Next Steps: • 💸 Start eliminating debt for free with EveryDollar - https://ter.li/knf775 • 📞 Have a question for the show? Call 888-825-5225 weekdays from 2–5 p.m. ET or send us an email.
A woman seeks advice on whether to allow her in-laws to fund and move into her unfinished basement as \"snowbirds\" and eventually permanent residents. The advisor strongly warns against this, citing a lack of exit strategies, potential boundary issues, and the financial risk of tying the parents' assets into a home they do not own.
Brought to you by the EveryDollar app. Start budgeting for free today.
We found y'all through our church through FPU about a year and a half ago and we are on baby step
four. And my in-laws kind of popped this idea to us about six months ago. We have,
we bought our house about two years ago and it has a very large unfinished basement.
And they have had this idea that when they retire, which is going to be my father-in-law's
retiring at the end of the year, that they want to kind of put some money into our house and finish
off our basement for them to kind of be snowbirds to be here, go in the South and then go up North
and then eventually kind of transition to living with us in our basement. And I'm not totally
against the idea because we have a good relationship. It'd be great for our kids to
have grandparents close by. But I'm a little bit concerned about the long-term effect of this.
You know, they wouldn't really have an ROI putting money into our house.
Do they know that?
Yes, we told them that. And my concern is just, you know, like what happens if we do this and,
in five years from now, someone has a stroke and now they need more care and a lot of their money
is tied up in our house. Or you decide to move and take a different job. And my husband said
that to them and they kind of were like, oh, well, I guess you just mean that two more people are
moving with you. Oh boy. Listen, there's a difference between having grandparents close
and having them in the basement. I don't know. You know, I want to be a good steward of, you know,
what we've been given and, you know, to help out how we can. It's more just, you know, we're 33.
Hey, I got to stop you. I got to stop you because you sound like someone who knows what they want
to do, but you don't feel firm enough in it that you're talking yourself in circles about it.
Yeah. You know, that's not a good idea, but you're afraid you're not being nice
and your classic Southern bless your heart, you know, bless your heart. So no, no, no, no,
no. They don't need to move in there. That's a bad idea. There's more downside than upside.
I think so. Yeah. And I just found out too that they got an annuity and I've got George's book
and I heard that like, that is not good either. And so I'm concerned about like their financial
future and their money. I would rather them use their money to buy a nice little condo in your
area. And that's cheap enough that it doesn't know that they can use it and still snowbird.
And they can still be around and babysit and see the grandkids, but they have their own life over
there. And it's not tied into your home and your decisions that we told them. And they said that
they don't think they're going to have the money, but that this is a snowbird thing. It's not their
primary residence. Yeah, but they want it to be eventually, right. But it's not today, which
means they have a place somewhere where there's equity building and he is retired from a job.
So there should be some sort of retirement, something, some nest egg. I don't know how
big or small bottom line is, whether they've got the money or not doesn't determine whether this
is a good idea. As a matter of fact, since they don't have the money, it further ensures that
this is not a good idea. If I woke up in your shoes, I would say, mom and dad, we love you.
We'd love to have you close, but not that close. Does your husband agree? Hey, George here for
Churchill Mortgage. Listen, with interest rates dropping, this might be your window to buy a home
or refinance. Building equity through home ownership is still one of the best ways to
create safety and security in your life. And you decide when the time is right. And my good friends
at Churchill Mortgage will give you a custom plan and a special offer so you can buy or refinance
the smart way. Go to churchillmortgage.com slash Ramsey offer. That's churchillmortgage.com
slash Ramsey offer. This is a paid advertisement NMLS ID 1 5 9 1 NMLSconsumeraccess.org
equal housing lender. I would say mom and dad, we love you. We'd love to have you close,
but not that close. Does your husband agree or is he fighting for the in-laws? No, he,
no, he does. And I think my, my concern is, um, you know, and we're going to, we're actually
seeing them next month to like really talk about this in more detail. Um, and they, uh, they,
like I told my husband, like, if they, if I find out, you know, they have like $5 million in their
next month, they get a hundred million to drop in our basement. If it may be a big deal, but
Dave is right. I don't care how much money they have. I don't care how responsible they are.
This is a bad idea because it handcuffs you guys, the exit strategies on this, as you said,
if something goes sideways and somebody needs help or whatever, you are stuck once you get in this
and there's no way out. And that's the problem with this. And you are not being mean by saying,
no, we have to figure out some other way that you guys have a sustainable life.
That's not mean. It's not mean at all. Uh, you're not, you know, you're scared of death.
You're not going to be nice because you're a sweet person. Uh, you can just be just smile
and be kind and say no. Uh, and you don't need to have the meeting next month either.
There's no reason to leave these poor people along. You need to just,
your husband needs to call his mother and say, no, you need to stay out of it.
He needs to tell her no, not you. Cause you'll be labeled the wicked witch of the West forever.
25 years ago, I wanted to move in her basement and she wouldn't let me that which, you know,
that's the kind of, that's how that stuff gets started, right? Yes. And so that starts a whole
narrative then and you'll get blamed for it. So no, make him have a backbone and tell his mommy,
no. And, um, and don't have a detailed meeting discussing it. I really would. I really would
not do this. I wouldn't do it either because there's no, how does this end? Well, well,
if you have the meeting, it looks like you're considering it. I know,
I know. And that's not fair. That's not fair. That's, that's not fair at all. And so, um,
you know, no, but, but if you, if I do move in, I can't think of an exit strategy that works unless
both of them died in their sleep. I mean, other than that, I can't think of a good exit strategy
here. No. And then everything, and they need to do that in time for you to move. Yeah. I mean,
no, this is just, no, no, no, no. There's going to be aging problems and disability issues and
care issues and you all and boundary issues. And you guys, there's like 99 things that can go wrong
and only one that can go right. Yeah. And all the risk is on you guys. It's there's no risk on them
because they get built in health care. It's on them as if you sold the house after they did a
bunch of improvements. Yeah, that's true. That's the risk on them, but still it's they, they need
to use their money more wisely and have a good life that it's fine to be close by, but we need
good, healthy, physical boundaries. It's a good thing. Man. So, um, you know, we are now getting
calls in the last three years that in 40 years of doing this show, I've not gotten much, much of
just this idea of multi-generational housing. Yeah. The parents, uh, we're going to, we're
going to, I mean, I've had the mother-in-law question. We're going to build a mother-in-law
apartment, right? Or we want to add onto our house and she wants to give us $200,000 to do that.
And then, um, she's going to give us that at her death and she's going to live over there.
That question I've had, but now we're seeing this thing of the family compound, you know, and,
and four families are moving onto one single piece of property and there's no exit. These things, uh,
you know, and they're doing it because they think it's more affordable to do it. But you guys have
to be real careful. You have to think through what happens in divorce. What happens in disability?
What happens in death? What happens when the sister-in-law across the way starts doing cocaine?
What happens when you decide you just don't like these people?
Well, that could happen to you. This is family after all.
Create your free every dollar budget today. The simplest way to budget for your life.