Garden thugs brilliant plants or a big mistake
AI Generated·May contain errors
Comments are disabled for this video.
Thugs in your garden doesn't sound like a very good idea does it?
Good doers of course, well that seems like a good idea.
When I was putting together this video on thugs and good doers
I took another look at our own garden and the whole of this back border where
I'm sitting is full of thugs and for one moment I
thought I'm going to have to dig it all up and
start again, but I've been talking to professional growers about thugs and
and even thugs do have a role in your garden
if you know how to control them. It's Alexandra here from the Middlesized
Garden YouTube channel and blog and I've been speaking to three
professional growers about thugs and good doers, how to
control them, what they're good for and if there's a
thug that actually none of us should grow. I started
by talking to Rosie Hardy who many of you
will know through her YouTube channel Rosie Hardy Gardening or through her
nursery Hardy's Cottage Garden Plants. She's also just started a new
membership club called Straightforward Gardening
where members get a weekly video telling them what they can do in the garden
this week and how to do it and I'll put a link to that in the description below.
So I asked Rosie to tell us about thugs. Thugs are plants that I would say have
aspirations to take over the world. So basically you plant one plant
and then suddenly you find you have got just an acreage of it, you know, even in a
small garden that means it's just taken over the whole thing.
There are thugs that are useful and a lot of people find that they are
because quite often they grow in conditions where a lot of other
things don't. So they could almost be described as
bomb-proof but I think they're probably a little bit more than that because
bomb-proof are things which stay, will be good-natured
and will survive anything that's going on. Whereas thugs will just go
sorry I don't like you neighbor I'm going to just take over your plot.
Thugs are going to be completely different in different locations
and they can be thuggy in different ways. So they can either be thugs because they
self-seed so prolifically that you're getting
loads and loads of more plants or they are spreading at such a rate
that they're making a massive amount of coverage through the garden.
And what plants would you call thugs? Right, so the top of the list is
anemone hybrida. So you know the Japanese anemone that's got to be
number one because it'd be in your garden and then it'll be about 10 doors
down and it's still the same colony or it goes
over under a path and comes out the other side of the garden. So lots of
people can relate to that. I would say something like symphytum is
as well. Now there are different symphytums, so
there are clump forming symphytums, absolutely fine.
But the ones that run around, so things like the grandiflorum types, you know
hiccup blue. I mean I've got a massive patch in the
back of my garden but it's there for a reason.
I don't want to have to fight the nettles out there. I want the nettles
so they're there as pollinator-friendly food for
and then they keep the nettles at bay and I have enough nettles for the rest
of my caterpillars. So that you know there's a reason for
using some of these things. Euphorbia fenserubi, so the euphorbia
saparisius types, they can be quite thuggy
especially in small gardens. I would say you know all of these plants
we sell but they go with a garden health warning.
You know to be advised they can get out of hand.
Majority of them will perfectly well be
dug up and you can get rid but if you leave a little bit of root then they'll
go oh yep off we go again. And you know the one
biggest thing I think are probably the bamboos.
That people just really shouldn't be putting bamboos in their garden anymore.
They really do spread a lot. And now let's go over to Paul Seaborn
of Pelham Plants to talk about thugs and good doers.
Hi I'm Paul Seaborn. I run Pelham Plants Nursery here in the Sussex Weald.
We specialize in plants that I like to grow
which is can be very broad but broadly speaking is herbaceous perennials and
grasses. Many of them working well on our heavy
clay soil here in the in the Sussex Weald.
And for my sins I also the event coordinator of the Plant
Fairs Roadshow. So I help bring lots of exciting independent specialist
expertise. Lots of growers to great venues across
the southeast. And we we think that this
is the best place to go for choice and expertise. Now a thug I think
it's probably a much easier one to explain. I think it's one
it's a plant that you lose control of and that can be for many reasons.
Often they seed prolifically or some of the worst will spread
vegetatively under the ground with bulbils,
side pieces, underground roots or rhizomes.
Thugs to avoid in the garden it I think it really does depend on your garden.
Some people find some plants more thuggish than others.
Personally one of the thugs I like to avoid
is Lysimachia firecracker. It's got fantastic purple foliage
and later on in the season it will have I suppose giving it its name these
cracking yellow flowers. But it does spread by underground runners
and I think if you allow it to go through a border
it will dart through and into your other herbaceous perennials
and through the root systems of long-lived perennials like
shrubs and I don't think you'll ever be rid of it. You'd have to do a really
thorough clean of a border to be able to get rid of it.
It's not as invasive as say a plant like
the three-cornered leek which is now illegal to
to plant in in Britain and there's there's one in particular
that I love and that's the plume poppy Maclea cordata.
It has a vigorous running habit and it's
dead easy to propagate for us. We take little root cuttings
but I grow it in a particular area of the garden where I know it can't
run amok. It dominates but it's held in by lawns and it's held in
by hedges. Box roots are quite intensive but
I would perhaps I always say to customers as they look at the beautiful
silvery foliage of Maclea cordata on the nursery
I warn them that this will run and some people are prepared to pull it
out every time it pops up in the wrong place
and you can weaken it by doing that and you can thin it by doing that
but for the faint-hearted and for the inexperienced gardener
I think it should be avoided. I think it would be too thuggish
particularly in an open light rich soil. A lawn or physical barriers can really
help control thugs. We know that people often
recommend sinking in membranes to control bamboo clumps. I
corral some thugs in lawn areas and if they pop up in the lawn
they get mown off and weakened and probably don't travel any further
but that's not always the case. There are some
willow varieties that will send out runners, bamboo varieties that will send
out runners and will pop up through a lawn and will
pop up across a pathway and into another border
without blinking an eyelid or it might take them a few years to get that far
but before you know it they've gone that far
so it really does depend on the plant and my
obvious response to that is to go to a good nursery and get
good advice on what you're buying. If the
label says vigorous cultivar that could be code
ask the question how vigorous is it? Is it a clump former?
Is it a runner? Does it seed about a lot?
How are you going to be able to control it? If you're unfamiliar
ask the nurseryman the question they want you to come back
they want to sell you a plant that's suitable for your garden so ask advice
go to the experts. Now we go over to Steve and Lou of the No Name Nursery
for their views on thugs and good doers. We're Steve and Louise
and the No Name Nursery is an off-grid sustainable nursery so we grow
everything ourselves in the ground mostly that we then
divide for cuttings and for cuttings in division.
Yeah so we grow down in Sandwich in East Kent
it's a very traditional nursery because it's mostly a garden
with a small nursery attached so that our garden
feeds the nursery and vice versa. And so what would you classify as thugs and
what would you classify as good doers? It's an interesting
proposition really that because we were talking about this as we've been
driving to various talks ourselves because
any plant in the right situation can be a thug.
If it's got its ideal conditions there are very few plants that won't take
advantage of that. I think Pitta Cytese Fragrance was the
one thing that we planted in the past and
you really can't get rid of it very easily. Yeah
There are some plants which are they're just tenacious
so you have to be certain if you're going to plant them
that's where you want them and I'm thinking of Acanthus
but now there are some lovely Acanthus cultivars
and species out there. I'm thinking of Rue Leaden which is a lovely white form
it's a gorgeous plant but you really need to be
absolutely certain that where you plant it is where you want it to live
because if you dig it up to move it as people often do
because they haven't necessarily got the placing
correct first time you'll leave bits of roots behind
and before you know it it'll be in multiple locations in your garden.
It's very rare that there is a plant that can't be controlled with enough
effort. It depends on the kind of gardener you are.
Some people just expect to plant something and just leave it be for years
on end with no interference and expect it to
stay where you put it. I'm afraid plants are living things and
they'll often they'll move where they want to go
they'll increase in size and they'll be having a jolly good time in your garden
quite often. I asked Steve Liu about bamboos and at
that point the internet cut out so I'm afraid I can't tell you exactly
what they said. They like bamboos they have them in
their garden and they think they're very good in urban gardens
for things like reducing neighborhood noise but they
did mention quite a lot of things that you have to do to them
to keep them under control and because of the lack of internet I didn't write
it down I can't tell you exactly what but I think that does qualify as the
third be careful if you plant bamboos and only
plant them if you know you're expert enough to keep
them absolutely under control. By now I realize that a border full of
thugs can be a wonderful thing in many ways.
There are big splashes of color and foliage at various times in the year
there are very few weeds so hardly any weeding and the plants don't need a lot
of care either in fact thugs can be the mainstay of a
low maintenance garden as Anne Wareham said their garden
Vedder has been named one of the hundred best gardens in Britain
and she says that plant thugs are a big part of its success
I'll put the video on their garden in the description below
however if I do want to introduce new plants to my thugs border
that's where I'm going to have to be very careful I'll need to clear a large
patch of soil and keep it clear and I'm going to have to nanny the new plants
more than usual this is obviously why I've struggled to get new plants
established in these borders and it would help if those new plants
were another thug or at the very least a good doer so let's
move on to what a good doer is and some of the professional experts
top good doers so so good doers I would normally say
are things which don't aggressively go sideways they just
are incredibly good plants they will make decent size
clumps so yes they'll make large clumps but they do it over a
slightly longer period and also don't tend to be ones that you dig them up and
you leave a bit root and then they regrow so
you know you'll have some really good forms in that
I suppose strontias always tend to be good doers
and then any of the hardy geraniums although hardy geraniums can
go into the thugs the good doers and then the ones which don't grow quite so
well so it's difficult when you look at a
plant family but you know they're my go-to plant for
anybody in a garden the hardy geraniums will go in so many
different locations they'll go in the shade they'll go in full sun they'll go
in poor soil they'll go in better soil but it's the ones which are probably more
the alpine type ones which people probably struggle with in the herbaceous
borders a bit because they get overshadowed by other plants
around them they may not they soil may be just too
rich for them and I think that's half the problem
um so it is very much ask when you're buying
or if you find it then just do a little bit of research about it because
if they want it free draining they want it free draining
you know majority of alpines do so if you go and put those
into good soil well manured that sort of thing they're just going to
not like it you know they won't be happy what are the best
ground cover plants to suppress weeds so adugas are really good but you need
if you're doing it for suppressing weeds you need the stronger growing ones so
aduga rectans in any of its named cultivars
lamiums are really good as ground cover and again you've got all sorts of
lamium that you can get so mainly the lamium maculatums
they'll have lovely silver foliage there they will they will spread nicely but
again these are all things which are easy to dig out should they get a little
bit too big for their boots and that that i think is the thing you
need to look at so if they're not deep rooted but just
shallow rooted it's much more easy to get rid of them or
keep them under control but if you've got an area where you don't want
specific pernicious weeds and you want to cover them out then the cymphytum
will smother that quite quickly then you would have to but you just
need to keep an eye on it because it will get quite big
and have you got a favorite good doer
yes my i think my favorite good doers have to be the geums
you know whether it's the spring ones the summer flowering ones
they're lovely they're just good strong plants they'll go in reasonable
conditions if you get and they know their repeat bloom
really well the early flowering ones have wonderful seed heads so they're of
interest later i asked paul what his favorite good doer
was i personally think a good doer is a plant
that has perhaps more than one feature and
therefore a much longer season of interest
than when you first purchase it in full flower on the nursery
it's got to be a survivor and obviously i think that could vary from garden to
garden as i mentioned i'm on a heavy clay soil
so things which are survivors for me might not be survivors for somebody else
so that can vary and and i think another feature of a
really good doer is that it's got to mix well we don't
want it to dominate other plants in the garden either by
reaching over and shading everything out or undermining and pushing with its
elbows all those other more perhaps vulnerable
plants self-seeding plants can be really really
useful in the garden obviously a species and many cultivars
can self-seed and it's a useful way that they reproduce
themselves renew themselves often we find that they position
themselves in the garden in a much better place than we ever considered
putting them and it also enables the plant if it
seeds about to renew itself not always the case but the self-seeding
can be very helpful and i think the
self-seeding aspect can be really useful i'll give you
an obvious example is that beautiful little erigeron erigeron
karwinskianus which will seed about in cracks of paving
and you buy one whenever i've tried to sow the seed i fail
but whenever i leave the plant in the garden it dots itself about in cracks
and nooks in the garden and i've never found it invasive and
never found it problematic when would you say a fast growing plant
becomes a problem when should people step in and think oh i've got to do
something about this i think you need to be observant in the
garden you need to observe your successes and
your failures if you catch it early and the roots
aren't too deep it's dead easy to deal with
observing the plant making sure it's not dominating out maybe some weaker
neighbors making sure it's moving into areas where you find it's going to be
most appealing it helps you to spot when things are
getting a little bit too far or maybe something is getting a little
bit weak as well and you can nurse it a little bit
with that quiet cup of tea that you might have in the morning
just strolling around the garden is actually gardening
it is that wander around the garden with a notepad perhaps if like me you've got
a terrible memory if i'm watering or hoeing in the garden
you can look around and see that's not doing as well as it did last year maybe
i need to do something about it or maybe something is taking over
the self-seeders are really easy to get on top of if you catch them at
the right season if you catch them just as they're beginning to emerge
probably in spring as the soil warms up and
you can deal with it as you do perhaps a hoe through or you mulch
or you do a fingertip weed you can just keep an eye on it
and if it's seeding in the wrong place save some of those babies and move them
into a new location plants for free and what is your
favorite good doer what good doer would you recommend
well i'd i'd really recommend using honesty
in in the garden we're talking now as it happens in spring
but actually i think honesty has a really long season of interest
it's a self-seeding annual in winter foliage begins to emerge so you can
check where the seedlings are you'll see them grow and flower in early
and mid-spring it's got the obvious advantage that
through the summer these flowers turn to at first opaque
fleshy flat pots and then the familiar by late summer and autumn dried flower
heads that you can take into the house possibly the best good
doers are self-seeders and so don't miss this video coming up
next about 25 of the best self-seeded plants for your garden
and thank you for watching goodbye

