In this episode of the Building Bigger Lives Podcast, Michael Regan and Kathryn Pedersen explore the distinction between loan officers and mortgage advisors, and how the titles professionals choose can shape both client perception and long-term relationships. Drawing from Kathryn’s experience in both banking and independent mortgage environments, they unpack how language influences trust, expectations, and even search behavior in an increasingly AI-driven world.
The conversation highlights the shift from transactional service to advisory relationships, emphasizing the importance of asking thoughtful questions, understanding client goals, and positioning yourself as a trusted resource rather than an order-taker. Michael and Kathryn discuss how mortgage advisors differentiate themselves by offering ongoing guidance and support beyond the initial transaction, ultimately building deeper, more meaningful client connections. The episode encourages listeners to reflect on how they present themselves to consumers, especially when refining scripts and strategies during mid-year planning.
AI Generated·May contain errors
Comments are disabled for this video.
Hello everyone. Welcome back to the Building Bigger Lives podcast. Michael Regan along with
Catherine Peterson. And like we do each and every Wednesday, we bring an episode to our
entrepreneurial community, largely from the housing industry. But like we've learned,
many of you follow along because you have found applications from some of these topics that extend
beyond the world in which we work. And we love that. We love hearing from you when that happens.
So please continue to add likes and comments when we post these episodes. It helps us know
what you're appreciating and where to spend our time. This week's episode is going to be one that
harkens back to a post I read about on LinkedIn just this last week. So depending on when you're
listening to this, this may be a bit of an older post, but the topic isn't going to age because
it's been there the whole time I've been in the housing industry. And I think we'll find out it's
similar for Catherine. And it's the title of the mortgage advisor and the title of the loan
officer. And what I'd like to dig into is certainly what those titles mean and maybe why
they matter to somebody. But most importantly, you know, why should it matter to you as the
consumer? That's really where we want to get to, because if our audience are largely in the space
that we work in, I'm hoping you'll think through this a little bit after you hear us riff on a few
of these ideas and decide how you might position yourself differently or how you might talk about
it differently when you're front facing with your consumers. But I won't set it up any further
without welcoming in my friend and my favorite co-host Catherine Peterson. Hey, Michael. All
right. This is going to be a good topic for everybody to listen to today because talking
through how we see ourselves and how we present ourselves to others, I think is a great topic as
we go into maybe some mid-year planning and redoing what we're scripting and all that kind
of stuff that we have to think about all the time as mortgage advisors. There we go. And, you know,
I think if we really look at this through the genesis of any opportunity we have to help
someone, we typically need a lead. We need an opportunity to serve someone to find out how we
can advise them, how we can help them. And it's really important. You and I've gone through this
exercise before where we look at the customer journey and what are the things they are doing
before we're even aware that they're interested in buying a home. And it's very important for us
to think that way because we realize in today's world, they're probably going to their favorite
AI tool. So, you know, maybe that's chat, maybe that's Grok, maybe that's Claude, wherever they're
going. And they're typing in words that will help them shape the question they want to ask
to start forming the answer they're going to get. And that's going to point them in a certain
direction. And so I think these are keywords that often get typed in, you know, mortgage, loan,
loan officer, advisor, whatever those words are, are going to shape the direction that that
algorithm within that AI agent is going to help them figure out, you know, what it is they're
asking and where to point them. And so it really does matter what these titles mean.
Catherine, you've worked at a bank. You've worked for an independent mortgage bank.
So you've seen both sides of the coin. Start with just that, the title alone. Like,
where did these titles come from or what have you experienced when you've heard these different
titles and you've had the opportunity to give yourself a description in the role that you play?
So in banking, it can be very, let's just say that there's kind of a preset track. So you might have
bank officer, you might have AVP, you might have VP, etc. And a lot of times people who've been
in banking really respect those titles. It's a little bit about tradition. And for me, I never
quite saw it like that. And part of that kind of goes back to my first job in mortgage in college.
And I was, I only did loan processing and very basic, right? New to the industry. And my boss
said, okay, great. What do you want to be? And I was like, I'm a processor. And he's like, no,
people won't take you seriously. We have to come up with a different title. Do you want to be
president? And I was like, CEO? And I was like, no, no, that sounds like a trick question. So I
at least knew enough to say no to that question. And so I ended up as VP of operations. And keep
in mind, I was entry-level processor. But he said, now when people call people, you call,
people will take your phone call. You just have to say that when you call.
So it taught me a lot about the way other people can see titles and really titles can be made up.
So some of that gives you some creative freedom to kind of reach out. And that was probably a much
longer question, but I think it's an important one as we talk through these distinctions.
Yeah. But I'm glad to hear your personal story because, you know, I have one too. I remember
the first 30 days that I was hired in my first loan origination job, I probably did it without
any business cards because at that point they're trying to figure out, are you even going to
make it? Is this worth us sending a set of these off to the printer? But once I got past my first
30 days, I got a box of cards that was delivered at the office and they said, senior loan officer.
And I remember thinking, okay, first of all, I'm in my twenties, I'm not a senior,
anything. Second of all, loan officer, what does this mean? That sounded to me like a banking title
and I was working for an independent mortgage bank and titles there, they treated them very
flippantly. They treated them like what kind of like your description, but from a different angle,
kind of like it in the sense of, we want to make sure you don't sound like you're not
the important person, but with much less, as you called it, respect around these titles matter.
These titles are either important to the perception of that role or maybe to the
person themselves. This was more just about marketing. They just wanted to make sure you,
when you're handing these things out, you look good. So let's talk about what these titles mean.
I mean, loan officer sounds like it comes from the banking world. Loan originator sounds a little
looser in how we state that. And yet today, I think we work in a world where loan originator
might even be a tighter definition than it was when we were taking things from soup to nuts.
Today, a loan originator might be just the person who gets that loan started and then the people,
or maybe even the AI tools take over and run it. Have you seen some of that in the evolution of
your role where even what that title means has changed a little over the years?
Oh, absolutely. I think as you add team members and you talk through how much paper was involved
in a file in the old days, and now we just don't have that. So many things are automated. We
rarely take an application. We might fill in some gaps, but that's all being done online.
So it's a little bit different than, and it evolves over time. It's different than it was
last year and it'll be different next year. So it's an always evolving title, I would say.
Yeah, I would agree with that. And I've definitely seen it evolve over the years.
And before we lose the audience with, okay, we're in the tomato-tomato world. You're even
acknowledging it changes. You're even acknowledging that it might not be that big a deal. Let's focus
on a group of people that's different than maybe the originator themselves or the company they
work for. Let's talk about the customer. Because that's what I was starting with is I think
if you think about customers looking for help in this space, these words suddenly do matter
because they'll shape the direction of the type of search they go through. Or if they get referred,
let's take the more traditional route. I think it's pretty common today. If you refer someone
to me before I pick up the phone and call them or send them a message, I might go look them up.
I might go find out, okay, I trust Catherine, but who is this person? And so I'm going to type
in keywords. So these keywords still matter at some level, even if we think tomato-tomato on the
definition of them. So look at it through the customer's eyes. What do you think a customer
is thinking if they type in loan officer versus mortgage advisor? What would be the customer's
reasoning for choosing the phrase that they use from your point of view? You've talked to a lot
of customers. Why do they pick a loan officer? Why do they pick a mortgage advisor?
I always think of loan officers, that's words that people just don't use as much. So let's
call it, yeah, it's a mortgage or even home loan. We hear that. But loan officer sounds more like
lettuce. Let's use that as an example. So pretty just kind of like standard and normal versus a
mortgage advisor, I think about someone who's going to advise you, who's going to give you
advice, who's going to tell you what's best for you and be very individual versus loan officer
makes that sound like they're working for the bank. Are they really working for you or are
they working for the bank? So I think that's where my brain goes now, exactly what every client is
thinking. I think it's going to vary, but I would say that that's the first thing that comes to my
mind. Yeah, great. And here's what comes to my mind, and I think it dovetails nicely with what
you just said. I think in my mind that the nuance between those is going to be who's asking the
questions. I think if it's a loan officer, that person is asking all the questions because they're
basically taking you through an application, even if, as you said, it's being done digitally these
days. They're essentially qualifying you with a series of questions. So if you as a consumer
don't know what to ask, a loan officer is going to ask all the questions, or a loan originator,
I guess, if we want to widen the net a little. They're going to ask all the questions where
a mortgage advisor would imply, hey, I have questions and I'd like to ask you about these
things and you're the advisor. I'd like you to give me some education. I'd like you to give me
some more information. I might even like some options. Could you show me what other things I
don't know about or I read about this or I heard about this? So to me, the advisor, maybe in the
direction you were going, opens up a whole wide plethora of options of things we can discuss,
where a loan officer, it's almost order-taking. It's just, hey, I need the number two and
supersize it. It's order-taking. And I don't want to imply that there's anything wrong with that.
So if our audience is out there and they feel like, well, yeah, but I know what I want. Why
can't I just get someone to take the order? Good news, that career and that person still
exists out in the ecosystem. But I think what's evolved over time, the advisor has come along
because, frankly, the opportunity to qualify someone properly and match them up with products
and pricing and rates, it's become very complicated. It's not vanilla. It's not easy.
And you know that better than anybody because you live in that seat every day.
So let's stay on the mortgage advisor side of this, since that's, I think, where this is
interesting. What are some of the questions that either you have experienced as the advisor
or that you enjoy exploring as the advisor? What are some of the questions that you've seen?
Because I do think that's really where this gets a little more interesting.
Yeah. So one of the ones I love is, what are the things that you're the most
concerned about, worry about, or are keeping you up at night right now?
Yeah. That doesn't sound like a loan officer.
No. And I want to make sure that when they leave, they're going to sleep well, right? That's an
important piece to me. Or, hey, yes, you're buying your home, but let's talk about what the next five
years look like for your family or this property. Yeah. I think that's key.
Yeah. And what's the most important thing for you? Is that cost? Is that cost over time? Is
that the lowest rate so you can brag to your neighbors? What does that look like?
Yeah. You're doing something that most planners do intuitively. And I think that's the heart of
the advisor. Is there really a mortgage planner? We don't use that term a lot. I know there is
designation out there for a certified mortgage planner, a certified mortgage planning specialist.
So those titles exist within certifications, but they're not the common language that maybe the
audience uses out in the world. I doubt that's being searched very often in the AI, but that's
the heart of it. Is you're helping them look at what happens after what happens next. What are
the outcomes that are preferable if this goes really well? And what are the concerns or the
risks that you're trying to mitigate along the way? So you're starting to look at things with
a little more complexity. How do people respond to that, Catherine? As a mortgage advisor,
do you get that odd look like, why are you asking me that? Or even worse, the, uh-oh, I don't know
how to answer this. I've never thought about that before. What happens when you start exploring
those types of questions with the consumer? I think I get really good responses. I don't think
people are like, some of them maybe don't know exactly how to answer it, but we talked through
that. Most people are comfortable answering whatever you ask them because they know that
they're coming in for an appointment with a professional. So they're expecting to answer
things. So at least, and this is where it comes down to mindset. I never think, oh, I'm asking
something that they may not want to answer, or, oh, I'm asking something that maybe I shouldn't
ask. So I think that that comes from the confidence in the question, because if you're
confident in your question, they're probably going to answer it, or do their best, or say,
I don't know how to answer that question. I haven't thought about it. That's okay.
So I think it's having expectations for the answer. If you already think you know what they're
going to say, that's not a good place to come from. So it comes back to the mindset in your
question and how you ask all the questions in your meeting. That's really good because it's
hard to argue with that logic, which is if you're confident, because you already know as the advisor
the complexity of what's in front of them, and you're showing them your ability to walk them
through that with that confidence, that's going to draw them into you. That's going to help them
feel more trust with you. And frankly, we haven't talked a lot about this yet, but on the other
side of that coin where those loan officers play, we're also in a world today where, thanks to the
modern evolution of AI, we're getting a lot of bots now that can do the job of the loan officer,
can just take the app. They can take the transaction. It's no different than if I used
the joke earlier about, you know, I'll take the number two meal. Well, most of us have at some
point in our lives walked into a fast food restaurant and there's a menu there. Today,
walk into one, you don't even get to do that with a person. You do that with a screen. You just start
pressing the buttons. This is what I want. And next thing you know, some food shows up. So that's
the way the world is going. So when you're asking those questions and you're building that trust,
you're demonstrating something that separates you from that experience. And for those of us
out there who've started having that little creeping doubt in your head of, oh, are the
machines coming to take my job? Catherine, I feel like the answers you're giving already are
evidence that, no, we're always going to stay ahead of that experience as long as we're willing
to ask better questions, explore options and different answers, and ultimately build trust
with people because they see that there is more out there than just press one and get mortgage.
I know a lot of people like the idea of an easy button, but the truth is the easy button
often is wrapped up in something that's also very easy for the bank providing that loan,
which means you're either paying a premium in cost, you're paying a premium in rate,
or you're not being given the options that might be better for you because they like the way that
product sells on the secondary market and you don't understand the secondary market. So it
doesn't matter to you. These are the things I think that do matter. Okay. So now you've asked
some better questions. Now you've helped point them toward outcomes. Does the journey then
continue? What does this look like once you've closed their loan? Was that, I hope you enjoyed
the experience. It was a little bit different than it used to be. We'll see you later. Or
what happens after we close this loan when you're a mortgage advisor?
Well, I think you first start before that and say, hey, at the initial appointment,
this is what we do for our clients after we've closed the loan. Because then they know that
this isn't just transactional. And then number two, at the closing or at a pre-closing meeting,
hey, this is what we're going to do. We're going to stay in touch at these touch points. We're
going to do an annual review. We're going to track your interest rate. We're going to send
you a post-closing mortgage coach. So there's things that you can do to show that you are
different in how you show up. And hey, if something comes up, call us. Because I know
that there's originators out there. Once that loan is closed, it's like peace out.
So I think we have to say, hey, this is more of a relationship, a long-term relationship,
not just a transactional. And I think that can be different. And they trust you. So they want
your advice. And I always say, hey, if something comes up, that's kind of random and you don't
know who to ask, feel free to call. Because if I don't know the answer, I can say, hey,
that's a great tax question. Do you have a tax advisor? Or hey, that's a great real estate
question. You should call your agent. Do you still want to work with your same agent? Great.
Here you go. So I think it's setting the stage so that that relationship continues up front,
and that can delineate different originators or advisors from each other.
I hope our audience picked up on that because you said that so effortlessly that they might
have just thought, oh, yeah, that's just a nuance. It's not a nuance. You were super intentional
by saying it's all in how you set it up in the first place. If you set the expectation
that the journey we're going to go on for the next 10 days or 20 days in this transactional moment
might have certain touch points, we're going to continue those touch points in the future.
And you put some definition around why we would do that. We're not here to be pesky. We're not
here because we need anything new from you. Your loan is fine. Your home is yours. We're happy for
you. But life continues to evolve. And some of those goals and dreams you told me about in the
initial interview where we took your loan application now get played out in that future.
And we want to check back with you to not only encourage the progress that you're making,
but to offer new opportunities that would accelerate the payoff of the goal that you
have. So that's really great that you said that. I just hope our audience picked up on that.
I thought of two things when you said that that I used to introduce in my initial consultation,
which was we're going to put your loan into processing and underwriting, which is a very
normal thing. And in that, we're going to have some questions that need to be clarified. So
we're going to need to follow up with you. I hope you'll be gracious with us. We're not trying to
be bothersome. We just need to make sure we get it right so that everybody lands smoothly and your
loan closes on time. But here's what they're looking for. They're going to look for things
like, is the property properly set up for title? Is the property properly set up for insurance?
And that's to protect the lender in most cases. What I want you to know is that I want to look
at the insurance that protects you. So at some point after this transaction closes, I want to be
able to sit down and talk with you about what happens if your income suddenly changes and what
can we do to properly protect your income? Or what happens if your situation after closing
changes and we need to legally hold your home in a different way? Maybe it's in a trust,
maybe it's in an LLC. These are things that we can explore through the network of folks
I know in the insurance world or in the legal world that can help us better secure that mortgage
for your benefit rather than for the lender's benefit. We have to do this upfront for the lender
because it's required to get the loan. But at the end of the day, my customer is the person I serve.
And I want to make sure that they do feel confident that when they come back to me for those
annual reviews and check-ins, that I'm always looking back toward their goals and their
objectives first. So those are some things I'll remind them. We'll follow up with that later.
And the good news is there's no close of escrow for those. We can do those at your pace. There's
no urgency. Right now, we've got urgency because the underwriter and the lock term require it.
But in the future, we'll be able to sit down and I'm happy to meet with you and walk through those
things and do it at your pace. And I've always received positive feedback from that because they
sense at that point, okay, this person actually is, again, way different than the loan officer who
once it's closed, I don't know, you might be in their Christmas card campaign and they'll say,
here's my card. Call me if you need me again. Way different than the mortgage advisor.
Any closing thoughts on the contrast between these two, Katherine?
I would say always think through in your head if I was the client and I was going to someone for
good solid advice, what would I want to be asked? How would I want to be treated? How would I want
that relationship to look? Because I think sometimes we forget that we come from a chair
that we know all the acronyms and we know the process and we know we don't feel like it's scary
because we've done it so much. But for them in that seat, what's going to make them feel
comfortable? And it's so good to think through that every so often just to reframe of, wait,
how are we saying this? Is that confusing? Are we doing it in a way that builds trust?
And just reanalyze your process as many times as you need to.
That's really great. You just triggered a thought for me back from some really old sales training
and someone described it this way, which was the golden rule says, treat others the way you would
want to be treated. The platinum rule says, treat others the way you know they would want to be
treated. And so your implication in that response is you've really been a student of this person
by asking them these questions and being an active listener, you're developing a relationship with
them. And I think that's a great place to close this topic is the outcome of the mortgage advisor
is a long-term relationship. It's obviously a professional relationship, but you and I both
know often they even become personal relationships. You actually learn that, oh my gosh,
there's a lot of interesting people that I get to help as an advisor. And we decide to develop a
relationship maybe over something that had nothing to do with their home or their loan. For me, I
find out they love baseball and suddenly we talk baseball. For you, you may find out they love
travel and you start talking about travel. The point is we have a different mindset. And I think
that was really the heart of this post that I read. So thanks to my friend, Dave Savage, who I
highlighted that post on LinkedIn that I read that triggered some of these thoughts that I wanted to
talk about. And so if you're out there today, you're in Catherine's seat. You are the mortgage advisor.
Be really clear with people about what that title means to you and what it hopefully means to them.
And then back it up with some of these examples that Catherine gave you today of ways in which
you can ask really intentional questions. You can aim for really intentional outcomes and ultimately
be in a position of loving and serving that client and their needs first. Because if you can do all
of that, you really do take a loan officer skillset and you become the mortgage advisor.
And I think that will create all the separation you need to keep you from worrying about whether
AI is coming to take your job. And maybe, just maybe, you'll start to trust that you can leverage
AI as well for some of those pesky back-end tasks. Because last time I checked, Catherine,
I don't think you or I ever signed up for a job where we said, I hope I get to chase paperwork or
I hope I get to fill in the blanks. That's not the fun part of our job. The fun part is all we've
talked about today. It's meeting with these people, hearing their story, and finding a way to help
them. We're professional problem solvers. And I think you did a great job today highlighting a few
of those things. So thanks for unpacking this one with me. Yeah, thanks Michael. It's always fun.
Great. Well, that's going to bring us to a wrap on this episode of Building Bigger Lives. We hope
you got some value today out of contrasting the loan officer and the mindset of the mortgage
advisor. And if you did, please share this episode with someone that you think might benefit from
the contrast as well and might enjoy the conversation. If you do, join us on our YouTube
channel. That's where we post the video versions of these episodes. You may or may not care about
watching us have this conversation, but what you can do is join it. And that's where you can join
in, in the comments. We hope we'll see you on YouTube, and we hope we'll see you on future
episodes of Building Bigger Lives.