zhuge Liang missed his chance to become an independent warlord.
With his ambition to save the world, could he achieve hegemony as he desired?
To ascend to the pinnacle of power.
The only path was to choose a lord to serve.
For Zhuge Liang, this was a step back to eventually advance.
Like Sima Yi serving his lord, it was merely a tactic to achieve political goals.
So, what were the criteria for the lord Zhuge Liang would choose?
Zhuge Liang's criteria for a lord were twofold.
First, the lord had to be a wise and capable ruler.
Second, he had to become the lord's right-hand man, highly trusted and empowered above all others.
The Longzhong plan shows he had a clear grasp of the world, noting Mu Biao, Lu Zhong, and Zhong Lu.
These incompetence weren't worth considering.
Only Chao Chao, Sun Quan, and Lu Bei were viable options.
Politically, Chao Chao had the best chance to unify the empire.
Why did Zhuge Liang reject him?
It wasn't because Chao Chao was a traitor to the Han,
but something else.
Zhuge Liang did not choose Chao Chao because the central plains were already full of talent.
After pacifying the north, Chao Chao was no longer in his early, vulnerable days.
And his camp was already crowded with brilliant generals and strategists.
For a newcomer from Longzhong, rising to power under Chao Chao would not be easy.
With his keen insight, Zhuge Liang surely knew that Sun Quan
was a capable leader, especially with his brother Zhuge Jin.
Already serving in Eastern Wu.
Yet, when the senior official Zhong Zhao recommended him,
Zhuge Liang flatly refused, stating
that while Sun Quan was a ruler who might appreciate him,
he could never fully utilize his potential, so he declined.
Why, then, did Zhuge Liang ultimately choose Lu Bei?
Lu Bei had great vision, a knack for evaluating talent,
and, above all, absolute trust in his subordinates.
This contrasted with Chao Chao's suspicious nature,
creating the perfect environment for him.
Moreover, Lu Bei's desperate search for talent,
exemplified by his three visits, deeply moved Zhuge Liang to serve.
During the late Eastern Han, eunuchs and imperial in-laws vied for power.
The court fell into decay, and after Dong Zhuo's chaos and warlord uprisings,
the Han dynasty gasped its final breath.
With the world in such turmoil,
could a brilliant mind like Zhuge Liang not see that clinging to a rotten,
dying regime was futile?
Zhuge Liang avoided Sun Quan simply because Sun could use,
but not fully employ him, it had nothing to do with their surnames.
Why would Zhuge Liang serve Lu Bei,
a wanderer with no base of his own to start with?
Until now, most historians have failed to fully grasp this secret.
Most assume Zhuge Liang was simply a visionary,
ignoring Lu Bei's lack of military strength and resources,
or that they simply shared a grand ambition.
In reality, the fascinating truth is that Lu Bei's weaknesses
were, in Zhuge Liang's eyes, his greatest advantages.
Just think, if Lu Bei had been like Chao Chao,
with immense power and countless talents,
would Zhuge Liang have ever been so highly valued?
Under Lu Bei, the generals were merely Guan Yu, Zhao Yun, and Zhang Fei.
The strategists were also limited to a few, like Mi Zhu, Sun Qian, and Jian Yong.
Lu Bei's camp, lacking top talent, offered a vast stage
for Zhuge Liang to fully display his abilities.
As mentioned, his standards for serving a master were high.
The lord had to value his virtue and utilize his full potential.
These two concepts, virtue and utility, run deep.
To value virtue, he had to be recognized as a sage.
The highest respect is to treat a sage as a national treasure.
For Zhuge Liang, this alone was not enough.
He was exceptionally ambitious.
Though young and fresh from his hut,
he had no intention of climbing the ranks from the bottom,
but demanded a high position from the start.
To use him fully, one had to grant him central power.
While praised by the likes of Sima Hui, his fame was limited to Jingzhou.
In the central plains or Jiangnan, he remained an unknown figure.
With his pride, powerful warlords wouldn't suffice.
But Lu Bei was different.
Lu Bei was then general of the left and governor of Yizhou.
By Han tradition, he could establish a staff and govern.
Yet, he suffered from a severe lack of talent.
Most capable men had already been claimed by Wei and Wu.
In Zhuge Liang's eyes, this was Lu Bei's greatest advantage.
One that no other warlord could match.
That is precisely why he chose to serve Lu Bei.
Did the title of chancellor truly belong to him alone?
After Guan Yu and Peng Tong fell, his power rose, but not yet supreme.
After entering Shu, Lu Bei trusted Fei Xing even more than Zhuge Liang.
Zhuge Liang understood this well.
When Lu Bei insisted on avenging Guan Yu,
he ignored all his ministers pleased to stop.
Following the disastrous defeat at Yiling,
Zhuge Liang sighed that if Fei Xing had lived, he would have stopped the lord.
This shows that regarding the Yiling campaign,
Zhuge Liang's influence on Lu Bei was lesser than Fei Xing's.
Lu Bei's conquest of the west relied on Fei Xing,
who helped secure Yizhou and Hanzhong, establishing great merit.
He possessed immense wit and perfectly understood his lord's intentions.
Records from the Hanzhong campaign state.
Amidst a hail of enemy arrows,
Lu Bei stood firm at the front to observe the battle.
Though officers pleaded, he would not move,
until Fei Xing rushed forward to shield him.
Saying, my lord is the hope of the empire,
I must use my body to protect you.
Only then did Lu Bei agree to withdraw.
This clearly shows how Fei Xing treated Lu Bei,
offering his life and keeping absolute faith in his lord.
After the victory,
Fei Xing was named governor of Shu and general of the Huzars,
acting as a key advisor.
Giving Fei Xing such immense authority
proved just how much Lu Bei trusted him.
Someone suggested to Zhuge Liang that Fei Xing was abusing his power
and should be reined in.
Zhuge Liang replied,
the lord feared Chao Chao's power in the north
and Sun Quan's pressure in the east.
With these internal and external crises,
Fei Xing provided vital support,
how could we stop him from acting as he pleased?
Zhuge Liang reflected the grim reality,
but it also reveals his own limitations at the time.
On one hand, Fei Xing acted unchecked,
on the other, Zhuge Liang felt powerless to intervene.
They had their differences.
Fei Xing was the only advisor Lu Bei obeyed completely,
a feat Zhuge Liang admitted he could not match.
Luckily for him,
Fei Xing died the second year after Lu Bei became king of Hanzhong.
By his coronation, his key men were gone.
Zhang Fei, though a sworn brother,
was ultimately just a field commander.
Ma Chao was a surrendered general who could not be fully trusted.
Others were mere scholars.
Lu Bei looked around,
and only Zhuge Liang remained to shoulder the burden.
Upon ascending the throne,
Lu Bei appointed Zhuge Liang as chancellor.
After Zhang Fei's death and his promotion to colonel director of retainers,
one question arises.
Did Zhuge Liang spend 15 years climbing to that chancellor's seat?
Only for it to be Lu Bei's final, reluctant choice?
Why insist on six northern expeditions despite a crumbling state?
After Lu Bei entrusted his son to Zhuge Liang at Beitisheng,
Zhuge Liang rested his troops for only five years
before launching five northern expeditions.
Why risk everything in a desperate offensive
instead of holding the rugged, defensible lands of Shu?
First, consider the geography.
Lu Bei famously wrote that the roads to Shu
are harder than ascending to heaven.
It is encircled by mountains,
making it easy to defend but difficult to attack.
The eastern passage, the Yangtze River,
connects to the Jiangnan region.
After flowing through Shu,
the Yangtze passes through the Three Gorges,
a region of extreme strategic peril.
With towering cliffs and swirling, violent currents,
it spans 200 kilometers to Yichang.
From Shu, one can easily sail downstream to Jiangnan.
However, Jiangnan forces cannot sail upstream
through the gorges to attack Shu.
Thus, Shu holds an absolute advantage over Jiangnan.
Historically, conquering Jiangnan required first seizing Shu
to control the upper Yangtze.
To the north, the Qinling Mountains separate
Hanzhong and Shu from the Guangzhou region.
Crossing the Qinling from Guangzhou to Hanzhong
has always been notoriously difficult,
with only four treacherous paths.
Even after crossing the Qinling,
one must still navigate the equally formidable Daba Mountains
to reach the plains.
This is precisely the path Lu Bei described
as harder than reaching the heavens.
A single garrison of these strategic bottlenecks
could hold off 10,000 men.
For instance, during the Wei invasion of Shu,
Jiang Wei used only a small force
to hold back a 150,000-strong main army,
preventing the enemy from reaching the Chengdu plains.
Furthermore, the Chengdu region was the breadbasket of Shu,
known as the Land of Abundance.
Even if isolated, it remains self-sufficient,
making Shu a natural, defensible, independent kingdom.
With these strongholds, it's hard to invade Shu.
Yet, it is equally hard for Shu to strike out.
This geography provides great defense,
but it also traps Shu, limiting its growth.
In times of chaos,
Shu could easily survive as an isolated, peaceful kingdom.
However, once the world is reunified,
Shu becomes a prison due to its location,
making it easy for a strong central power to trap and conquer it.
Furthermore, the Guangzhou region lies beyond the Qinling Mountains,
threatening Shu directly.
And Guangzhou was firmly in the hands of Qiao Wei.
Of the three kingdoms,
Qiao Wei was the strongest, bent on total unification.
Shu would be their first target,
a springboard to train troops and crush Eastern Wu.
If Shu stayed isolated,
it would not last long before being swallowed by Wei.
Thus, after losing Jingzhou,
Shu had to break out of its confinement,
adopting an offensive defense or facing inevitable doom.
This is why Zhuge Liang,
after stabilizing the realm and resting his troops,
launched his northern expeditions,
fighting until his final breath.
Let us examine Guangzhou,
a region of immense strategic value.
Through Heng'e Pass in the east,
one can reach the Central Plains.
To the south,
one can cross the Qinling Range to Shu,
or via Wu Pass,
reach Nanyang.
From there, the Yangtze and Huai Rivers become vulnerable.
Guangzhou is a fortress connecting four directions,
perfect for attack or defense.
Holding Wu Pass and Heng'e Pass alone
could repel any Central Plains force.
The Qin state used Guangzhou to unify the world.
During the Chu-Han contention,
Lu Bang was trapped in Shu by the three Qin lords
who guarded Guangzhou.
Yet, with Han exile and strategy,
he famously marched through the plank roads at Qinsong,
secretly crossing the mountains to take Guangzhou by surprise.
He then used Guangzhou as a base to defeat Xiangyu
and unify the empire.
Historically, Guangzhou was a strategic prize
between the Central Plains and Shu.
It was said that whoever held Guangzhou
could unify the empire.
Yet, during his northern expeditions,
why did Zhuge Liang not strike directly at Guangzhou?
Instead, he marched toward Qishan to seize Longyu.
Why was this?
There are four routes leading from Hanzhong
through the Qinling Mountains to Guangzhou.
From east to west,
Fen, Ziwu, Tangluo, Baiyue, and Qinsong.
These are perilous.
The Qishan route, however,
is relatively flat and easier to traverse.
Though it is long and leads only to Longyu,
not directly to Guangzhou.
The Ziwu Valley Strategy
Wei Yan proposed a daring plan
to lead 5,000 elite troops through Ziwu Valley
to strike Chongyun.
If successful,
he would hold the passes to block Chao Wei's reinforcements.
Meanwhile, Zhuge Liang would lead the main force
through Baiyue to secure Guangzhou.
But Zhuge Liang rejected this plan as too risky.
Guangzhou was the heart of Chao Wei's defenses.
It was heavily fortified and close to Wuyang.
Wei Yan's small force would surely be crushed.
Furthermore,
the rugged terrain made logistics nearly impossible.
Xu's military power could not sustain
such a prolonged struggle.
Zhuge Liang's main force
would likely be intercepted before making contact.
Wei Yan, isolated deep in enemy territory with no retreat,
risked total annihilation
ever since Guanyu lost Jingzhou
and Lu Bei was defeated at Yiling.
Xu was in a dire situation.
It could not afford such risks or heavy losses.
He had to advance steadily,
balancing offense and defense.
Thus, Zhuge Liang chose the Qishan route.
It leads directly west,
across the Long Mountains into the Longyu region.
Crossing the long range provides natural,
defensible terrain.
Beyond the range,
the main road offers a direct path to Guangzhou.
Moreover,
the Qishan road is flat and ideal for marching.
If a surprise attack fails,
it remains a safe path for retreat.
Longyu offers vast plains,
lush grass,
and excellent horses.
It allows for cavalry training and large-scale agriculture,
effectively solving the critical dilemma of grain transport
and easing the logistical burden on Xu Han.
It is perfect for stationing troops and growth.
This region served as the ideal strategic springboard for Xu Han.
The Qin ancestors rose by breeding horses there,
eventually conquering Guangzhou and the empire.
Zhuge Liang planned to secure Longyu first,
building a base to eventually seize Guangzhou.
His strategy was flawless and pragmatic,
yet fate was not with Xu Han.
In his first northern expedition,
his forces surged,
quickly taking the Longyu commanderies.
But at a critical moment,
Ma Su's recklessness led to defeat,
forcing a retreat.
During the fourth expedition,
he used wooden oxen for supply,
gaining the upper hand.
Yet again,
at a turning point,
treachery in the rear disrupted supply lines.
The emperor,
misled by slander,
ordered a retreat,
undoing his hard-won progress.
Knowing his time was limited,
he avoided the Qishan route this last time.
Choosing instead the Beiyue path
to strike directly at Guangzhou,
stationing his troops at the Wuzhong plains.
But Sima Yi remained firmly entrenched,
refusing to engage.
Until Zhuge Liang eventually exhausted his strength.
